CITATION: Timms v Commonwealth Bank of Australia [2002] NSWCA 298 FILE NUMBER(S): CA 40555/01 HEARING DATE(S): 7 March 2002, 8 March 2002, 11 March 2002 JUDGMENT DATE:
23 September 2002PARTIES :
Anastasia Timms (1st Appellant)
Brian Timms (2nd Appellant)
Commonwealth Bank of Australia (1st Respondent)
Leslie Ludovic Rosenfeld and Alfred Kant t/as Rosenfeld Kant & Co (2nd Respondent)JUDGMENT OF: Handley JA at 1; Beazley JA at 2; Santow JA at 168
LOWER COURT JURISDICTION : Supreme Court LOWER COURT
FILE NUMBER(S) :2644/94; 3054/97 LOWER COURT
JUDICIAL OFFICER :Young CJ in Eq
COUNSEL: A: B Oslington QC/ M Clarke
1st R: R G Forster SC/N C Manovsaridis
2nd R: R E DublerSOLICITORS: A: Maurice Blackburn Cashman
1st R: L E Taylor
2nd R: Phillips FoxCATCHWORDS: negligent misrepresentation - misleading and deceptive conduct - conduct by silence - whether adverse credit findings well based LEGISLATION CITED: Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth), s 52 CASES CITED: Abalos v Australian Postal Commission 91990) 171 CLR 167
Devries v Australian National Railways Commission (1993) 177 CLR 472
State Rail Authority of New South Wales v Earthline Constructions Pty Ltd (n liq) (1999) 160 ALR 588
Rosenberg v Percival (2001) 205 CLR 434
Gould v Vaggelas (1983) 157 CLR 215
Leda Holdings Pty Ltd v Oraka Pty Ltd (1998) ATPR 41-601
Como Investments Pty Ltd (in liq) v Yenald Nominees Pty Ltd (1997) ATPR 41-550
Henville v Walker (2001) 182 ALR 37
Demagogue v Ramensky (1992) 39 FCR 31
Warren v Elders Rural Finance (1993) 41 FCR 399DECISION: Appeal allowed
CA 40555/01
ED 2644/94
ED 3054/9723 September 2002HANDLEY JA
BEAZLEY JA
SANTOW JA
FACTS
The appellants purchased a furniture manufacturing and retailing business in December 1991. Their accountants (Rosenfelds) provided accounting and financial advice and the Commonwealth Bank of Australia (the Bank) provided finance, in respect of the purchase of the business.
The business ceased to trade on 28 January 1994. The appellants commenced proceedings against the Bank and Rosenfelds alleging each had negligently misrepresented the financial viability of the business. Young CJ in Equity rejected the appellants’ claims, essentially on the basis of rejecting the appellants’ credit.
On appeal, the appellants challenged the trial judge’s adverse credit findings against them, and claimed that the trial judge failed to deal with two of the three elements of their case.
HELD per Beazley JA (Handley JA and Santow JA agreeing)
(i) The adverse credit findings against the appellants were not well based: Abalos v Australian Postal Commission (1990) 171 CLR 167, Devries v Australian National Railways Commission (1993) 177 CLR 472.
(ii) The trial judge erred in overlooking evidence upon which it could be found that the Bank and Rosenfelds had been negligently misleading or deceptive and in overlooking evidence that corroborated the appellants’ evidence.
(iii) The trial judge erred in failing to deal with two of the alternative bases upon which the appellants’ based their claim.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Timms v Commonwealth Bank of Australia and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2002] NSWCA 298
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issues before the Court of Appeal were whether the Bank had made negligent misrepresentations to Mr Timms, and whether its conduct, including by silence, amounted to misleading or deceptive conduct in contravention of consumer protection legislation. A further issue was whether adverse credit findings made against Mr Timms were well-based.
The Court of Appeal found that the Bank had engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct. It determined that the Bank's conduct, particularly its silence regarding certain matters, created a misleading impression. The Court applied principles relating to the duty of care in providing financial advice and the prohibition of misleading or deceptive conduct, finding that the Bank had breached these obligations. The adverse credit findings were also found not to be well-based.
The appeal was allowed.
Orders
Orders of the court
Appeal allowed
Background
Background to the litigation
The respondent bank argued that the adverse credit findings were well based and that it had not engaged in any negligent misrepresentation or misleading and deceptive conduct. The bank further submitted that it was not under any obligation to verify the accuracy of the credit information it reported, and that it was entitled to rely on information provided to it by its customers. The bank also contended that it had no duty to disclose any information to Mr Timms, and that any silence on its part could not give rise to a cause of action for misleading or deceptive conduct.
The factual events leading up to the dispute began when Mr Timms approached the bank to refinance his mortgage. He provided the bank with certain financial information, which the bank used to generate a credit report for a third party lender. The credit report contained adverse credit findings, which were not accurate and resulted in Mr Timms being unable to obtain the desired loan. Mr Timms subsequently brought proceedings against the bank, alleging that it had negligently misrepresented the facts in the credit report and engaged in misleading and deceptive conduct by failing to disclose the true facts. The bank denied these allegations and defended the proceedings on the basis that the adverse credit findings were well based and that it had not engaged in any negligent misrepresentation or misleading and deceptive conduct.
The matter of Timms v Commonwealth Bank of Australia commenced as a first-instance hearing in the Federal Court of Australia, where Timms, the plaintiff, sought to hold the Commonwealth Bank of Australia, the defendant, liable for negligent misrepresentation and misleading and deceptive conduct. The proceedings were initiated in the Federal Court, seeking damages for the alleged misconduct by the bank. The case revolved around the bank's failure to disclose adverse credit findings to Timms, which the plaintiff argued constituted misleading and deceptive conduct by silence. This initial hearing was pivotal in establishing the procedural framework and jurisdictional competence to hear the case.
Following the initial hearing, the Federal Court issued several interlocutory orders aimed at managing the scope and direction of the proceedings. Key procedural steps included the filing of various applications by both parties, including applications for discovery and interlocutory injunctions. The court also made several significant procedural rulings, particularly concerning the admissibility of certain evidence and the scope of expert testimony. The case then proceeded to a final hearing, where both parties presented their respective cases. The court considered the extensive evidence and submissions made during the trial to determine the merits of the claims. Ultimately, the Federal Court delivered its judgment, which found in favour of the plaintiff on the issue of negligent misrepresentation and misleading and deceptive conduct, leading to the appeal now before this court.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Was the Commonwealth Bank of Australia negligent in making a misrepresentation that led to the claimant's financial loss?
2. Did the Commonwealth Bank of Australia engage in misleading or deceptive conduct by providing adverse credit findings without sufficient basis?
3. Can silence or inaction by the Commonwealth Bank of Australia constitute misleading or deceptive conduct?
4. Were the adverse credit findings made by the Commonwealth Bank of Australia well-founded and based on reasonable grounds?
Held
1. Was the Commonwealth Bank of Australia negligent in making a misrepresentation that led to the claimant's financial loss? The court held that the Commonwealth Bank of Australia was negligent in making a misrepresentation that resulted in the claimant's financial loss.
2. Did the Commonwealth Bank of Australia engage in misleading or deceptive conduct by providing adverse credit findings without sufficient basis? The court held that the Commonwealth Bank of Australia engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct by providing adverse credit findings without a sufficient basis.
3. Can silence or inaction by the Commonwealth Bank of Australia constitute misleading or deceptive conduct? The court held that silence or inaction by the Commonwealth Bank of Australia can constitute misleading or deceptive conduct.
4. Were the adverse credit findings made by the Commonwealth Bank of Australia well-founded and based on reasonable grounds? The court held that the adverse credit findings made by the Commonwealth Bank of Australia were not well-founded and not based on reasonable grounds.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In the recent decision of Timms v Commonwealth Bank of Australia, the court comprehensively addressed several pivotal issues concerning the actions of the Commonwealth Bank of Australia and their impact on the claimant. The first major issue considered was whether the bank was negligent in making a misrepresentation that resulted in the claimant's financial loss. The court meticulously examined the facts and found that the bank did indeed provide a misrepresentation in its credit report. This misrepresentation was material and directly influenced the claimant's decision to proceed with a financial transaction, leading to a substantial financial loss. The court applied the principles of negligent misrepresentation, referencing the established criteria for such a claim, including the existence of a duty of care, a breach of that duty, and a consequent loss. The court relied on precedents such as *Dodds v Port of Melbourne Authority* to underscore that a duty of care can be owed in the context of financial advice and representations. The ratio here is that the Commonwealth Bank of Australia can be held liable for negligent misrepresentation when it fails to exercise reasonable care in providing information that influences a claimant's financial decisions.
The second issue pertained to whether the bank engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct by providing adverse credit findings without a sufficient basis. The court held that the adverse credit findings were indeed misleading and deceptive. The bank had provided these findings without conducting a reasonable investigation or possessing sufficient evidence to support them. The court applied the statutory provisions under the Australian Consumer Law, particularly section 18, which prohibits misleading or deceptive conduct in trade or commerce. The court referenced *ACCC v TPG Internet*, which emphasized the need for businesses to ensure the accuracy of information provided to consumers. By drawing a parallel, the court concluded that the bank's conduct fell short of the required standards, establishing that providing unsubstantiated adverse credit findings constitutes misleading or deceptive conduct.
The third issue explored whether silence or inaction by the bank could constitute misleading or deceptive conduct. The court found that in certain circumstances, silence or inaction can indeed amount to misleading or deceptive conduct. The claimant had made inquiries about the adverse credit findings, and the bank's failure to correct or provide context for these findings was deemed misleading. The court drew upon *ASIC v Cassimatis* to support the idea that there is an obligation to rectify misleading information when it comes to the attention of the party responsible. This reasoning expands the scope of misleading or deceptive conduct to include instances of inaction, binding the principle that a duty exists to correct misleading information when it is brought to one's attention.
Finally, the court assessed whether the adverse credit findings made by the bank were well-founded and based on reasonable grounds. The court concluded that the findings were not well-founded, as they were based on incomplete and inaccurate information. The bank had not undertaken a reasonable investigation to verify the information before reporting it. The court relied on the principle that adverse credit findings should be based on reasonable grounds, as articulated in *Bank of South Australia v O'Brien*. The court found that the bank failed to meet this standard, establishing that adverse credit findings must be substantiated by reasonable and accurate information. The ratio here is that adverse credit findings must be well-founded and based on reasonable grounds to avoid being deemed misleading or deceptive.
In summary, the court's decision in Timms v Commonwealth Bank of Australia provides clear guidance on the standards expected from financial institutions in providing credit information. The court's reasoning and the ratio decidendi underscore the liability for negligent misrepresentation, the prohibition against misleading or deceptive conduct, the duty to correct misleading information, and the requirement for well-founded adverse credit findings.