Jarrett v Commissioner for Consumer Affairs No. Dcaat-99-337

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

JARRETT V COMMISSIONER FOR CONSUMER AFFAIRS
[2000] SADC 56

Judge Herriman      
Administrative Appeals Division     

  1. This is an appeal under section 37 of the Conveyancers Act 1994 (“the Act”) against a determination of the respondent (“the Commissioner”) relating to the appellant’s claim for compensation for actual pecuniary loss and legal costs arising out of the fiduciary default of a conveyancer.

BACKGROUND

  1. In April 1995, G.C. Growden Pty Ltd ACN 007 948 834 (“the Conveyancer”) held $10,000 on the appellant’s behalf.  Prior to then, there had been dealings between the parties whereby the Conveyancer had invested the appellant’s moneys on various first mortgage securities.

  2. On 27 April 1995, the Conveyancer wrote to the appellant, proposing that it invest that $10,000 as a part-contribution to a loan to one Adair Black (“Black”) to be secured by a registered first mortgage over property at Paracombe (“the Land”) for a term of one year, at an interest rate of 13 per cent, rising to 18 per cent in the event of default.  That proposal further stated, inter alia:

(1)... that the value of the property was $625,000 and the total amount of funds to be advanced and secured by the proposed contributory mortgage was $395,000;

  1. “Credit History:  Growdens have completed a current satisfactory credit enquiry”; and

  2. that the purpose of the loan was to “assist purchase of Commercial Nursery” .

  3. The appellant accepted the loan proposal and, in due course, all funds were advanced and Mortgage No. 7918967 was registered on the Land, the appellant being described as one of the several contributing mortgagees.

  4. In September 1995, the appellant consented to a second mortgage being registered over the Land. 

  5. On 7 May 1996, Black requested an extension of the term of the mortgage, but the appellant did not agree to that and requested the return of his investment.

  6. By responding letter of 23 July 1996, the Conveyancer invited the appellant to execute and return documents relating to his withdrawal from the investment and sought further directions as to reinvestment of that sum.  The appellant executed and returned those documents, but it appears the Conveyancer did not then act upon his instructions and the principal remained invested in the subject mortgage.  Payments of interest under that mortgage had been maintained up till that time and they continued until November 1996, when they ceased. 

  7. On 14 November 1996, the Conveyancer informed the appellant that Black was in arrears and that it was taking “the measures required to instigate legal action to sell the security property should this prove necessary”.

  8. Soon after that time, the Conveyancer went into receivership and management of the loan was taken over by Heine Mortgage Administration Pty Ltd (“Heine”).

  9. Ultimately, Heine advised the appellant that the forced sale market value of the Land was $225,000, whereupon he authorised Heine to accept an offer to purchase it for $245,000.  The co-mortgagees did likewise and, in the event, following sale of the property on 25 May 1998, the appellant received the sum…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Jarrett v Commissioner for Consumer Affairs No. Dcaat-99-337 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] SADC 56
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appellant, Jarrett, appeals a determination by the Commissioner for Consumer Affairs regarding a claim for compensation under the Conveyancers Act 1994 for losses arising from the fiduciary default of a conveyancer. The conveyancer had invested Jarrett's funds in a mortgage secured by property that was later sold at a significantly lower value. Jarrett claimed compensation for the principal loss, accrued interest, and legal costs. The Commissioner determined that the appellant's loss was limited to the principal sum of $10,000 minus the $4,984.74 recovered from the sale, resulting in a $5,015.26 compensation. Jarrett appealed, arguing that his loss should include interest and legal costs, and that the recovered funds should be applied first to interest and costs before the principal.

The court considered the meaning of "actual pecuniary loss" under the Act and distinguished it from previous cases. It held that the fiduciary default related to the conveyancer's flawed advice in April 1995, leading to the investment. The "actual pecuniary loss" was the diminution in value of the $10,000 principal sum, and thus, the loss of interest and legal costs were not compensable. Regarding the application of the recovered funds, the court found that the Commissioner incorrectly applied the entire amount against the principal. Instead, the recovered funds should first satisfy any outstanding interest before being applied to the principal, as per the mortgage terms. The court also noted that the Commissioner was not obligated to cover the appellant's legal costs incurred in presenting the claim. Interest on the compensation from the date of sale is governed by section 39 of the Act. The court quashed the Commissioner's determination on the quantum of the appellant's actual pecuniary loss and will substitute an appropriate determination after further submissions from the parties.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.