Tobacco Control Coalition Inc v Philip Morris (Australia) Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 69 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Tobacco Control Coalition Inc v Philip Morris (Australia) Ltd [2000] FCA 1004

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Representative proceeding brought on behalf of individuals and organisations in relation to cigarette smoking – Application for leave to file an Amended Application in a particular form – Whether the document provides a satisfactory description of group members – Necessity for description to be such as to enable possible group members to determine whether they fall within the described group – Definition that includes future elements is unsatisfactory  – Leave refused.

COSTS - Applications for security for costs - Impecunious corporate applicant - Whether applications for security for costs should be refused because an order for security would stifle a meritorious case - Width of claims made in Statement of Claim - Obscurities concerning applicant’s claims - Whether the Court would be likely to order costs against the applicant if claim failed

Bell Wholesale Co Pty Limited v Gates Export Corporation (1984) 2 FCR 1, Oshlack v Richmond River Council [1998] HCA 11; 193 CLR 72, Marks v GIO Australia Holdings Limited [1998] HCA 69; 196 CLR 494 referred to. Woodhouse v McPhee (1997) 80 FCR 529 applied

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976, ss 43 and 56
Trade Practices Act 1974, ss51AB, 52, 75B, 80 and 87

TOBACCO CONTROL COALITION INCOPORATED v PHILIP MORRIS (AUSTRALIA) LTD, PHILIP MORRIS LTD, W D & H O WILLS HOLDINGS LTD, W D & H O WILLS (AUSTRALIA) LTD, ROTHMANS HOLDINGS LTD and ROTHMANS OF PALL MALL (AUSTRALIA) LTD

N1089 of 1999

WILCOX J
SYDNEY
27 JULY 2000

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

N1089 of 1999

BETWEEN:

TOBACCO CONTROL COALITION INCORPORATED
Applicant

AND:

PHILIP MORRIS (AUSTRALIA) LTD and PHILIP MORRIS LTD
First Respondents

W D & H O WILLS HOLDINGS LTD and W D & H O WILLS (AUSTRALIA) LTD
Second Respondents

ROTHMANS HOLDINGS LTD and ROTHMANS OF PALL MALL (AUSTRALIA) LTD
Third Respondents

JUDGE:

WILCOX J

DATE OF ORDER:

27 JULY 2000

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The application of the applicant, Tobacco Control Coalition Incorporated, for leave to file an Amended Application in the form annexed to the affidavit of Stephen John Moss dated 3 December 1999 be refused.

2.On or before 30 September 2000, the said applicant provide security in the sum of $100,000 in respect of the costs of each of the three sets of respondents; the security to be provided in such manner as may be approved by the New South Wales District Registrar of the Court.

3.In the event of default by the applicant in providing security in accordance with order 2 to any particular set of respondents, subject to any contrary order of a Judge of the Court, the proceeding stand dismissed, with costs, against those respondents.

4.There be liberty to apply, in relation to orders 2 and 3, on three days’ notice.

5.The said applicant pay the costs incurred by each of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Tobacco Control Coalition Inc v Philip Morris (Australia) Lt... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] FCA 1004
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Tobacco Control Coalition Inc (TCCI) filed a representative proceeding against Philip Morris (Australia) Ltd and other respondents in relation to cigarette smoking. TCCI sought leave to file an Amended Application to change the form of their initial claim. The respondents opposed the application, arguing that the proposed amendment did not adequately describe the group members, which was necessary for potential group members to determine their inclusion within the described group. Additionally, the respondents sought security for costs, which TCCI resisted on the grounds of "public interest" litigation. The court had to determine whether TCCI's application for leave to file an Amended Application should be granted and whether security for costs should be required.

The court found that the definition of group members in TCCI's proposed Amended Application included future elements, which was unsatisfactory. The court held that unless the descriptions of group members were radically revised, the action should not proceed as a representative action. The court also rejected TCCI's argument that the proceeding should be considered as "public interest" litigation, as the claim was not brought for private ends but rather to address a matter of public concern. The court found that TCCI's prospects of success were not high, and the proceeding, as presently framed, had major difficulties.

The court refused TCCI's application for leave to file an Amended Application in the proposed form and ordered TCCI to provide security for costs in the sum of $100,000 in respect of each respondent. If TCCI defaulted in providing security, the proceeding would stand dismissed, with costs, against those respondents. TCCI was also ordered to pay the costs incurred by the respondents in relation to the Notice of Motion for leave to file an Amended Application and the Notices of Motions in respect of security for costs.

The court's decision emphasised the importance of clearly defining group members in representative proceedings and the need for potential group members to determine their inclusion within the described group. The court also clarified that "public interest" litigation does not necessarily exempt a plaintiff from providing security for costs. The outcome of this case highlights the importance of carefully framing representative proceedings and ensuring that the claims and descriptions of group members are well-defined and legally sound.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application of the applicant, Tobacco Control Coalition Incorporated, for leave to file an Amended Application in the form annexed to the affidavit of Stephen John Moss dated 3 December 1999 be refused.

2. On or before 30 September 2000, the said applicant provide security in the sum of $100,000 in respect of the costs of each of the three sets of respondents; the security to be provided in such manner as may be approved by the New South Wales District Registrar of the Court.

3. In the event of default by the applicant in providing security in accordance with order 2 to any particular set of respondents, subject to any contrary order of a Judge of the Court, the proceeding stand dismissed, with costs, against those respondents.

4. There be liberty to apply, in relation to orders 2 and 3, on three days’ notice.

5. The said applicant pay the costs incurred by each of the respondents in respect of:

(i) the Notice of Motion for leave to file an Amended Application filed by the applicant and dated 3 December 1999; and

(ii) the Notices of Motions in respect of security for costs filed by the various respondents and each dated 20 or 21 January 2000.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

WILCOX J
There may be a clearer link in relation to expenditure on the treatment of persons suffering from smoking related diseases. As I have indicated, it may be possible to reformulate the claim in such a way as to provide a remedy for some of the persons covered by Schedule A. But it would not be appropriate for me to evaluate Mr Francey’s submission about TCCI’s prospects of success, not by reference to the claim it in fact makes (and which it has been unwilling substantially to modify), but by reference to a claim that, perhaps, might be made.TCCI’s prospects of success: conclusion Having regard to the problems I have outlined, it cannot properly be said that the proceeding, as presently framed, enjoys a high possibility of success. Indeed, unless and until the descriptions of group members are radically revised, the action ought not be allowed to proceed at all; at least as a representative action. Even if that revision took place, major difficulties would remain. The first, and major, basis of Mr Francey’s resistance to the respondents’ applications for security for costs must be rejected.“Public interest” litigation As Mr Francey noted in argument, there have been cases in which courts (including this Court) refrained from making costs orders against unsuccessful plaintiffs because they perceived the claim to have been brought in the “public interest”, rather than for private ends. The cases were collected and analysed by Stein J, at first instance in Oshlack: see Oshlack v Richmond River Shire Council and Iron Gates Developments Pty Ltd (1994) 82 LGERA 236. His Honour was there exercising the discretion as to costs conferred upon him by s69(2) of the Land and Environment Court Act 1979 (NSW). That subsection provides:“Subject to the rules and subject to any other Act:(a)costs are in the discretion of the Court;(b)the Court may determine by whom and to what extent costs are to be paid; and(c)the Court may order costs to be taxed or otherwise ascertained on a party and party basis or on any other basis.” At 245 Stein J held that the subject matter of that proceeding was one of public interest. However, he did not rest his decision to refuse costs only on that circumstance. He took into account that “a significant issue in the case” concerned the meaning and legal certainty of a development consent issued by the respondent council. He thought the submissions, on that issue, made on behalf of Mr Oshlack “were respectable and in no way unarguable”. Submissions made on other aspects of the case “were eminently arguable although unsuccessful”. The case was also one of the first challenges under certain recently-enacted legislation and its determination would be “helpful to the future administration of the provisions and enforcement”. His Honour also noted the considerable local controversy concerning development of the subject land. He thought it relevant that Mr Oshlack had no pecuniary interest in the outcome of the case, and “was motivated by his desire to uphold the public interest in ensuring obedience to environmental law which he claimed was breached”. He said Mr Oshlack was also motivated by a desire to “preserve the habitat of the endangered koala on and around the site”, a stance shared “by a significant number of members of the public although they did not join in the challenge”.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: WILCOX J