Pine Rivers Shire Council v Queensland Heritage Council

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read

[2005] QPEC 077

PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT COURT

JUDGE RACKEMANN

P & E Appeal No 1867 of 2003

PINE RIVERS SHIRE COUNCIL Appellant

and

QUEENSLAND HERITAGE COUNCIL

and

HELICOPTER SERVICES PTY LTD

Respondent

Co-Respondent by Election

BRISBANE

..DATE 05/08/2005

JUDGMENT

HIS HONOUR:  In these proceedings the Pine Rivers Shire Council has appealed against a decision of the Queensland Heritage Council to enter the Lakeside International Raceway on the Heritage Register on a permanent basis.  By a document filed on the 23rd of December 2004, Helicopter Services Pty Ltd purported to elect to become a co-respondent to the appeal.

By application filed on 31 May 2005, the appellant applied for declaratory relief and other orders to the effect that Helicopter Services Pty Ltd was not a necessary or proper party and that it be removed as a party to the appeal. 

It would seem from the material and in particular from the affidavit of Mr Sakzewski, that the interest of the so-called co-respondent by election was that it claimed a right to become the owner of some of the land which it thought was part of the listing. 

There are currently proceedings on foot in the Supreme Court pursuant to which Helicopter Services claims a right to become the owner of certain land which is in close proximity to the raceway.  On the hearing of the application however, it was conceded that such land does not, in fact, form part of the land the subject of the decision of the Queensland Heritage Council and that Helicopter Services does not have any right to be a party to the appeal.

Nevertheless Helicopter Services asked to be included as a party pursuant to Rule 69 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules, and in particular, pursuant to Rule 1(b) which provides as follows:

"The Court may at any stage of a proceeding order that -

(b)any of the following persons be included as a party:

(i)a person whose presence before the court is necessary to enable the Court to adjudicate effectually and completely on all matters in dispute in the proceeding;

  1. a person whose presence before the court would be desirable, just and convenient to enable the court to adjudicate effectually and completely on all matters in dispute connected with the proceeding."

In relation to that rule, I was referred to the decision in Macquarie Bank Limited v Fu-Shun Lin and others [2001] QSC 341.

The motivation for Helicopter Services wishing to be a party to the proceedings was explained, in the course of submissions, as the effect which a listing or otherwise of the subject property might have on the future development potential, and hence worth, of the land in respect of which it claims an interest through the Supreme Court proceedings.  It was said that, if the heritage listing were set aside, then it would be more likely that the land upon which the race track sits would be redeveloped for some sort of residential purposes which would, in turn, make it…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Pine Rivers Shire Council v Queensland Heritage Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] QPEC 77
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Pine Rivers Shire Council v Queensland Heritage Council, the Pine Rivers Shire Council appealed against a decision of the Queensland Heritage Council to list the Lakeside International Raceway on the Heritage Register on a permanent basis. Helicopter Services Pty Ltd, which claimed an interest in land adjacent to the raceway, sought to become a co-respondent to the appeal, asserting that its presence was necessary and proper for the adjudication of the issues. The Council opposed the inclusion of Helicopter Services, arguing it was neither a necessary nor proper party to the appeal.

The legal issues before the court were whether Helicopter Services Pty Ltd had the right to be included as a party to the appeal under Rule 69 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules. Specifically, the court needed to determine whether Helicopter Services' presence was necessary to enable the court to adjudicate effectually and completely on all matters in dispute, or whether it was desirable, just, and convenient for the court to consider their interest in the proceedings. The court had to balance the criteria for joinder as outlined in the rules against the specific requirements of the current proceedings.

The court found that Helicopter Services Pty Ltd did not meet the criteria for being a necessary party under Rule 69(1)(i). While the company argued that its lengthy association with the raceway could provide valuable information on its heritage value, this did not meet the standard of necessity required for joinder. Furthermore, the court held that Helicopter Services' interest in the potential development of the land was not sufficient to warrant its inclusion under Rule 69(1)(ii), as its presence was not deemed desirable, just, or convenient for the adjudication of the specific issues in the appeal. The court exercised its discretion against joining Helicopter Services as a party, noting that its application for joinder was not frivolous but rather a procedural error.

The court ultimately made an order that Helicopter Services Pty Ltd be removed as a party to the appeal. In relation to costs, the court decided not to order costs against any party, considering the circumstances surrounding the application for joinder and the procedural misstep taken by Helicopter Services.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established