Townsville Harbour Board v Scottish Shire Line Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read
18 CLR 306

THE TOWNSVILLE HARBOUR BOARD

SCOTTISH SHIRE LINE LIMITED

DEFENDANTS,

ON APPEAL FROM THE SUPREME COURT OF

QUEENSLAND. Harbour Board-Injury to breakwater by ship in charge of pilot-Compulsory

pilotage-Absence of negligence or default on part of owner- - Vis major- Liability of owner-Demurrer-Harbour Boards Act 1892 (Qd.) (56 Vict. No. BRISBANE,

26), secs. 196, 197-Navigation Acts Amendment Act 1911 (Qd.) (2 Geo. V. April 30;

The Harbour Boards Act 1892, sec. 196, provides that " When any injury SYDNEY,

is done by a vessel, or by floating timber, or material, or by any person May 15.

employed about the same, to any part of the works or property of a Harbour Board, the following persons, namely, - (1) the owner of such vessel, floating timber, or material; and, (2) in case the injury IS caused through the wilful act or negligence of the master of such vessel, or of the person having charge of such timber or material, such master or person-shall each be answerable in damages to the Board for the whole injury; but so that a Board shall not be entitled by virtue of this section to recover twice for the same cause of

Sec. 2 of the Navigation Acts Amendment Act 1911 provides as follows:- "(1) No civil remedy shall lie against any pilot in the employment of the Crown as represented by the Government of the State of Queensland for or in respect of any damage or loss occasioned by his negligence or want of skill, or otherwise for any act, default, or omission as a pilot while in charge of any ship or vessel. (2) The Crown as represented by the Government of the State of Queensland shall not be liable for or in respect of any damage or loss occasioned by the negligence or want of skill of any pilot, or otherwise for any act, default, or omission of any pilot while in charge of any ship or

18 CLR 307

By the statement of claim in an action brought by a Harbour Board against the owners of a steamship, the plaintiffs alleged that the steamship had injured a wharf belonging to them, and claimed damages for such injury. The defendants in their defence pleaded that the master of the ship was not exempt from pilotage, and was compelled by law to deliver the steamship into the hands of a duly appointed and qualified pilot, who took sole control and charge of the vessel for the purpose of conducting the same into port; that while in charge of the pilot the steamship struck and injured the wharf, and that the injury was due solely to the acts and defaults of the pilot, and was not due or in any way caused by any default, negligence or want of proper care on the part of the vessel, her owners, master or crew.

Held, on demurrer to the defence, that the owners were not liable for the injuries caused to the wharf by their…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Townsville Harbour Board v Scottish Shire Line Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1914] HCA 33
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Townsville Harbour Board (the Board) appealed to the High Court of Australia from a decision of the Supreme Court of Queensland. The dispute concerned the liability of Scottish Shire Line Ltd. (the owners) for damage caused to the Board's breakwater by the owners' steamship, the Banffshire. The Board claimed damages under section 196 of the Harbour Boards Act 1892 (Qld). The owners' defence was that the ship was under the sole control of a compulsory pilot at the time of the incident, and the damage was caused solely by the pilot's acts or defaults, not by any negligence of the owners, master, or crew.

The legal issues before the High Court were whether the owners of a vessel are liable for damage caused to a Harbour Board's property when the vessel is in the charge of a compulsory pilot, and whether the provisions of the Harbour Boards Act 1892 (Qld) and the Navigation Acts Amendment Act 1911 (Qld) altered the common law position regarding such liability. Specifically, the Court had to determine if section 196 of the Harbour Boards Act 1892 imposed an absolute liability on shipowners for damage caused by their vessels, irrespective of fault, or if it merely provided a procedural mechanism for recovering damages for which someone was already liable at common law.

The High Court, by a majority, affirmed the decision of the Supreme Court of Queensland and dismissed the appeal. Griffith C.J. and Barton J. held that the owners were not liable. They reasoned that section 196 of the Harbour Boards Act 1892, which was substantially similar to section 74 of the English Harbours, Docks and Piers Clauses Act 1847, should be interpreted in light of the House of Lords' decision in *River Wear Commissioners v. Adamson*. This interpretation suggested that the section did not create a new form of absolute liability but rather made owners liable for damage caused by their vessels where someone was already liable at common law. Since the damage was caused by a compulsory pilot, whose employment was mandated by law, the owners were not liable, akin to a situation of *vis major*. They also noted that the *Navigation Acts Amendment Act 1911* (Qld), which removed civil remedies against pilots, did not alter this outcome, as the compulsory nature of pilotage itself relieved the owner of liability. Isaacs J. reached the same conclusion, finding that the provisions of the *Navigation Acts Amendment Act 1911* specifically relieved the owners of liability in this circumstance.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established