Anaki and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read

Anaki and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Migration) [2016] AATA 693 (8 September 2016)

Division

General Division

File Number

2016/0586

Re

Edward Anaki

APPLICANT

And

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Mr S. Webb, Member

Date 8 September 2016
Place Perth

The decision under review is set aside. The decision cancelling Mr Anaki’s visa is revoked under s 510CA(4) of the Migration Act 1958.

...........[Sgd].............................................................

Mr S. Webb, Member

CATCHWORDS

IMMIGRATION – mandatory visa cancellation – discretion to revoke – substantial criminal record  –  character test not satisfied – discretion to revoke visa cancellation if another reason  – primary and other considerations – decision set aside

LEGISLATION

Migration Act 1958, ss 499, 501, 501CA

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Direction No. 65 – Visa refusal and cancellation under s 501 and revocation of mandatory cancellation of a visa under s 501CA

REASONS FOR DECISION

Mr S. Webb, Member

8 September 2016

  1. Edward Anaki is a New Zealand citizen who has been living in Australia for most of his life. He has been convicted of a number of offences and he has served terms of imprisonment. This resulted in cancellation of his visa. Mr Anaki made representations to the Minister, seeking revocation of the visa cancellation. A delegate of the Minister decided not to exercise discretion to do so. Mr Anaki has applied for review of this decision.

  2. This case requires more than a cursory assessment of Mr Anaki’s record might suggest. On consideration of a criminal history involving numerous convictions spread over more than 29 years, one might presume the cancellation of his visa should not be revoked. But presumption is not the standard against which measure is to be made. The measure, so helpfully set out in the Minister’s Direction, requires close examination of the facts and the evidence, weighing the seriousness of crimes Mr Anaki has committed, and the risk he poses to the Australian community, with what that community might expect be done in respect of his privileged presence in Australia on trust of lawful obedience when that trust has, so often and despite formal warning, been breached.

    Background facts

  3. Mr Anaki is a New Zealand citizen of Samoan extraction. He is 46 years of age.

  4. He first arrived in Australia as a 16 year old child. He has spent most of his life in Australia. Most recently, on 27 August 2007, Mr Anaki re-entered Australia after visiting New Zealand for his mother’s funeral. He was granted a Class TY Subclass 444 Special Category (Temporary) visa, allowing him to stay indefinitely in Australia.

  5. Many years ago he became addicted to heroin, although I am unable to determine precisely when this occurred. His subsequent history, over the last 10 years at least, is that of a wayward, homeless, sometimes desperate man, committing offences in the grip of chronic addiction and unemployment.

  6. He has a lengthy criminal record. Over a 29 year period, he has been convicted of 127 criminal offences, 81 of which involved drug offences.[1] Mr…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Anaki and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Mi... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] AATA 693
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Mr Anaki to revoke the mandatory cancellation of his visa, which had been imposed by the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection due to Mr Anaki failing to satisfy the character test. Mr Anaki, a New Zealand citizen, had resided in Australia for most of his life and possessed a substantial criminal record spanning over 29 years, involving 127 convictions, many of which were drug-related. The Tribunal was required to consider whether to exercise its discretion to revoke the cancellation, weighing the seriousness of Mr Anaki's offending against other relevant considerations.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether the discretion to revoke the mandatory visa cancellation should be exercised in Mr Anaki's favour. This required a careful assessment of the "primary considerations" and "other considerations" as outlined in the Minister's Direction. The Tribunal had to determine if the seriousness of Mr Anaki's criminal history and the risk he posed to the Australian community were outweighed by factors such as his ties to Australia and any other relevant circumstances. The Tribunal was also tasked with considering the expectation of the Australian community regarding the consequences of repeated breaches of trust by individuals granted the privilege of residing in Australia.

In reaching its decision, the Tribunal acknowledged the significant length and nature of Mr Anaki's criminal record, noting that his offending had continued despite a formal warning issued in 2009. However, the Tribunal found that while Mr Anaki's conduct had tested the limits of tolerance, it had not yet been exceeded. The Tribunal gave considerable weight to Mr Anaki's extensive ties to Australia, having lived there since childhood and with all his immediate family residing in the country. Despite some reservations about the closeness of recent family relationships, the Tribunal concluded that these ties, along with other considerations, tipped the balance marginally in favour of revocation. The Tribunal ultimately determined that the considerations favouring revocation outweighed those against it, leading to the decision to revoke the mandatory cancellation of Mr Anaki's visa.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

This case requires more than a cursory assessment of Mr Anaki’s record might suggest. On consideration of a criminal history involving numerous convictions spread over more than 29 years, one might presume the cancellation of his visa should not be revoked. But presumption is not the standard against which measure is to be made. The measure, so helpfully set out in the Minister’s Direction, requires close examination of the facts and the evidence, weighing the seriousness of crimes Mr Anaki has committed, and the risk he poses to the Australian community, with what that community might expect be done in respect of his privileged presence in Australia on trust of lawful obedience when that trust has, so often and despite formal warning, been breached.Background facts Mr Anaki is a New Zealand citizen of Samoan extraction. He is 46 years of age. He first arrived in Australia as a 16 year old child. He has spent most of his life in Australia. Most recently, on 27 August 2007, Mr Anaki re-entered Australia after visiting New Zealand for his mother’s funeral. He was granted a Class TY Subclass 444 Special Category (Temporary) visa, allowing him to stay indefinitely in Australia. Many years ago he became addicted to heroin, although I am unable to determine precisely when this occurred. His subsequent history, over the last 10 years at least, is that of a wayward, homeless, sometimes desperate man, committing offences in the grip of chronic addiction and unemployment. He has a lengthy criminal record. Over a 29 year period, he has been convicted of 127 criminal offences, 81 of which involved drug offences.[1] Mr Anaki has been sentenced to custodial sentences on 33 occasions – 7 sentences were suspended, 22 were for terms of imprisonments from 2 to 10 months, and 4 were for 12-month terms of imprisonment. All but one of these sentences related to offences Mr Anaki committed prior to April 2010. [1] T11. On 13 July 2009, he was issued a “FORMAL COUNSELLING LETTER” by the Department of Immigration and Citizenship (as it was then known) in respect of his criminal record, warning that future offending conduct would weigh heavily against his migration status.[2] [2] T16 folios 230-231. In the period from October 2009 to January 2010, Mr Anaki committed a series of offences for which he was sentenced to concurrent terms of imprisonment of up to 12 months. On 2 September 2010, while serving out these custodial sentences, Mr Anaki was notified that cancellation of his visa was under consideration on character grounds.[3] On 3 December 2010, a delegate of the Minister notified Mr Anaki that a decision had been taken not to cancel his visa and that he was to be given the following formal warning –“Please note that visa cancellation may be reconsidered if you commit further offences or otherwise breach the character test in future. Disregard of this warning will weigh heavily against you if your case is reconsidered.”[4][3] T4 folios 57-62.[4] T16 folio 237.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

When all relevant considerations are given due weight, and all of the materials and evidence before the Tribunal is taken into account, the balance tips marginally in favour of revocation. Considerations weighing against revocation do not out-weigh those that weigh for revocation. That being so, it is appropriate to exercise the discretion conferred under s 510CA(4) of the Act to revoke the mandatory cancellation of Mr Anaki’s visa. I am satisfied that doing so is the preferable decision in all of the circumstances.Decision The decision under review is set aside. The mandatory cancellation of Mr Anaki’s visa is revoked.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

On balance, while the limit of tolerance of Mr Anaki’s offending conduct has been reached and tested, it has not yet been exceeded. Reasonable judgement of his conduct over time supports a proportionate assessment, presently. I accept that this is a point on which reasonable minds may differ. To my mind, weighing the evidence and having regard to the relevant circumstances, this expectation of the Australian community does not weigh against revoking cancellation of Mr Anaki’s visa. Other considerationsInternational non-refoulement obligations International non-refoulement obligations do not arise in this case.Ties to Australia The strength, nature and duration of Mr Anaki’s ties to Australia are secondary considerations that must be weighed in the balance, albeit with less weight than primary considerations. Mr Anaki has lived in Australia for most of his life. Mr Anaki is 46 years old and he has been in Australia for 30 years. Minds may differ about the extent of any positive contribution he may have made to the Australian community during that time. Mr Anaki’s first offence in Australia is recorded on 20 February 1987, within two years of his first arrival. He was a child at the time. All of Mr Anaki’s immediate family, including one brother, two sisters and their families (including children and grandchildren), reside in Australia – primarily in Sydney. Mr Anaki has two uncles, three aunts, three nieces, 13 nephews and 20 cousins residing in Australia.[19] One of Mr Anaki’s sisters (Elizabeth) is an Australian citizen. His other siblings (Ms Tanoi and Edward) are permanent residents in Australia. [19] T14 folio 175. There is very scant evidence of the effect on his immediate family members if the mandatory cancellation of his visa is not revoked. Ms Tanoi stated that Mr Anaki “is loved very dearly by all his family and have great concern’s [sic] for him if they decide to move him back to New Zealand with no family members residing there”.[20] I note the reported comments of Mr Anaki’s brother in 2010.[21] These comments are not indicative of a close sibling relationship, but they are now more than five years old.[20] Email by Hallen Tanoi, 27 July 2016.[21] T4 folios 120 and 122. On the basis of Ms Tanoi’s comments, it may be accepted that some negative effect may arise for Mr Anaki’s immediate family if the mandatory cancellation of his visa is not revoked, namely concerns about his well-being in New Zealand and, impliedly at least, the effects of distance across territorial borders on Mr Anaki’s relationship with his siblings and their children and grandchildren. I should say now that the present evidence does not establish that Mr Anaki has a close relationship with family members in recent years. Thus, in summary, despite his troubled background, Mr Anaki has been in Australia since childhood. Even though he commenced offending soon after arriving in Australia as a child, he has family ties to Australia, with all of his immediate family residing in Australia. On balance, Mr Anaki’s ties to Australia weigh in favour of revoking cancellation of his visa.Impact on business