Thomas v Commissioner for Consumer Affairs No. Dcaat-02-585

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

THOMAS & OTHERS v COMMISSIONER FOR CONSUMER AFFAIRS
[2003] SADC 147

Judge Trenorden
Administrative Appeals Division

  1. The appellants have appealed, pursuant to section 37 of the Conveyancers Act 1994, against the determination of the Commissioner for Consumer Affairs upon their respective claims for compensation made under section 32 of the Conveyancers Act.  The Commissioner had determined that compensation was not payable to any of the appellants.

  2. With respect to the Thomas and McAuley the Commissioner for Consumer Affairs advised each of them of the outcome of their claim, in identical terms, as follows:

    “I have determined that you are entitled to compensation from the Indemnity Fund in the amount of $5,104.

    Our investigations reveal that the mortgage in question was unenforceable, meaning no interest accrued under the mortgage.  The whole $4,896 recovered via legal proceedings is therefore considered to be a recovery of principal.”

  3. Concerning the O’Sullivan claim the Commissioner for Consumer Affairs determined the claim in the following terms:

    “I have determined that you are entitled to compensation from the Indemnity Fund in the amount of $3,320. 

    Our investigations reveal that the mortgage in question was unenforceable, meaning no interest accrued under the mortgage.  The whole $3,180 recovered via legal proceedings is therefore considered to be a recovery of principal.”

    The Grounds of Appeal & Notice of Alternative Contention

  4. The grounds of appeal are as follows:

    “1.That the Respondent erred in determining the mortgage was unenforceable and that no interest accrued under it.

    2.That the Respondent should have determined that interest accrued under the mortgage.

    3.That the Respondent erred in determining that amounts recovered by the applicants were recovery of principal.

    4.That the Respondent erred in determining that the appellants were precluded from appropriating recovered amounts pursuant to the mortgage.

    5.That the Respondent did not give any or any sufficient weight to the findings of the District Court (McCauley -v- Panagiatidis) (sic) (No. 2) [1998] SADC 3916 (Judgment of Judge Lunn, 25 November 1998) and McCauley -v- Panagiatidis (sic) (No. 3) [1999] SADC 6 (Judgment of His Honour Judge Lunn, 19 January 1999) in which the Trial Judge made no declaration concerning the validity of the mortgage and no finding that the mortgage was wholly unenforceable.”

  5. The respondent filed a Notice of Alternative Contention, in which it contended as follows:

    “1.That there has been no fiduciary default within the meaning of section 32 of the Conveyancers Act 1994 (“the Act”), and accordingly there is no basis for claiming against the Indemnity Fund; alternatively

    2.that the mortgage was only enforceable to $60,000. Accordingly, entitlement to interest in accordance with clause 28 of the mortgage document must be calculated upon that sum, and any funds exceeding interest calculated upon that basis must be treated as principal for the purposes of section 32(2) of the Act. The respondents’ entitlement from the Indemnity Fund is therefore as follows:



    Thomas            $7,726.42


    McCauley         $7,726.42


    O’Sullivan         $5,022.00”

  6. The appellant filed a Reply to the Respondent’s Notice of Further Contentions, in particular paragraph 1 thereof,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Thomas v Commissioner for Consumer Affairs No. Dcaat-02-585 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] SADC 147
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Thomas, McAuley and O'Sullivan have appealed against the determination of the Commissioner for Consumer Affairs that they are not entitled to compensation from the Indemnity Fund, as claimed under the Conveyancers Act 1994. The appeal arose from the dealings between the appellants and Growdens, a mortgage manager and finance broker that had since failed. The appellants submitted that Growdens had committed a fiduciary default by not ensuring Katerina Panagiotidis understood the mortgage in circumstances when Growdens knew she could not understand it, and that therefore she could challenge its validity. The Commissioner had rejected the claims for compensation on the basis that the mortgage was unenforceable, meaning no interest accrued under it. The appellants argued that interest accrued under the mortgage, and the Commissioner had erred in determining that amounts recovered by the applicants were a recovery of principal. The court held that there was a fiduciary default by Growdens, which occurred when Growdens applied the funds held in trust on behalf of the appellants when they had failed to ensure Katerina Panagiotidis understood the mortgage in circumstances when they knew she could not understand it, and that therefore she could challenge its validity. This amounted to a misapplication of trust money while it was in Growdens' possession, which amounted to a fiduciary default within the meaning of the Conveyancers Act. The court rejected the Commissioner's argument that the appellants' loss as a result of the fiduciary default is the principal invested, together with the interest payable but not received. The court held that the actual pecuniary loss suffered in consequence of the fiduciary default is, in each case, the whole of the principal. The appeal was upheld, and the court shall hear the parties as to final orders.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.