The State of Western Australia v Doyle

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

TITLE OF COURT :   THE COURT OF APPEAL (WA)

CITATION:   THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA -v- DOYLE [2017] WASCA 207

CORAM:   BUSS P

MAZZA JA
HALL J

HEARD:   1 AUGUST 2017

DELIVERED          :   8 NOVEMBER 2017

FILE NO/S:   CACR 197 of 2016

BETWEEN:   THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

Appellant

AND

BILLY MARK DOYLE
Respondent

ON APPEAL FROM:

Jurisdiction              :  DISTRICT COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

Coram  :EATON DCJ

File No  :IND 929 of 2016

Catchwords:

Criminal law - State appeal against sentence - 79 offers via mobile phone text messages to sell or supply a prohibited drug over 18-month period - Prohibited drugs offered were MDMA, methylamphetamine, cocaine, GHB, cannabis - Two refusals to comply with data access orders - Appellant 18 to 19 years old at time of offending - Whether individual sentences manifestly inadequate - Whether total effective sentence of 4 years' imprisonment infringed the first limb of totality principle

Legislation:

Criminal Code (WA), s 417
Criminal Investigation Act 2006 (WA), s 61(2)
Misuse of Drugs Act 1981 (WA), s 6(1)

Result:

Appeal allowed

Category:    D

Representation:

Counsel:

Appellant:     Mr J A Scholz

Respondent:     Mr S B Watters

Solicitors:

Appellant:     Director of Public Prosecutions (WA)

Respondent:     Mark Andrews Legal Pty Ltd

Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

CMB v Attorney General (NSW) [2015] HCA 9; (2015) 256 CLR 346

Director of Public Prosecutions (Vic) v Karazisis [2010] VSCA 350; (2010) 31 VR 634

Giglia v The State of Western Australia [2010] WASCA 9

The State of Western Australia v Baldini [2015] WASCA 39; (2015) 249 A Crim R 198

The State of Western Australia v Johnson [2010] WASCA 187

The State of Western Australia v Nillson [2017] WASCA 68

The State of Western Australia v Wilson [2015] WASCA 119

Vu v The Queen [2006] NSWCCA 188

  1. JUDGMENT OF THE COURT:    This is a State appeal against sentence. 

  2. The respondent was convicted on his pleas of guilty to 82 counts contained in an indictment. In summary, the respondent was convicted of 79 counts of offering to sell or supply a prohibited drug to another contrary to s 6(1)(c) of the Misuse of Drugs Act 1981 (WA) (MDA), two counts of failing to obey a data access order contrary to s 61(2) of the Criminal Investigation Act 2006 (WA) and one count of possession of stolen or unlawfully obtained property contrary to s 417(1) of the Criminal Code (WA).

  3. The MDA offences involved offers made by the respondent to others to sell or supply MDMA (59 counts), cocaine (14 counts), methylamphetamine (four counts), GHB (also known as 'fantasy') (one count) and cannabis (one count). 

  4. In respect of all counts, the respondent was sentenced to a total effective sentence of 4 years' immediate imprisonment with eligibility for parole to commence on 18 November 2016.  The details of the individual offences and the sentences that were imposed are set out later in these reasons. 

  5. The State relies on two grounds of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read The State of Western Australia v Doyle and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] WASCA 207
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The State of Western Australia appeals against the sentence imposed on the respondent, Doyle, who was convicted of various drug-related offences. Doyle was found guilty of 79 counts of offering to sell or supply prohibited drugs via text messages over an 18-month period, two counts of failing to comply with a data access order, and one count of possession of stolen property. The prohibited substances included MDMA, methylamphetamine, cocaine, GHB, and cannabis. Doyle was sentenced to a total effective term of 4 years' imprisonment with eligibility for parole starting on 18 November 2016.

The State challenges the adequacy of the individual sentences for nine counts of offering to sell or supply MDMA, asserting they were manifestly inadequate. The State also contends that the cumulative sentence contravened the first limb of the totality principle by being excessive. The Court granted leave to appeal on both grounds. In its judgment, the Court found that the sentences for the nine specified counts were indeed manifestly inadequate and that the total effective sentence did infringe the first limb of the totality principle.

The Court held that the individual sentences for the nine counts of offering to sell or supply MDMA should be increased to reflect the seriousness of the offences. The Court also determined that the total effective sentence should be reduced to ensure it did not exceed what was proportionate to the overall criminal conduct. The Court ordered a resentencing hearing to determine the appropriate revised sentences.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT: This is a State appeal against sentence. The respondent was convicted on his pleas of guilty to 82 counts contained in an indictment. In summary, the respondent was convicted of 79 counts of offering to sell or supply a prohibited drug to another contrary to s 6(1)(c) of the Misuse of Drugs Act 1981 (WA) (MDA), two counts of failing to obey a data access order contrary to s 61(2) of the Criminal Investigation Act 2006 (WA) and one count of possession of stolen or unlawfully obtained property contrary to s 417(1) of the Criminal Code (WA). The MDA offences involved offers made by the respondent to others to sell or supply MDMA (59 counts), cocaine (14 counts), methylamphetamine (four counts), GHB (also known as 'fantasy') (one count) and cannabis (one count). In respect of all counts, the respondent was sentenced to a total effective sentence of 4 years' immediate imprisonment with eligibility for parole to commence on 18 November 2016. The details of the individual offences and the sentences that were imposed are set out later in these reasons. The State relies on two grounds of appeal. Ground 1 alleges that nine of the individual sentences imposed for offences of offering to sell or supply MDMA were manifestly inadequate. Ground 2 alleges that the total effective sentence of 4 years' immediate imprisonment infringed the first limb of the totality principle. Leave to appeal has been granted on both grounds. For the reasons that follow, we would uphold the grounds of appeal and resentence the respondent. The respondent did not challenge any of the facts read to the court by the prosecutor at the sentencing hearing. They may be summarised in this way. On 12 January 2015, the police executed an MDA search warrant at the respondent's home. They seized illicit drugs and a Blackberry device. On 29 November 2015, police officers again executed a search warrant at the respondent's home situated in a suburb of Perth. The police located a number of illicit drugs and other items commonly associated with the sale and supply of illicit drugs including electronic scales, prohibited controlled weapons and numerous mobile telephones including two encrypted Blackberry telephones. An iPhone belonging to the respondent was found to contain numerous text messages in which he offered to sell illicit substances to various people. The text messages were the evidence upon which each of the charges of offering to sell or supply a prohibited drug was based. The messages commenced on 3 October 2014 and continued on a regular basis until 13 November 2015. The effect of the offers was as follows.Count 1MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On 3 October 2014 the respondent offered to supply to another 50 MDMA tablets weighing approximately 12.5 grams.Count 2MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On 7 October 2014 the respondent offered to supply to another 50 grams of MDMA.Count 3MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On 8 October 2014 the respondent offered to supply to another 15 MDMA tablets weighing approximately 3.75 grams.Count 4MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On 10 October 2014 the respondent offered to supply to another 1 gram of cocaine.Count 5MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On the same date the respondent offered to supply to another 3.5 grams of cocaine.Count 6MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On 16 October 2014 the respondent offered to supply to another 12 MDMA tablets weighing approximately 3 grams.Count 7MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On 21 October 2014 the respondent offered to supply to another 8 MDMA tablets weighing approximately 2 grams.Count 8MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On 22 October 2014 the respondent offered to supply to another 50 MDMA tablets weighing approximately 12.5 grams.Count 9MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On 23 October 2014 the respondent offered to supply to another 15 MDMA tablets weighing approximately 3.75 grams.Count 10MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On 25 October 2014 the respondent offered to supply to another 1 gram of MDMA.Count 11MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On 27 October 2014 the respondent offered to supply to another 140 MDMA tablets weighing approximately 35 grams.·Count 12MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On the same date the respondent offered to supply to another 150 MDMA tablets weighing approximately 37.5 grams.Count 13MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On 28 October 2014 the respondent offered to supply to another 50 MDMA tablets weighing approximately 12.5 grams.Count 14MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On 29 October 2014 the respondent offered to supply to another 50 MDMA tablets weighing approximately 12.5 grams.Count 15MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply Cocaine: On 17 November 2014 the respondent offered to supply to another 3.5 grams of cocaine.Count 16MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On 21 November 2014 the respondent offered to supply to another 20 MDMA tablets weighing approximately 5 grams.Count 17MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On 24 November 2014 the respondent offered to supply to another 6 MDMA tablets weighing approximately 1.5 grams.Count 18MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply Cocaine: On the same date as in count 17 the respondent offered to supply to another 0.5 grams of cocaine.Count 19MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On the same date as in count 18 the respondent offered to supply to another 10 MDMA tablets weighing approximately 2.5 grams.Count 20MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On 25 November 2014 the respondent offered to supply to another 50 MDMA tablets weighing approximately 12.5 grams.Count 21MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On 26 November 2014 the respondent offered to supply to another 1100 MDMA tablets weighing approximately 275 grams.Count 22MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On the same date as in count 21 the respondent offered to supply to another 20 MDMA tablets weighing approximately 5 grams.Count 23MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On 27 November 2014 the respondent offered to supply to another 100 MDMA tablets weighing approximately 25 grams.Count 24MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply Cocaine: On 6 December 2014 the respondent offered to supply to another 7 grams of cocaine.Count 25MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On 13 December 2014 the respondent offered to supply to another 100 MDMA tablets weighing approximately 25 grams.Count 26MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On the same date as in count 25 the respondent offered to supply to another 6 MDMA tablets weighing approximately 1.5 grams.Count 27MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On 17 December 2014 the respondent offered to supply to another 100 MDMA tablets weighing approximately 25 grams.Count 28MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On 19 December 2014 the respondent offered to supply to another 50 MDMA tablets weighing approximately 12.5 grams.Count 29MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On 21 December 2014 the respondent offered to supply to another 10 MDMA tablets weighing approximately 2.5 grams.Count 30MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply Cocaine: On 22 December 2014 the respondent offered to supply to another 0.5 grams of cocaine.Count 31MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On the same date as in count 30 the respondent offered to supply to another 2 MDMA tablets weighing approximately 0.5 grams.Count 32MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On 23 December 2014 the respondent offered to supply to another 1020 MDMA tablets weighing approximately 255 grams.Count 33MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply Cocaine: On the same date as in count 32 the respondent offered to supply to another 1 gram of cocaine.Count 34MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On the same date as in count 33 the respondent offered to supply to another 3 MDMA tablets weighing approximately 0.75 grams.Count 35MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On 24 December 2014 the respondent offered to supply to another 6 MDMA tablets weighing approximately 1.5 grams.Count 36MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On 29 December 2014 the respondent offered to supply to another 50 MDMA tablets weighing approximately 12.5 grams.Count 37MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On 2 February 2015 the respondent offered to supply to another 13 grams of MDMA.Count 38MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On 3 February 2015 the respondent offered to supply to another 100 MDMA tablets weighing approximately 25 grams.Count 39MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply Methylamphetamine: On the same date as in count 38 the respondent offered to supply to another 1 gram of methylamphetamine.Count 40MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On the same date as in count 39 the respondent offered to supply to another 1 gram of MDMA.…Count 42MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On 25 February 2015 the respondent offered to supply to another 30 MDMA tablets weighing approximately 7.5 grams.Count 43MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On the same date as in count 42 the respondent offered to supply to another 10 MDMA tablets weighing approximately 2.5 grams.Count 44MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On 26 February 2015 the respondent offered to supply to another 500 MDMA tablets weighing approximately 125 grams.Count 45MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On 5 March 2015 the respondent offered to supply to another 200 MDMA tablets weighing approximately 50 grams.Count 46MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply Methylamphetamine: On 19 March 2015 the respondent offered to supply to another 3.5 grams of methylamphetamine.Count 47MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On the same date as in count 46 the respondent offered to supply to another 1000 MDMA tablets weighing approximately 250 grams.Count 48MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply GHB: On 21 March 2015 the respondent offered to supply to another 8 millilitres of GHB.Count 49MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On 27 March 2015 the respondent offered to supply to another 250 MDMA tablets weighing approximately 62.5 grams.Count 50MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On 28 March 2015 the respondent offered to supply to another 50 MDMA tablets weighing approximately 12.5 grams.Count 51MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On 30 March 2015 the respondent offered to supply to another 100 MDMA tablets weighing approximately 25 grams.Count 52MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On 3 April 2015 the respondent offered to supply to another 7 MDMA tablets weighing approximately 1.75 grams.Count 53MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On 7 April 2015 the respondent offered to supply to another 100 MDMA tablets weighing approximately 25 grams.Count 54MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On 13 April 2015 the respondent offered to supply to another 100 MDMA tablets weighing approximately 25 grams.Count 55MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On 16 April 2015 the respondent offered to supply to another 500 MDMA tablets weighing approximately 125 grams.Count 56MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On 19 April 2015 the respondent offered to supply to another 2000 MDMA tablets weighing approximately 500 grams.Count 57MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On 21 April 2015 the respondent offered to supply to another 100 MDMA tablets weighing approximately 25 grams.Count 58MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply Cocaine: On 22 April 2015 the respondent offered to supply to another 1 gram of cocaine.Count 59MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply Cocaine: On 1 May 2015 the respondent offered to supply to another 1 gram of cocaine.Count 60MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply Methylamphetamine: On 5 May 2015 the respondent offered to supply to another 3.5 grams of methylamphetamine.Count 61MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On 8 May 2015 the respondent offered to supply to another 10 MDMA tablets weighing approximately 2.5 grams.Count 62MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On 10 May 2015 the respondent offered to supply to another 2000 MDMA tablets weighing approximately 500 grams.Count 63MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On 19 May 2015 the respondent offered to supply to another 70 MDMA tablets weighing approximately 17.5 grams.Count 64MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On 7 June 2015 the respondent offered to supply to another 10 MDMA tablets weighing approximately 2.5 grams.Count 65MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply Cocaine: On 19 June 2015 the respondent offered to supply to another 1.75 grams of cocaine.Count 66MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On 23 June 2015 the respondent offered to supply to another 200 MDMA tablets weighing approximately 50 grams.Count 67MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply Cocaine: On 11 July 2015 the respondent offered to supply to another 2 grams of cocaine.Count 68MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On 16 July 2015 the respondent offered to supply to another 40 MDMA tablets weighing approximately 10 grams.Count 69MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On the same date as in count 68 the respondent offered to supply to another 15 MDMA tablets weighing approximately 3.75 grams.Count 70MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply Cocaine: On 17 July 2015 the respondent offered to supply to another 3.5 grams of cocaine.Count 71MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On 9 August 2015 the respondent offered to supply to another 100 MDMA tablets weighing approximately 25 grams.Count 72MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On 13 August 2015 the respondent offered to supply to another 10 MDMA tablets weighing 2.5 grams.Count 73MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply Cocaine: On 15 August 2015 the respondent offered to supply to another 1 gram of cocaine.Count 74MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On 28 August 2015 the respondent offered to supply to another 50 MDMA tablets weighing approximately 12.5 grams.Count 75MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply Methylamphetamine: On 16 September 2015 the respondent offered to supply to another 3.5 grams of methylamphetamine.Count 76MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On 3 October 2015 the respondent offered to supply to another 100 MDMA tablets weighing approximately 25 grams.Count 77MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On the same date as in count 76 the respondent offered to supply to another 2000 MDMA tablets weighing approximately 500 grams.Count 78MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply Cannabis: On 5 October 2015 the respondent offered to supply to another 454 grams of cannabis.Count 79MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply MDMA: On 19 October 2015 the respondent offered to supply to another 350 MDMA tablets weighing approximately 87.5 grams.Count 80MDA 6(1) (c) Offer to Sell or Supply Cocaine: On 13 November 2015 the respondent offered to supply to another 3.5 grams of cocaine.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established