Tohu and Minister, Immigration and Border Protection (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

Tohu and Minister, Immigration and Border Protection (Migration) [2017] AATA 2710 (19 December 2017)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:2017/6108           

Re:Manuel Tohu  

APPLICANT

Minister, Immigration and Border ProtectionAnd  

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Dr L Bygrave, Member  

Date:19 December 2017

Place:Sydney

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

.......................[sgd].................................................

Dr L Bygrave, Member


CATCHWORDS

IMMIGRATION – Class TY Subclass 444 Special Category (Temporary) visa – whether the delegate’s decision to cancel the applicant’s visa should be revoked under section 501CA(4) of the Migration Act 1958 – the applicant does not pass the character test – substantial criminal record – there is no other reason why the original decision should be revoked – decision affirmed

LEGISLATION

Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ss 499, 501, 501CA

Direction No. 65 – Visa refusal and cancellation under s 501 and revocation of a mandatory cancellation of a visa under s 501CA

CASES

Anaki and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2016] AATA 693

Do and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2016] AATA 390

REASONS FOR DECISION

19 December 2017 

INTRODUCTION

  1. The applicant, Mr Manuel Tohu, is a citizen of New Zealand. He arrived in Australia on 4 December 1994 and was granted a Class TY Subclass 444 Special Category (Temporary) visa.

  2. The applicant’s visa was mandatorily cancelled under section 501(3A) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (the Act) on 18 May 2017 on the basis that he did not pass the character test because he had been sentenced to a term of imprisonment of 12 months or more and therefore had a ‘substantial criminal record’ as defined in section 501(7) of the Act.

  3. On 30 May 2017, the applicant made representations seeking revocation of the mandatory visa cancellation decision under subsection 501CA(4)(a) of the Act.

  4. The Minister’s delegate decided on 6 October 2017 not to revoke the cancellation decision and, on 13 October 2017, the applicant lodged an application with the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal) seeking a review of this decision.

  5. The matter was heard in Sydney on 7 December 2017. The applicant attended the hearing and gave evidence by videoconference from Christmas Island. He did not have legal representation.

    BACKGROUND

  6. The applicant was born in New Zealand in 1980. His father passed away and he moved to Australia when he was 14 years old. He lived with his mother and attended high school until year 10. The applicant told the Tribunal his mother remarried and he has younger step-sisters.

  7. After leaving school, the applicant was employed in casual labouring jobs in the construction industry, and he has worked as a factory worker and a tree-lopper.

  8. The applicant commenced a relationship with his ex-partner when they were 15 years old and they have seven children together. Their children were born between 1997 and 2008. The applicant and his ex-partner separated in 2008 but have maintained communication and a relationship because of their children.

  9. The applicant has never returned to New Zealand.

    Criminal record

  10. The applicant’s National Police Certificate dated 24…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Tohu and Minister, Immigration and Border Protection (Migrat... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] AATA 2710
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by the applicant, who held a Class TY Subclass 444 Special Category (Temporary) visa, to have the delegate's decision to cancel his visa revoked under section 501CA(4) of the *Migration Act 1958*. The applicant did not pass the character test due to a substantial criminal record, and the Tribunal was required to determine if there was any other reason why the original decision to cancel his visa should be revoked.

The Tribunal was required to consider the primary considerations under the relevant Direction, specifically the protection of the Australian community, the best interests of minor children in Australia, and any other substantial grounds. The applicant’s criminal record, which included 44 offences between 1999 and 2014, with convictions for serious offences such as aggravated break and enter, supply of prohibited drugs, assault occasioning actual bodily harm, aggravated robbery, and robbery in company, was a significant factor. The Tribunal also had to assess the strength, nature, and duration of the applicant's ties to Australia and the impediments to his removal to New Zealand, where he had not lived since the age of 14.

The Tribunal found that the seriousness and violence of the applicant's crimes over a long period weighed heavily against revoking the cancellation decision, as the Australian community would have limited consideration for his behaviour. While the best interests of his seven children, five of whom were under 18, were considered, and their statements indicated the traumatic impact of his potential removal, the Tribunal noted that the children could maintain contact by telephone and that future visits might be possible. The Tribunal also considered the applicant's ties to Australia, including his relationship with his children and his mother, but found these "other considerations" carried low weight and did not outweigh the primary considerations.

On balance, the Tribunal concluded that the protection of the Australian community weighed heavily against revoking the cancellation decision. Therefore, the Tribunal affirmed the delegate's decision to cancel the applicant's visa.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The matter was heard in Sydney on 7 December 2017. The applicant attended the hearing and gave evidence by videoconference from Christmas Island. He did not have legal representation.BACKGROUND The applicant was born in New Zealand in 1980. His father passed away and he moved to Australia when he was 14 years old. He lived with his mother and attended high school until year 10. The applicant told the Tribunal his mother remarried and he has younger step-sisters. After leaving school, the applicant was employed in casual labouring jobs in the construction industry, and he has worked as a factory worker and a tree-lopper. The applicant commenced a relationship with his ex-partner when they were 15 years old and they have seven children together. Their children were born between 1997 and 2008. The applicant and his ex-partner separated in 2008 but have maintained communication and a relationship because of their children. The applicant has never returned to New Zealand.Criminal record The applicant’s National Police Certificate dated 24 May 2017 shows he has been convicted of 44 offences between 1999 and 2014. These include the following criminal offences:·2 June 2004 – conviction in Campbelltown District Court: aggravated break and enter, and commit serious indictable offence-in company, imprisonment for 21 months.·13 August 2004 – conviction in Campbelltown Local Court: shoplifting value <=$2000-t2, imprisonment 4 months.·25 October 2004 – conviction in Campbelltown Local Court: common assault-t2, imprisonment 1 month.·16 May 2005 – conviction in Liverpool Local Court: supply a prohibited drug, imprisonment 16 months.·17 June 2005 – conviction in Burwood Local Court: shoplifting value <=$2000-t2, imprisonment 2 months.·4 August 2005 – conviction in Campbelltown District Court: supply a prohibited drug, conviction confirmed in lieu imprisonment.·22 August 2006 – conviction in Bankstown Local Court: goods in personal custody suspected being stolen (not m/v), imprisonment 4 months.·10 October 2006 – conviction in Bankstown Local Court: use etc offensive weapon to prevent lawful detention etc-t1, imprisonment 18 months; break and enter building (steal) value <= $15000-t1, imprisonment 9 months.·22 October 2010 – conviction in Sydney District Court: assault occasioning actual bodily harm-t2, imprisonment 6 months; assault occasioning actual bodily harm-t2, imprisonment 6 months; assault occasioning actual bodily harm-t2, imprisonment 6 months; aggravated robbery-si, imprisonment 2 years 10 months.·9 December 2014 – conviction in Parramatta District Court: robbery in company, imprisonment (aggregate) 4 years; robbery in company, imprisonment (aggregate) 4 years; assault with intent to rob in company-si.[1][1] Exhibit G, G4, pp 18-22. The applicant’s record of traffic and road offences includes driving while never licensed, driving while disqualified from holding a license, using an unregistered motor vehicle and using an uninsured motor vehicle.[2][2] Exhibit G, G4, pp 18-21.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

On balance, I find that the protection of the Australian community weighs heavily against revoking the cancellation decision.The best interests of minor children in Australia affected by the decision Clause 13.2(4) of the Direction sets out the factors that the Tribunal must consider in relation to whether revoking the cancellation decision is, or is not, in the best interests of a child affected by the decision. Relevant to this matter are the nature and duration of the relationship, the extent to which the applicant is likely to play a positive parental role, the likely effect any separation would have on the child, and whether there are other persons who already fulfil a parental role. The applicant has seven children with his ex-partner. The eldest children are aged 19 years old and 20 years old. The younger five children are aged between 17 years old and nine years old. The applicant told the Tribunal all of his seven children reside full-time in Australia with their mother. I must consider the best interests of the five children who are under the age of 18 years. The applicant’s personal circumstances form dated 29 July 2017 set out:The relationship and future life with my children are very love [sic] and caring. I am very proud as a father to have them in my life. Children need their father’s and I intend to be a good father who will put them first and encourage them to live a meaningful and positive life…The impact that it [visa cancellation] will have on my children would be traumatic and I will lose the bond and relationship I have had with them. I talk with them every day on the phone.[13][13] Exhibit G, G10, p 69. The applicant’s ex-partner also provided a written statement dated 30 May 2017 and briefly gave evidence at the Tribunal hearing. She wrote that the applicant:…has contact with the kids. If he is deported neither me or him have any money to fund trips to visit their father. If he is deported this will have a great impact on our children… I belive [sic] in the best interest [sic] of our children that he remains here instead of been [sic] deported… It will have a massive impact on our family life.[14][14] Exhibit G, G11, p 75. At the Tribunal hearing, the applicant’s ex-partner said she was aware of why he was in prison and is currently in detention, and confirmed that the applicant’s criminal behaviour was the reason for their separation as a couple. Nonetheless, she emphasised the applicant’s role as the father of her children and explained the younger children were looking forward to their father being released and coming home. The applicant’s eldest daughter, who is 20 years old, filed a written statement on 1 December 2017.[15] The statement is thoughtful and supportive of the applicant as a father, and expresses his children’s desire for him to be released from custody. His daughter wrote that the youngest four children have had a hard time understanding about their father being in prison and potentially being deported from Australia, and this has affected their behaviour. In particular, she noted her youngest sibling has sometimes displayed aggressive behaviour that was ‘more or less from the heart’ because he wanted to be with his father; and her second youngest sibling has a health issue and suffers from being bullied at school due to an absent father. Her third youngest sibling has experienced problems with the law because he ‘doesn’t have that sense of direction or someone to be that great fatherly role model…’.[15] Exhibit A3.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

I am certain the Australian community would have limited consideration for the applicant’s behaviour given the seriousness and violence of his crimes over a long period of time. On balance, I am satisfied the third primary consideration counts against revoking the mandatory cancellation under section 501CA of the Act.Other considerations While the primary considerations carry particular weight, the Direction acknowledges at clause 14 that other considerations must be taken into account where relevant. There are no international non-refoulement obligations in this matter. The Tribunal was not provided with any evidence about the impact of the applicant’s removal on any Australian business interests. There is no evidence of any impact on victims from the applicant’s criminal behaviour. I now consider the strength, nature and duration of the applicant’s ties to Australia and the extent of impediments if he is removed to New Zealand. As set out in paragraphs 46 to 53, the applicant is the father to seven children with his ex-partner; his ex-partner and their children reside in Australia. The applicant told the Tribunal it will be ‘devastating’ and ‘sad’ for his children if he is removed from Australia. This view is supported by written statements from the applicant’s daughter and his ex-partner. In a personal circumstances form on 2 October 2017, the applicant noted his mother resides in Australia. The applicant told the Tribunal he last spoke with his mother four weeks prior to the hearing, that she has remarried in Australia and he has younger step-sisters. There is no other information before the Tribunal regarding the applicant’s family. At the Tribunal hearing, the applicant said he left New Zealand when he was 14 years old and has never returned; he knows no one in New Zealand. I find that consideration of the applicant’s ties to Australia weigh in his favour. The impediments to removing the applicant from Australia rely on his separation from his children. He has no medical conditions that could not be treated within the New Zealand health system. There is no information before the Tribunal that he would not be able to live and work in New Zealand. While I am satisfied the applicant’s removal from Australia would be difficult for his children, I note they would be able to continue speaking regularly by telephone as they have done for many years while he was in jail. I also note that, while the family’s current financial situation prevents their travel to New Zealand, the applicant’s children may be able to fly to visit him in the future. Apart from separation from his children, I find that there are no other substantial impediments that would prevent the applicant commencing a life in New Zealand.CONCLUSION I have already indicated the first and third primary considerations weigh strongly against the applicant. The second primary consideration weighs for the applicant. In regard to the other considerations, the applicant’s ties to Australia weigh in his favour and the impediments weigh against him. However, the weight I must give these other considerations is low and they do not outweigh the primary considerations.