Transpacific Fish Exports Pty Ltd v Austmarine Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 78 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

TRANSPACIFIC FISH EXPORTS PTY LTD & ORS v AUSTMARINE PTY LTD & ANOR

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Bleby

19 April 2005

CONTRACTS - BUILDING, ENGINEERING AND RELATED CONTRACTS - PERFORMANCE OF WORK - TIME

CONTRACTS - BUILDING, ENGINEERING AND RELATED CONTRACTS - PERFORMANCE OF WORK - REMEDIES FOR BREACH OF CONTRACT - DAMAGES - OTHER MATTERS

TRADE AND COMMERCE - TRADE PRACTICES AND RELATED MATTERS - CONSUMER PROTECTION - MISLEADING, DECEPTIVE OR UNCONSCIONABLE CONDUCT - CHARACTER AND ATTRIBUTES OF CONDUCT - REPRESENTATIONS - AS TO FUTURE MATTERS

Action for damages for breach of contract, misleading and deceptive conduct and false or misleading representations – Contract by defendant to build and install fish holding tanks – Whether implied term that work would not commence until plaintiff complied with condition of contract regarding finance – Whether defendants represented that construction was not conditional upon plaintiffs obtaining finance – Effect of delay by plaintiffs in fulfilling finance condition – Variation of contract as to completion date – Whether representation as to earlier completion – Held no breach of contract, no misleading conduct or actionable misrepresentation – Discussion of claims for losses – Failure of plaintiffs to substantiate losses claimed – Failure of plaintiffs to identify contractual or other relationships between themselves – Action for damages dismissed.

Trade Practices Act 1974 s 52 and s 53, referred to.
Fitzgerald v Masters (1956) 95 CLR 420; Alexander v Cambridge Credit Corporation Ltd (1987) 9 NSWLR 310; Trident General Insurance Co Ltd v McNiece Bros Pty Ltd (1988) 165 CLR 107; March v E & MH Stramare Pty Ltd (1991) 171 CLR 506; Kenny & Good Pty Ltd v MGICA (1992) Ltd (1999) 199 CLR 413; Alfred McAlpine Constructions Ltd v Panatown Ltd [2001] 1 AC 518; Wallera Pty Ltd v CGM Investments Pty Ltd [2003] FCAFC 279, considered.

TRANSPACIFIC FISH EXPORTS PTY LTD & ORS v AUSTMARINE PTY LTD & ANOR
[2005] SASC 147

BLEBY J:

Introduction

  1. The third plaintiff, Barry John Bowyer (“Mr Bowyer”) is a fisherman. For some time he and his brother, the fourth plaintiff Wayne Wilkin Bowyer, had conducted a partnership known as “Lobster Enterprises”. That was a fishing and farming partnership conducted at Robe and Port Lincoln. In 1997 the farm was sold. At all material times Mr Bowyer’s principal activity was conducting the partnership’s lobster fishing activities near Robe.

  2. Mr Bowyer is married to Katrina Bowyer. They are the directors and shareholders of the first plaintiff Transpacific Fish Exports Pty Ltd (“Transpacific”).

  3. Katrina Bowyer was also a director and vice president of the second plaintiff Katrianna Pacific Corporation (“KPC”) which was incorporated in the State of Hawaii in the USA on 3 June 1996. She was also a 30% shareholder in KPC. A Dr Jim Prescott, a US resident, and a business associate of Mr and Mrs Bowyer, was the majority shareholder in order to comply with United States law. KPC was incorporated to obtain…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Transpacific Fish Exports Pty Ltd v Austmarine Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] SASC 147
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Transpacific Fish Exports Pty Ltd initiated legal proceedings against Austmarine Pty Ltd, asserting claims for damages stemming from breaches of contract, misleading and deceptive conduct, and false or misleading representations. The central dispute involved a contract wherein Austmarine agreed to construct and install fish holding tanks for Transpacific. Transpacific alleged that Austmarine breached the contract by not adhering to an implied term that construction would not commence until Transpacific satisfied a financial condition precedent. Additionally, Transpacific claimed that Austmarine misled them into believing that construction was not contingent upon securing finance. Transpacific also contended that Austmarine represented that the construction would be completed by a specific earlier date, which they failed to meet. The case was heard and determined by the court.

The legal issues before the court encompassed whether an implied term existed in the contract that construction could not start until Transpacific met a financial condition. The court had to ascertain whether Austmarine falsely represented that the construction was not dependent on Transpacific securing finance and if Austmarine falsely indicated an earlier completion date. Furthermore, the court needed to determine whether Transpacific suffered any actionable losses due to the alleged breaches and misrepresentations.

In its decision, the court found no breach of contract by Austmarine, as there was insufficient evidence to support Transpacific's claims. The court ruled that Transpacific failed to substantiate the losses they claimed, and their evidence was largely unreliable. The court found that Transpacific's claims for misleading conduct and misrepresentation were also unfounded. Consequently, the court dismissed all claims made by Transpacific against Austmarine. Judgment was entered in favour of Austmarine, dismissing the plaintiffs' claims in their entirety.

Background

Background to the litigation

Transpacific Fish Exports Pty Ltd (the plaintiffs) commenced an action against Austmarine Pty Ltd (the defendants) seeking damages for breach of contract, misleading and deceptive conduct, and false or misleading representations. The plaintiffs sought to recover losses they claimed to have suffered due to delays in the construction and installation of fish holding tanks by the defendants. The plaintiffs, Mr and Mrs Bowyer, were involved in the fishing industry and had entered into a contract with the defendants for the construction and installation of fish holding tanks for use in their fishing operations. The contract specified that the defendants would build and install the tanks and that the plaintiffs would provide the necessary finance for the project before construction commenced. The plaintiffs claimed that the defendants breached the contract by commencing construction before the plaintiffs had provided the required finance. They also alleged that the defendants misled them by representing that the construction was not conditional upon the plaintiffs obtaining finance, and that the defendants made false or misleading representations regarding the completion date of the project. The plaintiffs claimed various losses as a result of these alleged breaches and misrepresentations, including lost fishing opportunities, lost profits, and lost lease payments for the tanks. The defendants denied the allegations and argued that there was no breach of contract, no misleading conduct, and no actionable misrepresentation. They contended that the contract did not require the plaintiffs to provide finance before construction commenced and that any representations made by them regarding the completion date were not misleading or deceptive. The defendants further argued that the plaintiffs had failed to substantiate their claimed losses. The plaintiffs sought to rely on an exception to the general rule that only a party to a contract can recover damages for its own losses. They argued that their case fell within the exception discussed by Lord Clyde in Alfred McAlpine Construction Ltd v Panatown Ltd [2001] 1 AC 518 at 528-531. However, the court found that it was not necessary to resolve this issue, as there was insufficient evidence to support the plaintiffs' claims. The court held that the plaintiffs had failed to establish a breach of contract, misleading conduct, or actionable misrepresentation by the defendants. The plaintiffs' evidence was found to be unreliable and lacking in credibility, with numerous discrepancies between their oral testimony and the documentary evidence. As a result, the plaintiffs' claims for damages were dismissed, and judgment was entered in favour of the defendants.

The case of Transpacific Fish Exports Pty Ltd v Austmarine Pty Ltd originated as an action for damages for breach of contract, misleading and deceptive conduct, and false or misleading representations. The plaintiff, Transpacific Fish Exports Pty Ltd, alleged that the defendant, Austmarine Pty Ltd, breached a contract for the construction and installation of fish holding tanks by not adhering to the agreed timeline and conditions. The case proceeded through a series of procedural steps involving detailed submissions on the nature and existence of contractual obligations and representations made by the defendants. Evidence was presented in the form of documentary material, including tender documents and financial records, as well as witness testimony from the parties involved. The case came before the court on the basis of a trial where both parties presented their respective cases and arguments, with the plaintiff seeking to substantiate claims of losses resulting from delays and misrepresentations by the defendant. The court's decision to dismiss the plaintiff's claims was based on the lack of substantiated evidence regarding the alleged breaches and misrepresentations, along with findings regarding the credibility of the plaintiff's witnesses.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Bowyer Partnership claims losses by virtue of Mr Bowyer not being able to fish in South Australia in 1997, loss of profits by having to engage an alternative and less experienced skipper in South Australia, diminution in value of the tanks, loss of lease payments made to financiers for the tanks and loss of opportunity to use the assets to fund other projects.Nature of the evidence Most of the relevant documentary evidence was contained in three volumes of tender documents admitted as part of the plaintiffs’ case and with the consent of the defendants. They were admitted as evidence of the contents of the documents and of their authorship and as documents from which all proper inferences could be drawn both as to the occurrence of various acts and events referred to in them and as to the sending and receipt of the documents. In addition, further documentary evidence was admitted in respect of discrete aspects of the plaintiffs’ and defendants’ case, including a notebook kept by Mrs Bowyer and Mr Hanrahan’s 1997 diary. In some cases the originals of documents contained in the volumes of tender documents were also tendered, particularly where they were shown to differ from those in the tender documents. For the plaintiffs, both Mr & Mrs Bowyer gave evidence, along with Mr Carr, their accountant, who was allegedly involved in making some of the financial arrangements. Mr Wayne Bowyer was called but could say nothing about the contractual and other negotiations with Mr Hanrahan. He appears merely to have lent his name to the leasing of the tanks at his brother’s request. The plaintiffs also called a Mr Shelley who was experienced in building live fish tanks of various types and who eventually assembled the tanks in Hawaii and commissioned two of them. Mr David Kennedy, an accountant, who spoke to the various trading figures and budgets of the plaintiffs, was called in support of their claim for damages. The only witness for the defendants was Mr Hanrahan. The principal witnesses were Mr & Mrs Bowyer and Mr Hanrahan and, to a lesser extent, Mr Carr.The principal witnesses It is necessary to make some observations and findings concerning the credibility of the principal witnesses, as the success or otherwise of the plaintiffs is highly dependent upon findings as to their credibility. I consider that the oral evidence of Mr & Mrs Bowyer was unreliable. Each attempted to manipulate the truth to suit their own interests and position. Neither impressed me as a witness. In many crucial respects their evidence was not supported by the documents, and in some cases was directly contrary to them. As a result, where their evidence is disputed, I am not prepared to accept the evidence of either of them unless it is corroborated by some undisputed facts or supporting documentary evidence. This creates an obvious difficulty for the plaintiffs, who bear the onus of proof. Apart from their demeanour, a few examples of their evidence will indicate why I take this view. One of the issues in the case is whether the contract provided for the payment of a deposit before commencement of construction of the tanks. The document signed by Mrs Bowyer on behalf of the plaintiffs makes no reference to a deposit, whereas an earlier document which she had been asked to sign did contain such a reference, and referred to a deposit of 40% of the contract price. I find that Mrs Bowyer requested Mr Hanrahan to delete reference to the deposit in the document before she would sign it, knowing full well that a deposit or part payment was required, so she could obtain maximum advantage in obtaining finance for the project from her bank.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Argument was addressed by the plaintiffs that this case fell into the exception to the rule that only a party to the contract can recover damages for its own losses, that exception being of the type discussed by Lord Clyde in Alfred McAlpine Constructions Ltd v Panatown Ltd [2001] 1 AC 518 at 528-531. In the circumstances it is not necessary to resolve the question whether the plaintiffs in this case fall into that exception. There is a singular lack of evidence to disclose how or why the various contractual situations arose. In any event, it could only affect the claim for damages for breach of contract, and I am satisfied that there was no breach of contract by Austmarine. So far as the claims based on misleading conduct are concerned, it is not necessary that a contractual relationship be established for those to succeed. In respect of those claims the plaintiffs fail on other grounds.Conclusion For all these reasons it follows that the plaintiffs’ claims must be dismissed. Judgment must be entered for the defendants on the whole of the plaintiffs’ claim.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court in Transpacific Fish Exports Pty Ltd v Austmarine Pty Ltd considered whether the contract between Transpacific Fish Exports Pty Ltd and Austmarine Pty Ltd implied a term that work would not commence until Transpacific complied with a condition regarding finance. The court examined the terms of the contract and found that there was no express condition precedent that required Transpacific to obtain finance before work commenced. The court held that the contract did not imply such a term and therefore, Austmarine was not required to wait for Transpacific to secure finance before commencing work.

The court also examined whether Austmarine represented that the construction of the fish holding tanks was not conditional upon Transpacific obtaining finance. The court found that Austmarine did not make any representations that would suggest the construction was not conditional upon Transpacific securing finance. The court noted that the evidence indicated that Austmarine was aware of the finance condition and that Transpacific had not fulfilled it before work commenced. The court concluded that Austmarine did not represent that the construction was not conditional upon Transpacific obtaining finance.

The court considered whether Transpacific's delay in fulfilling the finance condition affected the contractual obligations of Austmarine. The court found that Transpacific's delay did not affect Austmarine's obligations to commence and complete the work as per the contract. The court noted that Transpacific's delay in fulfilling the finance condition did not constitute a breach of contract by Austmarine. The court held that Austmarine was not required to wait for Transpacific to secure finance before commencing work and that Transpacific's delay did not affect Austmarine's obligations under the contract.

The court examined whether Austmarine breached the contract by not commencing work as per the implied term, or by making representations that were not aligned with the contract. The court found that Austmarine did not breach the contract by not commencing work as per the implied term, as there was no such implied term. The court also found that Austmarine did not make any representations that were not aligned with the contract. The court held that Austmarine did not breach the contract in any way.

The court considered whether Austmarine's conduct was misleading or deceptive under Australian consumer protection laws, specifically regarding representations about the timing of the completion of the project. The court found that Austmarine's conduct was not misleading or deceptive. The court noted that Austmarine did not make any representations about the timing of the completion of the project and that any representations made were aligned with the contract. The court held that Austmarine's conduct did not constitute misleading or deceptive conduct under Australian consumer protection laws.

The court examined whether Transpacific Fish Exports Pty Ltd could substantiate the losses claimed due to the alleged breach of contract and misleading conduct. The court found that Transpacific could not substantiate the losses claimed. The court noted that the evidence provided by Transpacific was speculative and did not provide a clear link between the alleged breach of contract and misleading conduct and the losses claimed. The court held that Transpacific could not substantiate the losses claimed.

Finally, the court considered whether Transpacific Fish Exports Pty Ltd could identify the contractual or other relationships between themselves and other entities that may be relevant to their claims. The court found that Transpacific could not identify such relationships. The court noted that Transpacific's claims were based on the relationship between Transpacific and Austmarine and that Transpacific did not identify any other relationships that may be relevant to their claims. The court held that Transpacific could not identify the contractual or other relationships between themselves and other entities that may be relevant to their claims.

In conclusion, the court held that Austmarine did not breach the contract or engage in misleading or deceptive conduct. The court found that Transpacific could not substantiate the losses claimed and could not identify the contractual or other relationships between themselves and other entities that may be relevant to their claims. The court dismissed Transpacific's claims for damages for breach of contract, misleading conduct and false or misleading representations. The ratio decidendi of this case is that a party cannot recover damages for breach of contract or misleading conduct if they cannot substantiate the losses claimed or identify the contractual or other relationships between themselves and other entities that may be relevant to their claims.