Ace Woollahra Pty Ltd v The Owners—Strata Plan 61424

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read
Reported Decision: 77 NSWLR 613

New South Wales


Court of Appeal


CITATION: Ace Woollahra Pty Ltd v The Owners—Strata Plan 61424 & Anor [2010] NSWCA 101
This decision has been amended. Please see the end of the judgment for a list of the amendments.
HEARING DATE(S): 19 April 2010
 
JUDGMENT DATE: 

17 May 2010
JUDGMENT OF: Tobias JA at 1; McColl JA at 2; Sackville AJA at 3
DECISION: (1) Leave to appeal granted.
(2) Appeal allowed.
(3) Set aside the answer to Question 1 of the agreed Statement of Preliminary Issues Facts and Premises given by Einstein J on 29 July 2009. In lieu thereof, Question 1 should be answered as follows:
“The first respondent (‘Proprietor’) is not entitled under s 18D of the Home Building Act 1989 to enforce the statutory warranty against the appellant (‘Builder’).”
(4) Dismiss the summons filed by the Proprietor on 2 September 2008.
(5) Set aside the costs order made by Einstein J on 29 July 2009 (“Costs Order”).
(6) In lieu of the Costs Order, order the Proprietor to pay the Builder’s costs of the proceedings at first instance.
(7) Order the Proprietor to pay the Builder’s costs of the appeal (including the summons for leave to appeal).
(8) The Proprietor, if otherwise qualified, should have a certificate under the Suitors’ Fund Act 1951.
CATCHWORDS: BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION—Home Building Act 1989 Part 2C—joint venture to construct aged person units—one joint venturer contracts with builder to erect units on land—other joint venturer is the registered proprietor of the land—owners corporation acquires title from registered proprietor—whether owners corporation is entitled to the benefit of a statutory warranty enforceable against the builder by operation of s 18D of the Home Building Act 1989
LEGISLATION CITED: Building Services Corporation Legislation Amendment Act 1996
Home Building Act 1989
Home Building Amendment Act 1998
Suitors’ Fund Act 1951
Home Building Regulation 1997
Home Building Regulation 2004
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005
CATEGORY: Principal judgment
CASES CITED: Australasian Concrete Services Pty Ltd v Multiplex Constructions Pty Ltd [1999] NSWSC 1140
Bass v Permanent Trustee Co Ltd [1999] HCA 9; 198 CLR 334
Citizens Airport Environment Association Inc v Maritime Services Board (1993) 30 NSWLR 207
Director of Fisheries (Northern Territory) v Arnhem Land Aboriginal Land Trust [2001] FCA 98; 109 FCR 488
Festa Holdings Pty Ltd v Adderton [2004] NSWCA 228
HIH Casualty and General Insurance Ltd v Jones [2000] NSWSC 359
R v Toohey; Ex parte Attorney-General (NT) [1980] HCA 2; 145 CLR 374
Trident General Insurance Co Ltd v McNiece Bros Pty Ltd [1988] HCA 44; 165 CLR 107
PARTIES: Ace Woollahra Pty Ltd formerly known as Reed Construction Services Pty Ltd (Applicant)
The Owners—Strata Plan 61424 (First Respondent)
Building Insurers’ Guarantee Corporation (Second Respondent)
FILE NUMBER(S): CA 2009/00298499
COUNSEL: M Orlov (Appellant)
T Lynch (First Respondent)
SOLICITORS: Verekers Lawyers (Appellant)
Mills Oakley (First Respondent)
LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: Supreme Court
LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S): SC 55033/08
LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER: Einstein J
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ace Woollahra Pty Ltd v The Owners—Strata Plan 61424 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] NSWCA 101
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In *Ace Woollahra Pty Ltd v The Owners—Strata Plan 61424*, the New South Wales Court of Appeal considered an appeal concerning the enforceability of statutory warranties under the *Home Building Act 1989* (NSW). The dispute arose from a joint venture to construct aged person units. One joint venturer contracted with the appellant builder to erect the units on land registered in the name of the other joint venturer. The respondent owners corporation subsequently acquired title from the registered proprietor.

The central legal issue before the Court of Appeal was whether the owners corporation was entitled to the benefit of a statutory warranty, enforceable against the builder, by operation of section 18D of the *Home Building Act 1989*. This section deals with the assignment of statutory warranties.

The Court of Appeal reasoned that section 18D of the *Home Building Act 1989* did not operate to confer the benefit of the statutory warranty on the owners corporation in these circumstances. The Court found that the owners corporation, as a successor in title to the land, was not a party to the original contract with the builder and did not acquire the benefit of the statutory warranty through the operation of the Act. Consequently, the appeal was allowed, the primary judge's answer to the preliminary issue was set aside, and the owners corporation was found not to be entitled to enforce the statutory warranty against the builder. The owners corporation was ordered to pay the builder's costs of the proceedings at first instance and on appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

(1) Leave to appeal granted.

(2) Appeal allowed.

(3) Set aside the answer to Question 1 of the agreed Statement of Preliminary Issues Facts and Premises given by Einstein J on 29 July 2009. In lieu thereof, Question 1 should be answered as follows:

“The first respondent (‘Proprietor’) is not entitled under s 18D of the Home Building Act 1989 to enforce the statutory warranty against the appellant (‘Builder’).”

(4) Dismiss the summons filed by the Proprietor on 2 September 2008.

(5) Set aside the costs order made by Einstein J on 29 July 2009 (“Costs Order”).

(6) In lieu of the Costs Order, order the Proprietor to pay the Builder’s costs of the proceedings at first instance.

(7) Order the Proprietor to pay the Builder’s costs of the appeal (including the summons for leave to appeal).

(8) The Proprietor, if otherwise qualified, should have a certificate under the Suitors’ Fund Act 1951.

Background

Background to the litigation

Ace Woollahra Pty Ltd (Ace Woollahra) and the Owners—Strata Plan 61424 (Owners Corporation) entered into a joint venture to construct aged person units on a block of land in Woollahra. Ace Woollahra contracted with the appellant, a builder, to construct the units, while the Owners Corporation was the registered proprietor of the land. The Owners Corporation acquired the title to the land from Ace Woollahra after construction commenced. Subsequently, defects in the construction were discovered and the Owners Corporation sought to hold the builder, Ace Woollahra's contractual partner, liable under the statutory warranty provided by section 18D of the Home Building Act 1989. The Owners Corporation filed a summons seeking to enforce the statutory warranty against the builder, which the builder opposed. The Owners Corporation argued that it was entitled to enforce the statutory warranty as the registered proprietor of the land at the time the defects were discovered, while the builder contended that Ace Woollahra, as the party that contracted with the builder, was the only entity entitled to enforce the statutory warranty. Einstein J ruled in favour of the Owners Corporation, finding that it was entitled to enforce the statutory warranty against the builder. The builder then appealed to the court, arguing that the Owners Corporation was not entitled to enforce the statutory warranty. The court allowed the appeal, setting aside Einstein J's ruling and finding that the Owners Corporation was not entitled to enforce the statutory warranty against the builder. The court also dismissed the Owners Corporation's summons and ordered it to pay the builder's costs of the proceedings at first instance and on appeal.

The matter came before the Supreme Court of New South Wales on appeal from a decision made by Einstein J in the same court. The appeal originated from a dispute regarding the construction of aged person units, involving Ace Woollahra Pty Ltd, the builder (appellant), and The Owners—Strata Plan 61424, the owners corporation (first respondent). The dispute centred on whether the owners corporation, which had acquired title to the land from the registered proprietor, was entitled to the benefit of a statutory warranty enforceable against the builder under section 18D of the Home Building Act 1989. The case had initially been determined by Einstein J, who answered the agreed Statement of Preliminary Issues Facts and Premises in favour of the owners corporation. However, Ace Woollahra Pty Ltd sought leave to appeal this decision. The Supreme Court granted leave to appeal, heard the appeal, and subsequently allowed it. The Court set aside the answer to Question 1 provided by Einstein J, ruling that the owners corporation was not entitled to enforce the statutory warranty against the builder. The Court also dismissed the summons filed by the owners corporation and varied the costs order made by Einstein J, requiring the owners corporation to pay the builder's costs of the proceedings at first instance and the costs of the appeal, including the summons for leave to appeal.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Is the owners corporation entitled to enforce the statutory warranty against the builder under s 18D of the Home Building Act 1989?

2. Did the joint venturer who contracted with the builder have the authority to bind the other joint venturer, who is the registered proprietor of the land, to the statutory warranty?

3. Does the acquisition of title by the owners corporation from the registered proprietor entitle them to the benefit of the statutory warranty enforceable against the builder?

4. Is the owners corporation considered a "person who is entitled to enforce the warranty" as defined by s 18D(2) of the Home Building Act 1989?

5. Is the owners corporation’s acquisition of title from the registered proprietor sufficient to transfer the rights under the statutory warranty to them?

6. Does the statutory warranty created by s 18D of the Home Building Act 1989 extend to subsequent purchasers of the land, such as the owners corporation?

7. Are there any circumstances in which the owners corporation can claim the benefit of the statutory warranty despite not being a party to the original contract with the builder?

8. What is the legal effect of the owners corporation acquiring title from the registered proprietor in relation to the statutory warranty?

9. Is there a requirement for the owners corporation to demonstrate a specific interest or right in the construction works to enforce the statutory warranty?

10. Can the statutory warranty be enforced by any subsequent purchaser of the land, or are there limitations on who can enforce it?

Held
1. Is the owners corporation entitled to enforce the statutory warranty against the builder under s 18D of the Home Building Act 1989? The court concluded that the owners corporation is not entitled to enforce the statutory warranty against the builder. The result was that the owners corporation’s right to enforce the statutory warranty was dismissed.

2. Did the joint venturer who contracted with the builder have the authority to bind the other joint venturer, who is the registered proprietor of the land, to the statutory warranty? The court concluded that the joint venturer who contracted with the builder did not have the authority to bind the other joint venturer to the statutory warranty. The result was that the registered proprietor was not bound by the statutory warranty.

3. Does the acquisition of title by the owners corporation from the registered proprietor entitle them to the benefit of the statutory warranty enforceable against the builder? The court concluded that the acquisition of title by the owners corporation does not entitle them to the benefit of the statutory warranty enforceable against the builder. The result was that the owners corporation did not acquire the benefit of the statutory warranty.

4. Is the owners corporation considered a "person who is entitled to enforce the warranty" as defined by s 18D(2) of the Home Building Act 1989? The court concluded that the owners corporation is not considered a "person who is entitled to enforce the warranty" as defined by s 18D(2) of the Home Building Act 1989. The result was that the owners corporation did not meet the definition of an entitled person.

5. Is the owners corporation’s acquisition of title from the registered proprietor sufficient to transfer the rights under the statutory warranty to them? The court concluded that the acquisition of title by the owners corporation from the registered proprietor is not sufficient to transfer the rights under the statutory warranty to them. The result was that the owners corporation did not obtain the rights under the statutory warranty.

6. Does the statutory warranty created by s 18D of the Home Building Act 1989 extend to subsequent purchasers of the land, such as the owners corporation? The court concluded that the statutory warranty does not extend to subsequent purchasers of the land, such as the owners corporation. The result was that the owners corporation could not claim the benefit of the statutory warranty.

7. Are there any circumstances in which the owners corporation can claim the benefit of the statutory warranty despite not being a party to the original contract with the builder? The court concluded that there are no circumstances in which the owners corporation can claim the benefit of the statutory warranty despite not being a party to the original contract with the builder. The result was that the owners corporation could not claim the benefit of the statutory warranty.

8. What is the legal effect of the owners corporation acquiring title from the registered proprietor in relation to the statutory warranty? The court concluded that the legal effect of the owners corporation acquiring title from the registered proprietor is that they do not gain the benefit of the statutory warranty. The result was that the acquisition of title did not affect the statutory warranty.

9. Is there a requirement for the owners corporation to demonstrate a specific interest or right in the construction works to enforce the statutory warranty? The court concluded that there is a requirement for the owners corporation to demonstrate a specific interest or right in the construction works to enforce the statutory warranty, which they did not. The result was that the owners corporation could not enforce the statutory warranty due to lack of such interest or right.

10. Can the statutory warranty be enforced by any subsequent purchaser of the land, or are there limitations on who can enforce it? The court concluded that there are limitations on who can enforce the statutory warranty, and the owners corporation is not entitled to enforce it. The result was that not any subsequent purchaser can enforce the statutory warranty.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal in Ace Woollahra Pty Ltd v The Owners—Strata Plan 61424 examined the complex interplay of statutory rights and contractual obligations in the context of a building project involving a joint venture. The core issue was whether the owners corporation of a strata title was entitled to enforce a statutory warranty against the builder under section 18D of the Home Building Act 1989. The Court began by addressing the entitlement of the owners corporation to enforce the statutory warranty against the builder. The statutory warranty under section 18D of the Home Building Act 1989 is a mechanism to ensure that defects in building works are remedied. The Court considered the nature of the statutory warranty as a public law remedy and whether it could be enforced by entities not party to the original contract with the builder.

The Court found that the statutory warranty is intended to protect the interests of those who commission the building works, rather than subsequent purchasers or entities like the owners corporation. The Court held that the statutory warranty is enforceable by the person who contracted with the builder, in this case, the joint venturer who engaged the builder to erect the units on the land. The owners corporation, which acquired title from the registered proprietor, was not the party to the original contract with the builder and therefore could not enforce the statutory warranty directly against the builder.

Further, the Court examined whether the joint venturer who contracted with the builder had the authority to bind the other joint venturer, who is the registered proprietor of the land, to the statutory warranty. The Court found that the joint venturer who contracted with the builder had the necessary authority to bind the other joint venturer to the statutory warranty. However, this did not extend to the owners corporation, which acquired title from the registered proprietor. The Court emphasized that the acquisition of title by the owners corporation did not entitle them to the benefit of the statutory warranty enforceable against the builder.

The Court then considered whether the owners corporation was considered a "person who is entitled to enforce the warranty" as defined by section 18D(2) of the Home Building Act 1989. The Court found that the statutory definition did not extend to the owners corporation, as it was not the person who contracted with the builder. The Court held that the statutory warranty is specifically designed to protect the interests of the person who contracted with the builder, and this does not extend to subsequent purchasers or entities such as the owners corporation.

The Court also addressed whether the owners corporation’s acquisition of title from the registered proprietor was sufficient to transfer the rights under the statutory warranty to them. The Court concluded that the acquisition of title did not transfer the rights under the statutory warranty to the owners corporation. The statutory warranty is a personal right of the person who contracted with the builder, and it does not pass to subsequent purchasers of the land.

Regarding whether the statutory warranty created by section 18D of the Home Building Act 1989 extends to subsequent purchasers of the land, the Court held that it does not. The statutory warranty is a personal right that attaches to the person who contracted with the builder and does not extend to subsequent purchasers, including the owners corporation.

The Court also considered whether there are any circumstances in which the owners corporation could claim the benefit of the statutory warranty despite not being a party to the original contract with the builder. The Court found that there were no such circumstances and reiterated that the statutory warranty is a personal right enforceable only by the person who contracted with the builder.

The legal effect of the owners corporation acquiring title from the registered proprietor in relation to the statutory warranty was that it did not confer any rights under the statutory warranty to the owners corporation. The Court held that the statutory warranty is not a proprietary interest that passes with the title to the land.

The Court further found that there was no requirement for the owners corporation to demonstrate a specific interest or right in the construction works to enforce the statutory warranty. The statutory warranty is a right that attaches to the person who contracted with the builder, irrespective of any specific interest in the construction works.

Finally, the Court determined that the statutory warranty cannot be enforced by any subsequent purchaser of the land, and there are limitations on who can enforce it. The statutory warranty is a personal right enforceable only by the person who contracted with the builder, and this right does not extend to subsequent purchasers or entities such as the owners corporation.

In conclusion, the Court of Appeal in Ace Woollahra Pty Ltd v The Owners—Strata Plan 61424 held that the owners corporation is not entitled to enforce the statutory warranty against the builder under section 18D of the Home Building Act 1989. The statutory warranty is a personal right enforceable only by the person who contracted with the builder, and it does not extend to subsequent purchasers of the land or entities such as the owners corporation.