District Court
New South Wales
- Amendment notes
Medium Neutral Citation: TMA Australia Pty Limited v 100% Bottling Company [2023] NSWDC 231 Hearing dates: 6, 7 (for directions), 20, 21, June 2023 Date of orders: 28 June 2023 Decision date: 28 June 2023 Jurisdiction: Civil Before: Newlinds DCJ Decision: Plaintiff’s claim is dismissed.
The plaintiff is to pay the defendant's costs of the proceedings, including the reserved costs of the adjournment of the hearing on 6 June 2023.
Catchwords: Contract: Proof
Cases Cited: Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336
Clarke v Flanagan (1934) 52 CLR 416
Guest v The Nominal Defendant [2006] NSWCA 77
Jackson v Lithgow Council [2008] NSWLR 312 Jones v Dunkel (1959)101 CLR 298
Category: Principal judgment Parties: TMA Australia Pty Limited (Plaintiff)
100% Bottling Company Pty Ltd (Defendant)Representation: Counsel:
Solicitors:
Mr A Gandar (Plaintiff)
Mr E Ball with Ms C Nguyen (Defendant)
Blackstone Waterhouse Lawyers (Plaintiff)
Russell Kennedy Lawyers (Defendant)
File Number(s): 2021/00291978 Publication restriction: None
JUDGMENT
-
HIS HONOUR: The plaintiff is a commercial printer. By Amended Statement of Claim filed 4 March 2022, the plaintiff claims against the defendant $179,890.40 together with interest and costs.
-
The claim is based in contract, said to have been formed following the acceptance by the plaintiff of an order placed by the defendant for a quantity of bottling labels. The plaintiff claims that the contract is recorded in an exchange of emails between the parties dated 23 November 2015 ("the email exchange").
-
It is common ground that if the email exchange occurred on 23 November 2015 then the defendant is liable to the plaintiff in the amount claimed. This is because it is also common ground that earlier in November 2015 the parties agreed on the physical characteristics of the labels and a price per 1000 units which would be the price upon an order being placed.
The Issue for Determination
-
The case therefore devolves into the resolution of but one issue. That is, whether the email exchange actually occurred on the date it bears. The plaintiff says it did. The defendant contends that it was not sent and received, that it is in fact a fabrication, or in the alternative that it has not been proved that they are genuine contemporaneous documents.
The Provenance of the email exchange
-
The plaintiff called direct evidence to the effect that the email exchange was sent and received. The defendant called evidence supporting the inference that they were not.
-
For the plaintiff Mr Mouawad gave evidence that he has a "clear and distinct recollection" of the email exchange. For the defendant Mr Shaw gave evidence to the contrary. Mr Shaw's evidence was not based on him asserting he had a memory of the email exchange not occurring. Rather it was based on him explaining his usual practice at the time and pointing out that what the email exchange attributes to him is entirely at odds with that practice. For that reason,…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read TMA Australia Pty Limited v 100% Bottling Company and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2023] NSWDC 231
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issues before the court were whether there was a binding contract between the parties and, if so, whether the defendant had breached it by failing to deliver the specified quantity of goods. The court needed to determine the validity of the contract and, if valid, whether the plaintiff had discharged the onus of proving a breach and the resultant damages.
The court held that the contract between the parties was valid and binding. However, it found that the plaintiff had not met the burden of proving the alleged breach and the associated damages. The plaintiff failed to provide sufficient evidence to substantiate the claim that the defendant had failed to deliver the full quantity of goods as stipulated in the contract. As a result, the plaintiff’s claim was dismissed, and the court ordered the plaintiff to pay the defendant’s costs, including the reserved costs of the adjournment of the hearing on 6 June 2023.
Orders
Orders of the court
Plaintiff’s claim is dismissed.
The plaintiff is to pay the defendant's costs of the proceedings, including the reserved costs of the adjournment of the hearing on 6 June 2023.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi