Vadasz v Gadaleta Steel Fabrication Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Magistrates Appeals: Civil)

VADASZ v GADALETA STEEL FABRICATION PTY LTD

[2015] SASC 162

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Nicholson

16 October 2015

CONTRACTS - GENERAL CONTRACTUAL PRINCIPLES - CONSTRUCTION AND INTERPRETATION OF CONTRACTS - IMPLIED TERMS

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - APPEAL - GENERAL PRINCIPLES - INTERFERENCE WITH JUDGE'S FINDINGS OF FACT - FUNCTIONS OF APPELLATE COURT - WHERE FINDINGS BASED ON CREDIBILITY OF WITNESSES - GENERALLY

The appellant engaged the respondent to undertake certain steel and welding services for the construction of a school hall.  The appellant challenged the respondent's entitlement to be paid the invoiced amount of $70,168.01.  After making an allowance for a $10,000 part payment and a reduction of $1,496.55 on account of proved errors in the invoices, a Magistrate found for the respondent in the amount of $58,671.46.  The appellant raised a number of complaints on appeal, essentially, with reference to the Magistrate's findings of fact.

Held:

1.  Appeal allowed in part.

2.  The respondent had no contractual entitlement to charge a supervisor's hourly rate, to charge a minimum two hours for any supervisor site attendance or to charge overtime rates for employee attendances.

3.  The amount due and payable as otherwise determined by the Magistrate is to be reduced in accordance with 2. above but all other grounds of appeal are dismissed.

Jones v Dunkel [1959] HCA 8, (1959) 101 CLR 298; O’Donnell v Reichard [1975] VR 916; Payne v Parker [1976] 1 NSWLR 191; Spence v Demasi (1988) 48 SASR 536; Frederick v State of South Australia [2006] SASC 165, (2006) 94 SASR 545; Fox v Percy [2003] HCA 22, (2003) 214 CLR 118, considered.

VADASZ v GADALETA STEEL FABRICATION PTY LTD
[2015] SASC 162

Magistrates Appeal:  Civil

NICHOLSON J.

Introduction and factual background

  1. This is an appeal from the decision of a Magistrate who found that the appellant was liable, pursuant to a contract, to pay the respondent the sum of $58,671.46 for work performed. 

  2. In November 2012, the appellant engaged the respondent to supply certain steel and welding services with respect to the construction of a hall at the John Pirie Secondary School at Port Pirie (“the works”).  No written contract was entered into.  The works were undertaken during the period 27 November 2012 to 29 January 2013.  The works were satisfactorily completed or, at least, there is no complaint to the contrary. 

  3. Throughout the period during which the works were carried out, the respondent issued nine invoices for payment by the appellant of a total amount of $70,168.01.  The appellant does not deny that he is liable to pay for the works but challenges the amount claimed by the respondent.  The appellant, in his notice of appeal, has sought an order that the respondent have judgment for a “just and equitable amount that properly reflects the work carried out by the respondent at the request of the appellant”.The appellant contends that he should only have to pay…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Vadasz v Gadaleta Steel Fabrication Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] SASC 162
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Vadasz v Gadaleta Steel Fabrication Pty Ltd involved a dispute between the appellant, Vadasz, and the respondent, Gadaleta Steel Fabrication Pty Ltd, regarding the contractual terms of a construction project. The primary issue before the court was the interpretation of the contractual rate for the respondent's employees who performed the works. The respondent argued for a higher rate than the agreed upon hourly rate, while the appellant maintained that the agreed rate should apply to all hours worked. The court was tasked with determining the correct interpretation of the contract and whether the respondent was entitled to claim a higher rate for certain employees' attendances, a minimum two-hour attendance for each day on site, or overtime rates.

The court considered the evidence presented at the trial, including witness testimonies and the content of email exchanges between the parties. The court found that the contract between the parties was in simple terms and that the agreed rate was $75 per hour plus GST for all employees. The court also noted that the appellant failed to call Mr West, their site foreman, to give evidence at the trial, which could have challenged the respondent's evidence. However, the court concluded that the real issue was not the failure to call Mr West but rather the lack of evidence to challenge the respondent's evidence regarding the agreed rate.

The court ultimately decided that the respondent had no contractual entitlement to claim a higher rate for Mr Salvemini's attendances, a minimum two-hour attendance for Mr Salvemini for each day he was on site, or overtime rates. All hours of work performed by the respondent's employees, including Mr Salvemini, were to be charged out at the agreed rate of $75 per hour plus GST. The court allowed the appeal to the extent that the total amount found due and payable by the Magistrate was to be adjusted downwards accordingly. The court invited the parties to review the invoices and claim sheets to agree upon an amount by which the claim should be adjusted. The matter was adjourned to enable the respondent to file draft minutes of orders on the appeal that properly reflected the court's reasons. The court also indicated that it would hear the parties with respect to the costs of both the trial and the appeal on the next occasion, once the amount by which the judgment was to be reduced had been determined.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In any event, I have already found that the Magistrate did not err in finding that the parties had agreed an hourly rate of $75 per hour plus GST for all of the respondent’s employees who performed the works. Given this finding, the respondent was entitled to a contractually agreed rate and the questions of whether or not that rate was reasonable and, if not, what would constitute a reasonable rate, do not arise. Appellant’s failure to call Mr West to give evidence at the trial I have already dealt with the relevance of Mr West. Mr West could have been called and the reasons given for not calling Mr West were not persuasive. In any event, as I have indicated, the real problem for the appellant is not so much the question of whether an adverse inference might be drawn from the failure to call Mr West but arises from the fact that the appellant simply had no evidence to challenge the respondent’s evidence as to what took place between Mr Salvemini and Mr West on site and the fact that Mr West, as the appellant’s site foreman, signed and apparently approved the various daily claim sheets.Conclusion The appellant has succeeded with respect to one ground of appeal or contention; that being to the effect that the respondent had no contractual entitlement to claim: a higher rate for Mr Salvemini’s attendances, a minimum two hour attendance for Mr Salvemini for each day he was on site or the overtime rates. In other words, all hours of work performed by the respondent’s employees, including Mr Salvemini, were to be charged out at the agreed rate of $75 per hour plus GST. The appellant has failed with respect to all other grounds of appeal. The appeal is to be allowed only to the extent I have indicated and the total amount found due and payable by the Magistrate of $58,671.46 is to be adjusted downwards accordingly. I invite the respondent and the appellant to review the invoices and the claim sheets with a view to agreeing upon an amount by which the claim should be adjusted in this respect. I will adjourn the matter to enable the respondent to file draft minutes of orders on the appeal that properly reflect these reasons. I will hear the parties with respect to the costs of both the trial and the appeal on the next occasion and once the amount by which the judgment is to be reduced has been determined.

Decision

Reasons for decision

NICHOLSON J
I have already dealt with the relevance of Mr West. Mr West could have been called and the reasons given for not calling Mr West were not persuasive. In any event, as I have indicated, the real problem for the appellant is not so much the question of whether an adverse inference might be drawn from the failure to call Mr West but arises from the fact that the appellant simply had no evidence to challenge the respondent’s evidence as to what took place between Mr Salvemini and Mr West on site and the fact that Mr West, as the appellant’s site foreman, signed and apparently approved the various daily claim sheets.Conclusion The appellant has succeeded with respect to one ground of appeal or contention; that being to the effect that the respondent had no contractual entitlement to claim: a higher rate for Mr Salvemini’s attendances, a minimum two hour attendance for Mr Salvemini for each day he was on site or the overtime rates. In other words, all hours of work performed by the respondent’s employees, including Mr Salvemini, were to be charged out at the agreed rate of $75 per hour plus GST. The appellant has failed with respect to all other grounds of appeal. The appeal is to be allowed only to the extent I have indicated and the total amount found due and payable by the Magistrate of $58,671.46 is to be adjusted downwards accordingly. I invite the respondent and the appellant to review the invoices and the claim sheets with a view to agreeing upon an amount by which the claim should be adjusted in this respect. I will adjourn the matter to enable the respondent to file draft minutes of orders on the appeal that properly reflect these reasons. I will hear the parties with respect to the costs of both the trial and the appeal on the next occasion and once the amount by which the judgment is to be reduced has been determined.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: NICHOLSON J

In this case, the Magistrate heard and observed the witnesses give their evidence over two days and delivered her reasons for judgment some eight weeks or so after the first day of hearing. Her Honour had distinct and obvious advantages, as compared with this Court, when forming a view about the truthfulness and reliability of their respective accounts. Her Honour delivered reasons for judgment at a time when the impressions made by the various witnesses still must have been clearly in her mind. Issues on appeal - Consideration It is apparent from the evidence at trial and her Honour’s findings that the contract negotiated by the appellant and Mr Salvemini on behalf of the respondent was in simple, if somewhat imprecise, terms. In November 2012,[6] Mr Salvemini was contacted by the appellant and asked to undertake certain work at the John Pirie Secondary School. He and the appellant spoke by telephone about the works and thereafter exchanged emails. The works involved the installation of 120 to 140 steel piles drilled and/or hammered into the ground to support the foundations for a new hall. Each pile was to comprise various lengths of steel pipe which were to be prepared and bevelled by the respondent. The pipes were to be stored offsite at the respondent’s premises. Mr Salvemini’s role was to manage the respondent’s workers on and off site and to liaise with the appellant’s foreman or supervisor on the site, Mr West. [6] Mr Salvemini gave conflicting evidence as to this timing and her Honour refers to the oral discussions as taking place in December (Magistrate’s Reasons at [17]). However, a review of Mr Salvemini’s evidence on the topic as a whole, the date and content of the email exchanges referred to below and the fact that the works commenced in early December, combine to persuade me that the initial oral discussions took place in (probably, late) November. In any event, the precise timing, in this respect, is of no consequence for her Honour’s findings concerning the terms, particularly as to hourly rates, of the contract. The Magistrate found that during their discussions, it was more likely than not that Mr Salvemini told the appellant that his workers would be charged out at $75 an hour plus GST.[7] Her Honour also found that by proceeding to retain the respondent to perform the works, the appellant accepted this rate.[8] [7] Magistrate’s Reasons at [96].[8] Magistrate’s Reasons at [96]. After their oral discussions, the two men exchanged emails. On 27 November 2012, the appellant emailed Mr Salvemini in these terms:Sam, please supply steel and welding services to my supervisor, Simon West, as required and email your accounts to me for prompt payment.Thanks for your assistance!Postal address: PO Box ..., Dry Creek ...Mr Salvemini replied by email on the same day in the following terms:Thanks for the email to proceed with the works at John Pirie School, I will talk with Simon West and get him to sign the daily claim sheets as we go, please let me know if there are any issue (sic).