Toms v. Fuller

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

[2009] QSC 232

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CIVIL JURISDICTION

P LYONS J

No 3234 of 2009

STEPHEN NORMAN TOMS Plaintiff

and

DONALD FULLER Defendant

BRISBANE

..DATE 11/05/2009

ORDER

HIS HONOUR:  The plaintiffs have sued the defendant in

defamation for a number of publications alleged to have been

made by the defendant relating to their role in the

preparation of reports for Australian Agro Agricultural

Company Ltd.  The defendant has filed a conditional Notice of

Intention to Defend which includes a cross-claim.  He now

makes an application for the transfer of the action to the

Federal Court.

The application is based on section 5 subsection 1 of the

Jurisdiction of Courts Cross-Vesting Act 1987. The relevant

provision is found in section 5 subsection 1 paragraph (b).

In essence, it identifies a number of matters to which the

Court is to have regard and, if having done so, the Court is

satisfied that it is more appropriate that the proceedings be

determined by, in this case, the Federal Court, then this

Court must transfer the proceedings to that Court.

The first relevant consideration is whether, in the opinion of

this Court, apart from legislation such as the Cross-Vesting

Act, the relevant proceeding, or a substantial part of the

relevant proceeding, would have been incapable of being

instituted in the Supreme Court and capable of being

instituted in the Federal Court.  The plaintiff's claim is for

defamation.  It is accepted by the defendant that that claim

can be brought in the Supreme Court.

So far as the cross-claim is concerned, it is difficult at

this stage to clearly identify its nature, but it seems to be

a claim which, if maintainable, can be maintained in this

Court.  Indeed, the defendant, in his oral submissions, has

accepted that this Court has jurisdiction to deal with his

cross-claim.

The second matter to which regard is to be had is the extent

to which matters for determination in the action are matters

arising under or involving questions as to the application,

interpretation or validity of a law of the Commonwealth and

not within the jurisdiction of this Court, apart from

jurisdiction under the Courts Cross-Vesting Act or other

similar legislation.  It is clear that the plaintiff’s action

is not based on a law of the Commonwealth.  It is not by any

means clear whether the cross-claim is a cross-claim which is

based on Commonwealth legislation, although it may ultimately

involve questions as to the application, and possibly

interpretation, of a law of the Commonwealth.

The third matter to which regard must be had is the interests

of justice.  In that context, I have been referred to the

decision of the High Court in BHP Billiton Ltd v. Schultz

[2004] 221 Commonwealth Law Reports 400.  That case dealt with

the application of similar legislation from New South Wales

and South Australia.  A number of the members of the Court

made reference to Spilyarda Maritime Corporation and Vancellex

Ltd [1987] AC 460. One of the matters identified…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Toms v. Fuller and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] QSC 232
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Toms v Fuller [2009] QSC 232SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLANDCIVIL JURISDICTION involved the plaintiff, Stephen Norman Toms, suing the defendant, Donald Fuller, for defamation based on several publications that the defendant allegedly made about Toms' role in preparing reports for Australian Agro Agricultural Company Ltd. Fuller filed a conditional Notice of Intention to Defend which included a cross-claim, and subsequently applied for the transfer of the action to the Federal Court. The court considered the application based on section 5 subsection 1 of the Jurisdiction of Courts (Cross-Vesting) Act 1987, which allows for the transfer of proceedings to another court if it is more appropriate for the proceedings to be determined by that court. The court examined the nature of the proceeding, the extent to which matters for determination involved questions as to the application, interpretation or validity of a law of the Commonwealth and the interests of justice. The court found that the plaintiff's action was not based on a law of the Commonwealth and that it was not more appropriate that the proceedings be determined by the Federal Court. Therefore, the application for the transfer of the action to the Federal Court was refused.

In the same case, Fuller sought to join the Australian Securities and Investment Commission as a party to the proceedings. The court examined the rule which regulates joinder of parties and determined that there was no basis for joinder as no relief was sought against the Commission, no issue had been identified which would require the presence of the Commission to enable the Court to adjudicate effectually and completely on any matter in dispute in the proceedings and the presence of the Commission was not desirable, just and convenient to enable the Court to adjudicate on all matters in this action. Therefore, the application for the joinder of the Commission was dismissed.

Lastly, Toms made an application to strike out an amended Conditional Notice of Intention to Defend and Counterclaim filed by Fuller, which included some other material. The court found that Fuller did not have a clear understanding of matters which establish a claim or a defence relevant to the litigation against him or to what he appeared to be attempting to raise by way of counterclaim. The consequence was that there had been little, if any, attention to the need to plead material facts or indeed the other rules of pleading which are set out in the rules. The court proposed to order that the document be struck out together with some earlier documents which it seemed common ground should be struck out but to permit Fuller the opportunity to replead.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.