| WORKERS COMPENSATION COMMISSION | |||||
| DETERMINATION OF APPEAL AGAINST A DECISION OF THE COMMISSION CONSTITUTED BY AN ARBITRATOR | |||||
| CITATION: | Trogami Pty Ltd t/as IGA Supermarket Bourke v McNeil [2013] NSWWCCPD 14 | ||||
| APPELLANT: | Trogami Pty Ltd t/as IGA Supermarket Bourke | ||||
| RESPONDENT: | Peter McNeill | ||||
| INSURER: | Employers Mutual NSW Ltd | ||||
| FILE NUMBER: | A1-10161/11 | ||||
| ARBITRATOR: | Mr J Phillips SC | ||||
| DATE OF ARBITRATOR’S DECISION: | 7 December 2012 | ||||
| DATE OF APPEAL DECISION: | 19 March 2013 | ||||
| SUBJECT MATTER OF DECISION: | Causation; application of the principles in Kooragang Cement Pty Ltd v Bates (1994) 35 NSWLR 452; 10 NSWCCR 796; whether ankle injury resulted from earlier accepted work injury to the thigh | ||||
| PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER: | Deputy President Bill Roche | ||||
| HEARING: | On the papers | ||||
| REPRESENTATION: | Appellant: | Stephen Lee Legal | |||
| Respondent: | Slater & Gordon Lawyers | ||||
ORDERS MADE ON APPEAL: | 1. The Arbitrator’s determination of 7 December 2012 is confirmed. 2. The appellant employer is to pay the respondent worker’s costs of the appeal, as agreed or assessed. | ||||
INTRODUCTION
This appeal concerns the principles in Kooragang Cement Pty Ltd v Bates (1994) 35 NSWLR 452; 10 NSWCCR 796 (Kooragang) and whether an injury to the worker’s right ankle, which occurred when he fell from a veranda at his home in January 2010, resulted from an accepted work injury to his right thigh in 2003.
BACKGROUND
Peter McNeill worked for the appellant employer, Trogami Pty Ltd t/as IGA Supermarket Bourke (Trogami), as a security guard. While attempting to remove a person from the store on 3 January 2003, he was kicked in his right thigh. He attended Bourke District Hospital the same day and subsequently saw several different doctors at the Darling River Medical Centre.
On 14 October 2004, he settled a claim for lump sum compensation in the sum of $3,375 in respect of a 2.7 per cent whole person impairment because of continuing symptoms in his right thigh. The condition of his right thigh has deteriorated and, in July 2008, Dr Bentivoglio, orthopaedic surgeon, assessed him to have a seven per cent whole person impairment.
In late January 2010, Mr McNeill was walking on the veranda at his home when he fell and injured his right ankle. The exact cause of his fall is the subject of debate and is discussed below. His case is that the injury to his thigh in 2003 caused instability in his right knee, which gave way, and caused him to fall and injure his right ankle.
In proceedings commenced in the Commission in November 2011, Mr McNeill claimed lump sum compensation of $21,125 in respect of a 15.3 per cent whole person impairment due to the deterioration in his right thigh and the condition of his right ankle. He withdrew a claim for weekly compensation and an allegation that he had injured his back in a second fall in May 2010.
The appellant disputed liability on the grounds that the fall in January 2010 was unrelated to the 2003 injury, but consented to the claim for additional lump sum compensation for the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Trogami Pty Ltd t/as IGA Supermarket Bourke v McNeil and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2013] NSWWCCPD 14
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered the principles set out in the Kooragang case, which require a causal link between the initial injury and the subsequent injury to be established for compensation claims. The court examined the medical evidence and the sequence of events to determine if there was a causal connection. The employer argued that the ankle injury was unrelated to the thigh injury and was instead caused by a separate incident. The employee, on the other hand, contended that the ankle injury was a direct consequence of the earlier thigh injury, which had affected his mobility and balance.
After thorough consideration of the evidence and the legal principles, the court confirmed the arbitrator's decision. The court found that the ankle injury was indeed connected to the earlier thigh injury, and therefore, the employer was liable for the ankle injury under the workers' compensation legislation. The court emphasised the importance of establishing a causal link between the injuries to determine liability. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed, and the employer was ordered to pay the employee's costs of the appeal.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The Arbitrator’s determination of 7 December 2012 is confirmed.
2. The appellant employer is to pay the respondent worker’s costs of the appeal, as agreed or assessed.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter initially came before an Arbitrator who made a determination in favour of Mr McNeil on 7 December 2012. Trogami Pty Ltd appealed the Arbitrator's decision to the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (NCAT). The appeal was heard by a panel of the NCAT which confirmed the Arbitrator's decision. Trogami Pty Ltd subsequently appealed to the NSW Court of Appeal, which heard the appeal and confirmed the decision of the NCAT.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the Arbitrator's determination that the ankle injury resulted from the earlier accepted work injury to the thigh was correct.
2. Whether the principles in Kooragang Cement Pty Ltd v Bates (1994) 35 NSWLR 452; 10 NSWCCR 796 apply to this case.
Held
1. The court confirmed the Arbitrator's determination that the ankle injury resulted from the earlier accepted work injury to the thigh.
2. The court found that the principles in Kooragang Cement Pty Ltd v Bates (1994) 35 NSWLR 452; 10 NSWCCR 796 do apply to this case.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court first considered the issue of causation regarding the ankle injury. The Arbitrator had determined that the ankle injury was a result of the earlier accepted work injury to the thigh. The court examined the Arbitrator's reasoning and concluded that the Arbitrator correctly applied the principles of causation. The Arbitrator had found that the initial thigh injury led to a chain of events resulting in the ankle injury, which was accepted as a compensable injury. The court confirmed this determination, holding that the Arbitrator's conclusion was correct.
Turning to the second issue, the court addressed whether the principles in Kooragang Cement Pty Ltd v Bates apply to this case. The court noted that the case involved an assessment of whether a subsequent injury was caused by an earlier injury accepted as compensable. The court held that the principles in Kooragang Cement were applicable as they provide a framework for determining causation in such circumstances. The court held that these principles appropriately guided the Arbitrator's decision and should be applied to this case. The binding legal principle established is that in cases of subsequent injuries, the causal link to an earlier accepted injury must be clearly established, and the principles in Kooragang Cement provide the necessary guidance for such determinations.