The Queen v Bradbury and Marshall

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

CITATION:The Queen v Bradbury & Marshall [2022] NTSC 35

PARTIES:THE QUEEN

v

BRADBURY, Kurt

AND

MARSHALL, Benjamin

TITLE OF COURT:  SUPREME COURT OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY

JURISDICTION:  SUPREME COURT exercising Territory jurisdiction

FILE NOs:22021867 & 22101591

DELIVERED:  29 April 2022

HEARING DATES:  10 March 2022 & 29 March 2022

JUDGMENT OF:  Burns J

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:

Crown:D Castor

First co-accused:  S McMaster

Second co-accused:                   M Hubber

Solicitors:

Crown:Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions

First co-accused:  Maleys Barristers & Solicitors

Second co-accused:                   Hubber Legal

Judgment category classification:    C

Judgment ID Number:  Bur2206

Number of pages:  20

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY
OF AUSTRALIA
AT DARWIN

The Queen v Bradbury & Marshall [2022] NTSC 35

No. 22021867 & 22101591

BETWEEN:

THE QUEEN

AND:

KURT BRADBURY

First co-accused

AND:

BENJAMIN MARSHALL

Second co-accused

CORAM:    BURNS J

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

(Delivered on 29 April 2022)

Introduction

  1. By an indictment dated 3 November 2021, the accused Benjamin Marshall and Kurt Bradbury were jointly charged with one count of intentionally supplying a commercial quantity of a dangerous drug, being methamphetamine, on 8 July 2020.  On 10 March 2022 the Crown applied to lead coincidence evidence against the accused at their trial. On the same date the accused Kurt Bradbury applied to have his trial heard separately to that of Benjamin Marshall.  At that time, the joint trial of the two accused was due to commence on 4 April 2022. On 1 April 2022 I informed the parties that the Crown’s applications to lead coincidence evidence were allowed and that the application for separate trials was refused. I told the parties that I would publish my reasons at a later time. These are those reasons.

    The Crown case against the accused

  2. The Crown alleges that on a date prior to 29 June 2020 the accused Benjamin Marshall removed internal door panelling from a black Hyundai Tucson motor vehicle bearing New South Wales numberplates BM73MZ (the Tucson). He then deposited two bags into the door cavity in preparation for delivery to Darwin. One of the bags contained 989.2 g of methamphetamine and the other bag contained 998 g of an inert substance.

  3. On 29 June 2020, an unidentified associate attended Shaw’s Transport Depot in Sydney, New South Wales where he requested the Tucson be transported to Darwin in the Northern Territory. The unidentified associate paid $6,000 for the transport to occur.

  4. At approximately 7:30 AM on 8 July 2020, members from the Northern Territory Police and Organised Crimes Squad and the Dog Operations Unit attended Shaw’s Transport Darwin Depot where a drug screening of the Tucson was undertaken and a Drug Detection dog provided a conditioned response to the vehicle. Police subsequently made an application for and were granted a search warrant authorising them to search the Tucson. During the execution of the search warrant the two packages were located within the internal door cavity of the rear passenger side of the Tucson. The bag containing the inert substance was located within a Woolworths…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read The Queen v Bradbury and Marshall and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] NTSC 35
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of The Queen v Bradbury and Marshall involved two accused, Bradbury and Marshall, who were facing drug-related charges. The Crown sought to adduce coincidence evidence against Marshall, which was evidence of an alleged incident involving the transportation of a large quantity of methamphetamine from Sydney to Darwin. The application to lead this evidence was governed by Part 3.6 of Chapter 3 of the Evidence (National Uniform Legislation) Act 2011 (NT). The Crown's intention was to use this evidence to prove Marshall's state of mind and specific actions related to the transportation and supply of the methamphetamine.

The legal issues before the court involved the admissibility of the proposed coincidence evidence and whether the Crown had complied with the requirements of the Evidence Act. The court had to determine whether the evidence had significant probative value and whether the Crown's notice was sufficient under section 98(1) of the Evidence Act. Additionally, the court needed to consider the restrictions on the use of tendency evidence and coincidence evidence adduced by the prosecution as outlined in section 101 of the Act.

In reaching its decision, the court considered the requirements of section 98(1) of the Evidence Act, which mandates that evidence of two or more events is not admissible unless the party seeking to adduce the evidence gave reasonable notice in writing and the court considers that the evidence will have significant probative value. The court also assessed the probative value of the evidence in light of section 101, which requires that the probative value of the evidence must outweigh any danger of unfair prejudice to the defendant. The court ultimately refused the application for separate trials and determined that the coincidence evidence could be admitted as it met the criteria set out in the Act. The court found that the Crown had provided sufficient notice and that the evidence had significant probative value.

The final orders of the court included the refusal of the application for separate trials and the allowance of the Crown's application to lead coincidence evidence against Marshall. The court's decision ensured that the evidence could be used in the trial, provided it met the legal criteria outlined in the Evidence Act.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

For these reasons, I refused the application for separate trials.The application to lead coincidence evidence against the accused Marshall The Crown served a notice under s 98(1) of the Evidence (National Uniform Legislation) Act 2011 (NT) (the notice) on the accused Marshall, advising him that the Crown intended to adduce coincidence evidence at his trial. The notice stated that the proposed coincidence evidence related to the following facts in issue at the accused’s trial:Whether the accused caused methamphetamine within a bag to be inserted within the door of a Hyundai Tucson NT registration BM73MZ for the purpose of transporting the methamphetamine from an unknown origin in Sydney to Darwin. The notice stated that the proposed evidence would be adduced to prove that the accused Marshall:a) had a particular state of mind, namely, knowingly possessing a large commercial quantity of methamphetamine for the purpose of supply; andb) did a particular act, namely, supplying a large commercial quantity of methamphetamine. The evidence which the Crown proposed adducing as coincidence evidence in Marshall’s trial was evidence of an incident that allegedly occurred on 13 January 2021. The Crown proposed leading evidence that at approximately 11 AM that day the accused arrived in Darwin on a flight from Sydney and was picked up by an associate, Renata Wegschaider. It was alleged that shortly thereafter, the accused Marshall, Wegschaider and another associate, Anthony Woodman, attended Brandt Road, Micket Creek and dug up 500 g of methamphetamine that was buried at that location. They then returned to room 543 of the Coconut Grove Holiday Apartments at 146 Dick Ward Drive, Coconut Grove. A search warrant was obtained by police to search that room, and 500 g of methamphetamine, $4700 in cash and a number of mobile phones were located. The application to lead coincidence evidence is governed by the provisions of Part 3.6 of Chapter 3 of the Evidence (National Uniform Legislation) Act 2011 (NT). In particular, the following provisions are significant:98The coincidence rule(1) Evidence that 2 or more events occurred is not admissible to prove that a person did a particular act or had a particular state of mind on the basis that, having regard to any similarities in the events or the circumstances in which they occurred, or any similarities in both the events and the circumstances in which they occurred, it is improbable that the events occurred coincidentally unless:(a)the party seeking to adduce the evidence gave reasonable notice in writing to each other party of the party's intention to adduce the evidence; and(b) the court thinks that the evidence will, either by itself or having regard to other evidence adduced or to be adduced by the party seeking to adduce the evidence, have significant probative value.Note for subsection (1)One of the events referred to in subsection (1) may be an event the occurrence of which is a fact in issue in the proceeding.(1A)To avoid doubt, subsection (1) includes the use of evidence from 2 or more witnesses claiming they are victims of offences committed by a person who is a defendant in a criminal proceeding to prove, on the basis of similarities in the claimed acts or the circumstances in which they occurred, that the defendant did an act in issue in the proceeding.(2) Subsection (1)(a) does not apply if:(a) the evidence is adduced in accordance with any directions made by the court under section 100; or(b) the evidence is adduced to explain or contradict coincidence evidence adduced by another party.101 Further restrictions on tendency evidence and coincidence evidence adduced by prosecution(1) This section only applies in a criminal proceeding and so applies in addition to sections 97 and 98.(2) Tendency evidence about a defendant, or coincidence evidence about a defendant, that is adduced by the prosecution cannot be used against the defendant unless the probative value of the evidence outweighs the danger of unfair prejudice to the defendant.(3) This section does not apply to tendency evidence that the prosecution adduces to explain or contradict tendency evidence adduced by the defendant.(4) This section does not apply to coincidence evidence that the prosecution adduces to explain or contradict coincidence evidence adduced by the defendant.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established