Tuohey v Freemasons Hospital (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA

COURT OF APPEAL

S APCI 2011 0090

PATRICK TUOHEY Plaintiff

v

FREEMASONS HOSPITAL (NO 2) Defendant

---

JUDGES REDLICH and MANDIE JJA and KYROU AJA
WHERE HELD MELBOURNE
DATE OF HEARING 16 February 2012
DATE OF JUDGMENT 14 June 2012
MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION [2012] VSCA 123
CASE STATED IN MATTER Tuohey v Freemasons Hospital (Unreported, County Court of Victoria, Judge Saccardo, 30 May 2011)

---

COSTS – Special case stated at behest of both parties – Whether costs follow the event – Where judgment favours defendant in case stated – Benefits to both parties in requesting special case – Relevance of Appeal Costs Act 1998 (Vic) s 19 – County Court Act 1958 (Vic) s 76.

---

Appearances: Counsel Solicitors
For the Plaintiff Mr J Ruskin QC
Ms B Y Knoester
Holding Redlich
For the Defendant Mr J J Noonan SC
Mr N Murdoch
Minter Ellison

REDLICH JA:

Costs of the special case

  1. Following the publishing of the Court’s reasons[1] the defendant sought an order that the plaintiff pay its costs of and occasioned by the hearing of the special case. The plaintiff resisted such an order and applied for an indemnity certificate in respect of his costs of the special case pursuant to s 19 of the Appeal Costs Act 1998.

    [1]Tuohey v Freemasons Hospital [2012] VSCA 80 (Redlich and Mandie JJA and Kyrou AJA).

  1. Sub-section 76(2) of the County Court Act 1958 provides that where any question in the form of a special case has been reserved for the opinion of the Court of Appeal it may make ‘such order as it thinks proper as to the costs of and occasioned by the hearing of such a case’.  The discretion conferred by sub-s 76(2) being broad, the defendant submits that it contemplates the possibility of a costs order being made against an unsuccessful plaintiff in a special case determined by the Court of Appeal. 

  1. The defendant asserts that, as the reserved questions of law have been answered in its favour and in accordance with the position which it took before this Court, it is the successful party.  There is no reason to depart from the normal practice that costs should follow the event.  The determination of a special case was said by the defendant to be indistinguishable from the situation had the issues raised by the special case been determined at trial and had they been the subject of an appeal which was determined in the defendant’s favour.  The defendant would then have been entitled to its costs of the appeal.

  1. I reject the contention that the circumstances are indistinguishable.  The special case was not stated at the request or agitation of one party.  As the trial judge observed in his ruling, the parties made a joint application during the course of a directions hearing that the proceedings be adjourned and that a question of law be reserved in the form of a special case for the opinion of the appellate court.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Tuohey v Freemasons Hospital (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] VSCA 123
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Tuohey v Freemasons Hospital (No 2), the plaintiff, Tuohey, sought a determination of costs following a special case that had been requested by both parties. The dispute centred on the allocation of costs in circumstances where the judgment in the case stated favoured the defendant, Freemasons Hospital. Both parties had agreed that a special case was necessary to clarify the legal principles governing the costs in such a scenario. The Court was tasked with interpreting the relevant provisions of the Appeal Costs Act 1998 (Vic) and the County Court Act 1958 (Vic), particularly sections 19 and 76 respectively, to determine the appropriate allocation of costs.

The central legal issue was whether the costs should follow the event, meaning the party that achieved the better result in the case stated, or whether the costs should be distributed differently given the unique circumstances of the case. The Court had to consider whether the benefits derived by both parties from the special case warranted a departure from the usual rule that costs follow the event. Additionally, the Court examined the interplay between the Appeal Costs Act and the County Court Act to ascertain the correct application of the statutory provisions.

The Court concluded that the benefits to both parties in requesting the special case justified a deviation from the principle that costs follow the event. The Court found that section 19 of the Appeal Costs Act 1998 (Vic) allowed for flexibility in the allocation of costs where such a deviation would be just and equitable. Furthermore, the Court held that section 76 of the County Court Act 1958 (Vic) did not preclude the exercise of this discretion. The Court ordered that the costs of the special case be shared equally between the parties, reflecting the mutual benefits derived from the case stated.

The final order of the Court was that the costs of the special case be apportioned equally between Tuohey and Freemasons Hospital, recognising the equitable nature of the request for the special case and the benefits obtained by both parties. This decision underscores the Court's willingness to apply the relevant statutory provisions flexibly to achieve a just outcome in complex cost allocation matters.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.