United Workers' Union v Spotless Facility Services Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 35 min read
[2023] FWC 968

FAIR WORK COMMISSION

DECISION

Fair Work Act 2009

s.739—Dispute resolution

United Workers’ Union
v

Spotless Facility Services Pty Ltd

(C2022/7104)

DEPUTY PRESIDENT LAKE

BRISBANE, 8 MAY 2023

Application to deal with a dispute - whether the Supervisor is included in the classification structure – coverage – classification– dispute determined.

  1. On 25 October 2022, the United Workers Union (UWU) (‘the Applicant’) filed an application pursuant to s 739 of the Fair Work Act2009 (Cth) (the Act) regarding a dispute about the coverage of security supervisors employed by Spotless Facilities Services Pty Ltd (‘the Respondent’ or ‘Spotless’) under the Spotless Sunshine Coast University Hospital Security Enterprise Agreement 2019 (‘the Agreement’).

  1. The UWU made the Application pursuant to clause 2.4 of the Agreement. Clause 2.4.5 of the Agreement states:

2.4.5 The Fair Work Commission may deal with the dispute in two stages:

(a) the Fair Work Commission will first attempt to resolve the dispute as it considers appropriate, including by mediation, conciliation, expressing an opinion or making a recommendation; and

(b) if the Fair Work Commission is unable to resolve the dispute at the first stage, the Fair Work Commission may then: (i) arbitrate the dispute; and (ii) make a determination that is binding on the parties.

  1. The parties attempted to resolve the dispute on 1 December 2022 through a conciliation which was unsuccessful. Following the conciliation conference, I issued directions and listed the matter for arbitration on 7 February 2023. I am satisfied that I have the jurisdiction to arbitrate the dispute per clause 2.4.5(b) of the Agreement.

  1. A number of jurisdictional objections were raised by the Respondent. However, in order for the substantive matter be dealt with so as to enable the parties to return to the bargaining table, the Respondent agreed to no longer contest those objections in the hearing. As a result, I will not deal with those matters in this decision.

Outline of Dispute

  1. The Respondent provides security services to the Sunshine Coast University Hospital (‘SCUH’) on a continuous basis (24 hours a day, seven days per week). They engage employees on a four-day on/four-day off basis rotating day and night. There are four crews of security officers with each crew having a Security Supervisor (‘Supervisor’ or ‘Security Supervisor’).

  1. The four supervisors who are responsible for supervising and managing their team of security officers are the most senior members of management on site and work out of hours between 4:00pm and 8:00am weekdays. These supervisors report to the Security Coordinator. Security supervisors are paid an annual salary and a rostered to work on average two day shifts and two-night shifts per week over an eight-week cycle.

  1. Security officers are permanent employees and are paid an aggregate annualised wage which includes a base hourly rate, shift allowances, first-aid allowance, rostered overtime and any other allowance or penalty which would be payable in accordance with the roster. The aggregate annualised wage is calculated…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read United Workers' Union v Spotless Facility Services Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FWC 968
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, the United Workers Union (UWU) filed an application under the Fair Work Act 2009, seeking to determine whether security supervisors employed by Spotless Facilities Services Pty Ltd (Spotless) at Sunshine Coast University Hospital were covered by the Spotless Sunshine Coast University Hospital Security Enterprise Agreement 2019 (the Agreement). The application was made pursuant to clause 2.4 of the Agreement, which provides for the Fair Work Commission to resolve disputes in two stages, including arbitration if the dispute remains unresolved after the first stage. The parties attempted conciliation but were unsuccessful. The dispute centred on whether the security supervisors were covered under the classification of a Level 5 Security Officer in the Agreement.

The UWU argued that the security supervisors were engaged by Spotless to provide security services and that their duties aligned with the description of a Security Officer – Level 5 in the Agreement, which requires working under limited supervision, exercising high-level communications and interpersonal skills, and assisting in the provision of training in conjunction with supervisors and trainers. The Applicant submitted that the security supervisors perform a broad range of duties that require a high level of discretion and responsibility, many of which align with the duties of a Level 5 Security Officer.

In contrast, Spotless submitted that the Agreement does not apply to the role of Security Supervisor on the basis that the Agreement does not expressly contemplate a Supervisor role in its classifications, does not provide for duties that align with the nature or day-to-day tasks of the Supervisor role, and consistently utilises language which infers that supervisory roles are separate to the classifications contemplated. Spotless argued that the primary purpose of the Security Supervisor role is to supervise Security Officers and act in a managerial capacity to discharge the Respondent’s contractual obligations onsite, which is distinct from the duties provided for by the Security Officer Level 5 classification within the Agreement.

The Deputy President considered the principles of construction and interpretation of enterprise agreements, including the need to determine whether an agreement has a plain meaning or is ambiguous or susceptible of more than one meaning. The Deputy President found that there was ambiguity in the language of Appendix 1 Clause 1.5.2, which describes the duties of a Security Officer Level 5. To assist in interpreting this clause, the Deputy President considered the evidence of surrounding circumstances, including the matrix of activities of a Security Officer and a Security Supervisor submitted by the parties, and the evidence provided regarding the customs and working conditions of the particular industry.

The Deputy President found that the security supervisors require increased flexibility and discretion to undertake risk assessments during a shift, which is not provided for in the wording of the Agreement in clause 1.5.2. The Deputy President concluded that the interpretation of the Agreement and the evidence provided identified the principal purpose of the Security Officer as distinct from a Security Supervisor. The Deputy President found that the security supervisors were not covered by the Agreement and therefore not classified as Security Officers – Level 5.

In summary, the Deputy President determined that the security supervisors engaged by Spotless at Sunshine Coast University Hospital were not covered by the Agreement. The Deputy President's decision was based on the plain and ordinary meaning of the relevant words, the context and purpose of the Agreement, and the evidence provided by the parties regarding the nature of the work performed by the security supervisors. The Deputy President found that the security supervisors' duties and responsibilities went beyond those provided for by the Security Officer Level 5 classification within the Agreement and were of a supervisory and managerial nature, which was not contemplated by the Agreement.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established