Turner v George Weston Foods Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL

CITATION:      TURNER v GEORGE WESTON FOODS LTD TRADING AS TIP TOP BAKERIES (NEWCASTLE); TURNER v GEORGE WESTON FOODS LTD [2007]  NSWCA 67

FILE NUMBER(S):
40010/06
40465/06

HEARING DATE(S):               5 March 2007

JUDGMENT DATE: 30 March 2007

PARTIES:
David Jason Turner - Claimant in 40010/06 & 40465/06
George Weston Foods Limited t/as Tip Top Bakeries (Newcastle) - Opponent in 40010/06
George Weston Foods Limited - Opponent in 40465/06

JUDGMENT OF:       Beazley JA Hodgson JA Campbell JA   

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: District Court

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):          530/05

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:     Sidis DCJ

LOWER COURT DATE OF DECISION:    13 & 16 December 2005

COUNSEL:
D J Russell SC - Claimants
L King; P Rickard - Opponents

SOLICITORS:
Sparke Helmore Lawyers - Claimants
Goldbergs Lawyers - Opponents

CATCHWORDS:
WORKERS’ COMPENSATION — Alternative rights against employer and third parties — Where worker recovered compensation from employer — Employer’s statutory entitlement to indemnity from third party responsible for worker’s injuries — Employer’s indemnity limited to damages to which worker would have been entitled had worker sued third party — Quantification of damages to which worker would have been entitled had worker sued third party — Correct date at which to assess those damages  — Workers Compensation Act 1987 s 151Z(1)(d)
COURTS AND JUDGES — Appeals — Leave to appeal — Extension of time for leave to appeal — District Court Act 1973 s 127

LEGISLATION CITED:
District Court Act 1973
Interpretation Act 1987
Limitation Act 1969
Motor Accidents Act 1988
Supreme Court Act 1970
Supreme Court Rules
Worker’s Compensation Act 1987
Workmen’s Compensation Ordinance 1949-1968 (NT)

CASES CITED:
Baker v Willoughby [1970] AC 467
Brisbane South Regional Health Authority v Taylor (1996) 186 CLR 541
Cooper Brookes (Wollongong) Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation (Cth) (1981) 147 CLR 297
Ganter v Whalland (2001) 54 NSWLR 122
Grant v Royal Rehabilitation Centre Sydney (1999) 47 NSWLR 263
Johnson v Perez (1988) 166 CLR 351
Kizbeau Pty Ltd v W G & B Pty Ltd (1995) 184 CLR 281
Nikolaou v Papasavas, Phillips & Co (1989) 166 CLR 394
O’Brien v McKean (1968) 118 CLR 540
South Eastern Sydney Area Health Service v Gadiry & Anor (2002) 54 NSWLR 495
Tickle Industries Pty Ltd v Hann & Anor (1974) 130 CLR 321
Westpac Banking Corporation v Tomassian (1993) 32 NSWLR 207
Willis v The Commonwealth (1946) 73 CLR 105

DECISION:
1.  Extend time to apply for leave to appeal.
2.  Leave to appeal granted.
3.  Appeal dismissed.
4.  Claimant to pay costs of the opponent of the application for leave to appeal and of the appeal.

JUDGMENT:

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COURT OF APPEAL

CA 40010/06
CA 40465/06
DC 530/05

BEAZLEY JA
HODGSON JA
CAMPBELL JA

30 March 2007

DAVID JASON TURNER v GEORGE WESTON FOODS LIMITED T/AS TIP TOP BAKERIES (NEWCASTLE)
DAVID JASON TURNER v GEORGE WESTON FOODS LIMITED

Judgment

  1. BEAZLEY JA:  I agree with Campbell JA.

  2. HODGSON JA:  I agree with the orders…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Turner v George Weston Foods Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] NSWCA 67
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In *Turner v George Weston Foods Ltd*, the Court of Appeal of New South Wales considered an appeal concerning an employer's statutory entitlement to indemnity from a third party responsible for a worker's injuries. The dispute arose from the quantification of damages to which the worker would have been entitled had they sued the third party, and specifically, the correct date at which those damages should be assessed for the purpose of the employer's indemnity claim under section 151Z(1)(d) of the *Workers Compensation Act 1987* (NSW).

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the damages to which a worker would have been entitled, for the purpose of calculating an employer's indemnity under section 151Z(1)(d), should be assessed as at the date of the accident, or at a later date, such as the date of the indemnity proceedings or the date of trial. The claimant argued that other subsections of section 151Z implied a need for damages to be assessed at an earlier point in time, suggesting a similar limitation should apply to section 151Z(1)(d).

The Court of Appeal reasoned that the right to indemnity under section 151Z(1)(d) is a statutory right, distinct from a direct claim for damages by the worker. While the assessed damages serve as an upper limit on the indemnity recoverable by the employer, the actual amount recovered is the employer's compensation payments. The court affirmed the general principle that damages for personal injury are assessed as at the date of trial, citing established authorities. No compelling reason was found to depart from this principle in the context of section 151Z(1)(d), distinguishing it from situations where a worker directly sues a third party or where negligence has prevented such a suit.

The Court of Appeal granted an extension of time for the application for leave to appeal and leave to appeal, but ultimately dismissed the appeal. The claimant was ordered to pay the costs of the opponent for both the application for leave to appeal and the appeal itself.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Extend time to apply for leave to appeal.; 2. Leave to appeal granted.; 3. Appeal dismissed.; 4. Claimant to pay costs of the opponent of the application for leave to appeal and of the appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

By comparison, the right under section 151Z(1)(d) is a statutory right to indemnity, not itself a claim for damages: Westpac Banking Corporation v Tomassian (1993) 32 NSWLR 207 at 209 per Kirby A-CJ, 215-6 per Mahoney JA, 220 per Meagher JA. Such an action for indemnity can be (and frequently is) brought in circumstances where the worker in question has not sued the person who is liable to pay the damages of which section 151Z(1)(d) talks. Indeed, such an action for indemnity can be brought in circumstances where the worker in question never had the slightest intention of suing the person who is liable to pay those damages. The assessment of damages that is made for the purpose of an action under section 151Z(1)(d) is an essential part of the calculation of the amount of the indemnity to which the person by whom the compensation was paid is entitled, in the sense that the total amount for which indemnity is ordered can never exceed that amount of damages. But, subject to that upper limit, it is the amount of the employer’s payments of compensation that is recovered by the action. Thus, an assessment of the damages that the worker would have got at some earlier time is not an essential part of the proof of the cause of action of the plaintiff in the section 151Z(1)(d) action, in a way analogous to that in which proof of the damages that the plaintiff would have got if litigation he wished to bring against a third party had been tried is an essential part of proof of the cause of action of a plaintiff against a solicitor whose negligence has caused that action against the third party to be incapable of being tried. Further, the damages that are being assessed in the section 151Z(1)(d) action are damages that would be awarded in an action for personal injury. Prima facie, damages for personal injury are assessed as at the date of the trial: O’Brien v McKean (1968) 118 CLR 540 at 545; Baker v Willoughby [1970] AC 467 at 490-491, 496; Luntz, Assessment of Damages for Personal Injury and Death: General Principles (LexisNexis Butterworths 2006) para [4.8]. No reason has been shown to depart from that usual practice in the present case.The Claimant’s Arguments – Construe s.151Z(1) as a Whole The second argument that the claimant puts forward is that section 151Z(1) needs to be construed as a whole. Section 151Z(1)(a) has application only when the worker in question actually takes proceedings against the person liable to pay damages. For the reasons given in para [27] above, any such proceedings would need to be commenced within 3½ years of the accident, unless the court gave leave for them to be commenced later, and so would be likely to result in an assessment of damages being made considerably earlier than 14 years after the date of the accident. The argument continues by observing that section 151Z(1)(b) and (c) each apply only if the worker “recovers” damages from the tortfeasor. As section 151Z(5) makes clear, that situation could arise if either the worker sued, or if the worker received damages through a settlement or other out-of-court arrangement. Even so, it is still likely that any damages so “recovered” would be either assessed by a court, or determined through settlement or agreement, earlier than 14 years after the accident. A similar limitation should, the claimant submits, be imposed upon the damages recoverable under section 151Z(1)(d).