Thompson and Comcare

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2000] AATA 165

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)     No    A1999/215

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION          )          

Re      STEPHEN THOMPSON   

Applicant

And    COMCARE  

Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal       Pamela Burton, Senior Member  

Date28 February 2000

PlaceCanberra

Decision      The tribunal sets aside the reviewable decision and remits the matter for reconsideration with the direction that the calculation of increases in the applicant's normal weekly earnings since 16 June 1998 are to be made with reference to the increases in the base salary rate of the occupants of the position the applicant previously held at the National Library of Australia. The respondent is to pay the applicant's reasonable costs as agreed or taxed.     

..................(Sgd.)......................
  Pamela Burton  Senior Member
CATCHWORDS
COMPENSATION – NWE – adjustment to NWE for the purpose of assessing weekly compensation payments – applicant a senior public servant – salary of the applicant's previous position later governed by Australian Workplace Agreement – whether salary of current occupant constitutes an "increase in salary" within s8(6)(c) of the SRC Act – applicant's reasonable expectation of incremental advances in salary. 
Legislation
Industrial Relations Act 1988
Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988  s8
Workplace Relations Act 1996
Authorities
Saraswati v The Queen (1991) 172 CLR 1
McDonald v Department of Defence (1999) FCA 882
Re West and Comcare (1999) 29 AAR 32
Re Spurr and Comcare (1999) 28 AAR 424
Richards and Commission for the Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation of Commonwealth Employees (AAT 8735, 26 May 1993)

REASONS FOR DECISION

28 February 2000  Pamela Burton, Senior Member 

  1. This is an application for review of the decision of the respondent dated 1 July 1999 varying the determinations of 18 November 1998 and 8 June 1999 as to the quantum of the applicant's Normal Weekly Earnings ("NWE") for the purpose of assessing the applicant's weekly compensation payments.  The decision denied that the applicant's rate of weekly compensation is to be calculated with reference to the earnings of the current occupier of the applicant's pre-injury position of Assistant Director-General of the National Library of Australia ("the Library").

  2. The applicant represented himself and Mr Peter Hanks of counsel represented the respondent. The tribunal had before it the documents lodged pursuant to section 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (the "T-documents"), and various documents tendered by the parties.  The applicant gave evidence and made submissions in relation to his claim.  Mr Graham Still, employed by the Library, gave oral evidence on behalf of the respondent.  The tribunal received written submissions from both parties.
    The applicant's employment background

  3. The facts are not in dispute.  The applicant was employed by the Library as Assistant Director-General ("the position").  He was paid at the rate applicable to Level 2 in the Second Division of the Australian Public Service ("the APS").  He became incapacitated for work in 1985 and received total incapacity payments under the Compensation (Commonwealth Government Employees) Act 1971.  The applicant retired from the APS on the ground of invalidity and received payments under the

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Thompson and Comcare and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] AATA 165
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter of Thompson and Comcare involved the applicant, who was a former Assistant Director-General of the Library, seeking compensation for his incapacity following an injury. The applicant argued for an adjustment to his normal weekly earnings (NWE) for the purpose of assessing his weekly compensation payments. The dispute centred on whether the salary of the current occupant of the applicant's previous position, which was later governed by an Australian Workplace Agreement (AWA), constituted an "increase in salary" within the meaning of section 8(6)(c) of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (SRC Act). This determination was crucial as it impacted the calculation of the applicant's NWE.

The tribunal had to decide whether the salary increase provided for under the AWA qualified as an "increase in salary" under section 8(6)(c) of the SRC Act. Additionally, it needed to determine if the applicant's reasonable expectation of incremental advances in his salary was sufficient to warrant an adjustment to his NWE. The tribunal examined the relevant provisions of the SRC Act, particularly subsections 8(6) and 8(9), and considered Comcare's circular on the calculation of NWE. The applicant's evidence included the Library's Annual Report, an advertisement for the Deputy Director-General position, and work references that suggested he had reasonable expectations of earning the same salary as the current occupant of his former position.

The tribunal concluded that the increase in salary under the AWA did not constitute an "increase in salary" within the meaning of section 8(6)(c) of the SRC Act. The tribunal found that the applicant's NWE should be calculated based on the increases in the base salary rate of the occupants of the position he previously held at the Library. It did not find it necessary to determine the effect of subsection 8(9) in light of its decision regarding subsection 8(6)(c). The tribunal set aside the reviewable decision and remitted the matter for reconsideration, directing that the calculation of increases in the applicant's NWE since 16 June 1998 should reference the increases in the base salary rate of the occupants of the position the applicant previously held at the Library. The respondent was ordered to pay the applicant's reasonable costs as agreed or taxed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant represented himself and Mr Peter Hanks of counsel represented the respondent. The tribunal had before it the documents lodged pursuant to section 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (the "T-documents"), and various documents tendered by the parties. The applicant gave evidence and made submissions in relation to his claim. Mr Graham Still, employed by the Library, gave oral evidence on behalf of the respondent. The tribunal received written submissions from both parties.The applicant's employment background The facts are not in dispute. The applicant was employed by the Library as Assistant Director-General ("the position"). He was paid at the rate applicable to Level 2 in the Second Division of the Australian Public Service ("the APS"). He became incapacitated for work in 1985 and received total incapacity payments under the Compensation (Commonwealth Government Employees) Act 1971. The applicant retired from the APS on the ground of invalidity and received payments under the Superannuation Act 1976. On the coming into effect of the Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 ("the SRC Act"), the applicant received weekly payments pursuant to subsection 131(4) of that Act. The calculation of the weekly amount of incapacity payments payable to the applicant requires the determination of the applicant's NWE for the time being in accordance with section 8 of the SRC Act. Subsection 8(1) prescribes a formula for calculating NWE before an employee's injury. Subsections 8(6) and 8(9) provide for an increase in the NWE in certain circumstances. The relevant subsections read as follows:8.(1) For the purposes of this Act, the normal weekly earnings of an employee (other than an employee referred to in subsection (2)) before an injury shall be calculated in relation to the relevant period under the formula: (NH x RP) + Awhere: NH is the average number of hours worked in each week by the employee in his or her employment during the relevant period; RP is the employee's average hourly ordinary time rate of pay during that period; and A is the average amount of any allowance payable to the employee in each week in respect of his or her employment during the relevant period, other than an allowance payable in respect of special expenses incurred, or likely to be incurred, by the employee in respect of that employment.….8.(6) Subject to this section, if the minimum amount per week payable to an employee in respect of his or her employment by the Commonwealth or a licensed corporation at the date of the injury is increased, or would have been increased if the employee had continued in that employment, because of: (a) the attainment by the employee of a particular age; (b) the completion by the employee of a particular period of service; or (c) the receipt by the employee of an increase in salary, wages or pay by way of an increment in a range of salary, wages or pay applicable to the employee or to his or her office, position or appointment;the normal weekly earnings of the employee before the injury, as calculated under the preceding subsections, shall be increased by the same percentage as the percentage by which that minimum amount per week is increased, or would have been increased, as the case may be.8.(7) Subject to this section, if: (a) an employee continues to be employed by the Commonwealth or a licensed corporation after the date of an injury; and (b) the minimum amount per week payable to the employee in respect of that employment is increased because of the promotion of the employee;the normal weekly earnings of the employee before the injury, as calculated under the preceding subsections, shall be increased by the same percentage as the percentage by which that minimum amount per week is increased.….8.(9) If the minimum amount per week payable in respect of employees included in a class of employees of which the employee was a member at the date of the injury is increased or reduced on or after that date as a result of: (a) the operation of a law of the Commonwealth or of a State or Territory; or (b) the making, alteration or operation of an award, order, determination or industrial agreement, or of the doing of any other act or thing, under such a law;the normal weekly earnings of the employee before the injury, as calculated under the preceding subsections, shall be increased or reduced by the same percentage as the percentage by which that minimum amount was so increased or reduced, as the case may be.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

I also have regard to Comcare's own circular, "Guidelines for calculation of NWE" (Exhibit E). It reads: "NWE are to be a fair representation of what an employee could have expected to earn but for an injury", and "Should the situation change after the date of injury i.e. a National Wage Case, Increase or decrease in an overtime situation etc, then the Act provides for variation to the NWE at date of injury figure to reflect the change in the expected earnings. This ensures that at all times an employee will be compensated in relation to a fair representation of lost earnings at any particular point in time after the injury." The evidence The applicant produced the Library's 38th Annual Report 1997-8, p.97, setting out the remuneration levels of SES staff, which indicated that his former position attracted a remuneration package in the range of $130,000 to $139,000 (Exhibit B). He said that from other information available to the public it is not difficult to deduce that this remuneration package has a base salary element of between $100,000 and $105,000 as well as performance pay and other benefits. He concedes that other benefits such as spouse travel and telephone expenses are not relevant to the NWE figure. The respondent concedes that the motor vehicle allowance is to be included. In addition an increase of at least 3% was obtained in July 1999 (it could not be less, although it might be more according to the affidavit affirmed by Mr Still on 10 December 1999, and filed on behalf of the respondent). The applicant tendered an advertisement for the Deputy Director-General, published in September 1999 (Exhibit C), indicating that the position currently attracts a remuneration package of up to $155,000 and access to performance pay. The applicant had 13 to 14 years of experience as a Division Head and 11 years at Band 1 level as a policy adviser in education. Assuming no other promotion he had approximately 25 years experience, which he says, is more than any other of his counterparts. He maintains that his AWA would be no less than the maximum salary paid to the highest paid Band 1 officer, or the same as that received by the occupant of the position he formerly held. The applicant provided work references (Exhibit D) in support of his argument that he had reasonable expectations of being in receipt of the same salary as the present occupant of the position, leaving aside his prospects of promotion and performance pay. The applicant subpoenaed material from the Library relating to the salaries of the occupants of senior positions at the Library and in particular to the salary negotiations of the current occupant of the position. He hoped to establish from that material that his qualifications and skills were likely to have matched any current SES officer of the Library, and that he had a reasonable expectation that, had he remained at the Library, he would be receiving the same remuneration as the occupant of the position. The Library's legal representatives objected to production of the documents. The tribunal ordered the production of the documents but deferred an order granting access to the parties to the material, inviting the parties to reapply for access to the material if and when required, as the issues unfolded. At the hearing the argument focussed on the application of subsection 8(6)(c) to increases in salary negotiated under AWAs, and no further call on the material was made.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I am not convinced that subsection 8(9)(a) does not apply to the applicant. The WR Act does not provide for an increase in salary, only the means by which it is to occur. Yet it is an enactment which effectively provides for any increase in the salary applicable to the position. As it effectively removes increases envisaged by the drafters of subsection 8(6)(c) to which the applicant would otherwise have been entitled, it seems that the increase the WR Act provides for by way of a negotiated increase under an AWA falls within the increase referred to in subsection 8(9) "as a result of the operation of a law of the Commonwealth". However, I do not need to determine the effect of subsection 8(9) in view of my decision in relation to the application of subsection 8(6)(c) to the applicant's situation. Decision The tribunal sets aside the reviewable decision and remits the matter for reconsideration with the direction that the calculation of increases in the applicant's NWE since 16 June 1998 are to be made with reference to the increases in the base salary rate of the occupants of the position the applicant previously held at the Library. The respondent is to pay the applicant's reasonable costs as agreed or taxed.I certify that the 44 preceding paragraphs are a true copy of the reasons for the decision herein of Pamela Burton, Senior Member.Signed: Eva Dimopoulos ..................................................................................... AssociateDate of Hearing 25 November 1999Date of Decision 28 February 2000Counsel for the Applicant Self-representedCounsel for the Respondent Mr Peter HanksSolicitor for the Respondent Mr Jim Nealy, Australian Government Solicitor

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established