Turba Trium Pty Ltd v First Mortgage Capital Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Turba Trium Pty Ltd v First Mortgage Capital Pty Ltd [2021] QCA 100

PARTIES:

TURBA TRIUM PTY LTD
ACN 629 837 994
(appellant)
v
FIRST MORTGAGE CAPITAL PTY LTD
ACN 150 210 736
(respondent)

FILE NO/S:

Appeal No 11841 of 2020
SC No 6650 of 2020

DIVISION:

Court of Appeal

PROCEEDING:

General Civil Appeal

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane – Unreported, 8 October 2020 (Bond J)

DELIVERED ON:

11 May 2021

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

19 April 2021

JUDGES:

McMurdo and Mullins JJA and Bradley J

ORDER:

Appeal dismissed with costs to be assessed on the indemnity basis.

CATCHWORDS:

MORTGAGES – MORTGAGEE’S REMEDIES – POSSESSION – UNDER CLAUSE ENTITLING MORTGAGEE TO POSSESSION UPON DEFAULT OF MORTGAGOR – where the appellant stopped paying the monthly interest payments of a registered mortgage and failed to repay the principal when due – where the respondent exercised its rights pursuant to the terms of the mortgage and Property Law Act 1974 (Qld) and sought recovery of possession of the land – where the learned primary judge awarded the respondent summary judgment to recover possession of the land – whether the respondent had a valid claim to recover possession – whether the mortgage document was defective

PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – COSTS – INDEMNITY COSTS – PARTICULAR CASES – where the respondent was successful in its application for summary judgment – where the learned primary judge ordered the appellant pay the respondent’s costs of the proceeding on the indemnity basis pursuant to the terms agreed by the parties – whether the court ought to exercise its discretion to reflect such a contractual right

Property Law Act 1974 (Qld), s 84
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld), r 292

Platinum United II Pty Ltd & Anor v Mortgage Management Ltd (in liq)[2011] QCA 229, cited

COUNSEL:

Director (S P Beard) appeared by leave for the appellant
R A Kipps for the respondent

SOLICITORS:

The appellant was not legally represented
Summer Lawyers for the respondent

  1. McMURDO JA:  I agree with Bradley J.

  2. MULLINS JA:  I agree with Bradley J.

  3. BRADLEY J:  On 8 October 2020, the respondent First Mortgage Capital Pty Ltd (FMC) obtained judgment to recover possession of land at Bray Road, Lawnton (the land) from the appellant Turba Trium Pty Ltd (TTPL) and for TTPL to pay FMC’s costs of the proceeding on the indemnity basis.  The judgment followed a successful application by FMC for summary judgment.  The learned primary judge, who heard the application, found that TTPL had no real prospect of successfully defending against FMC’s claim.

  4. TTPL has appealed against the whole of that decision.

    Summary of the facts

  5. At the relevant time, TTPL had three directors: John William Cini, Shane Peter Beard, and Marcel Ligthart.  Mr Ligthart was also the company secretary.  Each director held ten shares.  In Latin, turba trium means three is a crowd.  To some, this name might have indicated…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Turba Trium Pty Ltd v First Mortgage Capital Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] QCA 100
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal in Turba Trium Pty Ltd v First Mortgage Capital Pty Ltd was brought before the court by TTPL, contesting the decision of the learned primary judge who awarded summary judgment in favour of FMC. The central issue revolved around the validity of the mortgage agreement between TTPL and FMC and whether FMC had the right to seek recovery of possession of the land following TTPL's default in making interest payments and failing to repay the principal amount as agreed. Additionally, the appeal sought to challenge the imposition of indemnity costs against TTPL, as per the terms of the mortgage agreement.

The court considered whether the mortgage document was indeed defective, as claimed by TTPL. It was determined that the registered mortgage was valid and enforceable, despite TTPL's assertion that a separate "Schedule A" document had not been signed by FMC. The court found that TTPL's signing of the "Schedule A" document indicated their agreement to the terms included within it, and the absence of FMC's signature on this document did not invalidate the mortgage. Therefore, the court dismissed TTPL's challenge on this ground.

In addressing the issue of costs, the court noted that the primary judge's decision to award indemnity costs to FMC was in line with the contractual agreement between the parties. The court held that it should generally exercise its discretion to uphold such contractual rights, and therefore found no error in the primary judge's decision. The appeal was dismissed, and costs were to be assessed on the indemnity basis, in accordance with the terms agreed upon by the parties.

**Orders:**

The appeal was dismissed with costs to be assessed on the indemnity basis, as per the contractual terms agreed between TTPL and FMC.

Orders

Orders of the court

Appeal dismissed with costs to be assessed on the indemnity basis.

Background

Background to the litigation

TTPL has appealed against the whole of that decision.Summary of the facts At the relevant time, TTPL had three directors: John William Cini, Shane Peter Beard, and Marcel Ligthart. Mr Ligthart was also the company secretary. Each director held ten shares. In Latin, turba trium means three is a crowd. To some, this name might have indicated that trouble lay ahead. TTPL sought a loan from FMC to complete the purchase of the land. On 28 March 2019, FMC offered to make a 12-month interest-bearing loan of $712,366 to TTPL. The loan was to be used only for the purpose of purchasing the land. It was to be secured by a first registered mortgage over the land, a personal guarantee by each of the three directors, and other charges. FMC made the offer in writing. On 31 March 2019, TTPL accepted FMC’s offer. TTPL did so in writing, signed by its director and secretary, Mr Ligthart. Each of the directors also signed the acceptance document as guarantors of the loan. On 5 April 2019, TTPL executed a mortgage over the land in favour of FMC in registerable form (the mortgage). TTPL executed the mortgage by Mr Cini, a director, and Mr Ligthart, a director and secretary.[1][1]On 3 April 2019, TTPL, by its directors Mr Ligthart and Mr Beard, executed a mortgage in the same terms. However, Mr Beard wrote “All rights reserved” under his signature. This earlier dated instrument was not accepted by FMC and was not registered over the title to the land. On 12 April 2019, FMC’s solicitor signed the mortgage on its behalf. The terms and conditions of the mortgage were those set out in registered standard terms document No 718188316 and the additional terms set out in the mortgage itself under the heading Schedule A. According to the standard terms, if TTPL failed to pay the principal amount advanced or any interest on it, then FMC could take possession of the land and exercise any right or power conferred by the mortgage. The standard terms also provided that TTPL was liable to pay on a full indemnity basis all solicitor’s costs, barrister’s fees and disbursements incurred by FMC in the exercise of any right or power under the mortgage. In Schedule A of the mortgage, an additional term provided that TTPL was to pay interest on the same day each month as the Commencement Date and repay the principal amount to FMC on the day which was 12 months after the Commencement Date. It is common ground that, in the events that have occurred, the Commencement Date was 12 April 2019 and TTPL was to repay the principal amount on 12 April 2020. On 12 April 2019, FMC advanced the loan according to the written direction of TTPL. A representative of FMC attended the settlement of the contract of sale of the land from its former owners to TTPL, and paid $661,219 of the loan funds to the ANZ Bank, in exchange for a release of a mortgage to ANZ that had been registered over the title to the land and $3,781 to the State for government fees. In accordance with TTPL’s written directions, the balance of the loan was paid to FMC for various fees ($18,569) and the first month’s interest on the loan ($9,680), to FMC’s solicitors as a loan documentation fee ($3,445), and to Cashbase as an introducer’s or brokerage fee ($15,672).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

On appeal, the evidence remained as it was before the learned primary judge. It follows that TTPL fails in its challenge to the learned primary judge’s decision on grounds 1, 2, 11 and 12.Whether the evidence established the mortgage was defective On grounds 14 and 15, TTPL submitted that the registered mortgage was “defective and therefore void” because a document headed “Schedule A” had been signed by TTPL and the guarantors, but it had not been signed by FMC. TTPL offered no explanation or authority for this submission. It is plainly wrong. The registered mortgage executed by TTPL and FMC included a Schedule A under the heading additional terms and conditions. This Schedule A included a definition of “Commencement Date” as well as information about the lender, the borrower and the guarantors, the principal amount, interest rates, interest payments and early repayment. TTPL and each of the guarantors signed another document headed “Schedule A” containing the same definition and information as that in Schedule A in the mortgage. By signing this document, TTPL and the guarantors indicated their agreement to the additional terms and conditions to be included in the mortgage. In addition to this separate “Schedule A” document, separate Schedules “B” to “G” were signed by variously TTPL, each of the three guarantors, and their respective solicitors. These documents set out directions for the payment of the principal amount, other directions and authorities, declarations by TTPL and each of the guarantors about having taken advice on the loan and the guarantee, and the solicitors’ certificates of advice to TTPL and to each guarantor on the loan and the guarantee. Unlike the mortgage, none of these schedules, including “Schedule A”, was in the form of an instrument to be registered over the title to the land. FMC exercised its rights as mortgagee under the mortgage registered over the title to the land. The failure of FMC to sign the separate “Schedule A” document had no effect on the effectiveness or the validity of the mortgage. It follows that TTPL fails in its challenge on grounds 14 and 15.Costs of the proceeding TTPL also challenged the costs element of the judgment obtained by FMC. For the reasons set out above, FMC was entitled to summary judgment on its claim. Having failed, TTPL was also liable to pay FMC’s cost of the proceeding. The learned primary judge ordered TTPL to pay those costs on the indemnity basis because that is the bargain agreed between TTPL and FMC in the standard terms in the mortgage. Ordinarily, the court should exercise its discretion to reflect such a contractual right.[3] In the circumstances, there was no error in ordering TTPL to pay FMC’s costs of the proceeding on the indemnity basis.[3] Platinum United II Pty Ltd & Anor v Mortgage Management Ltd (in liq) [2011] QCA 229 at [6].Final Disposition The appeal should be dismissed with costs to be assessed on the indemnity basis. The costs awarded in this court should also accord with the contractual entitlement.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established