Tisdall v Health Insurance Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 64 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Tisdall v Health Insurance Commission [2002] FCA 97

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – judicial review – medical practitioner – inappropriate practice – Professional Services Review Committee – procedural fairness – form of referral – jurisdiction of Committee – whether proposed findings in excess of jurisdiction – apprehension of bias – waiver of bias– duty to act fairly – whether delay is breach of duty – expert bodies – duty to disclose way in which expertise used to reach conclusion

Health Insurance Act 1973 (Cth) ss 81, 82, 83, 86, 87, 93, 95, 96, 97, 99, 102, 103, 104, 105, 106, 106A, 106F, 106L, 106R, 106S, 106T, 106V, 117, 119 and 124A

Veterinary Surgeons Act 1923 (NSW)

Retnaraja v Morauta (1999) 93 FCR 397 followed
Mercado v Holmes [2000] FCA 620 followed
Grey v Health Insurance Commission [2001] FCA 1257 discussed
Romeo v Asher (1991) 29 FCR 343cited
Minister for Health v Thomson (1985) 8 FCR 213 followed
R v Metropolitan Fair Rents Board; Ex parte Canestra [1961] VR 89 cited
Spurling v Development Underwriting (Vic) Pty Limited [1973] VR 1 followed
Roads Corporation v Dacakis [1995] 2 VR 508 discussed
Kalil v Bray [1977] 1 NSWLR 256 followed
Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336 cited
Pfizer Pty Ltd v Birkett [2000] FCA 303 discussed
Re Refugee Review Tribunal; Ex parte H [2001] HCA 28 followed
Tankey v Adams [2000] FCA 1089 followed

Jago v The District Court of New South Wales (1989) 168 CLR 23 followed

Aronson and Dyer, Judicial Review of Administrative Action, 2nd ed. at 419-425

PETER THOMAS TISDALL v
HEALTH INSURANCE COMMISSION AND ORS
V 849 OF 2000

TAMBERLIN J
MELBOURNE
15 FEBRUARY 2002


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

V 849 OF 2000

BETWEEN:

DR PETER THOMAS TISDALL
APPLICANT

AND:

HEALTH INSURANCE COMMISSION
FIRST RESPONDENT

DR ALAN JOHN HOLMES (as the Director of Professional Services Review)
SECOND RESPONDENT

DR KENNETH NEVILLE (as Chairperson of Professional Services Review Committee No 106)
THIRD RESPONDENT

DR DAVID ROSENTHAL (as a Member of Professional Services Review Committee No 106)
FOURTH RESPONDENT

DR NICHOLAS DEMEDIUK (as a Member of Professional Services Review Committee No 106)
FIFTH RESPONDENT

DR LOUISE MORAUTA (as the Determining Officer)
SIXTH RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

TAMBERLIN J

DATE OF ORDER:

15 FEBRUARY 2002

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The application for review is dismissed.

2.The applicant pay the respondents’ costs.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

V 849 OF 2000

BETWEEN:

DR PETER THOMAS TISDALL
APPLICANT

AND:

HEALTH INSURANCE COMMISSION
FIRST RESPONDENT

DR ALAN JOHN HOLMES (as the Director of Professional Services Review)
SECOND RESPONDENT

DR KENNETH NEVILLE (as Chairperson of Professional Services Review Committee No 106)
THIRD RESPONDENT

DR DAVID ROSENTHAL (as a Member of Professional Services Review Committee No 106)
FOURTH RESPONDENT

DR NICHOLAS DEMEDIUK (as a Member of Professional Services Review Committee No 106)
FIFTH RESPONDENT

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Tisdall v Health Insurance Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] FCA 97
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Tisdall v Health Insurance Commission involved the applicant, Dr Tisdall, challenging a decision made by the Health Insurance Commission regarding his professional conduct. Dr Tisdall argued that the Committee established to review his conduct had failed to properly consider evidence and had acted outside its jurisdiction. The case was heard in the Federal Court of Australia.

The central legal issues in the case were whether the Committee had investigated matters outside the terms of the Referral, whether it had considered matters outside its jurisdiction, and the extent to which an expert tribunal is entitled to rely on its undisclosed use of expertise and experience. The applicant also argued that the Committee failed to consider uncontradicted evidence and ignored other evidence, and that some findings were unsupported by evidence or based on undisclosed matters.

The court found that the Committee had not investigated or considered matters outside the terms of the Referral or its jurisdiction. It further determined that the Committee, as an expert body, was entitled to rely on its expertise and experience in assessing the evidence, and that there was no requirement for the Committee to disclose the reasoning behind its decisions. The court held that the Committee had acted within its jurisdiction and had properly considered the evidence before it. Consequently, the application for review was dismissed, and the applicant was ordered to pay the respondents' costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application for review is dismissed.

2. The applicant pay the respondents’ costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

For these reasons, I do not consider that the Committee investigated or considered matters outside the terms of either the Referral or the particulars of hearing. Nor am I persuaded that the Committee investigated matters outside its jurisdiction.EVALUATION OF EVIDENCE A number of submissions were made by the applicant which relate to the way in which the Committee considered or failed to consider the evidence. They also include claims that the Committee failed to have regard to uncontradicted evidence and also ignored evidence. They also include findings that were unsupported by evidence or simply based on matters not disclosed. These submissions call for a consideration of the extent to which and, the way in which, an expert tribunal should act in its consideration of material before it.THE ROLE OF THE COMMITTEE AS AN EXPERT BODY – NEED FOR DISCLOSURE The Committee in this case was comprised of “experts” who in terms of the Act are “specialists” in the field of general practice which is under consideration. In accordance with the Act, the three members of the Committee were also practitioners in the profession in which Dr Tisdall was practising at the relevant time when the referred services were rendered. As mentioned earlier they were general practitioners, two being country general practitioners as was the applicant and the other member being a suburban general practitioner. The proceedings before the Tribunal are not curial or adversarial in the strict sense but they have a strong inquisitorial element. In terms they are in the nature of an inquiry into expressed specific “concerns”. The legislative provisions relating to the Committee have been set out earlier. They point away from the normal characteristics of a curial inquiry. The Committee is obliged to conduct an inquiry if, after considering the matters which comprised the subject of the referral, it considers that the person under review may have engaged in relevant inappropriate practice. This contemplates that the Committee would have given some prior consideration to the concerns expressed before a hearing is convened and formed a tentative view. There is no right of representation, legal or otherwise, but there is a right with the consent of the Committee for a non-lawyer to be present and question a witness or address the Committee. The Committee can require the practitioner to appear and produce documents. The rules of evidence do not apply and the Committee can inform itself in any way that it thinks appropriate. These provisions are indications that the power being exercised is essentially administrative in character. An important issue raised in the applicant’s submissions concerns the extent to which an expert tribunal is entitled to rely on its undisclosed use of its expertise and experience in accepting or rejecting material placed before it. Specifically, for example, it is submitted that the Committee had rejected the sixteen affidavits from specialists not in general practice, produced in response to the Draft Report, and that in so doing, the Committee should have answered questions and given Dr Tisdall particulars of those aspects of their expertise and experience relied on to reject this evidence. The Committee, it is said, should have given him an opportunity to meet with evidence, documents and arguments, the reasoning and use of expertise on the part of the Committee members which led them to “reject” these further affidavits. It is also submitted that the treatment of this material in the Report of the Committee is cursory and non-informative.

Decision

Reasons for decision

TAMBERLIN J
Relevantly, the Referral is in the following terms:“REASON FOR THE DECISION TO REFERThe Health Insurance Commission is concerned that the high total volume of services, services per patient and prescribing may be inappropriate, contain insufficient clinical input, or may not be reasonably medically necessary for the care of his patients.The nature of this concern regards the professional quality of the services provided. …Health Insurance Commission concerns include:1. High Volume of Rendered Services: In the referral period 1 January 1996 to 31 December 1996, Dr Tisdall provided 27,686 services of which … 22,602 were level B consultations (item 23) … Dr Tisdall’s services are above the 99th percentile of all active vocationally registered general practitioners in Australia (16,042 services). During this period Dr Tisdall provided between 61 and 80 services per day on 42 occasions, and between 81 and 100 services per day on 116 occasions, between 101 and 120 on 81 occasions, and between 120 and 140 on 11 occasions in his apparent average surgery working day. Time calculations based on the Entry Standards of the Royal Australian College of General Practitioners (RACGP) suggest that Dr Tisdall would have needed to spend between 10.2 and 23.3 hours of direct patient contact per surgery working day to provide quality care at a standard acceptable to the RACGP. The Health Insurance Commission believes that the appropriate level of clinical input may not be able to be maintained at this servicing rate on a regular and continuing basis.2. High Average Number of Services per PatientDuring the referral period Dr Tisdall provided 27,686 services to 4,359 patients. Dr Tisdall provided an average of 6.35 services per patient, which was more than the average services per patient provided by 97% of all active vocationally registered general practitioners in Australia. The Health Insurance Commission believes that some of the services rendered or initiated by Dr Tisdall may not be reasonably medically necessary for the care of his patients.3. High Level of Prescribing. During the referral period Dr Tisdall, with a total patient base of 4,359 patients, prescribed a total of 35,065 items under the Pharmaceutical Benefit Scheme, at a cost of $470,560.09 … [reference made to prescribing rate of four specified items all substantially above the 99th percentile when compared with all medical practitioners in Australia]. The Health Insurance Commission believes the rate of prescribing of items, in particular codeine linctus, codeine phosphate with paracetamol, diazapam and prednisolone by Dr Tisdall may be inappropriately high.For these reasons, the Health Insurance Commission has formed the view that Dr Tisdall’s conduct in connection with the rendering and initiation of Medicare services may constitute inappropriate practice.” (Original emphasis) On 9 September 1997 the applicant provided written submissions in answer to the matters raised in the Referral. After a considerable lapse of time, on 12 February 1999, the Director set up a Committee consisting of the third, fourth and fifth respondents to consider whether the applicant had engaged in inappropriate practice. On 23 February 1999, the applicant challenged the appointment of Dr Demediuk to the Committee on grounds of bias. On the same day, the applicant also wrote to the Director requesting information as to the specific charges against him and as to the specific questions which the Committee would be asking him. The Director responded on 25 February 1999 advising that the challenge on the grounds of bias was not justified. In relation to the questions raised by the applicant, the Director informed him that the matter was in the hands of the Committee and that correspondence would be forwarded to the Committee for its consideration.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: TAMBERLIN J