The Trustee for Hardev Property (Dev 10) Unit Trust v Palmgrove Holdings Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

The Trustee For Hardev Property (Dev 10) Unit Trust v Palmgrove Holdings Pty Ltd & others [2019] QSC 208

PARTIES:

THE TRUSTEE FOR HARDEV PROPERTY (DEV 10) UNIT TRUST, TRADING AS HARDEV PROPERTY (DEV 10) PTY LTD (ABN 70 342 914 520)

(applicant)

v
PALMGROVE HOLDINGS PTY LTD, TRADING AS CARRUTHERS CONTRACTING (ABN 37 010 870 925)

(first respondent)
And
PETER SARLOS
(second respondent)
and
THE ADJUDICATION REGISTRAR, QUEENSLAND BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION COMMISSION
(third respondent)

FILE NO/S:

BS No 7185 of 2019

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

23 August 2019

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

23 July 2019

JUDGE:

Lyons SJA

ORDER:

The orders of the Court are:

1.   The Originating Application filed 8 July 2019 be dismissed.

2.   The Registrar is directed to pay to the First Respondent the monies described at paragraph 10 of the affidavit of Lucinda Mary McPhee filed 11 July 2019 and which were paid by the Applicant into Court on 12 July 2019.

3.   The Applicant pay the First Respondent’s costs of and incidental to the Originating Application to be assessed or agreed, on the standard basis.

CATCHWORDS:

CONTRACTS – BUILDING, ENGINEERING AND RELATED CONTRACTS – REMUNERATION – STATUTORY REGULATION OF ENTITLEMENT TO AND RECOVERY OF PROGRESS PAYMENTS – ADJUDICATION OF PAYMENT CLAIMS – where the applicant and first respondent entered into contract for construction of a subdivision – where contract related to water services, sewerage services and retaining wall and fencing works – where then applicant contends that the work is building work – where the applicant argues that the first respondent contravened s 42(1) of the Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (Qld) by undertaking to carry out the work – where the applicant seeks final declaratory relief that the adjudication decision is void together with consequential orders for payment of the adjudicated amount – whether the first respondent breached s 42(1) of the Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (Qld) – whether the adjudication decision should be void

Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (Qld), s 42, Schedules 1, 1A, 1B, 2.
Queensland Building And Construction Commission Regulation 2018 (Qld)
Building Industry Fairness (Security of Payment) Act 2017 (Qld), Schedule 1
Land Sales Act 1984 (Qld)
Land Title Act 1994 (Qld), 49A

Craig v State of South Australia (1995) 184 CLR 163
Dart Holdings Pty Ltd v Total Concept Group Pty Ltd & Ors [2012] QSC 158
Ooralea Developments Pty Ltd v Civil Contractors (Australia) Pty Ltd [2015] 1 Qd R 311

COUNSEL:

M Ambrose QC for the applicant

M Jones for the first respondent

SOLICITORS:

Clayton Utz for the applicant
Butler McDermott Lawyers for the first respondent

Current application

  1. The applicant (Hardev Property) seeks final declaratory relief that an adjudication decision issued by the second respondent pursuant to the Building Industry Fairness (Security of Payment) Act 2017 (Qld) (BIF Act), is void by reason of jurisdictional error together with consequential orders for the payment…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read The Trustee for Hardev Property (Dev 10) Unit Trust v Palmgr... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] QSC 208
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Trustee for Hardev Property (Dev 10) Unit Trust (the Applicant) sought to challenge an adjudication decision which found that Palmgrove Holdings Pty Ltd (the First Respondent) was entitled to a progress payment under their contract. The Applicant argued that the First Respondent had contravened s 42(1) of the Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (Qld) by undertaking to carry out the work and that the adjudication decision was void. The Applicant sought final declaratory relief that the adjudication decision is void and consequential orders for payment of the adjudicated amount. The central legal issues for the court to determine were whether the First Respondent breached s 42(1) of the QBCC Act and whether the adjudication decision should be void. The court considered the statutory scheme and the terms of the contract to conclude that the work in question was not "domestic building work" as defined in Schedule 1B of the QBCC Act. The court held that the First Respondent did not breach s 42(1) of the QBCC Act and that the adjudication decision was not void. Consequently, the court dismissed the Applicant's application. The orders of the court were that the originating application be dismissed, the Registrar to pay the First Respondent the monies paid by the Applicant into court, and the Applicant to pay the First Respondent's costs of and incidental to the originating application.

Orders

Orders of the court

The orders of the Court are:

1. The Originating Application filed 8 July 2019 be dismissed.

2. The Registrar is directed to pay to the First Respondent the monies described at paragraph 10 of the affidavit of Lucinda Mary McPhee filed 11 July 2019 and which were paid by the Applicant into Court on 12 July 2019.

3. The Applicant pay the First Respondent’s costs of and incidental to the Originating Application to be assessed or agreed, on the standard basis.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 27 May 2019, Carruthers Contracting filed an adjudication application pursuant to the BIF Act with the third respondent.Statutory Background Sections 42(1), (2) and (3) of the QBCC Act provide as follows:“Unlawful carrying out of building work(1) Unless exempt under schedule 1A, a person must not carry out, or undertake to carry out, building work unless the person holds a contractor’s licence of the appropriate class under this Act.Maximum penalty—(a) for a first offence—250 penalty units; or(b) for a second offence—300 penalty units; or(c) for a third or later offence, or if the building work carried out is tier 1 defective work—350 penalty units or 1 year’s imprisonment.(2) An individual who contravenes subsection (1) and is liable to a maximum penalty of 350 penalty units or 1 year’s imprisonment, commits a crime.(3) Subject to subsection (4), a person who carries out building work in contravention of this section is not entitled to any monetary or other consideration for doing so.” The expression “carry out” used in s 42(1) is defined in Schedule 2 of the QBCC Act to include for building work to:(a)Carry out the work personally; or(b)Directly or indirectly cause the work to be carried out; or(c)Provide building work services for the work. The expression “undertake to carry out” building work means:[6](a)Enter into a contract to carry out the work;(b)Submit a tender to carry out the work;(c)Make an offer to carry out the work. [6] QBCC Act, Schedule 2. Section 8, Schedule 1A of the QBCC Act provides as follows:“Head contracts to carry out building work(1) An unlicensed person who enters into a contract to carry out building work does not contravene section 42(1) merely because the person entered into the contract if the building work—(a) is not residential construction work or domestic building work; and(b) is to be carried out by a person (an appropriately licensed contractor) who is licensed to carry out building work of the relevant class.(2) Also, the unlicensed person does not contravene section 42(1) merely because the person—(a) directly or indirectly causes the building work to be carried out by an appropriately licensed contractor; or(b) enters into another contract, with an appropriately licensed contractor, to carry out the work.(3) However, subsection (1) ceases to apply to the unlicensed person if the person causes or allows any of the building work to be carried out by a person who is not licensed to carry out building work of the relevant class.” Section 42(1) of the QBCC Act contains two separate prohibitions:1.A person is prohibited from undertaking to carry out building work unless they hold a contractor’s licence of the appropriate class under the Act; and2.A person is prohibited from carrying out building work unless that person holds a contractor’s licence for the appropriate class under the Act at the time when the building work is carried out. The distinction was explained by McMurdo J in Dart Holdings Pty Ltd v Total Concept Group Pty Ltd & Ors,[7] where his Honour said:“…if the plaintiff can prove that the defendant, by the Contract, undertook to perform unlicensed work so that the Contract was unenforceable, then it would follow that the Payments Act did not apply and the adjudication was of no effect.Therefore, the present enquiry concerns the work which was agreed to be performed rather than that which was performed…”[7] [2012] QSC 158 at [15]-[16].

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The matters relied upon by Mr Rozis appear to be matters inevitably involved in the engagement by a contractor of a sub-contractor to carry out works which are required by the head contract. If the applicant’s submissions are correct, the exemption introduced by s 8 (it would seem from the Committee Report, a matter of some importance, which was “needing to be progressed for implementation as soon as possible”) would be deprived of effect. Indeed, it borders on the farcical to suggest that the legislature intended that a head contractor would not breach s 42 by entering into a contract for building work, if the work was to be carried out by an appropriately licensed sub-contractor, nor by causing the sub-contractor to carry out the work, but then breached the section if the sub-contractor was paid. In my view, the matters relied upon by the applicant come within s 8(2), being incidental to the entry into the contract with an appropriately licensed sub-contractor, and causing that sub-contractor to carry out the work. It follows that these activities do not result in a breach by the respondent of s 42 of the QBCC Act.Conclusion In my view, the correct interpretation of both the contract and the QBCC Act is that the work is not captured by the definition in Schedule 1B of “domestic building work”. It is not domestic building work and is not residential work because it is work which needs to be carried out prior to the subdivision. In that situation I consider that it cannot be work connected with a dwelling or a residence. In my view, this work must be completed as a pre-requisite to the creation of the residential lots. Numerous other steps are required before any domestic building work can be performed. The building “is yet to be”. I accept the argument of the respondents that on a fair reading of the contract as a whole when read with the statutory scheme, the form and substance of the contract are consistent with the role of a civil works contractor performing work which results in the registration of a survey plan and the creation of lots upon which ultimately dwellings may later be built. I accept the argument of the respondents that the QBCC Act’s licencing requirements are not designed to protect commercial property developers when engaging contractors for these types of work. Whilst some of the terms in the contract in this case do fall within some of the examples of domestic building work such as fencing, water supply, sewerage and drainage etc., they will only be domestic building work when considered together with the actual contract in question. It would seem to me, work falling within those descriptions is domestic building work only where the work under the contract relates to a dwelling or an intended dwelling. The present contract did not extend to work of that nature in my view. The applicant’s case has depended entirely on showing that the respondent has breached s 42 of the QBCC Act, so that the respondent has no contractual right to a progress payment under the BIF Act, and the adjudicator had no jurisdiction to make an adjudication decision in favour of the respondent. It has failed to establish any breach. The application should be dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established