Transport Workers' Union of Australia v Darling Downs Express

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read
[2015] FWC 2658
FAIR WORK COMMISSION

DECISION


Fair Work Act 2009

s.236—Majority support determination

Transport Workers’ Union of Australia
v
Darling Downs Express Transport Pty Ltd
(B2014/1452)

COMMISSIONER SPENCER

BRISBANE, 19 MAY 2015

Application for costs arising out of majority support determination application - s.611 - material did not support a majority support; Applicant sought to further test evidence in support of petition; further material filed - s.236 application withdrawn - initial application and its furtherance not vexatious, not without reasonable cause or no reasonable prospect of success - costs application dismissed.

Introduction

[1] This decision relates to an application for costs made by Darling Downs Express Transport Pty Ltd (DDET/the Employer/the Respondent/the costs Applicant) in relation to an application by the Transport Workers’ Union of Australia (TWU/the Applicant/the costs Respondent) for a determination as to whether there was a majority of employees who wanted to bargain with the Employer, for an agreement. The majority support determination application was made pursuant to s.236 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (the Act). The TWU, after being advised by the Fair Work Commission (FWC/the Commission), that the petition of employees did not represent a majority, sought to confirm the number of employees at that time. The TWU subsequently withdrew their s.236. The Respondent then made an application for costs, pursuant to s.611 of the Act. This decision deals with the application for costs.

[2] The TWU was represented by Ms Margarita Cerrato, industrial officer and DDET was represented by Ms Lisa Oldham, solicitor, of McInnes Wilson Lawyers.

Background

[3] In assessing the costs application, it is necessary to consider the progress of the related s.236 application.

[4] Directions were issued for the filing of material, in relation to the majority support determination application and the material was filed accordingly. The TWU filed a petition, signed by employees, in support of bargaining. This was also provided by the TWU, of their own volition, to DDET. DDET (in correspondence in response to this) offered to provide a list of employees (to the TWU) to be examined with the petition. The TWU foreshadowed that, if the Commission, on comparing the petition and DDET’s list of employees, found there was not a majority in support of bargaining, the TWU would seek a copy of the list, so that they could verify it with their delegates, prior to the matter being finally determined.

[5] The TWU provided the petition to the Commission on 28 November 2014, and they also provided it to the Respondent at this time. The petition included 23 signatures dated from 16 September to 19 September 2014. The Respondent’s solicitor indicated in correspondence to Chambers on 1 December 2014, that she was following up her client in relation to the provision of the outstanding list of employees. There was a subsequent delay associated with the provision of the list of employees by DDET and on 18 December 2014, the Respondent’s solicitor indicated that the list would be provided to the Commission, with a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Transport Workers' Union of Australia v Darling Downs Expres... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] FWC 2658
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Transport Workers' Union of Australia sought costs from the Darling Downs Express in relation to a majority support determination application that was withdrawn. The union had applied to the Fair Work Commission (FWC) for a determination that its members were majority supported in their claim for unfair dismissal. After some initial material was filed, the union sought to further test the evidence in support of its petition. The employer filed further material in response and the union subsequently withdrew its application. The union then applied for costs under section 611 of the Fair Work Act 2009, arguing that the application and its furtherance were not vexatious, had reasonable cause and a reasonable prospect of success.

The FWC considered whether the union's application and its furtherance were vexatious, without reasonable cause or had no reasonable prospect of success. The union argued that the employer's material did not support a majority support determination and that the employer's conduct in filing the material was unreasonable. The employer argued that the union's application and its furtherance were vexatious and without reasonable cause or prospect of success. The FWC found that the union's application and its furtherance were not vexatious, had reasonable cause and a reasonable prospect of success. The employer's conduct in filing the material was not unreasonable, and the union's application and its furtherance did not lack reasonable cause or prospect of success. The FWC dismissed the union's costs application.

The FWC found that the union's application and its furtherance were not vexatious, had reasonable cause and a reasonable prospect of success. The employer's conduct in filing the material was not unreasonable, and the union's application and its furtherance did not lack reasonable cause or prospect of success. The union's costs application was dismissed. The FWC found that the union's application and its furtherance were not vexatious, had reasonable cause and a reasonable prospect of success. The employer's conduct in filing the material was not unreasonable, and the union's application and its furtherance did not lack reasonable cause or prospect of success. The union's costs application was dismissed, and no orders for costs were made.