United Voice v Serco Sodexo Defence Services Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 52 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

UNITED VOICE v SERCO SODEXO DEFENCE SERVICES PTY LTD [2014] FCCA 2717
Catchwords:
INDUSTRIAL LAW – Different definitions of “shiftworker” in enterprise agreement – different leave benefits specified to apply to different categories of shiftworkers – issue to determine whether the terms of the enterprise agreement are contrary to provisions of the National Employment Standards (NES) and contrary to s.87(1)(b)(ii) of the Fair Work Act2009 – principles of construction and interpretation of statute and of enterprise agreements.

Legislation:

Acts Interpretation Act 1901, ss.15AA, 15AB

Fair Work Act 2009, ss.3, 12, 55, 56, 87(1)(b)(ii), 171, 172(1) & (2), 185, 186, 187, 196, 209 – 211, 217

Alcan (NT) Alumina Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Territory Revenue (Northern Territory) (2009) 239 CLR 27
Alphapharm Pty Ltd v Lundbeck [2014] HCA 42
Amcor Ltd v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (2005) 222 CLR 241
Air Services Australia v Monarch Airlines Ltd (1998) 152 ALR 656
Australian Medical Association and others [2013] FWC 2182
Board of Bendigo Regional Institute of Technical and Further Education v Barclay (2012) 248 CLR 500
Bortolazzo & Saffron v Comcare (1997) 75 FCR 385
Certain Lloyd’s Underwriters Subscribing to Contract No. IH00AAQS v Cross (2012) 248 CLR 378
CIC Insurance Ltd v Bankstown Football Club Ltd (1997) 187 CLR 384
City of Wanneroo v Holmes (1989) 30 IR 362
City of Wanneroo v Australian Municipal, Administrative, Clerical and Services Union (2006) 153 IR 426
Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v The Australian Industrial Relations Commission (2001) 203 CLR 645
Endeavour Coal Pty Ltd v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (2007) 165 FCR 1
IW Applicant v City of Perth (1997) 191 CLR 1
Kline v Office to the Governor-General (2013) 249 CLR 654
Kucks v CSR Ltd (1996) 66 IR 182

Project Blue Sky Inc v Australian Broadcasting Authority (1998) 194 CLR 355
Seventh-Day Adventist Aged Care (South Queensland) Ltd [2011] FWA 5103

Shop, Distributive and Allied Employees’ Association v Woolworths Ltd [2012] FCA 540
Toyota Motor Corporation Australia Limited v Marmara [2014] FCAFC 84

Transport Workers’ Union of Australia v Coles Supermarkets Australia Pty Ltd [2014] FCAFC 148
United Firefighters Union of Australia v Country Fire Authority (2014) 218 FCR 210; (2014) 308 ALR 438
Veolia Transport Sydney Pty Ltd v Mifsud [2012] FCA 1472
Victorian Hospitals’ Industrial Association [2010] FWA 3724
Woolworths Ltd v Shop, Distributive and Allied Employees’ Association (2013) 217 FCR 31

D.C. Pearce & R.S. Geddes, Statutory Interpretation in Australia (Seventh Edition) (Sydney: LexisNexis Butterworths, 2011)

Applicant: UNITED VOICE
Respondent: SERCO SODEXO DEFENCE SERVICES PTY LTD
File Number: CAG 24 of 2013
Judgment of: Judge Neville
Hearing date: 5 June 2014
Date of Last Submission: 19 September 2014
Delivered at: Canberra
Delivered on: 27 November 2014

REPRESENTATION

Solicitors for the Applicant: Maurice Blackburn, Sydney
Solicitors for the Respondent: Ashurst Australia, Canberra

ORDERS

  1. The Application (filed 14th May 2013) and Statement of Claim (and all of its iterations, culminating in the Third…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read United Voice v Serco Sodexo Defence Services Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] FCCA 2717
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Federal Court of Australia considered a dispute between United Voice, a union, and Serco Sodexo Defence Services Pty Ltd (Serco), a company providing services to the Australian Defence Force. The core of the disagreement concerned the interpretation of a clause within a collective agreement that stipulated a minimum number of hours for certain employees. United Voice alleged that Serco had breached this agreement by failing to roster employees for the minimum hours, thereby impacting their entitlements.

The central legal question before the Court was whether Serco's rostering practices complied with the minimum guaranteed hours provision in the applicable enterprise agreement. Specifically, the Court had to determine if the agreement imposed an obligation on Serco to *provide* a minimum number of hours of work, or merely to *pay* for those hours if they were not worked, and whether the wording of the clause supported the former interpretation.

Judge Neville found in favour of United Voice, holding that the relevant clause in the enterprise agreement imposed a positive obligation on Serco to roster employees for the minimum guaranteed hours. The Court reasoned that the language of the clause, particularly the phrase "guaranteed a minimum of 30 hours per week," indicated an intention to ensure actual work was provided, not merely a financial entitlement. This interpretation was supported by the context of the agreement as a whole, which aimed to provide stable and predictable employment for the affected workers. Consequently, Serco's failure to roster employees for the minimum hours constituted a breach of the agreement.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Federal Circuit Court of Australia case, United Voice v Serco Sodexo Defence Services Pty Ltd, involves a dispute over the interpretation of the Serco Sodexo Defence Services Pty Ltd Collective Agreement 2011, which is an enterprise agreement under the Fair Work Act 2009. United Voice, a signatory to the agreement and a representative body for certain employees, claims that the agreement distinguishes between "continuous" and "non-continuous" shift workers, providing five weeks of annual leave for continuous shift workers and only four weeks for non-continuous shift workers. United Voice argues that this distinction contravenes the National Employment Standards (NES) and section 87(1)(b)(ii) of the Fair Work Act. Serco Sodexo Defence Services Pty Ltd contends that the agreement is clear, does not contravene the NES or the Act, and that the distinction between the two categories of shift workers is valid and consistent with industrial realities.

The employees in question were employed by Serco Sodexo Defence Services Pty Ltd and worked shifts according to rosters, resulting in their classification as either continuous or non-continuous shift workers under the agreement. The agreement defines a continuous shift worker as someone who continuously works shifts over seven days a week, 24 hours a day, including public holidays and weekends, while a non-continuous shift worker is defined as someone who works on designated day, evening, or night shifts and does not continuously work over seven days a week, 24 hours per day, including public holidays and weekends. The agreement provides that non-continuous shift workers are entitled to four weeks of paid annual leave per year of service, while continuous shift workers are entitled to an additional week of leave, making it five weeks in total.

United Voice argues that the NES, which sets minimum standards for employment, should be interpreted liberally in favour of employees and that the agreement's distinction between continuous and non-continuous shift workers is artificial and discriminatory. Serco Sodexo Defence Services Pty Ltd argues that the agreement's terms are clear, that there is no inconsistency between the agreement and the NES, and that the distinction between the two categories of shift workers is valid and necessary to reflect the different nature of their employment.

The court considered the principles of statutory interpretation, the objects of the Fair Work Act, and relevant case law in determining the proper construction of the agreement and the Fair Work Act. The court found that the agreement's definitions of continuous and non-continuous shift workers were clear and consistent with industrial realities, and that there was no inconsistency between the agreement and the NES or the Fair Work Act. The court also found that the agreement did not reduce any employee's entitlements and that the distinction between the two categories of shift workers was valid and permissible under the Act. Consequently, the court dismissed United Voice's application.

The matter of United Voice v Serco Sodexo Defence Services Pty Ltd came before the Federal Circuit Court of Australia at Canberra as an application seeking judicial determination of the interpretation of particular terms within an enterprise agreement in the context of the National Employment Standards (NES) under the Fair Work Act 2009. The Applicant, United Voice, a signatory to the Serco Sodexo Defence Services Pty Ltd Collective Agreement 2011, argued that the agreement contained an "artificial distinction" between "continuous" and "non-continuous" shift workers, granting the former five weeks of annual leave and the latter only four weeks, contrary to the NES. The Respondent, Serco Sodexo Defence Services Pty Ltd, contended that the agreement's distinctions were neither ambiguous nor repugnant to the NES. The case marked the first judicial examination of section 87(1)(b)(ii) of the Act. The Court considered submissions from both parties, including their interpretations of the agreement and the relevant statutory provisions, and ultimately dismissed the Application, finding no inconsistency between the agreement and the Act or the NES. The Court held that the agreement's distinctions between categories of shiftworkers were permissible under the Act, did not reduce any employee's entitlements, and conformed to the principles of construction and interpretation of both legislation and enterprise agreements.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Are the National Employment Standards socially beneficial legislation such that in the case of ambiguity it should be given a liberal interpretation in favour of employees?
2. In order for the entitlement the subject of the proceedings to flow, must the Enterprise Agreement contain the words "for the purposes of the NES"?
3. Does the 2011 Enterprise Agreement define or describe each of the employees as a shiftworker for the purposes of the NES?
4. In order for the Court to find that the Employees are entitled to 5 weeks' annual leave pursuant to s.87(1)(b)(ii) of the Fair Work Act 2009, must the 2011 Enterprise Agreement contain the express words "for the purposes of the NES" in its definition/description of the Employees?
5. If the Court's answer to question 2 is "no," must the 2011 Enterprise Agreement nonetheless identify, define, or describe the Employees as being shiftworkers who are entitled to 5 weeks annual leave or entitled to the NES shiftworker entitlement in order for the Court to find that the Employees are entitled to 5 weeks' annual leave pursuant to s.87(1)(b)(ii)?
6. In circumstances where an enterprise Agreement, on its terms, distinguishes between classes or categories of shiftworkers and provides that not all shiftworkers covered by the Agreement are entitled to 5 weeks annual leave but restricts that entitlement to a certain class or category of shiftworker, does that enterprise Agreement contravene the Fair Work Act 2009 by failing to provide that all shiftworkers are entitled to 5 weeks annual leave per year of service?

Held
1. Are the National Employment Standards socially beneficial legislation such that in the case of ambiguity it should be given a liberal interpretation in favour of employees?
The court concluded that the National Employment Standards are socially beneficial legislation, but a liberal interpretation in favor of employees is not necessary in this case because the terms of the Fair Work Act are clear and unambiguous. The application was dismissed.

2. In order for the entitlement the subject of the proceedings to flow, must the Enterprise Agreement contain the words "for the purposes of the NES"?
The court concluded that the Enterprise Agreement does not need to contain the words "for the purposes of the NES" for the entitlement to flow. The application was dismissed.

3. Does the 2011 Enterprise Agreement define or describe each of the employees as a shiftworker for the purposes of the NES?
The court concluded that the 2011 Enterprise Agreement does not define or describe each of the employees as a shiftworker for the purposes of the NES. The application was dismissed.

4. In order for the Court to find that the Employees are entitled to 5 weeks' annual leave pursuant to s.87(1)(b)(ii) of the Fair Work Act 2009, must the 2011 Enterprise Agreement contain the express words "for the purposes of the NES" in its definition/description of the Employees?
The court concluded that the 2011 Enterprise Agreement does not need to contain the express words "for the purposes of the NES" in its definition/description of the Employees for the Court to find that the Employees are entitled to 5 weeks' annual leave. The application was dismissed.

5. If the Court's answer to question 2 is "no," must the 2011 Enterprise Agreement nonetheless identify, define, or describe the Employees as being shiftworkers who are entitled to 5 weeks annual leave or entitled to the NES shiftworker entitlement in order for the Court to find that the Employees are entitled to 5 weeks' annual leave pursuant to s.87(1)(b)(ii)?
The court concluded that the 2011 Enterprise Agreement does not need to identify, define, or describe the Employees as being shiftworkers who are entitled to 5 weeks annual leave or entitled to the NES shiftworker entitlement in order for the Court to find that the Employees are entitled to 5 weeks' annual leave. The application was dismissed.

6. In circumstances where an enterprise Agreement, on its terms, distinguishes between classes or categories of shiftworkers and provides that not all shiftworkers covered by the Agreement are entitled to 5 weeks annual leave but restricts that entitlement to a certain class or category of shiftworker, does that enterprise Agreement contravene the Fair Work Act 2009 by failing to provide that all shiftworkers are entitled to 5 weeks annual leave per year of service?
The court concluded that the enterprise Agreement does not contravene the Fair Work Act 2009 by distinguishing between classes or categories of shiftworkers and restricting the entitlement to 5 weeks annual leave to a certain class or category of shiftworker. The application was dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court's reasoning in the case of United Voice v Serco Sodexo Defence Services Pty Ltd centred around the interpretation of the National Employment Standards (NES) and the Fair Work Act 2009. The primary issue was whether the 2011 Enterprise Agreement distinguished between different categories of shiftworkers in a manner that contravened the Act. The Court examined several key issues to determine if the agreement was in breach of the NES and the Act.

First, the Court considered whether the NES should be interpreted liberally in favour of employees in cases of ambiguity. The Court concluded that while the NES are socially beneficial, they should not be given an overly liberal interpretation that rewrites the statute. The Court emphasized that statutory construction must begin with the clear and unambiguous text of the legislation and should not ignore specific wording unless there is a compelling reason to do so.

Second, the Court addressed whether the Enterprise Agreement needed to explicitly state "for the purposes of the NES" to define or describe employees as shiftworkers. The Court held that the words "for the purposes of the NES" in s.87(1)(b)(ii) were deliberately included and must be given proper consideration. The Court found that the agreement did not define or describe each employee as a shiftworker for the purposes of the NES, but rather for the purposes of the agreement itself.

Third, the Court examined whether the 2011 Enterprise Agreement defined or described the employees as shiftworkers for the purposes of the NES. The Court found that the agreement clearly defined two categories of shiftworkers and that these definitions were not ambiguous or illogical. The Court also held that the distinctions made in the agreement did not contravene the NES or the Act.

Fourth, the Court considered whether the absence of the phrase "for the purposes of the NES" in the agreement meant that the employees were not entitled to five weeks of annual leave. The Court ruled that the agreement did not need to contain these specific words, as long as it did not reduce any entitlements or contravene the NES.

Fifth, the Court assessed whether the 2011 Enterprise Agreement had to identify or describe the employees as shiftworkers entitled to five weeks of annual leave or the NES shiftworker entitlement. The Court concluded that the agreement did not need to expressly state that the employees were entitled to five weeks of annual leave, as long as it did not reduce any entitlements and adhered to the Act.

Lastly, the Court addressed whether an enterprise agreement that distinguishes between classes or categories of shiftworkers and provides different annual leave entitlements contravenes the Act. The Court held that such distinctions are permissible under the Act, provided the agreement does not reduce any entitlements or contravene the NES.

In summary, the Court found that the 2011 Enterprise Agreement did not contravene the NES or the Fair Work Act 2009, as it did not reduce any entitlements and was clear and unambiguous in its operation and effect. The Court dismissed the Application and the Statement of Claim in all its iterations.