Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: The Owners – Strata Plan No 93543 v Zhang [2021] NSWSC 277 Hearing dates: 22 March 2021 Date of orders: 22 March 2021 Decision date: 22 March 2021 Jurisdiction: Equity - Technology and Construction List Before: Stevenson J Decision: Leave to withdraw admissions refused
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application to withdraw admissions – admission in List Response that plaintiff owners corporation was entitled to benefit of statutory warranties – further admissions that defendant entered into a contract with the builder of the strata development and that the builder entered into contracts with contractors on behalf of defendant – application to withdraw admissions made on first day of a 5 day hearing – where admissions said to have been made as a result of an error by counsel then briefed and by present solicitor – where withdrawal of admissions would cause plaintiff to seek to investigate further facts hitherto admitted and result in vacation of hearing dates
Legislation Cited: Home Building Act 1999 (NSW)
Cases Cited: Ace Woollahra Pty Ltd v Owners - Strata Plan 61424 (2010) 77 NSWLR 613; [2010] NSWCA 101
Category: Procedural rulings Parties: The Owners – Strata Plan No 93543 (Plaintiff)
Hui Zhang (Defendant)Representation: Counsel:
Solicitors:
A G Rogers (Plaintiff)
P Moorehouse with J Tsang (Defendant)
Alexander Richards Lawyers (Plaintiff)
Marando Solicitors (Defendant)
File Number(s): 2018/382960
Judgment
-
The plaintiff is the Owners Corporation of a 20-unit residential strata development at Cabramatta.
-
Immediately prior to registration of the strata plan on 16 June 2016, the defendant, Mr Zhang, was the owner of the property on which the complex is now built.
-
The Owners Corporation alleges that there are defects in the building and that Mr Zhang, as the builder and/or developer of the complex, is liable to compensate it for that defective work by reason of the statutory warranties specified in ss 18C and 18D of the Home Building Act 1999 (NSW).
-
On 28 August 2020, the proceedings were set down for hearing for five days commencing on 22 March 2021.
-
By notice of motion filed on Sunday 21 March 2021, the day before the hearing, Mr Zhang sought to withdraw admissions made by him in his List Response that:
he entered into building contracts with various contractors in connection with the residential building work on the subject land;
a company, ZH International Pty Ltd, of which he was a director and shareholder and which is now in liquidation, entered into contracts on his behalf with contractors in relation to that residential building work; and
the Owners Corporation is entitled to the benefit of the statutory warranties.
-
I dealt with the application at the outset of the hearing and refused to grant Mr Zhang leave to withdraw these admissions.
-
These are my reasons.
-
Mr Zhang accepts that, by reason of the provisions of s 3A of the Home Building Act, and in the events that have happened, he was the developer of the project. He contends…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read The Owners - Strata Plan No 93543 v Zhang and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2021] NSWSC 277
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue the court had to address was whether Zhang's application to withdraw certain admissions made in the List Response should be allowed. The admissions included the recognition that the plaintiff was entitled to the benefit of statutory warranties and that Zhang had entered into a contract with the builder and the builder had entered into contracts with contractors on behalf of Zhang. The application to withdraw these admissions was made on the first day of a scheduled five-day hearing. Zhang argued that the admissions were the result of an error by the counsel originally briefed and by the present solicitor. The plaintiff opposed the withdrawal, arguing that allowing it would necessitate further investigation of facts that had been previously admitted, potentially causing significant delays and inconvenience.
The court considered the principles governing applications to withdraw admissions, emphasising the importance of finality and efficiency in litigation. It noted that while the court has discretion to permit the withdrawal of admissions, this discretion is not to be exercised lightly, particularly when the withdrawal would lead to a reopening of matters that had already been decided upon by the parties. The court also took into account the potential disruption and prejudice to the plaintiff if the admissions were withdrawn. Ultimately, the court decided that the application to withdraw the admissions should be refused, as the proposed withdrawal would undermine the integrity of the proceedings and cause unnecessary delay. The court further ordered that the hearing proceed as scheduled.
Background
Background to the litigation
This case came before the court on an application to withdraw admissions made during the proceedings. The application was lodged on the first day of a scheduled five-day hearing. The plaintiff opposed the application, arguing that allowing the defendant to withdraw the admissions would cause unnecessary delays and further investigations into facts that had already been admitted. The court was required to decide whether to permit the withdrawal of the admissions and the implications of such a decision on the proceedings.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the defendant is permitted to withdraw the admissions made on the first day of the hearing.
2. What are the consequences of allowing the withdrawal of the admissions on the scheduled hearing dates and the further investigations required by the plaintiff.
3. Whether the alleged error by the counsel and the current solicitor justifies the withdrawal of the admissions.
Held
1. The court concluded that the defendant is not permitted to withdraw the admissions made on the first day of the hearing.
2. The court determined that allowing the withdrawal of the admissions would necessitate further investigations by the plaintiff, potentially resulting in the vacation of the scheduled hearing dates.
3. The court held that the alleged error by the counsel and the current solicitor did not justify the withdrawal of the admissions.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court considered the application to withdraw admissions made by the defendant in The Owners - Strata Plan No 93543 v Zhang. The admissions, made on the first day of a five-day hearing, acknowledged that the plaintiff owners corporation was entitled to the benefit of statutory warranties. Additionally, the defendant admitted to entering into a contract with the builder of the strata development and that the builder, in turn, entered into contracts with contractors on behalf of the defendant. The defendant sought to withdraw these admissions, attributing the error to counsel who was originally briefed and the current solicitor.
The court examined the principles of practice and procedure in relation to the withdrawal of admissions. It noted that such admissions are generally binding and should not be lightly set aside, particularly when they impact the scheduling and conduct of a multi-day hearing. The court considered the consequences of permitting the withdrawal of admissions, including the potential need for the plaintiff to investigate further facts that had been previously admitted. The court also weighed the impact on the scheduled hearing dates and the additional burden on the plaintiff to conduct further investigations.
The court referred to relevant legal authorities and precedents that underscored the importance of maintaining the integrity of admissions made in court proceedings. It emphasised that allowing the withdrawal of admissions could lead to significant disruptions and unfairness, particularly if the other party has already organised their case around the initial admissions.
The court distinguished between errors made by counsel and the defendant’s current position. It found that the error by the original counsel did not automatically justify the withdrawal of admissions. Furthermore, the current solicitor's stance did not provide a sufficient basis to permit the withdrawal, as the defendant had not demonstrated a compelling reason that would warrant such action. The court concluded that the alleged error did not justify the withdrawal, given the potential for causing further delay and prejudice to the plaintiff. The binding principle established by this decision is that admissions made in court are binding unless there is a compelling reason to set them aside, and such reasons must be demonstrated convincingly to avoid unfairness and disruption to the proceedings.