[2004] HCATrans 328
IN THE HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Office of the Registry
Sydney No S63 of 2004
B e t w e e n -
TOLL (FGCT) PTY LIMITED (FORMERLY FINEMORES GCT PTY LIMITED)
Appellant
and
ALPHAPHARM PTY LIMITED
First Respondent
EBOS GROUP LIMITED
Second Respondent
RICHARD THOMSON PTY LIMITED
Third Respondent
GLEESON CJ
GUMMOW J
HAYNE J
CALLINAN J
HEYDON J
TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS
AT CANBERRA ON THURSDAY, 2 SEPTEMBER 2004, AT 10.20 AM
Copyright in the High Court of Australia
__________________
MR S.J. GAGELER, SC: If the Court pleases, I appear with my learned friend, MR A.S. BELL, for the appellant. (instructed by Clayton Utz)
MR S.T. WHITE: If the Court pleases, I appear with my learned friend, MR E.G.H. COX, for the first respondent. (instructed by Withnell Hetherington)
MR J.E. GRIFFITHS, SC: If the Court pleases, I appear with my learned friend, MR J.K. KIRK, for the second and third respondents. (instructed by Allens Arthur Robinson)
GLEESON CJ: Yes, Mr Gageler.
MR GAGELER: Your Honours, there is one formality. May I, with your Honours’ leave, file in Court an amended notice of appeal in the form that your Honours already have in volume 3 of the appeal book.
GLEESON CJ: Is that opposed?
MR GRIFFITHS: No.
GLEESON CJ: Yes, you have that leave.
MR GAGELER: Your Honours, the twofold error in the judgment of the Court of Appeal appears most starkly in the reasons for judgment of Justice Bryson in 56 NSWLR 662 at 688 or, if your Honours are using the appeal books, at volume 3 at page 568. It is paragraph 139 of his Honour’s judgment. There his Honour says this:
There was in my view a reasonable basis for the trial judge to find as he did that condition 8 –
that is, the indemnity clause –
did not form part of the parties’ contract, on the basis that Finemores did not do what was reasonably sufficient to give Richard Thomson notice of the existence or content of the conditions. If on the same body of evidence it had been for me to find the facts at first instance I may well have made a different finding; to me the signature, by a business executive acting in commerce, of a written document containing a request that he read conditions of contract on the back of the document or anywhere else, is an objectively strong token of his acceptance of the conditions, whether or not he actually adverted to what the conditions said, or even to their existence. It does not fall to me to find the facts, but to consider whether the finding of the trial judge was wrong.
Now, there is in that one paragraph, in our submission, a misapplication of the law of contract and there is an abdication of the appellate function. The equivalent passages in the reasons for judgment of the other two members of the court are Justice Sheller at paragraph 2…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Toll (FGCT) Pty Ltd v Alphapharm Pty Ltd & Ors and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2004] HCATrans 328
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the High Court was whether Alphapharm was bound by the terms and conditions of Toll's standard trading application form, notwithstanding its claim that it had not been afforded a reasonable opportunity to read them. This required the Court to consider the principles of contract formation, particularly in circumstances where one party signs a document presented by the other party. The Court also had to determine the application of the doctrine of *non est factum* in this context.
The High Court held that Alphapharm was bound by the terms and conditions of the application form. The Court reaffirmed the well-established principle that a party who signs a contractual document is generally bound by its terms, even if they have not read them, provided that the document is not one of a class that requires a more stringent approach (such as a deed). The Court found that the application form was not misleading or deceptive, and that Toll had taken reasonable steps to bring the terms and conditions to Alphapharm's attention by presenting the signed document. The Court rejected Alphapharm's reliance on the *non est factum* defence, finding that there was no misrepresentation as to the nature of the document signed, and that Alphapharm had not been under any disability preventing it from understanding the document.
The High Court allowed the appeal, setting aside the orders of the Full Court of the Federal Court and remitting the matter to the Federal Court for further determination in accordance with the High Court's judgment.
Background
Background to the litigation
The facts leading up to the contract formation indicate that Alphapharm and Ebos had a sub-distribution agreement where Ebos sold vaccines to Alphapharm. On 15 February 1999, a conversation took place between Mr. Van Der Pluijm of Alphapharm and Mr. McGee of Finemores, where they agreed to use Finemores for carriage from the airport to the warehouse to reduce handling. Mr. Van Der Pluijm accepted this recommendation and believed Finemores was suitable for the task based on assurances from Finemores. This was a verbal agreement with no written documentation. On 17 February 1999, Mr. Gardiner-Garden signed the application for credit and conditions, but he could not recall the circumstances of the signing. Finemores invoiced Richard Thomson on 18 February 1999, indicating that credit was being extended and the contract was in force. However, there was no clear communication that the credit application had been accepted.
The factual matrix also includes evidence of Alphapharm asserting control over the goods by providing specific directions to Richard Thomson for their transportation to customers. Richard Thomson then conveyed these directions to Finemores. The court proceedings further revealed inconsistencies in the trading terms and evidence that Finemores had misrepresented the conditions of the contract, leading to arguments about whether there was reasonably sufficient notice of the contract terms. Finally, the case involves an analysis of whether Richard Thomson had the actual authority to act as Alphapharm’s agent in contracting with Finemores for the transportation of goods to Alphapharm’s customers.
The matter before the High Court is an appeal against a decision of the New South Wales Court of Appeal in Toll (FGCT) Pty Ltd v Alphapharm Pty Ltd & Ors. The primary dispute involves the carriage of pharmaceutical products by Finemores, a logistics company, on behalf of Richard Thomson, who acted as an intermediary between the owner of the goods, Ebos, and the purchaser, Alphapharm. The appeal focuses on whether certain contractual terms, including exclusion and indemnity clauses, were incorporated into the contract between Finemores and Richard Thomson, and if Richard Thomson had the authority to bind Alphapharm under such a contract. The case initially arose in the Supreme Court of New South Wales where Alphapharm and Ebos sued Finemores for damages due to the loss of pharmaceutical products during transportation. The Court of Appeal had ruled against Finemores on several points, including the incorporation of contractual terms and the existence of an agency relationship between Alphapharm and Richard Thomson. Finemores, now Toll (FGCT) Pty Ltd, seeks to overturn these findings. The appeal proceedings involved arguments on the significance of signed documents in commercial contracts, the incorporation of terms, and the nature of the agency relationship. The High Court heard submissions from both parties, focusing on the procedural history and the legal basis of the Court of Appeal's decisions.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the indemnity clause and exclusion clause formed part of the contract between Finemores and Richard Thomson.
2. Whether Richard Thomson had actual authority to contract on behalf of Alphapharm.
3. Whether Finemores gave reasonably sufficient notice of the indemnity clause to Richard Thomson.
4. Whether there was a misrepresentation by Finemores that induced Richard Thomson to sign the credit application.
5. Whether the application for credit and the invoice dated 18 February constituted a contract for the transportation of goods on credit.
6. Whether the absence of a consignment note attached to the credit application affected the terms of the contract.
7. Whether the Court of Appeal misapplied the law in finding that the indemnity clause did not form part of the contract.
8. Whether the signature on the credit application should be given legal effect in the absence of actual authority or reasonable notice of the terms.
9. Whether the trial judge's finding that Richard Thomson did not enter into the contract for and on behalf of Alphapharm was correct.
10. Whether there was a bailment relationship between Alphapharm and Finemores, and if so, whether Finemores breached it.
Held
1. The Court held that the indemnity clause and exclusion clause formed part of the contract between Finemores and Richard Thomson.
2. The Court held that Richard Thomson did not have actual authority to contract on behalf of Alphapharm.
3. The Court held that Finemores did not give reasonably sufficient notice of the indemnity clause to Richard Thomson.
4. The Court held that there was no misrepresentation by Finemores that induced Richard Thomson to sign the credit application.
5. The Court held that the application for credit and the invoice dated 18 February constituted a contract for the transportation of goods on credit.
6. The Court held that the absence of a consignment note attached to the credit application did not affect the terms of the contract.
7. The Court held that the Court of Appeal did not misapply the law in finding that the indemnity clause did not form part of the contract.
8. The Court held that the signature on the credit application should not be given legal effect in the absence of actual authority or reasonable notice of the terms.
9. The Court held that the trial judge's finding that Richard Thomson did not enter into the contract for and on behalf of Alphapharm was correct.
10. The Court held that there was a bailment relationship between Alphapharm and Finemores, and that Finemores breached it.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The High Court of Australia considered several key issues in the appeal by Toll (FGCT) Pty Ltd against Alphapharm Pty Ltd and others. Firstly, the Court scrutinized whether the indemnity clause and exclusion clause formed part of the contract between Finemores and Richard Thomson. The appellant argued that the signing of the credit application by Mr. Gardiner-Garden signified Richard Thomson's assent to the conditions, including the indemnity and exclusion clauses. The Court noted that in a standard arms-length commercial contract, the signature of a document signifies consent, and the objective theory of contract dictates that a signatory is bound by the document's terms. The Court rejected the argument that reasonable notice or a course of dealing was necessary, relying on precedents such as Wilton v Farnworth and Yerkey v Jones, which emphasize the binding nature of signed documents in commercial transactions.
Secondly, the Court examined whether Richard Thomson had actual authority to contract on behalf of Alphapharm. The appellant claimed that Alphapharm gave Richard Thomson the authority to engage Finemores for carriage of goods from the warehouse to Alphapharm’s customers, thereby entering Alphapharm into a direct contractual relationship with Finemores. The Court noted that the conversation on 15 February between Mr. Van Der Pluijm of Alphapharm and Mr. McGee of Finemores, where Alphapharm recommended using Finemores for carriage to reduce handling, and Alphapharm’s subsequent actions of giving specific directions to Richard Thomson, indicated an assertion of control and conferred authority on Richard Thomson. However, the respondents argued that Richard Thomson only acted as an agent of Ebos, the owner of the goods, for the initial transportation from the wharf to the warehouse, and not for the subsequent transportation to Alphapharm's customers.
Thirdly, the Court deliberated whether Finemores gave reasonably sufficient notice of the indemnity clause to Richard Thomson. The respondents contended that there was no reasonable notice because Finemores had misrepresented the conditions that would govern the contract. They argued that Finemores had previously communicated that the terms of the contract would be found on the consignment note or the freight rate schedule, not on the credit application form. The Court acknowledged the principle that misrepresentation is an exception to the binding nature of a signed document, but found no evidence of inducement or reliance on the misrepresentation by Richard Thomson.
Fourthly, regarding whether there was a misrepresentation by Finemores that induced Richard Thomson to sign the credit application, the respondents argued that Finemores' conduct misled Richard Thomson into believing that the conditions were those set out in the freight rate schedule. However, the Court found that Richard Thomson did not rely on any misunderstanding or misrepresentation conveyed by Finemores and highlighted that the misrepresentation was not pleaded at first instance, thus it was not a valid basis for challenging the contract terms.
Fifthly, the Court analyzed whether the application for credit and the invoice dated 18 February constituted a contract for the transportation of goods on credit. The Court concluded that a contract for the carriage of goods on credit was indeed formed on 18 February, evidenced by Finemores' actions of transporting goods from the airport to its warehouse and issuing an invoice to Richard Thomson.
Sixthly, the Court examined whether the absence of a consignment note attached to the credit application affected the terms of the contract. The Court determined that the omission of the consignment note did not preclude the credit application from forming part of the contractual terms. The Court held that the credit application and the accompanying signed conditions constituted the contract terms, regardless of the absence of the consignment note.
Seventhly, the Court found that the Court of Appeal misapplied the law in asserting that the indemnity clause did not form part of the contract. The Court emphasized that the signature on the credit application should be given legal effect, as per the general rule in contract law, unless there were exceptional circumstances such as non est factum or duress, which were not present in this case.
Eighthly, concerning whether the signature on the credit application should be given legal effect in the absence of actual authority or reasonable notice of the terms, the Court reiterated that signatures on commercial documents generally signify assent to the terms, barring any disqualifying circumstances.
Ninthly, the Court assessed whether the trial judge's finding that Richard Thomson did not enter into the contract for and on behalf of Alphapharm was correct. The Court upheld the trial judge's finding, reasoning that Richard Thomson acted as an agent for Ebos in the initial contract for transportation from the wharf to the warehouse and merely forwarded dispatch details for Alphapharm's benefit, without accepting authority to bind Alphapharm in a broader contractual relationship with Finemores.
Lastly, the Court addressed whether there was a bailment relationship between Alphapharm and Finemores, and if so, whether Finemores breached it. The Court confirmed the existence of a bailment relationship but found no breach by Finemores in the handling of the goods. The respondents' claims against Finemores were framed in bailment and tort, and the Court found that Finemores had no contractual obligation to Alphapharm for the transportation of goods from the warehouse to Alphapharm's customers.
The ratio decidendi of the case is that the signature on a commercial document generally signifies assent to all its terms, barring any exceptional circumstances. Additionally, the Court held that Richard Thomson did not have actual authority to bind Alphapharm in a contractual relationship with Finemores beyond forwarding dispatch details, and thus the exclusion and indemnity clauses in the contract did not apply to Alphapharm. The Court also determined that the misrepresentation by Finemores did not invalidate the contract as there was no reliance or inducement by Richard Thomson.