SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION: Toula Holdings Pty Ltd & Anor v Lee Turnbull & Co [2023]
QSC 11PARTIES: TOULA HOLDINGS PTY LTD (ACN 059 859 684) (first plaintiff) DANTE (NQ) PTY LTD (ACN 100 998 169) (second plaintiff) v
LEE TURNBULL & CO (A FIRM)(defendant) FILE NO/S:
BS No 10651 of 2019 BS No 12883 of 2022
DIVISION: Trial Division PROCEEDING: Applications ORIGINATING Supreme Court at Brisbane COURT: DELIVERED ON: 13 February 2023 DELIVERED AT: Brisbane HEARING DATE: 16 December 2022 JUDGE: Davis J ORDER:
1. Application BS12883 of 2022 is dismissed. 2. The plaintiffs’ application for leave to proceed in BS10651 of 2019 is dismissed.
3. The plaintiffs’ claim in BS10651 of 2019 is dismissed for
want of prosecution.
4. By 4.00 pm on 20 February 2023 the plaintiffs shall file and serve any written submissions as to why they
should not pay the defendant’s costs of proceedings in
BS10651 of 2019 including their application for leave to
proceed and the defendant’s application to dismiss the
claim, and the costs of BS12883 of 2022.
5. By 4.00 pm on 27 February 2023 the defendant shall file and serve any written submissions on costs.
6. By 4.00 pm on 7 March 2023 each party has leave to file and serve an application for leave to make oral submissions on the question of costs.
7. In the event that no party files an application for leave to make oral submissions on costs by 4.00 pm on 7
March 2023, the question of costs will be determined on
any written submissions filed and without further oral
hearing.
CATCHWORDS:
EQUITY - EQUITABLE REMEDIES - INJUNCTIONS - INTERLOCUTORY INJUNCTIONS - UNDERTAKING AS TO DAMAGES - GENERALLY - where a lessee of premises claimed the lease was void - where the owner of the premises had contracted to sell the premises - where the owner had covenanted to transfer the benefit of the lease to the purchaser - where the lessee sought interlocutory relief enjoining the sale - where solicitors for the owner of the premises advised the
owner to accept “the usual undertaking as to damages” from the lessee - where the trial judge found that the lease was void - where the purchaser of the premises rescinded the contract because the owner could then not transfer the benefit of the lease - where the owner appealed - where the owner was successful on appeal - where the premises was sold below the original contract price - whether the loss flowed from the interlocutory orders - whether the lessee was liable under the
undertaking as to damages - whether the owner’s solicitors were negligent in advising the owner to accept the usual
undertaking as to damagesPROCEDURE - CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS - COURT SUPERVISION - WANT OF PROSECUTION OR LACK OF PROGRESS - where there had been delay of over two years in taking a step in the
proceedings - where the plaintiff sought leave to…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Toula Holdings Pty Ltd v Lee Turnbull & Co and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2023] QSC 11
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues before the court were whether the plaintiffs had a valid cause of action against the defendants, and if the claim had any prospect of success. Additionally, the court needed to determine if the plaintiffs had suffered any significant prejudice due to delay in commencing the proceedings, and whether the defendants had been prejudiced by the length of time it had taken for the plaintiffs to commence the action.
The court found that the plaintiffs' claim had no prospect of success due to the circumstances surrounding the loss and the advice provided by the defendants. The court emphasised that the loss suffered by the plaintiffs was not due to the defendants' undertakings or directions orders, but because the plaintiffs were unable to assign the lease as a result of the lease being declared void. The court also found that any prejudice experienced by the defendants was due to being vexed by proceedings that were unlikely to succeed, rather than any delay in the proceedings. Consequently, the application for leave to proceed was dismissed, and the claim was dismissed for want of prosecution.
The court made the following orders: the application for leave to proceed was dismissed, the application for validation was dismissed, and the claim was dismissed for want of prosecution. The parties were directed to proceed with a submission on costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
1.
Application BS12883 of 2022 is dismissed.
2.
The plaintiffs’ application for leave to proceed in
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The loss suffered by Toula and Dante was not suffered because they gave undertakings on 10 and 18 October 2013; nor was it suffered because North J made directions orders. The loss was suffered because on 30 January 2014, Toula and Dante could not assign the benefit of the lease to Davark. That circumstance was as a result of the fact that North J had declared the lease void. Other discretionary considerations Lee Turnbull & Co point to delay and prejudice as discretionary factors suggesting against the granting of leave to proceed in the claim. Any cause of action probably arose on 30 January 2014 when Davark rescinded the contract. It is at that point that loss was suffered.[28] [28] Wardley Australia v Western Australia (1992) 175 CLR 514. The proceedings were not commenced until 1 October 2019. That is understandable because although the loss was suffered in 2014, it may not have been apparent to Toula and Dante until the judgment of Holmes CJ[29] that the undertakings did not cover the loss. [29] 20 June 2019. The proceedings have not progressed past the filing of an amended statement of claim. In the three years and four months since the filing of the claim, all that seems to otherwise have been achieved is the reregistration of Toula and Dante and the securing of litigation funding. Lee Turnbull & Co point to general prejudice caused by the passage of time and the general inability to properly defend a claim arising from events now almost a decade ago. However, it is unlikely that the facts of the case will be in dispute. There is no doubt that Lee Turnbull & Co were retained. The facts leading up to the giving of the undertakings could hardly be in contest. The real issues are whether it was negligent to advise Toula and Dante to give the undertaking not to settle and to consent to the directions orders based on the undertakings offered by Morgo’s, Morgan and Hassett. Ms Cassimatis, in her affidavit,[30] expresses her complaint in terms of a failure to [30] Court file index no 12 advise. In relation to the giving of the undertaking on 10 October 2013, Ms Cassimatis says: Although no defence has been filed, it would be very surprising if Lee Turnbull & Co asserted that advice was given in the terms that Toula and Dante allege it should have been. This is because, consistently with my earlier analysis, and following the subparagraph numbers in paragraph 2 of Ms Cassimatis’s affidavit: The prejudice which is being suffered by Lee Turnbull & Co is not prejudice caused by delay but rather by being vexed by proceedings which have no prospect of success. Conclusions Toula and Dante’s case has, for the reasons I have explained, no prospect of success. Whatever other discretionary features may or may not be present, there can be no justification for granting leave to proceed in a claim which must fail. The application for leave to proceed is dismissed. For the reasons explained earlier,[35] it follows that the application for validation should be dismissed and the claim should be dismissed for want of prosecution. [35] Paragraph [3] of these reasons.