Trevor John & Associates Pty Ltd
v John Harold Bugg and Andrew Charles Huddy
[2000] SADC 128
Civil
Judge Smith
Introduction
The plaintiff corporation carries on the business of a consulting civil engineer. Its principal, Trevor John, is a qualified civil engineer. The first defendant was, at the times material to this action, a partner in a firm called Rivercity Sheds which operated a business at 31 Princes Highway, Murray Bridge. From these premises, steel framed sheds for domestic, rural and industrial applications were made and sold to the public. The second named defendant, who retired from the partnership in October 1998, was not served and has taken no part in these proceedings. Nothing turns on his absence. Hereinafter I will refer to the first defendant as “the defendant” or Mr Bugg.
In this action, the plaintiff sues the defendant, in contract, on a quantum meruit for professional fees amounting to $42,000, which it alleges, remains owing of a total account of $45,750.00 for professional engineering services rendered between May 1998 and December 1998 described in the plaintiff’s invoice Exhibit P7, inter alia, as:-
consultations;
attendance at meeting at your office;
review of proposed building construction details;
preparation of engineering designs for complete range of domestic, industrial and rural buildings in accordance with the agreed scope of works.
In particular, this work included the preparation of 122 structural designs for the purpose of facilitating Council approval for almost every shed in the range of steel framed sheds likely to be made and sold to the public by the defendant. The defendant agrees that he retained the plaintiff to prepare structural designs, but contends that the terms of engagement required only eight structural designs, which the defendant said was all that was required for his needs as he could use one design for a number of sheds within the range of sheds sold by him.
Amongst the 122 designs prepared by the plaintiff, were seven of the eight designs which the defendant agrees he ordered. Whilst resisting any obligation to pay for the 122 structural designs and the work incidental thereto, the defendant accepts, and has paid for 10. So he has paid $3750 of the total account of $45,750.
The Issue
The sole issue for my determination is to ascertain what was the subject matter of the agreement, or to put it in the building parlance used in the documents in this case, what was “the scope of works” to be carried out by the engineer. In particular, there is no issue as to the reasonableness of the plaintiff’s charges.
The legal parameters
The steps are, firstly, to ascertain the terms of the contract and having done so proceed to construe it; (see Contract Law in Australia 3rd Edition, Carter & Harland at paras 701-703.) The onus is upon the plaintiff to prove, on the balance of probabilities, that the terms of the contract, and its legal effect, are as it contends.
If the parties are at cross purposes, so…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Trevor John & Assoc P/L v John Bugg & Ano No. DCCIV-99-1522 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2000] SADC 128
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court first sought to ascertain the terms of the contract and then proceeded to construe it. It was established that if the parties were at cross purposes, such that after the evidence, the subject of the offer and acceptance remained ambiguous, there would be no proven contract. However, if a party had a view about the subject matter of the contract that did not accord with the intent of the other, this would not necessarily cause the agreement to fail. The court was concerned with the interpretation that would be placed upon the words and actions of the parties by a reasonable person.
The court found that there was ambiguity about the scope of work the subject of the agreement, and it received evidence of circumstances surrounding the contractual negotiations in an attempt to resolve the ambiguity. The court found that there was no consensus ad idem as to the work to be done by TJA, and therefore, the defendant was not liable in contract to pay the reasonable charges of TJA for the work associated with the preparation of 122 structural calculations.
However, the defendant's liability to TJA was not necessarily eclipsed by the finding that the contract was unenforceable. The court found that the defendant had accepted and paid for 14 designs, making him liable to pay TJA $5,000 for the value of the professional services rendered for the preparation of those designs. The court also noted that it would hear the parties as to any interest and costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi