Rushleigh Services Pty Ltd v Forge Group Limited (In Liquidation) (Receivers and Managers Appointed)

Link copied
Case Copied 57 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Rushleigh Services Pty Ltd v Forge Group Limited (In Liquidation) (Receivers and Managers Appointed) [2018] FCA 26

File number: NSD 1382 of 2014
Judge: MARKOVIC J
Date of judgment: 31 January 2018
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for leave to bring or continue proceeding against insurers under Civil Liability (Third Party Claims Against Insurers) Act 2017 (NSW) – where substantive claims made against insured company in liquidation and insured former company directors – where leave to proceed against insured company in liquidation denied – whether to exercise discretion to grant leave to bring or continue proceeding against insurers
Legislation:

Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) s 79

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) rr 9.05, 8.21, 16.53

Civil Liability (Third Party Claims Against Insurers) Act2017 (NSW) s 4, 5

Cases cited:

Bede Polding College v Limit (No 3) Limited and Anor [2008] NSWSC 887

Chubb Insurance Company of Australia Ltd v Moore (2013) 302 ALR 101; [2013] NSWCA 212

DSHE Holdings Ltd (receivers and managers appointed) (in liq) v Abboud; National Australia Bank Limited v Abboud [2017] NSWSC 579

Energize Fitness Pty Ltd v Vero Insurance Limited [2012] NSWCA 213

Hopkins (as trustee for the Hopkins Superannuation Fund) v AECOM Australia Pty Ltd (No 4) (2015) 328 ALR 1; [2015] FCA 307

Opes Prime Stockbroking Ltd (In Liq) (Scheme Administrators Appointed) v Stevens [2014] NSWSC 659

Date of hearing: 19 October 2017
Registry: New South Wales
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Corporations and Corporate Insolvency
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 112
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr M J Darke SC with him Dr O Bigos
Solicitor for the Applicant: Phi Finney McDonald
Counsel for the First Respondent: The first respondent did not appear
Counsel for the Second Respondent: Mr M R Elliott
Solicitor for the Second Respondent: Minter Ellison
Counsel for the Third Respondent: Mr R Shankland
Solicitor for the Third Respondent: Wotton + Kearney
Counsel for Chubb Insurance Australia Limited, Allianz Australia Insurance Limited and Axis Speciality Europe SE: Mr E Muston SC with him Mr J Dooley

ORDERS

NSD 1382 of 2014
BETWEEN:

RUSHLEIGH SERVICES PTY LTD ACN 096 004 803

Applicant

AND:

FORGE GROUP LIMITED ACN 065 464 226 (IN LIQUIDATION) (RECEIVERS AND MANAGERS APPOINTED)

First Respondent

PETER GEOFFREY HUTCHINSON

Second Respondent

DAVID MICHAEL SIMPSON

Third Respondent

CHUBB INSURANCE AUSTRALIA LIMITED (FORMERLY ACE INSURANCE LIMITED) (ACN 001 642 020)
Other

ALLIANZ AUSTRALIA INSURANCE LIMITED (ACN 000 122 850)
Other

AXIS SPECIALITY EUROPE SE (ARBN 131 203 122)
Other

JUDGE:

MARKOVIC J

DATE OF ORDER:

31 JANUARY 2018

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Pursuant to r 9.05 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) (Rules), Chubb Insurance Australia Limited (ACN 001 642 020), Allianz Australia Insurance Limited (ACN 000 122 850) and Axis Speciality Europe SE (ARBN 131 203 122) be joined to the proceeding as the fourth, fifth and sixth respondents respectively.

2.Pursuant to s 5 of the Civil Liability (Third Party Claims Against Insurers) Act

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Rushleigh Services Pty Ltd v Forge Group Limited (In Liquida... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] FCA 26
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Rushleigh Services Pty Ltd applied for leave to bring or continue proceedings against the insurers of Forge Group Limited, a company in liquidation, under the Civil Liability (Third Party Claims Against Insurers) Act 2017 (NSW). The Federal Court was required to decide whether to exercise its discretion to grant leave to proceed against the insurers, Chubb, Allianz, and Axis. The court also needed to determine whether to join these insurers to the proceeding as respondents.

The court considered the Insurers' argument that the application sought to circumvent a previous decision in Rushleigh No 1, where leave to proceed against Forge was denied. The Insurers argued that the claim against Forge was stayed and that Rushleigh could lodge a proof of debt. However, the court found that the Insurers could not rely on the previous decision as a conclusive prediction of the likely outcome. The court noted that the Civil Liability (Insurers) Act can be engaged where proceedings are not taken against a defendant and that the availability of other possible claims by a claimant weighs against granting leave to proceed against the Insurers.

The court granted the application, finding that the Insurers could not rely on the previous decision and that the availability of other possible claims by Rushleigh weighed against denying leave to proceed against the Insurers. The court also found that the Insurers' argument regarding the possibility of inconsistent findings in appeal proceedings was not a sufficient reason to deny leave.

The court made orders joining Chubb, Allianz, and Axis to the proceeding as respondents, granting Rushleigh leave to bring or continue the proceeding against them, and allowing Rushleigh to file and serve a further amended originating application and a further amended statement of claim. The Insurers were ordered to pay Rushleigh’s costs of the application.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to r 9.05 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) (Rules), Chubb Insurance Australia Limited (ACN 001 642 020), Allianz Australia Insurance Limited (ACN 000 122 850) and Axis Speciality Europe SE (ARBN 131 203 122) be joined to the proceeding as the fourth, fifth and sixth respondents respectively.

2. Pursuant to s 5 of the Civil Liability (Third Party Claims Against Insurers) Act 2017 (NSW), the applicant have leave to bring or continue the proceeding against the fourth, fifth and sixth respondents.

3. Pursuant to rr 8.21 and 16.53 of the Rules, the applicant have leave to file and serve a further amended originating application and a further amended statement of claim in the form of schedule A and schedule B respectively to the applicant’s interlocutory application filed on 7 July 2017 (Interlocutory Application).

4. The fourth, fifth and sixth respondents pay the applicant’s costs of paragraphs 1 and 2 of the Interlocutory Application.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Messrs Hutchinson and Simpson appeared at the hearing of the application but did not wish to be heard and made no submissions. BACKGROUND FACTSForge Forge was a public company which provided engineering, procurement, construction, project management and maintenance services for the resources, oil and gas and power sectors. It had operations in Australia, West Africa and the United States of America. On 28 November 2013 Forge announced to the market a profit write-down for the financial year ending 30 June 2014 associated with unbudgeted cost increases in relation to two power projects and a net cash outlay of $45 million to complete both projects. By the close of trade on that day Forge’s share price had fallen 84% from its closing price on 1 November 2013, the last day on which its securities traded prior to the announcement. On 11 February 2014 the directors of Forge resolved to appoint Martin Jones, Andrew Saker and Ben Johnson of Ferrier Hodgson as voluntary administrators of Forge pursuant to s 436A of the Corporations Act (Administrators). On 18 March 2014 the Administrators were appointed as joint and several liquidators of Forge pursuant to ss 446A and 499 of the Corporations Act. Mr Saker subsequently retired as a liquidator of Forge and its subsidiaries, leaving Messrs Jones and Johnson as joint and several liquidators (Liquidators). On 29 August 2014 Forge was removed from official quotation on the Australian Stock Exchange (ASX).The Insurers Chubb, Allianz and Axis are Forge’s primary and excess layer insurers. Chubb Chubb is the primary insurer. It issued a directors and officers liability insurance policy bearing number 05CH007330 to Forge for the period from 30 June 2013 to 30 June 2014 with a limit of liability in the aggregate for all loss of $20 million (Chubb Policy). The Chubb Policy is a claims made policy. The Chubb Policy provides indemnity for claims made against directors and officers. Clause 1 relevantly provides:1. Insuring AgreementA.The Insurer will pay to or on behalf of the Insured all Loss, except where the Company has paid such Loss, resulting from a Claim first made against an Insured during the Policy Period or Discovery Period, if applicable. By Endorsement Number 4 titled “Entity Cover for Securities Claims Endorsement excluding North America” the Chubb Policy provides indemnity for securities claims made against Forge. Clause 1D of that endorsement provides: The Insuring Agreement is extended by adding the following:D.The Insurer will pay to or on behalf of the Company all Loss resulting from any Securities Claim first made against the Company after the Effective Date and during the Policy Period (or Discovery Period if applicable) for any Wrongful Act committed by the Company. Definitions are found in cl 3. Relevantly:(1)cl 3.12 provides that “Insured” means “a natural person who was, now is or becomes during the Policy Period”, among other things, “a Director or Officer”;(2)cl 3.7 defines “Director or Officer” to mean, among other things, “a director or officer of the Company including the equivalent position in any other jurisdiction”; and (3)cl 3.18 defines “Non-Indemnifiable Loss” as follows:Non-Indemnifiable Loss means Loss where a Company is unable to indemnify an Insured due to:(a) legal prohibition; or(b) a prohibition in the Articles of Association, charter, bylaws, contract or similar documents of such Company; or(c)insolvency under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) or the equivalent law in any other jurisdiction.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

For those reasons the Insurers cannot rely on the statement made at [69] of Rushleigh No 1 as a conclusive prediction of the likely outcome. The decision in Rushleigh No 1 The third reason why the Insurers submitted that the Court would not exercise its discretion to grant leave was because of the decision in Rushleigh No 1. The Insurers submitted that this application seeks to circumvent that decision, from which there was no appeal. The Insurers noted that in Rushleigh No 1 Foster J observed at [68] that a claimant should proceed by way of proof of debt unless he or she could demonstrate that there was some good reason to depart from that procedure. The Insurers contended that his Honour held, implicitly, based on his Honour’s refusal to grant leave to proceed against Forge, that there was no good reason warranting departure from the proof of debt process. The Insurers submitted that the alleged “central difference” between the circumstances in this proceeding and those in DSHE Holdings, being the presence of the claim against Forge, is more perceived than real when it is recognised that:(1)the claim against Forge is stayed and no appeal was brought from the decision in Rushleigh No 1;(2)it is open to Rushleigh to lodge a proof of debt in respect of its claim;(3)the Insurers have, subject to the usual reservations, agreed to indemnify Forge in respect of that claim; and(4)Foster J in Rushleigh No 1 concluded that a proof of debt would be the appropriate way to proceed. The Insurers submitted that, contrary to Rushleigh’s contention, Foster J disagreed that a proof of debt procedure was ill-suited to the present case, a conclusion that was not challenged. They submitted that the possibility of inconsistent findings in appeal proceedings brought from the determination of proofs of debt by a liquidator was something that Foster J must have taken into account in determining the application for leave to proceed and that, in any event, such a risk is a reason why any such appeal should be heard concurrently with this proceeding, thereby removing the risk. The Insurers accepted that the Civil Liability (Insurers) Act can be engaged where proceedings are not taken against a defendant. But they submitted that, in considering the exercise of the discretion under the Civil Liability (Insurers) Act, the relevant circumstances would include the availability of other possible claims by a claimant. The Insurers contended that the availability of a more appropriate avenue for relief against an insolvent insured, which has not been acted upon, weighs against granting leave to proceed against the Insurers. The Insurers referred to the decision of the New South Wales Court of Appeal in Energize Fitness Pty Ltd v Vero Insurance Limited [2012] NSWCA 213 (Energize Fitness) at [59]. They submitted that the consequence of the refusal to grant the Leave Application is that no relief is available against Forge in the proceeding and that there will be no “Loss” within the meaning of cl 3.17 of the Chubb Policy incurred by Forge in the proceeding that will be the subject of a grant of indemnity.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Subsequent to filing its originating application Rushleigh sought a declaration pursuant to s 500(2) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Corporations Act) that it have leave, nunc pro tunc, to issue the proceeding against Forge (Leave Application) and an order that the proceeding be transferred pursuant to s 5(4) of the Jurisdiction of Courts (Cross-vesting) Act 1987 (Cth) or, alternatively, s 1337H of the Corporations Act to the Supreme Court of New South Wales (NSW Supreme Court) (Transfer Application). Those applications were heard together. On 7 December 2016 the Court made orders, among others, refusing the Leave Application and the Transfer Application: see Rushleigh Services Pty Ltd v Forge Group Ltd (In Liq) (Receivers and Managers Appointed); In the Matter of Forge Group Ltd (In Liq) (Receivers and Managers Appointed) [2016] FCA 1471 (Rushleigh No 1). I return to the Court’s reasons for refusing those applications later in these reasons. By interlocutory application filed on 7 July 2017 Rushleigh now seeks:(1)an order pursuant to r 9.05 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) (Rules) that Chubb Insurance Australia Limited (formerly ACE Insurance Limited) (Chubb), Allianz Australia Insurance Limited (Allianz) and Axis Speciality Europe SE (Axis) be joined to the proceeding as the fourth, fifth and sixth respondents respectively; (2)leave under s 5 of the Civil Liability (Third Party Claims Against Insurers) Act2017 (NSW) (Civil Liability (Insurers) Act) to bring or continue the proceeding against Chubb, Allianz and Axis, each an insurer under s 4 of that Act; and (3)leave under rr 8.21 and 16.53 of the Rules to file and serve a further amended originating application and a further amended statement of claim which, respectively, remove the claims for relief against Forge and substitute claims for relief against Chubb, Allianz and Axis; and plead the proposed claims against Chubb, Allianz and Axis. Chubb, Allianz and Axis (collectively, Insurers) oppose the application that they be joined to the proceeding and the application for a grant of leave under s 5 of the Civil Liability (Insurers) Act. However, assuming that Rushleigh is successful in its application to join them, they do not oppose its application for leave to file the further amended originating application and further amended statement of claim. Messrs Hutchinson and Simpson appeared at the hearing of the application but did not wish to be heard and made no submissions. BACKGROUND FACTSForge Forge was a public company which provided engineering, procurement, construction, project management and maintenance services for the resources, oil and gas and power sectors. It had operations in Australia, West Africa and the United States of America. On 28 November 2013 Forge announced to the market a profit write-down for the financial year ending 30 June 2014 associated with unbudgeted cost increases in relation to two power projects and a net cash outlay of $45 million to complete both projects. By the close of trade on that day Forge’s share price had fallen 84% from its closing price on 1 November 2013, the last day on which its securities traded prior to the announcement.