Uthenwoldt and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

Uthenwoldt and National Disability Insurance Agency [2024] AATA 148 (8 February 2024)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number(s):2021/9351      

Re:Tynan Uthenwoldt  

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:The Honourable Pru Goward AO, Senior Member

Date:8 February 2024

Place:Sydney

Pursuant to subsection 43(1)(c)(ii) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), the Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and remits the matter to the Chief Executive Officer of the National Disability Insurance Agency in accordance with the following direction:

(a) The decision is remitted to the Respondent for the temporary provision of sole residency SDA, at the agreed level of Improved Liveability. During this period, the Applicant is to be provided with high intensity support worker assistance with capacity building while a search for a suitable co-resident is undertaken.

(b) When a suitable SDA co- residency is established, the Applicant is to be provided with 1:1 Intensive support 16 hours per day, with additional overnight support for eight hours per day.

.........................[SGD]..............................................

The Honourable Pru Goward AO, Senior Member

CATCHWORDS

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME - reasonable and necessary supports - Specialist Disability Accommodation - single occupancy - shared accommodation - value for money - harm to the participant and risk to others - decision under review set aside and remitted with direction

LEGISLATION

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) s 43(1)(c)(ii)
National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) ss 3, 33, 34

National Disability Insurance Scheme (Supports for Participants) Rules 2013 (Cth)

CASES

Beezley v Repatriation Commission [2015] FCAFC 165

Boicovitis and National Disability Insurance Agency [2022] AATA 204

Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336

Kennedy and National Disability Insurance Agency [2022] AATA 265

McGarrigle v National Disability Insurance Agency (2017) 252 FCR 121

McLaughlin and National Disability Insurance Agency [2021] AATA 496

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v Li (2013) 249 CLR 332

National Disability Insurance Agency v WRMF (2020) 378 ALR 449

SECONDARY MATERIALS

National Disability Insurance Agency, Our Guidelines – Including Specific Types of Supports in Plans Operational Guidelines (Web Page) < FOR DECISION

The Honourable Pru Goward AO, Senior Member

8 February 2024

INTRODUCTION

  1. Mr Tynan Uthenwoldt (the Applicant) is a 33-year-old man who is a participant in the National Disability Insurance Scheme (the Scheme) on the basis of his autism spectrum disorder, severe intellectual disability and his Klippel-Trenaunay-Weber syndrome.  He is noted to be non-verbal and has an anxiety disorder. 

  2. The Applicant’s NDIS Plan commenced on 28 July 2021 and has been extended several times. The Plan includes several supports which are not in contention and Specialist Disability Accommodation (SDA) at the level of Improved Liveability, house, two residents, VIC- Ballarat.

  3. On 15 October 2021, the Applicant requested internal review of his plan under s 103 of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013, (the Act), and the original decision was confirmed by a delegate of the CEO of the National Disability Insurance Agency (the Respondent) on 3 November 2021. This is the decision under…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Uthenwoldt and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] AATA 148
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by the Applicant, Mr Uthenwoldt, against a decision by the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) regarding Specialist Disability Accommodation (SDA). The Applicant had a history of aggressive behaviour and self-isolation, stemming from a "fight or flight" response to the presence of others. The core dispute was whether sole occupancy SDA, or shared accommodation with another resident, represented value for money and was therefore a reasonable and necessary support under section 34(1)(c) of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth). The Applicant contended that sole occupancy was necessary to minimise his behaviours of concern and reduce the need for restrictive practices, while the NDIA argued that shared accommodation with appropriate support would be more cost-effective.

The Tribunal was required to determine the appropriate SDA design category and level of housing for the Applicant, considering his specific needs and Australia's obligations under the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities. Specifically, the Tribunal had to assess whether sole occupancy SDA, at the agreed "Improved Liveability" design level, was reasonable and necessary, or if shared accommodation with one other resident would satisfy the requirements of the Act, particularly the "value for money" criterion. The Tribunal also considered the provision of 24/7 one-on-one Supported Independent Living (SIL) support in conjunction with the SDA.

The Tribunal accepted the Applicant's evidence, supported by an occupational therapist and other witnesses, that he had an extensive history of physically attacking others, particularly those he perceived as weaker, in moments of distress. This behaviour was described as a "fight or flight" response, and the occupational therapist noted a narrow window of tolerance for the Applicant, suggesting that even an inadvertent incident with a co-resident could have a lasting impact. The Tribunal found that the NDIA had not provided sufficient evidence to confirm the frequency of past aggression or the likelihood of future aggression towards a co-resident. Consequently, the Tribunal set aside the NDIA's decision and remitted the matter for the temporary provision of sole occupancy SDA at the Improved Liveability design level, with high-intensity support. During this period, a search for a suitable co-resident would be undertaken, with a view to transitioning to a shared SDA arrangement with intensive SIL support once established.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

For the purposes of determining the appropriate SDA design category, Rule 17 applies, requiring the CEO to have: regard to the specific needs of the eligible applicantand to give effect to Australia’s obligations under the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (CRDP).BACKGROUND The Applicant has lived in Ballarat, Victoria, with four other NDIS participants in Melba Support SIL accommodation, described as a group home, since 2011. He had a history of physical violence towards co-residents, and, in his most recent group home, one female co-resident. He had also absconded from care. Although the Applicant attended a day program, including swimming, he was otherwise solitary. He played with his trains or watched television in his room and reportedly sought to avoid other residents. He also ate in his room to avoid being in the presence of co-residents. The Applicant visited his family regularly and they remain actively involved in his life. He had a history of violence towards his younger sister, who is also a participant in the Scheme, but their relationship is now more congenial and, according to the Applicant’s father, only infrequently aggressive and requiring parental intervention. Police have attended incidents at the Applicant’s group home involving the Applicant and the other female resident. It is unclear whether the violence reported was the result of the Applicant’s fear or aggression, described by various witnesses as Flight or Fight responses. The family of the co-resident, who has consistently been his target over several years, has reportedly expressed concerns about her safety and sought intervention. CONTENTIONS At the outset, the Tribunal notes that although the Respondent’s and Applicant’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions (‘SFIC’s) identified the preferred level of house design for the Applicant to be robust, throughout the hearing and in closing submissions, the preferred level of housing, Improved Liveability, was referenced by both sides. No submissions about which level was to be preferred were made. Accordingly, the Tribunal accepts that Improved Liveability is the level of housing preferred by the parties, and, since no further submissions were made regarding it, the Tribunal will duly note this in its decision. The Applicant contended that sole occupancy SDA, Improved Liveability, represented value for money, so satisfying the requirements of s 34 (1) (c). Particularly, that it would reduce his behaviours of concern, such as aggression and self-isolation, and minimise the use of the restrictive practices to which the Applicant is currently subjected. The Applicant also contended there was no alternative support available which would enable this, as also required by s 34(1) (c). The Respondent contended that the alternative to sole occupancy was shared accommodation with one other resident and that this was value for money, thus meeting the requirements of s 34 (1) (c). The Applicant contended that, in conjunction with the requested level of SDA, it was reasonable and necessary that the Applicant be provided 24/7 1:1 SIL support, and that this also satisfied s 34 (1) (c). The request was for sixteen hours of 1:1 SIL and eight hours of Inactive Overnight Support. Further, the provision of 1:1 SIL would assist with capacity building.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Tribunal has had regard to various material before it, including:(a)Applicant’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions dated 10 October 2023(b)Respondent’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions dated 7 November 2023(c)Applicant’s amended Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions and bundle of documents filed on 30 November 2023 (d)Hearing Tender Bundle filed on 1 November 2023(e)Further Statement of Ms Kylie Brooks filed on 4 December 2023(f)Applicant’s closing submissions dated 3 January 2024(g)Respondent’s closing submissions dated 3 January 2024 ORAL EVIDENCE The hearing in this matter was held on 4 and 11 December 2023 by audio-visual link. The Tribunal heard oral evidence from the following witnesses:a)Ms Anja Hoogendijk, Occupational Therapistb)Mr Craig Uthenwoldt, Applicant’s fatherc)Ms Kylie Brooks, House Managerd)Ms Kathleen Dennis, behavioural support practitionere)Ms Phi Van Houston, Independent Occupational TherapistCONSIDERATIONS The parties have agreed that the Applicant’s current living arrangements are not suitable. They disagree over what constitutes a suitable living arrangement; sole or dual residency. The Applicant contends he is:Unable to accommodate the desires or needs of a co-resident (closing submissions) Whereas the Respondent, relying upon the assessment of the OT, Ms Houston, contends:The Applicant has the ability to live with another person when receiving high levels of support (closing submissions). The Applicant’s Statement of Facts, issues and Contentions reported that the Applicant had a pattern of aggression towards other people with whom he lived, as well as to staff members, and also self-seclusion in his room; these constituted his behaviours of concern. The Applicant contended both these behaviours of concern were driven by his “fight or flight” response to the presence of others. On this basis, the Applicant concluded there was no suitable alternative support to Sole Occupancy SDA (p27 SFIC). The Respondent contended there was insufficient evidence to either confirm the frequency of his targeted aggression in the past or the likelihood that he would become aggressive towards a co-resident in future, and therefore that a co-residency constituted better value for money, so satisfying s 24 (1) (c) of the Act. The Applicant relied upon the evidence of the Applicant’s father, the house manager, Ms Kylie Brooks and the behavioural support worker, Ms Kathleen Dennis, as well as the OT, Ms Anja Hoogendijk, who confirmed the Applicant’s history of apparently triggered aggression. Ms Hoogendijk wrote of the Applicant’s:“extensive history of…physically attacking other people in various settings…” Ms Hoogendijk also noted a number of violent incidents in a Functional Behaviour Analysis report between January 2021 and February 2022, and in cross examination observed there were probably other incidents that the staff managed before they escalated and were reported. The Tribunal accepts that evidence and found Ms Hoogendijk to be a straightforward and insightful witness.As Ms Hoogendijk told the Tribunal:“There is a long history…it would have started when [the Applicant] was 19 years old of [the Applicant] targeting people that he perceives as weaker than himself in moments of distress”

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal also notes it is open to the Respondent to review the Applicant’s progress and consider other options in a future plan.DECISION Pursuant to subsection 43(1)(c)(ii) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), the Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and remits the matter to the Chief Executive Officer of the National Disability Insurance Agency in accordance with the following direction:(a) The decision is remitted to the Respondent for the temporary provision of sole residency SDA, at the agreed level of Improved Liveability. During this period, the Applicant is to be provided with high intensity support worker assistance with capacity building while a search for a suitable co-resident is undertaken.(b) When a suitable SDA co- residency is established, the Applicant is to be provided with 1:1 Intensive support 16 hours per day, with additional overnight support for eight hours per day.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The hearing in this matter was held on 4 and 11 December 2023 by audio-visual link. The Tribunal heard oral evidence from the following witnesses:a)Ms Anja Hoogendijk, Occupational Therapistb)Mr Craig Uthenwoldt, Applicant’s fatherc)Ms Kylie Brooks, House Managerd)Ms Kathleen Dennis, behavioural support practitionere)Ms Phi Van Houston, Independent Occupational TherapistCONSIDERATIONS The parties have agreed that the Applicant’s current living arrangements are not suitable. They disagree over what constitutes a suitable living arrangement; sole or dual residency. The Applicant contends he is:Unable to accommodate the desires or needs of a co-resident (closing submissions) Whereas the Respondent, relying upon the assessment of the OT, Ms Houston, contends:The Applicant has the ability to live with another person when receiving high levels of support (closing submissions). The Applicant’s Statement of Facts, issues and Contentions reported that the Applicant had a pattern of aggression towards other people with whom he lived, as well as to staff members, and also self-seclusion in his room; these constituted his behaviours of concern. The Applicant contended both these behaviours of concern were driven by his “fight or flight” response to the presence of others. On this basis, the Applicant concluded there was no suitable alternative support to Sole Occupancy SDA (p27 SFIC). The Respondent contended there was insufficient evidence to either confirm the frequency of his targeted aggression in the past or the likelihood that he would become aggressive towards a co-resident in future, and therefore that a co-residency constituted better value for money, so satisfying s 24 (1) (c) of the Act. The Applicant relied upon the evidence of the Applicant’s father, the house manager, Ms Kylie Brooks and the behavioural support worker, Ms Kathleen Dennis, as well as the OT, Ms Anja Hoogendijk, who confirmed the Applicant’s history of apparently triggered aggression. Ms Hoogendijk wrote of the Applicant’s:“extensive history of…physically attacking other people in various settings…” Ms Hoogendijk also noted a number of violent incidents in a Functional Behaviour Analysis report between January 2021 and February 2022, and in cross examination observed there were probably other incidents that the staff managed before they escalated and were reported. The Tribunal accepts that evidence and found Ms Hoogendijk to be a straightforward and insightful witness.As Ms Hoogendijk told the Tribunal:“There is a long history…it would have started when [the Applicant] was 19 years old of [the Applicant] targeting people that he perceives as weaker than himself in moments of distress” And she agreed that if the Applicant was to live with another resident, it may take only once incident or exchange to have a lasting impact, even something “entirely inadvertent”. She described the Applicant as having a very narrow window of tolerance. Under cross examination, Ms Hoogendijk agreed she had not observed any aggressive behaviour herself but based these assertions on reports provided by his house manager, his father and his behaviour support practitioner. The Tribunal finds that her consideration of the experience of these other witnesses to be a sound basis for her conclusions.