Theofylatos v Animal Welfare Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

Theofylatos v Animal Welfare Authority [2013] NTSC 61

PARTIES:THEOFYLATOS, Belinda

v

ANIMAL WELFARE AUTHORITY

TITLE OF COURT:  SUPREME COURT OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY            

JURISDICTION:  SUPREME COURT OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY EXERCISING APPELLATE JURISDICTION

FILE NO:LA 5 of 2013 (21315068)

DELIVERED:  4 OCTOBER 2013

HEARING DATES:  17 JUNE 2013

JUDGMENT OF:  KELLY J

APPEAL FROM:  J NEILL SM

CATCHWORDS:

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW—Natural justice—Procedural fairness—Adjournment—Application by Animal Welfare Authority for disposal of seized animals—Adjournment sought by owner to file application for return of animals—Adjournment refused—Failure to ask whether evidence was to be called in defence—Subsequent refusal to allow owner to give evidence—Held denial of natural justice—Appeal allowed

Sali v SPC (1993) 116 ALR 625; Consolidated Press Holdings Ltd v Wheeler (1992) 84 NTR 42; Escobar v Spindaleri (1986) 7 NSWLR 51, applied

Bayram v Benton (1994) 98 NTR 1; Kioa v West (1985) 159 CLR 550, referred to

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:

Appellant:Self Represented

Respondent:  C O’Connor

Solicitors:

Appellant:Self Represented

Respondent:  Solicitor for the Northern Territory

Judgment category classification:   B

Judgment ID Number:  KEL13014

Number of pages:  11

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY
OF AUSTRALIA
AT DARWIN

Theofylatos v Animal Welfare Authority [2013] NTSC 61

No. LA 5 of 2013 (21315068)

BETWEEN:

BELINDA THEOFYLATOS

Appellant

AND:

ANIMAL WELFARE AUTHORITY

Respondent

CORAM:    KELLY J

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

(Delivered 4 October 2013)

Background

  1. On 19 March 2013 the Animal Welfare Authority (“the Authority”) seized 34 dogs and 3 horses belonging to Ms Theofylatos from her property in the rural area south of Darwin.

  2. On 17 April, the Authority served Ms Theofylatos with an application under s 68G of the Animal Welfare Act for an order that the animals be disposed of.  The return date on the application was 22 April 2013. 

  3. Section 68G provides:

    Return or disposal orders

    (1)This section applies if an animal or thing:

    (a)has been seized under this Act; and

    (b)has not been forfeited to the Crown; and

    (c)has not been sold or disposed of under section 68F.

    (2)On application by the Authority or any person entitled to the animal or thing, a return or disposal order may be made:

    (a)by the appropriate civil court; or

    (b)if a person has been charged with an offence against this Act with which the animal or thing is connected – by the court hearing the charge.

  4. Ms Theofylatos engaged a solicitor on 19 April.  The matter was mentioned in the Local Court on 22 April and adjourned for 1 week to enable the solicitor to obtain proper instructions and to provide advice to the client.

    The proceedings at first instance

  5. On 29 April, 10 days after the application had first been served, Ms Theofylatos appeared with her solicitor and the solicitor sought an adjournment to enable Ms Theofylatos to file an application under s 68G for the return of the animals and to file and serve supporting affidavit material.

  6. There was evidence that it was costing the Authority $5,253.50 per week to feed and house the animals.  That cost was being…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Theofylatos v Animal Welfare Authority and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NTSC 61
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Theofylatos v Animal Welfare Authority, the Animal Welfare Authority applied for an order for the disposal of animals seized by it from the appellant, Ms Theofylatos. Ms Theofylatos sought an adjournment to file an application for the return of the animals and to prepare the necessary evidence. The application was heard by a magistrate, who refused the adjournment. The magistrate proceeded to hear the Authority's application and made an order for the disposal of the animals without allowing Ms Theofylatos to present her case. Ms Theofylatos appealed the magistrate's decision, arguing that the refusal of the adjournment and the failure to allow her to present evidence denied her natural justice.

The legal issues in this case were whether the refusal of an adjournment and the failure to allow the appellant to present evidence denied her natural justice. The appeal hinged on whether the magistrate's conduct breached the principles of procedural fairness. The central issue was whether Ms Theofylatos was given a reasonable opportunity to present her case.

The appeal was allowed because the magistrate's conduct breached the principles of procedural fairness. The magistrate refused the adjournment despite knowing that Ms Theofylatos wished to apply for the return of the animals and that her solicitors had spent a week collecting statements. The magistrate also failed to ask Ms Theofylatos whether she wished to adduce evidence and did not allow her to give evidence despite her protest. The magistrate's conduct denied Ms Theofylatos a reasonable opportunity to present her case, which breached the principles of procedural fairness.

The final orders of the court were that the appeal was allowed, and the order of the magistrate was set aside. The case was remitted to the magistrate for rehearing.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Natural justice or procedural fairness, however, does require that a party be given a reasonable opportunity to present his or her case.[11] Application to the facts It seems to me that in this case, by reason of a combination of all of the factors about which the appellant complains, Ms Theofylatos was not accorded such a reasonable opportunity to present her case. (a)The learned trial magistrate refused to adjourn the matter to allow Ms Theofylatos to file an application for the return of the animals, and to complete the preparation of the evidence necessary to support such an application, although he knew that she wished to apply for an order for the return of the animals and that her solicitors had spent a week collecting statements for use in such an application. This was despite knowing that the Authority had spent a month preparing its application and it had been only ten days since its application was served on Ms Theofylatos. His Honour did not even enquire how long an adjournment was requested. (b)His Honour did not treat her counsel’s submissions (referred to above) as an oral application for return of the animals, and did not advert to them in any way in his reasons for decision. Rather he proceeded to deal with the matter on the basis that there was no application for return of the animals, and that the only real issue before him was whether the criteria for the making of an order for the disposal of the animals had been satisfied.(c)He did not ask Ms Theofylatos’s counsel whether she wished to adduce evidence, but called upon counsel for the Authority to make submissions as soon as the Authority’s evidence was complete. This, it seems to me was, on its own, a clear denial of natural justice.[12] Although Ms Theofylatos’s counsel did not protest, there is no suggestion that Ms Theofylatos had positively waived her right to adduce evidence. Indeed, it is clear from her subsequent protests that if the learned magistrate had asked, and Ms Marsh had taken instructions (as she would have been bound to do), Ms Theofylatos would have given evidence. She was effectively denied this right.(d)This was compounded when Ms Theofylatos protested as the learned magistrate was about to pronounce the order. It was clear to him then, assuming he was unaware of it before, that Ms Theofylatos wanted to give evidence: it was not too late to allow her to do so, but his Honour refused to hear her, simply saying, “Unfortunately these steps were not taken in a timely fashion.” The appeal is therefore allowed.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established