The Owners Strata Plan No 91086 v Fairview Architectural Pty Ltd (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 71 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

The Owners – Strata Plan No 91086 v Fairview Architectural Pty Ltd (No 3) [2023] FCA 814

File number(s): NSD 940 of 2019
Judgment of: WIGNEY J
Date of judgment: 20 July 2023
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – representative proceedings pursuant to Pt IVA of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) – interlocutory application for an order pursuant to r 9.05 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) that the insurer of the respondent be joined to the proceeding as the second respondent – interlocutory application for leave pursuant to s 5 of the Civil Liability (Third Party Claims Against Insurers) Act 2017 (NSW) to bring and continue the proceeding against the insurer of the respondent – application for leave to file and serve amended originating application and amended statement of claim – consideration of whether affixation of allegedly combustible cladding constitutes property damage within the scope of the second respondent’s insurance policies – consideration of expert evidence regarding methods of cladding affixation and removal – found that cladding removal will cause damage to applicant’s property, including requiring removal of top hat structure and remediation of building prior to affixation of replacement cladding – found that affixation of panels makes property less suitable for intended residential purpose – found that damage caused to building at moment of affixation of cladding – leave to proceed against insurer and to amend pleadings granted
Legislation:

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) sch 2 (Australian Consumer Law) ss 29, 33

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 440D, 444E

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) pt IVA

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) rr 8.21, 9.05, 16.53, 30.01

Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) ss 39B(1A)(c), 79

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) ss 53, 55

Building Products (Safety) Act 2017 (NSW) s 9(1)

Civil Liability (Third Party Claims Against Insurers) Act 2017 (NSW) ss 3(1), 4, 5

Law Reform (Miscellaneous Provisions Act) 1946 (NSW) s 6

Cases cited:

Armstrong World Industries Inc v Aetna Casualty and Surety Co 45 Cal App 4th 1 (Cal Ct App 1996); 52 Cal Rptr 2d 690 (1996)

Austral Plywoods Pty Ltd v FAI General Insurance Company Ltd (1992) 7 ANZ Insurance Cases 61-110; [1992] QCA 4

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Edensor Nominees Pty Ltd (2001) 204 CLR 559; [2001] HCA 1

Bundy Tubing Company v Royal Indemnity Company 298 F2d 151 (6th Cir, 1962)

Canadian Equipment Sales & Service Co Ltd v Continental Insurance Co (1975) 59 DLR (3d) 333

Carwald Concrete and Gravel Co Ltd v General Security Insurance Company of Canada (1985) 24 DLR (4th) 58

Chubb Insurance Australia Ltd v Giabal Pty Ltd; Caitlin Australia Pty Ltd v Giabal Pty Ltd [2020] NSWCA 309

Clough Engineering Ltd v Oil and Natural Gas Corp (2008) 249 ALR 458; [2008] FCAFC 136

DSHE Holdings Ltd (receivers and managers appointed) (in liq) v Abboud [2017] NSWSC 579

F & H Construction v ITT Hartford Insurance Company of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read The Owners Strata Plan No 91086 v Fairview Architectural Pty... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 814
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Owners Strata Plan No 91086 brought a proceeding against Fairview Architectural Pty Ltd and Fairview's insurer, AAI Limited. Fairview had affixed Vitrabond panels to Owners' buildings, which Owners claimed were defective and needed to be removed. Owners sought to join AAI as a respondent and amend its pleadings to include a claim against AAI. The dispute centred on whether AAI's insurance policies covered Fairview's liability for the affixation of the panels, and whether Owners should be allowed to proceed against AAI and amend its pleadings.

The legal issues included whether the affixation of the panels constituted "property damage" within the scope of AAI's insurance policies, and whether Owners should be granted leave to proceed against AAI and amend its pleadings. The court considered expert evidence on the methods of affixation and removal of the panels, and the potential damage caused by removal. The court also considered the provisions of AAI's policies and the Civil Liability (Third Party Claims Against Insurers) Act 2017 (NSW).

The court found that the affixation of the panels caused damage to Owners' property, including the need to remove the top hat structure and remediate the building before replacement cladding could be affixed. The court also found that the affixation of the panels made the property less suitable for its intended residential purpose, and that the damage occurred at the moment of affixation. The court held that it was appropriate to grant Owners leave to proceed against AAI and amend its pleadings, as there were no discretionary reasons for refusing leave. The court also ordered that AAI be joined to the proceeding as a second respondent and that Owners be granted leave to file and serve an amended statement of claim.

The court granted the interlocutory application and made orders joining AAI as a respondent, granting leave to proceed against AAI, and allowing Owners to file and serve an amended statement of claim. AAI was ordered to pay Owners' costs of and incidental to the application. The proceeding was listed for further case management.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to r 9.05 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), AAI Limited (ACN 005 297 807) (trading as Vero Insurance) be joined to the proceeding as the second respondent.

2. Pursuant to s 5 of the Civil Liability (Third Party Claims Against Insurers) Act 2017 (NSW), the applicant have leave to bring and continue the proceeding against AAI Limited.

3. Pursuant to rr 8.21 and 16.53 of the Rules, the applicant have leave to file a further amended originating application and a further amended statement of claim in the form attached to the applicant’s interlocutory application dated 17 December 2021.

4. AAI Limited pay the applicant’s costs of and incidental to this application.

5. The proceeding be listed for further case management on 16 August 2023 at 9.30am.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

It is convenient to first consider the evidence and make factual findings concerning the affixation of the Vitrabond panels to the buildings and the likely effect of their removal. The authorities relied on by the parties, and the arguments that were advanced based on those authorities, can then be considered in light of the factual findings. Evidence As has already been noted, the parties each adduced expert evidence from façade engineers and builders concerning the manner in which the Vitrabond panels were affixed to the relevant buildings and the means by which the panels could be removed. The main issue which divided the experts in relation to that issue was whether the panels could be removed without damaging the “top hat” substructure on which the panels were affixed. The experts also addressed the means or method by which replacement panels could be affixed to the buildings. The main issue which divided the experts in relation to that issue was whether the existing top hat substructure, assuming that it would not be damaged during the removal process, could be re-used for the purpose of affixing the replacement panels. Each of the experts furnished reports. They also gave oral evidence concurrently and were cross-examined.Affixation of the panels Before addressing the main issues which divided the expert witnesses, it is convenient to first address an aspect of their evidence in respect of which there was broad agreement. That issue was the means by which the existing Vitrabond panels had been affixed to the buildings. With the possible exception of one of AAI’s witnesses, whose inspection of the panels on the buildings was very limited, there was ultimately broad agreement between the experts that the Vitrabond panels were affixed to the buildings by means of a subframe structure that comprised vertical and horizontal metal “top hats”. The top hats were affixed to the building in two ways. First, some of the top hats were affixed directly to the concrete wall structure of the buildings using masonry anchors or concrete nails. The concrete wall was covered by sarking (foil backed sheeting used as a moisture barrier), so the affixation of the top hat structure involved piercing the sarking with the anchors or nails. Only horizontal top hats were directly affixed to the concrete. Vertical top hats were then screwed to the horizontal top hats. When affixed in this manner, the vertical and horizontal tops hats were not in the same plane. Second, some (perhaps most) of the top hats were affixed to the vertical steel studs which comprised much of the wall structure in the building. The steel studs were also covered with sarking. Vertical and horizontal top hats were affixed to the metal studs by metal anchors or self-tapping screws. When affixed in this manner, the vertical and horizontal tops hats were in the same plane. The anchors or screws again pierced the sarking placed over the stud walls. Once the top hat subframe was affixed to the buildings, the Vitrabond panels were then affixed to the top hats by means of a very high strength double sided tape. The double sided tape was intended to provide a permanent bond which was capable of withstanding significant wind pressure. Where the top hat subframe had been affixed to the concrete walls, the panels were only taped to the vertical top hats. Where the subframe had been affixed to the steel stud walls, the panels were mainly taped to the horizontal top hats.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Finally, as for clause 3.19, that clause excludes liability in respect of damages arising out of the insured’s “withdrawal, recall, inspection, repair, reconditioning, modification, reinstallation, replacement or loss of use” of its products. There is, however, no evidence that Fairview did any of those things in respect of any of its products. AAI contended that it may be inferred that Fairview had withdrawn or recalled Vitrabond panels from the fact that the authorities had ordered Owners to remove the panels from its buildings. That submission is rejected. No such inference can be drawn. CONCLUSION IN RESPECT OF COVERAGE For the detailed reasons that have been given, it is at the very least arguable that AAI’s policies respond to Fairview’s claim in respect of the compensation it may be found liable to pay Owners arising from the affixation of defective Vitrabond panels to its buildings. On the basis of the evidence currently before the Court, I am satisfied that Fairview’s claim could properly be characterised as a claim in respect of amounts which it might become liable to pay as compensation in respect of “property damage” happening during the period of insurance and caused by an “occurrence”. The property damage comprised physical loss, destruction or damage to Owners tangible property, that property being its buildings, as well as the top hat subframe which had been affixed to the buildings. The occurrence was the affixation of the panels. The loss, destruction or damage was not expected or intended from Fairview’s standpoint. I am not satisfied, on the basis of the evidence currently before the Court, that AAI has established that it is entitled to disclaim liability under its policies. DISCRETION – LEAVE TO PROCEED AGAINST AAI SHOULD BE GRANTED AAI did not identify any factors or considerations that could or should lead to the discretionary refusal of leave under s 5 of the Third Party Claims Act if Owners was able to establish that AAI’s policies responded to Fairview’s claims. Nor am I able to discern any discretionary reasons for refusing leave. Owners has established that it is appropriate to grant it leave to proceed against AAI pursuant to s 5 of the Third Party Claims Act. OTHER ORDERS – JOINDER AND LEAVE TO AMEND AAI’s opposition to the interlocutory orders sought by Owners rested entirely on the proposition that the Court must or should refuse Owners leave to proceed against it pursuant to s 5 of the Third Party Claims Act. For the reasons already given, it is appropriate to grant Owners leave to proceed against AAI. AAI did not submit that, if the Court granted Owners leave to proceed against it, the Court should nonetheless refuse to grant Owners leave to amend its originating application and pleading. It is, in all the circumstances, appropriate to order that AAI be joined to the proceeding as a respondent and appropriate to grant Owners leave to file the further amended originating application and further amended statement of claim in the form annexed to its interlocutory application. DISPOSITION

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

On 7 July 2020, Fairview was placed into voluntary administration by its director. That had the effect of staying Owners’ proceeding against it: see s 440D of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). Fairview subsequently entered into a deed of company arrangement. The deed of company arrangement provided for the transfer of Fairview’s business to a new company, FVA Group Pty Ltd, and the extinguishment of all unliquidated claims against Fairview except to the extent that Fairview held an insurance policy that responded to those claims. On 27 November 2020, the Court granted Owners leave to proceed against Fairview pursuant to s 444E of the Corporations Act: The Owners – Strata Plan No 91086 v Fairview Architectural Pty Ltd [2020] FCA 1892. One of the factors that the Court took into account in granting leave to proceed was that Fairview had insurance policies that arguably covered Owners’ claim. The finding that the policies arguably covered Owners’ claim was made in circumstances where there was no contradictor and without any detailed consideration of the relevant facts and circumstances. It was noted that if AAI declined coverage, Owners may seek leave to join AAI pursuant to the Third Party Claims Act. THE INTERLOCUTORY APPLICATION Owners’ interlocutory application seeks the following orders:1.Pursuant to r 9.05 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) (Rules), AAI Limited (ACN 005 297 807) (trading as Vero Insurance) be joined to the proceeding as the second respondent.2.Pursuant to s 5 of the Civil Liability (Third Party Claims Against Insurers) Act 2017 (NSW), the applicant have leave to bring and continue the proceeding against AAI Limited (the proposed second respondent).3.Pursuant to rr 8.21 and 16.53 of the Rules, the applicant have leave to file a further amended originating application and a further amended statement of claim in the form of Schedule A and Schedule B to this interlocutory application.4.AAI Limited (the proposed second respondent) pay the applicant's costs of and incidental to this application.(Emphasis in original) The interlocutory application was initially supported by an affidavit sworn by Owners’ solicitor, Mr Blagoj (Bill) Petrovski, and a large volume of documents. Mr Petrovski’s affidavit addressed, among other things, Fairview’s deed of company arrangement, the Court’s grant of leave to proceed against Fairview, Fairview’s insurance policies issued by AAI, correspondence with AAI concerning a claim under those policies arising from the affixation of Vitrabond panels to Owners’ buildings and documents relevant to Owners’ application to amend its pleadings. The documentary exhibits included documents relevant to Owners’ claim against Fairview and documents relating to the insurance policies AAI issued to Fairview and AAI’s denial of liability under those policies. Mr Petrovski was not cross-examined. The parties subsequently filed expert reports prepared by façade engineers and building consultants which addressed issues relating to the affixation and removal of the Vitrabond panels that had been affixed to the two buildings in question. That evidence was directed primarily at the question whether the affixation of the panels caused any relevant damage to the buildings, on the premise that the panels are defective and will at some point have to be removed. The experts in due course gave concurrent evidence and were cross-examined. Their evidence and the factual findings arising from it are discussed in detail later in these reasons. THE POLICIES OF INSURANCE