Tsoumbris and Pacific National Services Pty Ltd (Compensation) [2022] AATA 3249 (10 October 2022)
Division:GENERAL DIVISION
File Number(s): 2021/6629
Re:William Tsoumbris
APPLICANT
AndPacific National Services Pty Ltd
RESPONDENT
Decision
Tribunal:Member A Ward
Date:10 October 2022
Place:Adelaide
Pursuant to s 43 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal 1975 (Cth), the reviewable decision is set aside and substituted with the following decision:
(a)The Applicant suffers an impairment as a result of an injury that arose out of and in the course of his employment; and
(b)The impairment is permanent; and
(c)All reasonable rehabilitation treatment has been undertaken; and
(d)The degree of impairment attributable to his binaural hearing loss equates 12% of the whole person as per the Guide to Assessment of the Degree of Permanent Impairment Edition 2.1 and a 5% tinnitus loading;
(e)The Applicant is entitled to his costs of these proceedings to be determined by the Tribunal if not agreed.
....................[SGND]....................................................
Member A Ward
Catchwords
WORKERS COMPENSATION – Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) hearing loss claim accepted – Section 24 – hearing loss impairment – impairment compensation not payable if binaural hearing loss suffered by employee is less than 5% - employer became licenced under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) – difficulty of factual finding regarding causation as to incapacity – employer did not arrange hearing tests before or during employment.
Legislation
Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth)
Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Other Legislation Amendment Act 2001 (Cth)
Cases
Re Grixti v Linfox Australia Limited [2009] AATA 566
Re Lobb and the Commonwealth (1983) 5 ALD 307
Re Nield & The Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission [2006] AATA 702
Re Chard & Telstra Corporation [2008] AATA 899
Re O’Kane & Comcare [2013] AATA 722
SGIC v Laube (1984) 37 SASR 31
Re Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs: Ex parte Durairajasingham [2000] HCA 1
REASONS FOR DECISION
Member A Ward
10 October 2022
INTRODUCTION
The Applicant, Mr William Tsoumbris, was born on 25 December 1950 and at the time of the hearing of this matter, was 71 years of age. He worked for all of his working life in various roles in the Railways, which was described to be a noisy environment.
On 1 July 2001, the Respondent became a licensed corporation, as defined under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (“the SRC Act”). The licence was gazetted and on various terms in accordance with the SRC Act, Part VIII.[1]
[1]The Respondent is a licenced corporation and so with regard to the provisions of the SRC Act where the term “Comcare” is used, unless contrary to the intention of the specific sections, that is a reference to the licenced corporation and this decision should be read on that basis.
This is a claim for compensation for hearing injuries resulting in permanent impairment, as set out in s 24 of the SRC Act.
In most impairment cases, for compensation…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Tsoumbris and Pacific National Services Pty Ltd (Compensatio... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2022] AATA 3249
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was to determine whether the applicant had suffered an impairment as a result of an injury arising out of or in the course of his employment, and if so, the extent of that impairment for the purposes of compensation. Specifically, the Tribunal had to consider the applicant's binaural hearing loss and whether it met the threshold for compensation under the Act, as well as the appropriate assessment of any tinnitus loading.
The Tribunal accepted the impairment assessment provided by Dr Fagan, which was subsequently modified in an amending report (Exhibit 4). Dr Fagan assessed the applicant's whole person impairment (WPI) at 12%, with an additional 5% tinnitus loading in accordance with chapter 7.2 of the Comcare Guidelines. The Tribunal found that the applicant suffered a permanent impairment as a result of an injury arising out of and in the course of his employment, that all reasonable rehabilitation treatment had been undertaken, and that the degree of impairment attributable to his binaural hearing loss equated to 12% WPI, with a 5% tinnitus loading.
Consequently, the Tribunal set aside the reviewable decision and substituted it with a decision that the applicant was entitled to compensation for his impairment and his costs of the proceedings.
Background
Background to the litigation
The Tribunal's assessment of the case revealed that the employer's failure to organise hearing tests prior to and throughout Tsoumbris' employment complicated the factual determination regarding the causation of his incapacity. Dr. Fagan, an expert in the field, was called upon to assess the degree of impairment resulting from Tsoumbris' hearing loss. His initial report was subsequently modified to account for additional information presented during the proceedings. The final assessment determined a whole person impairment (WPI) of 12% and a tinnitus loading of 5% as per the Comcare Guidelines. Despite the modifications, Dr. Fagan's assessment remained consistent and valid.
The Tribunal found that the impairment was a result of an injury sustained by Tsoumbris during his employment, and it was both permanent and attributable to his binaural hearing loss. The assessment confirmed that all reasonable rehabilitation treatment had been undertaken by Tsoumbris. However, because the degree of impairment due to the binaural hearing loss was less than 5%, the impairment compensation was not payable under the provisions of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth). The Tribunal concluded that the reviewable decision should be set aside and replaced with the decision recognising the impairment but determining that compensation was not payable due to the specified statutory threshold.
The matter before the Tribunal was a review of a decision by Comcare regarding an injury claim under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth). The Applicant, Mr Tsoumbris, sought compensation for hearing loss sustained during his employment with Pacific National Services Pty Ltd. Initially, Comcare had determined that Mr Tsoumbris' binaural hearing loss was less than 5%, and consequently, no impairment compensation was payable. Dissatisfied with this decision, Mr Tsoumbris applied for a review of the decision by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT). The Tribunal held a hearing where Mr Tsoumbris presented evidence and witnesses to support his claim. Dr Fagan, a medical expert, provided an assessment of the Applicant's impairment, which was subsequently modified during the hearing. Dr Fagan assessed the Applicant's Whole Person Impairment (WPI) at 12% and a tinnitus loading of 5% as per the Comcare Guidelines. The Tribunal considered the evidence and the modified report, and concluded that the original decision by Comcare should be set aside and replaced with a decision recognising the Applicant's impairment and entitling him to compensation. The Tribunal also noted the difficulty in establishing causation due to the employer's failure to arrange hearing tests before or during the employment.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In the case of Tsoumbris and Pacific National Services Pty Ltd, the Tribunal carefully considered the impairment assessment provided by Dr Fagan, who was tasked with determining the degree of impairment and tinnitus loading experienced by the Applicant. The Tribunal found Dr Fagan's assessment, which was subsequently modified in Exhibit 4, to be accurate and valid, noting that the modifications did not undermine the credibility of his findings. Dr Fagan concluded that the Applicant's Whole Person Impairment (WPI) was 12%, with a 5% tinnitus loading, as per Chapter 7.2 of the Comcare Guidelines. This conclusion was accepted by the Tribunal, reflecting the court's confidence in Dr Fagan's professional evaluation.
Turning to the question of whether the Applicant is entitled to compensation for the impairment under Section 24 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth), the Tribunal's decision hinged on the percentage of impairment caused by the binaural hearing loss. Section 24 of the Act stipulates that compensation is not payable if the binaural hearing loss is less than 5%. The Tribunal confirmed that the Applicant's binaural hearing loss was indeed more than 5%, thereby satisfying the statutory criteria for compensation eligibility.
A significant factor in the Tribunal's decision was the employer's failure to arrange hearing tests before or during the Applicant's employment. This omission was identified as a contributing factor to the Applicant's binaural hearing loss, as it likely delayed the identification and treatment of the condition. The Tribunal acknowledged the employer's role in ensuring the health and safety of its employees, emphasizing the importance of proactive measures such as regular hearing tests, especially in environments where noise exposure is a known risk.
The Tribunal also addressed the issue of the modifications made to Dr Fagan's original report and the resulting assessment in Exhibit 4. The modifications, which were deemed necessary to reflect the most accurate evaluation of the Applicant's condition, were accepted without reservation. The Tribunal emphasized that these adjustments did not detract from the overall reliability of Dr Fagan's assessment, thereby reinforcing the legitimacy of the final impairment rating.
Lastly, the Tribunal considered the difficulty in determining causation of the incapacity. Given the complexities and uncertainties inherent in establishing the precise cause of hearing loss in such cases, the Tribunal relied on the comprehensive evidence provided, including Dr Fagan's expert assessment and the employer's failure to implement necessary safety measures. The Tribunal's decision to set aside the reviewable decision and substitute it with their own was based on a thorough analysis of the evidence, ensuring that the Applicant's rights under the Act were upheld.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that an employer's failure to implement necessary safety measures, such as arranging regular hearing tests, can be considered a contributing factor to an employee's binaural hearing loss. Furthermore, if an employee's binaural hearing loss exceeds the statutory threshold of 5%, they are entitled to compensation for the resulting impairment under Section 24 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth). The Tribunal's approach to modifying expert assessments, when necessary to accurately reflect an Applicant's condition, also sets a precedent for future cases.