Universal Supermodels Pty Ltd v Commissioner of State Revenue

Link copied
Case Copied 69 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Universal Supermodels Pty Ltd v Commissioner of State Revenue [2018] QSC 257

PARTIES:

UNIVERSAL SUPERMODELS PTY LTD
(appellant)
v
COMMISSIONER OF STATE REVENUE
(respondent)

FILE NO/S:

SC No 880 of 2016

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Appeal

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

9 November 2018

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

1 August 2018, 2 August 2018

JUDGE:

Boddice J

ORDERS:

1.   I shall hear the parties as to the form of orders and costs.

CATCHWORDS:

TAXES AND DUTIES – PAYROLL TAX – OBJECTIONS, APPEALS AND REVIEWS – where the respondent issued tax reassessments to the appellant for the tax years 2009 to 2014 –where the appellant was required to pay payroll tax, with a sum of penalty tax and interest, following an audit by the respondent – where the penalty tax was remitted from 75 per cent to 20 per cent – where the appellant objected to the reassessments on the basis the payments assessed as wages were rather payments to independent contractors – where the respondent disallowed the appellant’s objection – where the appellant now appeals, pursuant to s 69 of the Taxation Administration Act 2001 (Qld) – whether or not the payments assessed as wages were payments to independent contractors – where, if determined to be payments to independent contractors, whether the penalties imposed by the respondent should be remitted to nil – whether the discretion of the respondent had erred

EMPLOYMENT LAW – EMPLOYMENT RELATIONSHIP – ASCERTAINING EXISTENCE AND NATURE OF RELATIONSHIP – PARTICULAR RELATIONSHIPS – INDEPENDENT CONTRACTOR – where the appellant is the operator of adult entertainment venues – where dancers perform at those venues – whether those dancers are employees of the appellant or independent contractors – where the relevant test is a multifactorial test – where the dancers agreed to the appellant’s  ‘dancer’s protocol’ – where the terms of the protocol included authority for the appellant to impose fines and deductions on the dancers’ remuneration, or terminate their contract, if dancers did not comply with the protocol – where the dancers were required to obtain permission from the appellant’s senior staff before undertaking breaks – where payments by clients for lap-dances, including tips, were deposited directly with the appellant – where the prices for lap-dances were fixed by the appellant – where the payment for dances, including tips, was distributed between the appellant and dancer at a rate of 50 per cent each – where the appellant paid dancers $50 if they concluded a shift without having performed any lap-dances – where the appellant issued recipient-created tax invoices to the dancers – where some dancers had ABNs, whilst others did not – where the appellant’s senior staff assisted dancers to obtain ABNs – where dancers could work at other adult entertainment venues and wear their own clothing – where some dancers had regular clients particular to that dancer – where dancers could not arrange, if they were unavailable, for someone of their choice to take their place…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Universal Supermodels Pty Ltd v Commissioner of State Revenu... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] QSC 257
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Universal Supermodels Pty Ltd has appealed against reassessments issued by the Commissioner of State Revenue, following an audit of the appellant's business for the financial years 2009 to 2014. The Commissioner determined that the payments made to the dancers were properly characterised as wages, with penalties and interest imposed on the appellant for late payment. The appellant contends the dancers were independent contractors and not employees. The penalties imposed on the appellant should be remitted to nil if the dancers are found to be employees. The court must determine the nature of the relationship between the appellant and the dancers, and whether the penalties imposed should be remitted.

The court found that the relationship between the appellant and the dancers was that of an employer and employee. The court considered the multifactorial test, including the level of control exercised by the appellant over the dancers, the terms of the dancers' protocol, and the nature of the work performed. The court found that the dancers were subject to a high degree of control by the appellant, including restrictions on their availability, dress, and conduct. The dancers were also paid a fixed rate for their services, with no commercial risk or responsibility in performing at the appellant's club.

The court rejected the argument that the dancers were independent contractors, despite the fact that they had ABNs, operated on a cash-only basis, and were not entitled to superannuation or leave entitlements. The court found that these factors were consistent with the dancers being employees, rather than independent contractors. The court also noted that the outcome of an audit of the appellant's business regarding GST and PAYG withholding tax did not support the appellant's claim that the dancers were independent contractors.

The court found that the penalties imposed on the appellant should not be remitted to nil. The court found that the appellant had failed to take reasonable care in assessing its liability for payroll tax and had not acted in good faith. The court rejected the argument that the penalties should be remitted on the basis that the appellant had complied with the requirements of the adult entertainment code and had obtained ABNs for some of the dancers.

The court orders that the appeal be dismissed and that the appellant pay the costs of the Commissioner. The court will hear the parties as to the form of orders and costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. I shall hear the parties as to the form of orders and costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

At issue on the appeal, is whether dancers at adult entertainment venues operated by the appellant were employees of the appellant, or independent contractors carrying on their own businesses. The appellant contends there is a subsidiary issue, in the event the dancers are found to be employees, namely whether the penalties should be remitted to nil.Background The appellant is the holder of a Liquor License and an adult entertainment license. During the financial years, the subject of the appeal, it operated three clubs, Players Universal Lounge, Club Minx and Club Vixen. Each operated separately, although the features of their operation were the same. As the operator of an adult entertainment license, the appellant was required to comply with the Adult Entertainment Code in accordance with the Liquor Act 1992 (Qld). That Code prescribed the live entertainment that may be performed on licensed premises by a person performing an act of an explicit sexual nature. Pursuant to that Code, adult entertainment did not include sexual intercourse, masturbation or oral sex, the touching of the genitalia, placing faces in close proximity of genitalia, or soliciting any person for the purposes of prostitution. The appellant’s clubs imposed a cover charge for customers. The cover charge, collected by door-girls, was given to a receptionist adjacent to the front door of the club. That receptionist recorded the number of people in the club for safety purposes. The main area of the club contained a bar area, seating and a stage. Dancers performed on the stage. In between such performances, a dancer would walk around the main floor talking to customers. Hostesses would also be on the main floor. They facilitated interaction between dancers and customers, including the booking of private lap-dances. Customers who booked a private dance paid the fee to the receptionist. The fee, set by the appellant, was based on the duration of the dance. A private dance was conducted in a separate room. An adult entertainment controller, a person approved under the Liquor Act 1992, observed all dances. Their role was to monitor compliance with the club’s adult entertainment license. The clubs were subject to regular inspection to ensure compliance with both the adult entertainment license and liquor license. Objection Decision The re-assessments were issued following an audit by the respondent. During the audit process, the appellant contended that dancers were engaged by it on a contractor basis and were not employees. The appellant advised that dancers were paid for each contract on a cash basis, with settlement of each contract being made at the end of the next working day. The appellant provided employee records evidencing the omission of any payments to dancers. The appellant also provided a copy of a dancers’ protocol, which it said was signed by all dancers before they were allowed to perform at the appellant’s clubs. Having considered the material obtained in its audit, the respondent determined the dancers were properly to be characterised as employees. The respondent concluded the dancers’ protocol was consistent with the appellant exercising authority to control the dancers, in what they wore, when they worked, how they performed their job, who they reported to each night and when they could take leave. That control was consistent with an employer/employee relationship. Further, the dancers’ protocol outlined a dancer’s pay rate for lap dancing. Again, indicative of an employer/employee relationship.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Disavia conveyed this information to the proprietors of the club and proceeded to train administration staff on how to complete an ABN registration form. Thereafter, Club Minx complied with the ATO request and assisted dancers in registering for an ABN. Following the conclusion of the audit, the ATO issued a series of interpretative decisions and industry specific fact sheets in relation to the collection and payment of GST in the supply of adult entertainment services by dancers.Further evidence In cross-examination, Daley agreed the club, not the dancers had the necessary adult entertainment license. Dancers do not own the premises or provide door or other administrative staff. However, the appellant did not provide the dances. There was an engagement by which dancers could use the appellant’s venue to advertise their services. The system by which the appellant and the dancers operated, was that the club wrote out a tax invoice, with the original being given to the dancer, and the club retaining a carbon copy. The tax invoice was the tax invoice of the dancer. The critical thing for the profitability of the appellant’s business, was the dancer. You could have an adult entertainment permit with no dancer, but you would have no service. Daley accepted the dancer could only provide that service in licensed premises. Daley agreed dancers were asked to indicate their willingness to follow the appellant’s dance protocol. That protocol contained an acknowledgement the dancer may be fined or have her contract terminated if she failed to follow that agreement. Some dancers, but not all dancers, signed that agreement. The protocol provided the dancer would be given agreed hours every week. Daley did not agree dancers were controlled by the club. The club would not favourably view a request that a dancer send a friend for a rostered shift, although that had happened in the past. The roster was important for dancers to adhere to, as it ensured dancers were available on every night. Other reasons for the preparation of a roster, were so dancers could contact their clients to make arrangements for them to attend when the dancer was to dance and to remind dancers to be available on a particular day. The requirement that dancers seek permission before going on breaks was for safety reasons. It was strongly recommended dancers give a minimum of two weeks’ notice if they wanted time off. Dancers were required to wear their uniform correctly at all times. The protocol also provided that dancers must be well groomed with their hair and makeup done fashionably. Daley did not accept that if a dancer turned up in an untidy state, they would be asked to do something about their appearance. They were never asked not to dance. It was strongly suggested, for their own benefit, that they think about their presentation. The protocol also provided that dancers were not to “cut other dancer’s grass”. That was a suggestion that a dancer not ‘muscle in’ on another dancer’s client.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Customers who booked a private dance paid the fee to the receptionist. The fee, set by the appellant, was based on the duration of the dance. A private dance was conducted in a separate room. An adult entertainment controller, a person approved under the Liquor Act 1992, observed all dances. Their role was to monitor compliance with the club’s adult entertainment license. The clubs were subject to regular inspection to ensure compliance with both the adult entertainment license and liquor license. Objection Decision The re-assessments were issued following an audit by the respondent. During the audit process, the appellant contended that dancers were engaged by it on a contractor basis and were not employees. The appellant advised that dancers were paid for each contract on a cash basis, with settlement of each contract being made at the end of the next working day. The appellant provided employee records evidencing the omission of any payments to dancers. The appellant also provided a copy of a dancers’ protocol, which it said was signed by all dancers before they were allowed to perform at the appellant’s clubs. Having considered the material obtained in its audit, the respondent determined the dancers were properly to be characterised as employees. The respondent concluded the dancers’ protocol was consistent with the appellant exercising authority to control the dancers, in what they wore, when they worked, how they performed their job, who they reported to each night and when they could take leave. That control was consistent with an employer/employee relationship. Further, the dancers’ protocol outlined a dancer’s pay rate for lap dancing. Again, indicative of an employer/employee relationship. The respondent noted dancers were wholly or predominantly providing labour services, in circumstances where they did not supply their own material, equipment and tools needed to complete that work. Dancers were initially provided with a uniform. Payment of the uniform was deducted from their pay, with the uniform being handed back each night until it was paid off. Shoes could also be hired for a fee per night. The appellant was responsible for all other materials and tools, including dancer’s poles, stage, music and lap-dance rooms. These factors were consistent with dancers being employees. The respondent accepted that dancers had an ABN, operated on a cash only basis, were not entitled to superannuation, sick leave or recreational leave, were provided with an invoice to manage their own tax liability and that no income tax was withheld from the payments made to the dancers. Whilst this payment method was indicative of an independent contractor, the dancers’ hours of work included a requirement to work set shifts and set days. Dancers were also restricted from exchanging phone numbers or private details and in leaving the club with customers. These factors were suggestive of control, consistent with dancers being an employee. Dancers also did not have any commercial risk or responsibility in performing at the appellant’s club.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In response to that request for further information, the appellant, by letter dated 16 June 2015, acknowledged the payroll tax audit did not include a technical review of whether dancers were independent contractors, but asserted the appellant had an expectation the respondent was satisfied dancers were not employees. The appellant provided statutory declarations from its managers, Lisa Beetham and Teraza Daley, a dancer, Courtney Thompson and its accountant, Guiseppi Disavia. The appellant submitted these statutory declarations supported its contentions that dancers were independent contractors, operating separate businesses, with any control in the operation of those businesses only at the level consistent with the appellant’s obligations to ensure compliance with the adult entertainment code, for the purposes of continuation of its licenses.Original Statutory Declaration The statutory declarations of Beetham and Daley were in identical terms, as to the structure of the appellant in respect of employees, the engagement of contractors and the terms and circumstances of the agreement with dancers. Beetham began working for Club Minx in 2001. She commenced working for the appellant in 2006, when it purchased Club Minx. In 2008 she began operating at the appellant’s other club, Players Universal Lounge. In 2015, she was employed as the appellant’s operations manager, with responsibility for the day to day running of the business of both its clubs. Teraza Daley has also been involved in adult entertainment since 2001. She worked at Players, prior to its purchase by the appellant in 2002. In 2015, she was the appellant’s general manager, responsible for the day to day running of Players and Club Minx. More recently, she purchased Players Universal Lounge. According to their statutory declarations, the appellant regularly advertised for employees, through job sites. It did not advertise for dancers on those sites. Employees were the door girls who accepted the cover charge from customers and escorted them into the main area of the club; the receptionist responsible for collecting cash from door girls, hostesses and customers; hostesses, who worked on the floor of the club facilitating dancers to sell private lap-dances; team leaders, being duty managers or liquor approved managers, licensed under the Liquor Act 1992; bar staff, responsible for serving alcohol and other beverages; and controllers, who were individually licensed under the Liquor Act to ensure compliance with the appellant’s adult entertainment license and the associated regulations. The appellant engaged three types of contractors, security, cleaners and dancers. There were usually about 30 dancers on the books for each club, at any period of time, with between 8 and 15 dancers performing per night at each club. Dancers performed on stage. They also provided private lap-dances for customers. When a dancer sells a private dance, the client paid reception the fee before being taken into a separate room. This room was large enough to accommodate up to 20 clients and their dancers at any one time. It did not contain individual rooms for each private dance. Some areas were afforded privacy, based on the positioning of curtains and internal walls. The layout of the room was designed so that one controller sitting in the control booth had a direct line of sight to each of the dancers, a requirement of the adult entertainment permit.