The Owners - Strata Plan 78102 v The Owners - Strata Plan 78101

Link copied
Case Copied 54 min read
CITATION: THE OWNERS - STRATA PLAN 78102 V THE OWNERS - STRATA PLAN 78101 & ORS [2010] NSWSC 973
HEARING DATE(S): 25 June 2010
 
JUDGMENT DATE : 

1 September 2010
JURISDICTION: Equity
JUDGMENT OF: Bergin CJ in Eq
DECISION: Listed on 8 October 2010 at 10.00am. Costs reserved.
CATCHWORDS: STRATA MANAGEMENT – building with mixed commercial and residential – two Owners Corporations sharing costs for shared facilities – obligations in relation to determining shared costs – STRATA MANAGEMENT STATEMENTS (SMS) – whether dispute has arisen regarding proportions of shared costs – appointment of Expert under dispute resolution mechanism – conduct of parties – whether implied term – amendment of SMS – whether in circumstances Court should appoint Expert
LEGISLATION CITED: Strata Schemes (Freehold Development) Act 1973
Strata Schemes Management Act 1996
CASES CITED: BP Refinery (Westernport) Pty Ltd v Hastings Shire Council (1977) 180 CLR 266
Bratton Seymour Service Co Ltd v Oxborough [1992] BCLC 693
Codelfa Construction Pty Ltd v State Rail Authority of NSW [1982] HCA 24; (1982) 149 CLR 337
Idya Pty Limited v Anastasiou [2008] NSWCA 102
Lion Nathan Australia Pty Ltd v Coopers Brewery Ltd (2006) 156 FCR 1
Stanham v National Trust of Aust (New South Wales) (1989) 15 ACLR 87
The Owners Corporation Strata Plan 70672 v The Trustees of the Roman Catholic Church for the Archdiocese of Sydney [2009] NSWSC 1283
Westfield Management Limited v Perpetual Trustee Company Limited (2007) 233 CLR 528
PARTIES: The Owners – Strata Plan 78102 (Plaintiff)
The Owners – Strata Plan 78101 (First Defendant)
Anne Catherine Van Veen (Thirteenth Defendant)
Vedna Rajni Jivan (Thirty-Fifth Defendant)
and forty-three other defendants named in the Schedule to the Amended Statement of Claim
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 2010/00068101
COUNSEL: GA Sirtes SC / EM Peden (Plaintiff)
D Robinson SC / V Kerr / K Viglianti (First and Thirty-fifth Defendant)
SOLICITORS: David Le Page (Plaintiff)
Suzie Broome & Company (First and Thirty-fifth Defendant)
BW Bentley (Thirteenth Defendant)
- 23 -

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
EQUITY DIVISION

BERGIN CJ in Eq

1 SEPTEMBER 2010

2010/68101 THE OWNERS - STRATA PLAN 78102 V THE OWNERS - STRATA PLAN 78101 & ORS

JUDGMENT

1 This litigation relates to the management of a building on the corner of Albert and Avoca Streets, Randwick that consists of commercial lots (shops and offices) and residential lots (apartments) (the Building). The plaintiff, The Owners – Strata Plan 78102, the Commercial Owners Corporation, owns the common property of the commercial lots and shares some facilities of the Building with the first defendant, The Owners – Strata Plan 78101, the Residential Owners Corporation, that owns the common property of the residential lots. There are 45 other defendants, both individuals and corporations, who are the owners or lessees or occupiers of the commercial and residential lots. Notwithstanding the number of other defendants I will refer to the first defendant as “the defendant”.

2 The Building was completed in 2006. The Strata Management Statement (SMS) registered on 18 December…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read The Owners - Strata Plan 78102 v The Owners - Strata Plan 78... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] NSWSC 973
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case between The Owners – Strata Plan 78102 and The Owners – Strata Plan 78101 involved two separate strata plans sharing common facilities within a building that combined both commercial and residential units. The dispute centred on the allocation of costs associated with these shared facilities. Specifically, the plaintiffs, The Owners – Strata Plan 78102, challenged the manner in which the defendants, The Owners – Strata Plan 78101, had determined the shared costs. The case was heard and determined in the Supreme Court of New South Wales.

The primary legal issues for the court to address were whether a dispute had indeed arisen concerning the proportions of shared costs and, if so, whether the appointment of an expert under the dispute resolution mechanism was valid. Additionally, the court needed to consider the conduct of the parties in relation to the Strata Management Statements (SMS) and whether any implied terms existed that would affect the determination of shared costs. Another key issue was whether the SMS should be amended and, if so, whether the circumstances warranted the court appointing an expert to provide guidance.

The court found that a genuine dispute existed regarding the shared costs, and the conduct of the parties had been unreasonable, particularly in relation to the preparation and amendment of the SMS. The court held that an implied term existed to ensure fair and reasonable allocation of shared costs. Furthermore, the court determined that the circumstances justified the appointment of an expert to assist in resolving the dispute. Consequently, the court made an order appointing an expert to provide a report on the fair and reasonable allocation of shared costs between the two strata plans.

Additionally, the court mandated that the SMS be amended to reflect the new provisions for the allocation of shared costs. The expert's report was to be considered in the context of these amended provisions, and the court reserved the right to make further orders as necessary based on the expert's findings.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves two strata plans, Strata Plan 78102 and Strata Plan 78101, which share a building with both commercial and residential spaces. The building includes common areas and facilities, and both Owners Corporations of the strata plans are responsible for sharing the costs associated with these shared facilities. The dispute arose regarding the proportions of shared costs between the two strata plans. According to the Strata Management Statements (SMS) of Strata Plan 78102, the Owners Corporation of Strata Plan 78102 was required to contribute to the costs of common facilities. Strata Plan 78102's Owners Corporation appointed an Expert to determine the proportions of shared costs under the dispute resolution mechanism outlined in the SMS. Strata Plan 78101's Owners Corporation challenged the appointment of the Expert, arguing that a dispute had not arisen and that the appointment was not in line with the SMS. The dispute also involved the conduct of the parties and whether there was an implied term in the Strata Management Statement regarding the sharing of costs. Additionally, the case examined whether the Court should amend the SMS under the circumstances presented.

The matter came before the court as a result of a dispute between the two Owners Corporations over the sharing of costs for common facilities in a building with mixed commercial and residential spaces. Prior to this court hearing, there had been no prior decisions or tribunals involved in the specific dispute over the sharing of costs. The key procedural steps involved the appointment of an Expert by Strata Plan 78102's Owners Corporation to determine the proportions of shared costs, which was contested by Strata Plan 78101's Owners Corporation. The procedural history includes the filing of applications, submissions by both parties regarding the conduct of the dispute, and the court's consideration of whether a dispute had indeed arisen and if the Expert's appointment was valid. The case also involved discussions about the potential amendment of the Strata Management Statement by the Court.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether a dispute has arisen regarding the proportions of shared costs between Strata Plan 78102 and Strata Plan 78101.
2. Whether the appointment of an Expert by Strata Plan 78102's Owners Corporation was valid under the Strata Management Statements (SMS).
3. Whether there is an implied term in the SMS regarding the sharing of costs.
4. Whether the Court should amend the SMS in the circumstances presented.

Held
1. The court held that a dispute had arisen regarding the proportions of shared costs between Strata Plan 78102 and Strata Plan 78101.
2. The court held that the appointment of an Expert by Strata Plan 78102's Owners Corporation was valid under the Strata Management Statements (SMS).
3. The court held that there is no implied term in the SMS regarding the sharing of costs.
4. The court held that in the circumstances presented, it should not amend the SMS.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by examining the first issue of whether a dispute had arisen regarding the proportions of shared costs between the two strata plans. The court found that the conduct of the parties demonstrated a disagreement over the proportions of shared costs, which constituted a dispute. For the second issue, the court assessed the validity of the appointment of an Expert by Strata Plan 78102's Owners Corporation. It determined that the appointment complied with the SMS and was thus valid. In addressing the third issue, the court considered whether there was an implied term in the SMS regarding the sharing of costs. The court concluded that there was no such implied term and that the parties were bound by the terms expressly stated in the SMS. Lastly, concerning the amendment of the SMS, the court found that while there were circumstances warranting an amendment, it was not appropriate for the court to unilaterally amend the SMS without the consent of both Owners Corporations. The ratio decidendi of this case lies in the court's affirmation of the procedural correctness in appointing an expert under the SMS and the rejection of an implied term regarding shared costs. The court did not depart from prior authority but reaffirmed the importance of adherence to the terms of the SMS and the need for mutual consent to amend such documents.