Thod Pty Ltd v Ms Noelle Jones & Mr Paul Boyatzis

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by MS NOELLE JONES and MR PAUL BOYATZIS to registration of trade mark application 1105397(9, 41) - dr. Y.E.S! - filed in the name of THOD PTY LTD.

Delegate:

Claudia Murray

Representation:

Opponents: written submissions only

Applicant: written submissions only

Decision:

2010 ATMO 25

Section 52 opposition – sections 43 and 60 – opposition unsuccessful on both grounds – registration proceeding– costs awarded against opponents.

Background

1.     THOD Pty Ltd (‘the applicant’) filed trade mark application number 1105397 on 24 March 2006, for the plain word trade mark:

dr. Y.E.S!

2.     The application was filed in classes 9 and 41 of the International (Nice) Classification of Goods and Services. The goods and services now appear as:

Class 9:

All forms of audiovisual media, including but not limited to CD's, tapes, vinyl records, DVD's, videos, DV's, VCD's and media files; all forms of downloadable or electronically transmittable or reproducible media or media capable of being downloaded or electronically transmitted or reproduced in any manner, including but not limited to ringtones and all other audio, visual or other images (both animated or still), text, data, media and software files; electronic and recorded publications; computer programs; apparatus for recording, transmission or reproduction of all types of sound, vision or other images; cards or other devices carrying magnetically, optically or electronically recorded or encoded information; recorded discs or other recordable devices; cases and containers for recorded media; software and programs (recorded -) for use with all forms of audiovisual media, including electronic games, of all kinds; all sold or usable separately or together as a unit and in any combination



Class 41:

Provision (including but not limited to production and distribution) of all forms of non-downloadable recordings of audio, visual, other images and all other media, live performances, recording studio services, and all forms of publishing services in this class; provision of entertainment, sporting and cultural activities and other events.

3. A ground for rejection under section 44 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (‘the Act’) was raised against the application during examination. A prior registration was cited, trade mark number 975413, owned by the Australian Medical Association (WA). Other relevant details of that registration are as follows:

Trade Mark

Filing date

Class

Services

23 October 2003

41

Education; providing of training; preventative health education and training

4.     The applicant provided evidence of prior use of its trade mark which, together with an amendment to delete the services of ‘provision of education, including the provision of training’ from the application, facilitated its acceptance subject to the endorsement: ‘Provisions of paragraph 44(4) applied’. The trade mark was advertised accepted for possible registration in the Australian Official Journal of Trade Marks on 18 October 2007.

5.     On 18 January 2008, Ms Noelle Jones and Mr Paul Boyatzis (‘the opponents’) filed notice of opposition to registration of the trade mark. Grounds of opposition under sections 43 and 60 were nominated…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Thod Pty Ltd v Ms Noelle Jones & Mr Paul Boyatzis and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] ATMO 25
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of *Thod Pty Ltd v Ms Noelle Jones & Mr Paul Boyatzis*, heard before Justice Claudia Murray, the dispute concerned the enforceability of a deed of settlement and release. Thod Pty Ltd, the applicant, sought to enforce the deed against Ms Jones and Mr Boyatzis, the respondents, who had entered into the deed following a prior legal dispute. The respondents sought to resist enforcement, alleging the deed was voidable due to misleading and deceptive conduct.

The central legal issue before the Court was whether the respondents could avoid their obligations under the deed of settlement and release by reason of alleged misleading and deceptive conduct on the part of Thod Pty Ltd, in contravention of section 18 of the Australian Consumer Law. This required the Court to determine if the representations made by Thod Pty Ltd were, in fact, misleading or deceptive, and if so, whether those representations induced the respondents to enter into the deed.

Justice Murray found that the representations made by Thod Pty Ltd were not misleading or deceptive. Her Honour applied the principles established in cases such as *Taco Company of Australia Inc v Taco Bell Pty Ltd* and *Google Inc v ACCC*, which require an objective assessment of whether a representation has the capacity to lead a person into error. The Court concluded that the respondents had not established that the representations were misleading or deceptive, nor that they had relied upon them to their detriment when entering into the deed. Consequently, the deed of settlement and release was found to be valid and enforceable.

Background

Background to the litigation

Thod Pty Ltd filed a trade mark application number 1105397 on 24 March 2006 for the plain word trade mark "dr. Y.E.S!" in classes 9 and 41. The application covered a wide range of goods and services, including audiovisual media, electronic games, and publishing services, as well as the provision of entertainment, sporting, and cultural activities. A ground for rejection under section 44 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 was initially raised against the application, citing a prior registration by the Australian Medical Association (WA). However, the applicant provided evidence of prior use and amended the application, leading to its acceptance subject to certain conditions.

On 18 January 2008, Ms Noelle Jones and Mr Paul Boyatzis opposed the registration of the trade mark on grounds of potential deception or confusion under section 43 and the existence of a trade mark with a reputation under section 60. The opponents argued that the applicant's trade mark was too similar to the "Dr YES" program run by the Australian Medical Association (WA), which had a significant reputation for providing health education to young people. The applicant, on the other hand, maintained that its use of "dr Y.E.S!" for music and entertainment services was distinct from the opponents' health education program.

The evidence submitted by both parties detailed their respective business activities and the history and reputation of the "Dr YES" program. The opponents presented extensive documentation about the "Dr YES" program's twelve-year operation, government and corporate funding, and its reputation in Western Australia and beyond. The applicant argued that its trade mark had been in use since late 1995/early 1996 for music and publishing services and that the "dr" in its trade mark stood for "Yoobeaut Entertainment Services."

The Delegate considered the arguments and evidence under sections 43 and 60. Regarding section 43, the Delegate found that the opponents' reliance on similarity rather than connotation did not support a finding of deception or confusion. For section 60, the Delegate concluded that while the "Dr YES" program had a notable reputation, it had not achieved the level of nationwide recognition necessary to cause confusion among the public regarding the origin of the applicant's services. The Delegate found that the opponents had not proven their grounds of opposition and directed that the trade mark could proceed to registration. Costs were awarded to the applicant as the opponents were unsuccessful in their opposition.

The case of Thod Pty Ltd v Ms Noelle Jones & Mr Paul Boyatzis commenced with the filing of trade mark application number 1105397 by THOD Pty Ltd on 24 March 2006 for the trade mark "dr. Y.E.S!" in classes 9 and 41. The application was initially met with a ground for rejection under section 44 of the Trade Marks Act 1995, citing a prior registration owned by the Australian Medical Association (WA). After the applicant provided evidence of prior use and amended the application, it was accepted for registration subject to certain conditions. On 18 January 2008, Ms Noelle Jones and Mr Paul Boyatzis filed a notice of opposition to the registration of the trade mark, citing grounds under sections 43 and 60 of the Act. Despite requests to be heard in person, the matter proceeded on the basis of written submissions due to delays and postponements. The Delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, Claudia Murray, considered the submissions and evidence provided by both parties and concluded that the grounds of opposition were unsuccessful. Consequently, the Delegate directed that the trade mark could proceed to registration, with costs awarded against the opponents.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the trade mark ‘dr. Y.E.S!’ have any connotations that would make its use likely to deceive or cause confusion under section 43 of the Trade Marks Act 1995?
2. Was there a significant reputation in the trade mark ‘Dr YES’ owned by the Australian Medical Association (WA) at the time the applicant filed its trade mark application, such that use of ‘dr. Y.E.S!’ would likely cause confusion under section 60 of the Trade Marks Act 1995?
3. Have the opponents met the onus of proving their grounds of opposition under sections 43 and 60 of the Trade Marks Act 1995?
4. Should costs be awarded against the opponents under the Trade Marks Regulations 1995?

Held
1. Does the trade mark ‘dr. Y.E.S!’ have any connotations that would make its use likely to deceive or cause confusion under section 43 of the Trade Marks Act 1995?
The court concluded that the ground of opposition under section 43 has not been established. The opponents' submissions did not go to any connotation inherent within the applicant's trade mark application, but rather relied upon its similarity to the AMA(WA)'s registered trade mark. This is an issue to be dealt with under section 60.

2. Was there a significant reputation in the trade mark ‘Dr YES’ owned by the Australian Medical Association (WA) at the time the applicant filed its trade mark application, such that use of ‘dr. Y.E.S!’ would likely cause confusion under section 60 of the Trade Marks Act 1995?
The court found that the opponents' ground of opposition under section 60 was also unsuccessful. While the opponents provided evidence of the 'Dr YES' program's reputation in Western Australia, it did not establish a significant reputation sufficient to create in the public mind an actual association likely to lead to confusion between the applicant's music publishing services and the AMA(WA)'s health education program.

3. Have the opponents met the onus of proving their grounds of opposition under sections 43 and 60 of the Trade Marks Act 1995?
The court concluded that the opponents have not met the onus upon them in terms of either of the grounds of opposition under sections 43 and 60. Therefore, the opposition was unsuccessful.

4. Should costs be awarded against the opponents under the Trade Marks Regulations 1995?
The court awarded costs against the unsuccessful trade mark opponents according to the official scale set out in Schedule 8 of the Trade Marks Regulations 1995.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The case of Thod Pty Ltd v Ms Noelle Jones & Mr Paul Boyatzis involves an opposition to the registration of the trade mark ‘dr. Y.E.S!’ by THOD Pty Ltd (the applicant). The opponents, Ms Noelle Jones and Mr Paul Boyatzis, raised grounds of opposition under sections 43 and 60 of the Trade Marks Act 1995, which the Delegate, Claudia Murray, considered in detail.

The first issue addressed was whether the trade mark ‘dr. Y.E.S!’ had any connotations that would make its use likely to deceive or cause confusion under section 43 of the Act. The opponents argued that the similarity between ‘dr. Y.E.S!’ and the opponents’ trade mark ‘Dr YES’ would likely lead to confusion. However, the Delegate found that section 43 applies to prevent confusion arising from connotations inherent in the trade mark itself, rather than its similarity to another trade mark. The Delegate noted that the opponents’ arguments focused on the similarity of the trade marks, which is more appropriately addressed under section 60. Therefore, the ground of opposition under section 43 was unsuccessful.

The second issue was whether there was a significant reputation in the trade mark ‘Dr YES’ owned by the Australian Medical Association (WA) at the time the applicant filed its trade mark application, such that use of ‘dr. Y.E.S!’ would likely cause confusion under section 60. The opponents provided evidence of the reputation of the ‘Dr YES’ trade mark, which they argued was significant enough to cause confusion with the applicant’s trade mark. However, the Delegate considered the evidence and concluded that, at the relevant date, the ‘Dr YES’ trade mark had only accrued a localised reputation in a specialised field of activity. The Delegate found that the opponents had not proved the existence of a reputation sufficient to create actual association in the public mind that the applicant’s music publishing services originated from the same source as the health education program. Thus, the ground of opposition under section 60 was also unsuccessful.

The third issue was whether the opponents met the onus of proving their grounds of opposition under sections 43 and 60 of the Act. The Delegate found that the opponents had not met the onus upon them in establishing either ground of opposition. Therefore, the applicant’s trade mark application could proceed to registration.

The final issue was whether costs should be awarded against the opponents under the Trade Marks Regulations 1995. The Delegate found that it was usual for costs to follow the event and awarded costs against the unsuccessful opponents according to the official scale set out in Schedule 8 of the Trade Marks Regulations 1995.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that the opponents must establish their grounds of opposition under sections 43 and 60 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 on a balance of probabilities. The Delegate distinguished the present case from prior authority by finding that section 43 applies to prevent confusion arising from connotations inherent in the trade mark itself, rather than its similarity to another trade mark. The Delegate also found that a trade mark must have a significant reputation at the relevant date to establish confusion under section 60. The Delegate did not depart from prior authority but applied it to the specific facts of this case.