Supreme Court
New South Wales
- Amendment notes
Medium Neutral Citation: The Owners - Strata Plan 32735 v Heather Lesley-SWAN [2012] NSWSC 383 Hearing dates: 16 December 2011 Decision date: 10 August 2012 Jurisdiction: Common Law Before: Hall J Decision: (1) Appeal allowed.
(2) The judgment and order of the Local Court made on 30 May 2011 by way of a verdict in the sum of $39,997.18 together with interest be set aside.
(3) The costs order made by the Local Court on 30 May 2011 be set aside.
(4) The proceedings be remitted to the Local Court on the following bases;
(a) The claim for lost rental income only to be determined by that Court constituted by another member of that Court.
(b) Judgment to be entered in favour of the appellant (the defendant to proceedings 2010/3041 in the Local Court) in respect of the respondent's claim in that Court for expenses incurred by her for the re-tiling of the balcony, the subject of the proceedings.
Catchwords: REAL PROPERTY - STRATA MANAGEMENT - Appeal from Local Court - management and control - rights and obligations of proprietors - where owners corporation breached duty to repair and maintain common property - where lot owner made repairs to common property without permission of owners corporation - whether lot owner entitled to be compensated for expense incurred in undertaking rectification work on common property - expenses not recoverable as a loss attributable to breach of duty - Act does not authorise lot owner to determine nature and extent of construction to be undertaken on common property or engage a contractor to perform work on common property without the consent or approval of the owners corporation - statutory and other remedies available to lot owner where owners corporation in breach of statutory duty - whether lot owner entitled to be compensated for loss of rent attributable to the owners corporation's breach of its duty - Magistrate failed to resolve disputed issues of fact and failed to provide proper reasons as to the basis for conclusions reached - order awarding damages for lost rental claimed set aside - rental claim remitted to Local Court for determination. Legislation Cited: Evidence Act 1995
Fair Trading Act 1987
Local Court Act 2007
Strata Schemes Management Act 1996
Strata Titles Act 1973Cases Cited: Alchin v Daley [2009] NSWCA 418
Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd v GSF Australia Pty Ltd [2005] HCA 26; (2005) 79 ALJR 1079
Campbell Davys v Lloyd [1901] 2 Ch 518
Earl of Lonsdale v Nelson (1823) 2 B & C 302, (1823) 107 ER 396
Falcke Scottish Imperial Insurance Co (1886) 34 Ch D 234
Groves v Lord Wimborne [1898] 2 QB 402
Lagan Navigation Co v Lambeg Bleaching, Dyeing and Finishing Co Ltd [1927] AC 226
Lubrano v Proprietors of Strata Plan No 4038 (1993) 6 BPR 13,308
Makita (Australia) Pty Ltd v Sprowles [2001] 52 NSWLR 705, [2001] NSWCA 305
Nicita v Owners of Strata Plan (No 64837) [2010] NSWSC…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read The Owners - Strata Plan 32735 v Heather Lesley-SWAN and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2012] NSWSC 383
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues in this case centred around whether the lot owner was entitled to be compensated for the expense incurred in undertaking rectification work on common property, and whether the lot owner was entitled to be compensated for the loss of rent attributable to the owners corporation's breach of its duty. The court needed to consider the statutory and other remedies available to the lot owner where the owners corporation was in breach of its statutory duty.
The court found that the Magistrate failed to resolve disputed issues of fact and did not provide proper reasons for the conclusions reached. The order awarding damages for lost rental claimed was set aside, and the rental claim was remitted to the Local Court for determination. The court emphasised the need for the tribunal to resolve issues of credibility and to apply the principles of judicial method of reasoning. The court also found that the evidence presented by the lot owner in relation to the market rental value was inadmissible and of little or no weight.
The court concluded that the claim for lost rental had a different basis to the claim for rectification costs, and it was necessary to determine whether it could be said to have been a recoverable loss. In light of the above, the court set aside the order in favour of the respondent on the rental claim and remitted the claim for lost rental to the Local Court for determination. The court did not make any final orders in this appeal, but rather directed that the rental claim be reconsidered by the Local Court.
Background
Background to the litigation
The case originated in the Local Court, where the lot owner, Heather Lesley-Swan, sought damages for the expenses incurred in repairing the common property and for loss of rent attributable to the owners corporation's breach of its duty. The Local Court found in favour of the lot owner and awarded damages for lost rental. The owners corporation appealed the decision to a higher court, arguing that the lot owner was not entitled to be compensated for the expenses incurred in repairing the common property and that the claim for loss of rent was not properly supported. The higher court reviewed the decision of the Local Court and found that the lot owner was not entitled to be compensated for the expenses incurred in repairing the common property and that the claim for loss of rent should be remitted to the Local Court for further determination.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the lot owner is entitled to be compensated for the expenses incurred in repairing the common property without the permission of the owners corporation.
2. Whether the lot owner is entitled to be compensated for loss of rent attributable to the owners corporation's breach of its duty.
3. Whether the Magistrate failed to resolve disputed issues of fact and provide proper reasons for the conclusions reached in the original decision.
Held
1. The court concluded that the lot owner is not entitled to be compensated for the expenses incurred in repairing the common property without the permission of the owners corporation. The expenses were not recoverable as a loss attributable to the breach of duty. The Act does not authorise the lot owner to determine the nature and extent of construction to be undertaken on the common property or engage a contractor to perform work without the consent or approval of the owners corporation.
2. The court held that the lot owner is not entitled to be compensated for the loss of rent attributable to the owners corporation's breach of its duty. The court found that the lot owner's claim for lost rental was afflicted by errors of law and should be set aside. The claim for lost rental should be remitted to the Local Court for determination.
3. The court found that the Magistrate failed to resolve disputed issues of fact and provide proper reasons for the conclusions reached in the original decision. The order awarding damages for the lost rental claimed was set aside, and the rental claim was remitted to the Local Court for determination.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In Pollard v RRR Corporation [2009] NSWCA 110 McColl JA emphasised the need, where there are issues of credibility involved in sub-issues, for the tribunal to resolve them. Her Honour observed: In my opinion, his Honour failed, in finding in favour of the respondent on the loss of rental, to apply the above principles. His Honour made no reference to the evidence, or to the submissions and on the issue of the condition of the balcony on September 2007, whether the photographs in Annexure G were taken in September 2007 or after work was performed in April 2008. In determining the likely market rental for the property his Honour accepted the evidence of Mr Pavlakis over Mr Hyam. The evidence of Mr Pavlakis, however, did not comply with the essential requirements for expert evidence. The opinion given by him as to market rental value consisted of an unsupported assertion without reference to comparable rental data or other underpinning material to support it. In those circumstances the evidence of Mr Pavlakis was strictly inadmissible: Makita (supra) at 731, 743 - 5 per Heydon JA (as his Honour then was). The evidence of Mr Pavlakis was in any event, for the reasons discussed above, of little or no weight. The learned Magistrate failed to evaluate its probative value and additionally failed to resolve the conflict between Mr Pavlakis' opinion and that of Mr Hyam. The failure to do so constitutes an omission to apply judicial method of reasoning in accordance with the principles discussed above. The order in favour of the respondent on the rental claim was accordingly afflicted by errors of law and should be set aside. The claim for lost rental, of course, has a different basis to the claim for rectification costs. It is claimed as a direct loss said to have resulted from the appellant's breach of statutory duty. Whether it could be said to have been a recoverable loss was a matter that required determination as discussed above. In the circumstances the rental claim in the proceedings should be remitted to the Local Court for determination. Accordingly, I have concluded that the following orders should be made: