Thomasson Earthmoving Pty Ltd v Cyonara Snowfox Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION

Thomasson Earthmoving Pty Ltd v Cyonara Snowfox Pty Ltd (No 2) [2010] QSC 77

PARTIES:

THOMASSON EARTHMOVING PTY LTD ACN 073540511

Applicant

v

CYONARA SNOWFOX PTY LTD ACN 079510795

Respondent

FILE NO/S:

S9 of 2010

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Rockhampton

DELIVERED ON:

12 March 2010

DELIVERED AT:

Supreme Court Rockhampton

HEARING DATE:

1 February 2010

JUDGE:

McMeekin J

ORDER:

The respondent pay the applicant’s costs of and incidental to the application to be assessed on the standard basis.

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – COSTS – GENERAL RULE – COSTS ON INDEMNITY BASIS – where both the applicant and the respondent applied for indemnity costs to be paid by the other side – whether there was any disqualifying behaviour on the part of the applicant – whether it should have been obvious to the respondent that the application would succeed

PROCEDURE – COSTS – GENERAL RULE – COSTS FOLLOW THE EVENT – COSTS OF ISSUES – where prima facie position that costs follow the event is not displaced – whether costs should be awarded to the applicant on the standard or indemnity basis

Austrac Rail P/L v Hunter Premium Funding Limited [2001] NSWSC 654

Colgate Palmolive Co & Anor v Cussons Pty Ltd (1993) 118 ALR 248; 46 FCR 225

Emanuel Management Pty Ltd (in liq) v Fosters Brewing Group Ltd & Ors [2003] QSC 299

Rosniak v Government Insurance Office (1997) 41 NSWLR 608

Todrell Pty Ltd v Finch & Ors [2007] QSC 386

COUNSEL:

A Arnold for the applicant

JH Pitman (solicitor) for the respondent

SOLICITORS:

Grant and Simpson solicitors for the applicant

Morgan Conley for the respondent

[1]      McMeekin J:  Thomasson Earthmoving Pty Ltd (“the applicant”) successfully applied to set aside a statutory demand issued by the respondent, Cyonara Fox Pty Ltd, on the basis that the applicant had led sufficient evidence to prove there to be a genuine dispute as to the existence of an antecedent debt.  I reserved the question of costs pending submissions from the parties which I have now received.

[2]      The applicant seeks that its costs be paid on the indemnity basis. The respondent submits that despite its lack of success on the application its costs should be paid by the applicant and on the indemnity basis, or in the alternative, that there should be no order as to costs.

[3]      Ordinarily, costs follow the event subject to any disqualifying behaviour on the part of the successful party. The respondent submits that there are present here circumstances analogous to those cited in Colgate Palmolive Co & Anor v Cussons Pty Ltd (1993) 118 ALR 248 at 249; 46 FCR 225 per Sheppard J. I disagree.

[4]      Indemnity costs orders may be appropriate where proceedings are commenced or continued for some ulterior motive, or in wilful disregard of known facts, or clearly established law:  Colgate-Palmolive Company (supra). In Rosniak v Government Insurance Office (1997) 41 NSWLR 608 the New South Wales Court of Appeal indicated that the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Thomasson Earthmoving Pty Ltd v Cyonara Snowfox Pty Ltd (No... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] QSC 77
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involves Thomasson Earthmoving Pty Ltd, the applicant, and Cyonara Snowfox Pty Ltd, the respondent, before the court. The dispute pertains to the allocation of costs following an application for indemnity costs by both parties. The court was required to determine whether there was disqualifying behaviour on the part of the applicant and if it should have been apparent to the respondent that the applicant's application would succeed. Additionally, the court needed to decide whether the prima facie position that costs follow the event was displaced and, if so, whether costs should be awarded to the applicant on the standard or indemnity basis.

The court began by examining whether the applicant's application for indemnity costs was justified. It considered if there was any disqualifying behaviour on the part of the applicant that would prevent them from being awarded indemnity costs. The court also assessed whether it should have been evident to the respondent that the applicant's application would be successful. In determining the appropriate basis for costs, the court examined if the standard rule that costs follow the event was applicable and whether any exceptional circumstances warranted a departure from this rule. The court concluded that the applicant's application for indemnity costs was not tainted by disqualifying behaviour and that it should not have been apparent to the respondent that the application would succeed. Given that the prima facie position that costs follow the event was not displaced, the court awarded costs to the applicant on the standard basis.

In its reasoning, the court emphasised that while both parties sought indemnity costs, the applicant's application was not precluded by any disqualifying conduct. The respondent had not demonstrated that the outcome of the application was sufficiently predictable to warrant an award of indemnity costs. The court also noted that the standard rule of costs following the event remained applicable unless there were exceptional circumstances warranting a different approach. The court found no such exceptional circumstances in this case, and therefore, the costs were to be assessed on the standard basis.

The final order of the court was that the respondent pay the applicant's costs of and incidental to the application, to be assessed on the standard basis. This decision underscores the importance of the court's assessment of both the conduct of the parties and the predictability of the outcome when determining the appropriate basis for awarding costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

The respondent pay the applicant’s costs of and incidental to the application to be assessed on the standard basis.

Background

Background to the litigation

Thomasson Earthmoving Pty Ltd (the applicant) and Cyonara Snowfox Pty Ltd (the respondent) had been involved in a contractual dispute which led to litigation. The applicant sought indemnity costs from the respondent, while the respondent sought indemnity costs from the applicant. The primary dispute between the parties was regarding the entitlement to costs under the indemnity basis. The case centred around the costs incurred during the proceedings and whether either party exhibited disqualifying behaviour that would affect their entitlement to indemnity costs.

The applicant submitted that the respondent’s conduct during the litigation process was unreasonable and that the respondent’s application for indemnity costs should be denied. Conversely, the respondent argued that the applicant’s application for indemnity costs should be rejected due to the applicant's own conduct. Both parties presented their submissions on the conduct and the costs incurred during the course of the litigation.

This matter came before the court following an application by both parties for indemnity costs. The case was not a first-instance hearing but rather a proceeding related to the costs incurred during the earlier litigation. The court had to consider the applications for indemnity costs made by both the applicant and the respondent. Prior to this application, there had been a primary dispute between the parties, the outcome of which was not in question in this cost application. The court had to determine whether there was any disqualifying behaviour by either party that would affect their entitlement to indemnity costs.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether there was any disqualifying behaviour on the part of the applicant that should affect their entitlement to indemnity costs.
2. Whether it should have been obvious to the respondent that the applicant’s application would succeed.
3. Whether the prima facie position that costs follow the event is not displaced in this case.
4. Whether costs should be awarded to the applicant on the standard or indemnity basis.

Held
1. The court concluded that there was no disqualifying behaviour on the part of the applicant that should affect their entitlement to indemnity costs.
2. The court found that it was not obvious to the respondent that the applicant’s application would succeed.
3. The court determined that the prima facie position that costs follow the event was not displaced in this case.
4. The court decided that costs should be awarded to the applicant on the standard basis.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In determining the appropriate basis for awarding costs, the court examined the conduct of the applicant and whether any disqualifying behaviour was present. The court held that the applicant had not engaged in any disqualifying behaviour, thus preserving their entitlement to indemnity costs. In assessing whether it should have been obvious to the respondent that the application would succeed, the court found that the respondent could not have reasonably anticipated the outcome given the circumstances and the evidence presented. Regarding the principle that costs follow the event, the court acknowledged that the general rule applies, but considered whether exceptional circumstances warranted a departure from this rule. The court found no such circumstances present to justify awarding costs on an indemnity basis. Ultimately, the court concluded that the costs should be awarded on the standard basis due to the lack of disqualifying behaviour by the applicant and the absence of circumstances that would otherwise warrant indemnity costs. The decision reaffirmed the principle that the party that initiates an application bears the risk of not succeeding, reinforcing the general rule that costs follow the event unless there are exceptional reasons to deviate from this principle.