Thompson v Department of Environment and Conservation

Link copied
Case Copied 74 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Thompson v Department of Environment and Conservation [2011] FCA 617

Citation: Thompson v Department of Environment and Conservation [2011] FCA 617
Parties: MATT WILLIS THOMPSON and JANET HUFNAGEL THOMPSON v DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENT AND CONSERVATION, STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA, PAUL BYRNES, NATIONAL AUSTRALIA BANK LTD (ACN 004 044 937), MARTIN JONES, ANDREW SAKER AND DANIEL WEAVER and NARROGIN BEEF PRODUCERS PTY LTD (RECEIVERS AND MANAGERS APPOINTED) (ACN 100 851 376)
File number: NSD 1383 of 2010
Judge: BARKER J
Date of judgment: 3 June 2011
Catchwords:

CORPORATIONS - Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 237 - application by applicants to bring derivative action - criteria specified in s 237(2) not met - applicants refused leave

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE - application by fifth respondents to set aside or permanently stay originating process issued against it - where validity of appointment of fifth respondents as receivers and managers challenged by applicants - where issue considered in separate proceedings and appointment confirmed under s 418A of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE - application to strike out pleadings - whether applicant has no reasonable prospect of successfully prosecuting proceeding - alleged contravention of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) - whether Act binds State parties - whether activities of State parties in granting or purporting to grant licences amounts to carrying on a business

Legislation: Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) s 2B, s 2C, s 45
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 236, s 237, s 418A, s 1323
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 50
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) s 45, s 51AC, s 52, s 82
Environmental Protection Act 1985 (WA) s 20, s 49, s 56, s 121
Cases cited: American Cyanamid Co v Ethicon Ltd [1975] AC 396
Australian Broadcasting Corporation v O'Neill (2006) 227 CLR 57
Australian Securities and Investments Commission v National Exchange Pty Ltd (2005) 148 FCR 132
Deangrove Pty Ltd v Commonwealth Bank of Australia [2001] FCA 173; (2001) 108 FCR 77
General Steel Industries Inc v Commissioner for Railways (NSW) (1964) 112 CLR 125
Goozee v Graphic World Group Holdings Pty Ltd [2002] NSWSC 640; (2002) 170 FLR 451
Markit Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation (Cth) [2006] QSC 157
McMillan v Commonwealth (1997) 77 FCR 337
Murex Diagnostics Australia Pty Ltd v Chiron Corporation (1995) 55 FCR 194
NT Power Generation Pty Ltd v Power and Water Authority (2004) 219 CLR 90
Ragless v IPA Holdings Pty Ltd (in liq) [2008] SASC 90; (2008) 65 ACSR 700
RP Data Ltd (ACN 087 759 171) v State of Queensland [2007] FCA 1639; ATPR 42-197
SBBS v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2002] FCAFC 361; (2002) 194 ALR 749
Sirway Asia Pacific Pty Ltd v Commonwealth of Australia [2002] FCA 1152; (2002) ATPR 46-226
Spencer v Commonwealth of Australia [2010] HCA 28; (2010) 241 CLR 118
State of New South Wales v RT and YE Falls…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Thompson v Department of Environment and Conservation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] FCA 617
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Thompson v Department of Environment and Conservation involves a complex web of legal disputes, primarily concerning the validity of certain appointments and the admissibility of evidence in a derivative action brought by the applicants. The applicants sought to bring a derivative action against the respondents, citing breaches of duty under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). The central legal issues revolved around whether the applicants met the criteria set out in s 237(2) of the Act, and whether the evidence presented adhered to the rules of evidence, particularly in relation to hearsay and speculation. The court was also tasked with determining the validity of the appointment of certain respondents as receivers and managers, which had been challenged by the applicants.

The court found that the applicants had not met the criteria specified in s 237(2) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) for bringing a derivative action. The court further ruled that the evidence presented by the applicants contained significant amounts of hearsay, speculation, and irrelevant opinion, which were not admissible. The court struck out specific paragraphs of the applicants' statement of claim and portions of the affidavits provided by the applicants, finding them to be either speculative, irrelevant, or inadmissible under the rules of evidence. Additionally, the court confirmed the validity of the appointment of certain respondents as receivers and managers, dismissing the applicants' challenges to this appointment.

In light of these findings, the court ordered that certain paragraphs of the applicants' statement of claim be struck out and dismissed the applicants' notice of motion. The court also ruled that the applicants pay the costs of the respondents in respect of various motions filed. The matter was listed for further hearing on costs. The court's decision underscores the importance of adhering to statutory criteria for derivative actions and the strict application of evidentiary rules in court proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. On the notice of motion of the first, second and third respondents dated 25 March 2011, it is ordered that the following paragraphs of the applicants’ statement of claim be struck out: [44(b)(iii)], [44(c)(iii)], and in so far as they refer to the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth), [45(a), (b) and (c)].

2. On the objections of the first, second and third respondents, it is ordered that those portions of the affidavits of Mr and Mrs Thompson filed in support of the applicants’ notice of motion filed 16 February 2011, and referred to in the attached Schedule be struck out on the basis indicated.

3. (a) On the objections of the fourth, fifth and sixth respondents as to the affidavit of Mrs Thompson sworn 19 October 2010 and filed 20 October 2010, the following portions be struck out on the basis indicated:

· [103], second and third sentences from “this development … shore up their position” (inadmissible speculation and opinion).

· [104], last sentence “we believe … purchaser(s)” (speculation and opinion).

· [118], the whole (irrelevant opinion).

· [130], the whole (hearsay).

· [137]‑[141], (hearsay).

· [149], the whole (conclusory, vague and no basis).

(b) As to the affidavit of Mr Thompson sworn 16 February 2010, the following portions be struck out on the basis indicated:

· [20], the whole (irrelevant).

· [21], the whole (irrelevant).

· [25], last sentence (opinion, irrelevant).

(c) As to the affidavit of Mr Will Thompson sworn 4 March 2011 and filed 8 March 2011, the following portions be struck out on the basis indicated:

· [8(f)], “and Janet… did not see” (hearsay).

· [10], last sentence from “Janet informs me … to NBP” (hearsay).

· [13(c)(ii)], “neither Janet nor”.

· [14(b)], the whole (opinion, speculation).

· [19], the whole (speculative opinion and hearsay).

(d) As to the affidavit of Mrs Thompson sworn 10 March 2011 and filed 11 March 2011, the following portions be struck out on the basis indicated:

· [8], the whole (conclusory, hearsay, opinion).

· [9], the whole (irrelevant and hearsay).

· [10], the whole (hearsay).

· [11], the whole (a combination of speculations, opinion, hearsay and relevancy).

4. On the fifth respondents’ notice of motion dated 24 November 2010, [86(b)] of the applicants’ statement of claim be struck out.

5. The applicants’ notice of motion filed 16 February 2011 be dismissed

6. The applicants pay the costs of the fifth respondent in respect of the fifth respondents’ notice of motion filed 24 November 2010 to be fixed at a gross sum, in any event.

7. The applicants pay the costs of the respondents in respect of the applicants’ notice of motion filed 16 February 2011 to be fixed at a gross sum, in any event.

8. The applicants pay the costs of the first, second and third respondents’ notice of motion dated 25 March 2011 to be fixed at a gross sum, in any event.

9. The respondents file and serve and affidavits and submissions in support of the assessment of the gross sum within 21 days.

10. The applicants file and serve any affidavits and submissions in response to the respondents’ affidavits within 21 days thereafter.

11. The matter be listed for further hearing on costs on Tuesday 26 July 2011 at 10.15am.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Thompson v Department of Environment and Conservation involves a derivative action under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). The applicants, Mr and Mrs Thompson, sought to bring a derivative action on behalf of a corporation against various respondents, including the Department of Environment and Conservation. The applicants' action was in response to alleged contraventions of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) and the improper granting of licences by the State parties. The applicants also sought to challenge the validity of the appointment of certain respondents as receivers and managers.

The dispute arose from the applicants' belief that the respondents engaged in activities that were detrimental to the corporation's interests. This included allegations that the respondents had acted improperly in the granting or purporting to grant licences, and that these activities amounted to carrying on a business within the meaning of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth). The applicants filed various affidavits in support of their claims, which were subsequently objected to by the respondents on the grounds of irrelevance, hearsay, speculation, and opinion.

The matter came before the court following the applicants' filing of a notice of motion to bring a derivative action and several other motions to address specific issues raised by the respondents. The respondents, including the receivers and managers, filed objections to portions of the applicants' affidavits and notices of motion. The court was required to determine the validity of the receivers and managers' appointment and the admissibility of the applicants' evidence. The court also had to rule on the applicants' request to strike out certain paragraphs of their statement of claim and to set aside or permanently stay the originating process against the receivers.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In these circumstances, I would order that the following paragraphs of the statement of claim be struck out:(1)[44(b)(iii)];(2)[44(c)(iii)];(3)In so far as they refer to the TP Act, [45(a), (b) and (c)].OBJECTIONS TO APPLICANTS’ AFFIDAVIT EVIDENCE The State parties object to portions of the affidavit evidence that the applicants seek formally to read in relation to their notice of motion filed 16 February 2011, to bring the derivative proceeding. The objections to the affidavits of Mr and Mrs Thompson made by the State parties and the nature of the objection in each case is set out in Sch 1 of these reasons for judgment. I uphold each objection on the ground specified and order that such affidavit evidence be struck out. NAB, the receivers and the sixth respondent (in receivership) also object to portions of these affidavits. I rule as follows on their objections and order that:(1)As to the affidavit of Mrs Thompson sworn 19 October 2010 and filed 20 October 2010, the following portions be struck out on the basis indicated:·[103], second and third sentences from “this development … shore up their position” (inadmissible speculation and opinion).·[104], last sentence “we believe … purchaser(s)” (speculation and opinion).·[118], the whole (irrelevant opinion).·[130], the whole (hearsay).·[137]‑[141], (hearsay).·[149], the whole (conclusory, vague and no basis).(2)As to the affidavit of Mr Thompson sworn 16 February 2010, the following portions be struck out on the basis indicated:·[20], the whole (irrelevant).·[21], the whole (irrelevant).·[25], last sentence (opinion, irrelevant).(3)As to the affidavit of Mr Thompson sworn 4 March 2011 and filed 8 March 2011, the following portions be struck out on the basis indicated:·[8(f)], “and Janet… did not see” (hearsay).·[10], last sentence from “Janet informs me … to NBP” (hearsay).·[13(c)(ii)], “neither Janet nor”.·[14(b)], the whole (opinion, speculation).·[19], the whole (speculative opinion and hearsay). As to the affidavit of Mrs Thompson sworn 10 March 2011 and filed 11 March 2011, the following portions be struck out on the basis indicated:·[8], the whole (conclusory, hearsay, opinion).·[9], the whole (irrelevant and hearsay).·[10], the whole (hearsay).·[11], the whole (a combination of speculations, opinion, hearsay and relevancy). I should observe that the applicants and particularly their legal advisors seem not to have exercised any or any real judgment in placing this affidavit evidence before the Court. The affidavits seek to tell a story without regard, in many respects, to the rules of evidence such that blatant hearsay evidence, irrelevancies and extraneous opinions have been allowed to remain in the affidavits. One really expects much greater discrimination than this from trained legal practitioners.RECEIVERS APPLICATION TO STRIKE OUT ORIGINATING PROCESS By notice of motion filed 24 November 2010, the receivers move for an order that the originating process issued against them in this proceeding be set aside or permanently stayed.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the applicants meet the criteria specified in s 237(2) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) to bring a derivative action.
2. Whether the validity of the appointment of the fifth respondents as receivers and managers should be set aside or permanently stayed.
3. Whether the applicants have a reasonable prospect of successfully prosecuting their proceeding, and if not, whether the pleadings should be struck out.
4. Whether the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) binds State parties and if the activities of the State parties in granting or purporting to grant licences amount to carrying on a business.

Held
1. The applicants did not meet the criteria specified in s 237(2) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) to bring a derivative action, and therefore their application was refused.
2. The validity of the appointment of the fifth respondents as receivers and managers should not be set aside or permanently stayed.
3. The applicants had no reasonable prospect of successfully prosecuting their proceeding, and thus their pleadings were struck out.
4. The Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) does not bind State parties, and the activities of the State parties in granting or purporting to grant licences do not amount to carrying on a business.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by addressing the applicants' request for leave to bring a derivative action under s 237 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). The court examined the criteria set out in s 237(2) of the Act and determined that the applicants had not satisfied those criteria. As such, the court refused the applicants' leave to bring a derivative action.

Next, the court considered the application by the fifth respondents to set aside or permanently stay the originating process issued against them. The applicants had challenged the validity of the fifth respondents' appointment as receivers and managers, but the validity of the appointment had already been considered in separate proceedings and confirmed under s 418A of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). The court found that there was no basis for setting aside or permanently staying the originating process.

The court then addressed the application to strike out the applicants' pleadings. The applicants were alleged to have no reasonable prospect of successfully prosecuting their proceeding. The court found that the applicants did not have a reasonable prospect of success, and therefore, the pleadings were struck out. The court also struck out specific paragraphs of the applicants' statement of claim, as well as portions of affidavit evidence filed by the applicants, on the basis of inadmissibility, irrelevance, speculation, hearsay, and lack of basis.

Lastly, the court considered whether the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) binds State parties and whether the activities of the State parties in granting or purporting to grant licences amount to carrying on a business. The court concluded that the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) does not bind State parties and that the activities of the State parties in granting or purporting to grant licences do not amount to carrying on a business. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) does not apply to State parties and their actions in granting or purporting to grant licences do not constitute carrying on a business.