Thanh Huynh and Australian Postal Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

[2015] AATA 235 

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number(s)

2012/4849

2014/4024
2014/4026

2014/4027

Re

Thanh Huynh

APPLICANT

And

Australian Postal Corporation

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

John Handley, Senior Member 

Date 17 April 2015
Place Melbourne

The decisions under review are each set aside and in substitution it is decided the respondent is liable:

1.          in applications, 2014/4024 and 2014/4027, to pay compensation from the date of the reviewable decisions pursuant to ss 16 and 19 of the Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (the Act); and

2.          in application 2014/4026, to pay compensation pursuant to s 14 of the Act; and

3.          in application 2012/4849, to pay compensation pursuant to s 19 of the Act from 3 August 2012 calculated by regard to the loss of income by incapacity to work overtime.

The applicant is entitled to have his costs and disbursements paid by the respondent pursuant to part 6.10 of the Guide to the Workers Compensation Jurisdiction (version 2.0).

.....[sgd]...................................................................

Senior Member

WORKERS COMPENSATION – Applicant diagnosed with plantar fasciitis – worked more than 20 years standing and walking on concrete floors – plantar fasciitis idiopathic , pre-existing and a  non-compensable ailment – bilateral chronic pain experienced – no change in the pathology of the condition – applicant vulnerable to pain by the employment activities – no relevant distinction between aggravation or exacerbation – pain part of the disease – contribution to a significant degree by the employment – decisions set aside.

Legislation

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988, sections 4, 5A, 5B, 14, 16 and 19

Cases

Federal Broom Company Pty Ltd v Semlitch (1964) 110 CLR 626

Commonwealth Banking Corporation v Percival (1988) 20 FCR 176

Commonwealth of Australia v Beattie (1981) 35 ALR 369

Tippett v Australian Postal Corporation (1998) 27 AAR 40

Wiegand v Comcare Australia [2002] FCA 1464

Mellor v Australian Postal Corporation (2009) 108 ALD 159

Treloar v Australian Telecommunications Commission (1990) 97 ALR 321

Comcare v Sahu-Khan (2007) 156 FCR 536

Comcare v Canute (2005) 148 FCR 232

Canute v Comcare (2006) 226 CLR 535

Popovski v Ericsson Australia Pty Ltd (1998) VSC 61

Meddis v Victorian WorkCover Authority and Anor (County Court, Unreported, 24 April 1996)

Allman v Major Furnace and Engineering Pty Ltd (County Court, Unreported, 14 March 1997)


REASONS FOR DECISION

John Handley, Senior Member

17 April 2015

  1. Mr Huynh, the applicant in these proceedings, arrived in Australia in 1979. He was born in Vietnam and has been a full-time employee of the respondent since 1993. He is presently 60 years of age.

  2. He applies to review two decisions of the respondent, the Australian Postal Corporation, seeking to restore liability which had previously been accepted for plantar fasciitis of his right foot and to review two decisions of the respondent for plantar fasciitis of his left foot, for which liability was denied.

  3. The diagnosis of bilateral plantar fasciitis was not in issue. The issues principally in dispute were the relationship between plantar fasciitis and the employment and whether the applicant…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Thanh Huynh and Australian Postal Corporation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] AATA 235
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Thanh Huynh against the Australian Postal Corporation involved a dispute over the relationship between the applicant's bilateral plantar fasciitis and his employment, and whether this condition incapacitated him from working overtime. The applicant, who had worked in various roles involving significant standing and walking, alleged that his employment significantly contributed to his condition. The respondent denied this relationship and argued that the applicant was capable of working overtime.

The primary legal issues in the case were whether the applicant's bilateral plantar fasciitis was significantly contributed to by his employment and whether this condition incapacitated him from working overtime. The applicant contended that his employment, involving prolonged standing and walking, significantly contributed to his condition, which is an ailment under the relevant legislation. The respondent denied this relationship, arguing that any pain experienced by the applicant was merely a temporary exacerbation and that he remained capable of working overtime.

The court found that the applicant's bilateral plantar fasciitis was indeed significantly contributed to by his employment, as evidenced by the prolonged periods of standing and walking involved in his roles. The court accepted the medical evidence that the applicant's work had exacerbated or aggravated his condition. Additionally, the court ruled that the applicant's condition did incapacitate him from working overtime, given the extent of his pain at the end of his base hours. Consequently, the court decided in favour of the applicant on these key points.

The court ordered that the respondent's decisions to deny compensation for the applicant's incapacity to work overtime were to be reviewed, and the applicant was to be compensated for his loss of income due to his inability to work overtime. The court also determined that the applicant's condition was significantly contributed to by his employment, affirming the applicant's primary contentions.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant began his employment with the Australian Postal Corporation (APC) in 1993 and worked in various roles, all of which required standing for significant periods. He worked as a mail officer at the Southern Mail Centre in Clayton, where he rotated between sitting and standing positions every hour. His duties involved sorting and processing mail, which required heavy lifting and prolonged standing on a concrete floor. The applicant worked overtime regularly, averaging about six hours per week, until he began experiencing heel pain in April 2009. The pain was initially in his right heel and later developed in his left heel. Despite a rehabilitation plan suggesting alternating between 30 minutes standing and 90 minutes sitting, the applicant did not follow this regime until May 2011. The applicant claimed compensation for loss of income due to his incapacity to work overtime after the onset of heel pain. APC initially compensated the applicant but later ceased payments, asserting that the applicant could still earn his normal weekly earnings.

The case before the court involved a review of several decisions made by the APC regarding the applicant's compensation for loss of income due to incapacity to work overtime. The applicant had previously sought compensation for the impact of his bilateral plantar fasciitis on his ability to work overtime, a condition he claimed was significantly contributed to by his employment. The APC had paid compensation until 3 August 2012 but subsequently denied further compensation, asserting that the applicant could still earn his normal weekly earnings. The applicant challenged these decisions, leading to this review proceeding.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The diagnosis of bilateral plantar fasciitis was not in issue. The issues principally in dispute were the relationship between plantar fasciitis and the employment and whether the applicant had an incapacity to work overtime.The EvidenceThe Applicant The applicant first worked in Australia operating a machine which printed T-shirts. His duties involved folding and packing the T-shirts into boxes. He then obtained employment elsewhere connecting electrical cables to lights. He worked whilst standing in both of those jobs. He did not have heel pain. He then obtained employment for about two months with the respondent but left when he obtained a tip truck and became a self-employed driver for about five years. On 18 May 1993 the applicant re-commenced work with the respondent and has remained in its employment. He worked initially as a mail officer at the Southern Mail Centre in Clayton. His work involved one-hourly rotations each day between sitting and standing. The applicant also worked overtime which was regularly available at about six hours per week. In 1999, the applicant moved to the Dandenong Letters Centre. He rotated between different sections which involved sorting and processing mail. Compared to his previous duties at the Southern Mail Centre, the applicant was exposed to heavy work, frequently lifting bags, tubs and boxes of mail up to 16 kilograms and significantly, much more standing whilst working. All of his work was conducted wearing heavy boots, standing and walking on a concrete floor. The applicant affirmed a statement he lodged prior to the proceedings dated 12 August 2014 (Exhibit A1) where at paragraphs 7 and 8 he recorded:7.….I did not sit down at all unless I was on a break…. I was working a nine-day fortnight during this period and performed approximately 10 hours of work per day including the regular overtime.8.…. If I was lucky I would get half an hour to sit down whilst sorting but most of the time I was on my feet … On 7 April 2009 the applicant experienced pain in the heel of his right foot whilst at work. In his incident report (T4, page 36), investigation reports (T4, page 37 and T5, page 39) and a witness statement (T8, page 43) there are recordings of the pain occurring after working the entire shift whilst standing and walking. Despite a rehabilitation plan recommending that the applicant work alternating between 30 minutes standing and 90 minutes of sitting, commencing on 4 May 2009 (T13, page 51), the applicant said that regime did not commence until May 2011. He said from May 2009 he worked alternating between sitting and standing each at one hour. The basic shift worked by the applicant was 7 hours and 21 minutes. Before April 2009, the applicant always worked overtime which was regularly offered. He worked overtime after April 2009 until August 2011, at about the time he began to experience pain in his left heel. He claimed compensation for loss of income by incapacity to work overtime. His normal weekly earnings (NWE) were calculated having regard to the regularity of overtime that he had worked and which would have been available to him. The respondent paid compensation until 3 August 2012 as a consequence of the loss of income by incapacity to work overtime. From that date the respondent decided, by regard to a report from Dr Turnbull, its facility nominated doctor, that the applicant has a capacity to earn his NWE (T94, page 178 and T99, pages 185 – 187). In effect, the respondent ceased compensation payments for loss of income by incapacity to work overtime. That is one of the decisions under review in this proceeding.

Decision

Reasons for decision

He said the extent of the applicant’s pain at the end of his base hours incapacitated him from working overtime. He did not dismiss the possibility of overtime being resumed but only if he was appropriately treated and the work undertaken in overtime allowed him to remain seated.Conclusion and Reasons for Decision The applicant impressed me as a witness of truth. He did not embellish or exaggerate the pain he suffers in both feet which, as a fact, I am satisfied he endures. The parties agree that the applicant suffers bilateral plantar fasciitis. The evidence points to the painful effects of the condition first becoming apparent in the applicant’s right foot and later in his left foot. As a fact, I am satisfied that there was a significant contribution to the bilateral pain (as a consequence of the bilateral plantar fasciitis) by the applicant’s employment. I will give reasons for this finding later. The respondent has made four decisions which are under review in these proceedings:(a)2012/4849 – the applicant is able to earn NWE and has no present entitlement under s 19 of the Act; (the respondent had paid compensation for loss of income by incapacity to work overtime up to 3 August 2012);(b)2014/4024 – liability denied pursuant to ss 16 and 19 of the Act for the left foot;(c)2014/4026 – liability denied pursuant to s 14 of the Act for the left foot:(d)2014/4027 – no present entitlement to compensation benefits pursuant to ss 16 and 19 of the Act for the right foot. On behalf of the applicant it was submitted that bilateral plantar fasciitis is an idiopathic inflammatory condition which is aggravated and/or exacerbated by protracted periods of standing and walking on hard surfaces. The condition is an ailment within the meaning of the Act (s 5B) to which the employment has contributed to a significant degree. The development of the condition occurred over many years of employment with the respondent and the pain which subsequently emerged has continued. It is now chronic and the effects of it have not ceased. The respondent contends that there is no relationship between bilateral plantar fasciitis and the employment, any pain suffered by the applicant is no more than a temporary exacerbation and the employment did not contribute significantly to the manifestation of bilateral plantar fasciitis. Additionally, it was contended that the applicant is capable of working overtime. Dr Bloom reported that the applicant’s work had significantly contributed to an aggravation and/or exacerbation of the painful symptoms. Mr Haig reported a similar conclusion but confined it to an aggravation. In evidence, they both resiled from the reported opinions of aggravation and preferred the expression exacerbation. They both said the symptoms of pain were likely to spontaneously resolve and the painful symptoms can therefore be regarded as having a temporary duration. The concept of aggravation suggested to them a degree of permanence which by the characteristics of the diagnosed condition, was not appropriate. Dr Turnbull was also of the view that the pain is likely to be of temporary duration. Hopefully, the prophecy of each of those doctors is fulfilled.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the evidence presented regarding the applicant's employment history and the onset of his bilateral plantar fasciitis. It noted that the applicant's duties involved significant standing and walking, and that the condition first became apparent in his right foot after working an entire shift standing and walking. Despite a rehabilitation plan recommending alternating between sitting and standing, the applicant did not start following this regime until May 2011. The court found that the evidence pointed to a significant contribution to the bilateral pain by the applicant's employment. It dismissed the respondent's argument that the relationship between the condition and the employment was not significant and that any pain suffered by the applicant was merely a temporary exacerbation.

The court also considered the opinions of medical experts who testified on behalf of the applicant. Dr Bloom and Mr Haig both concluded that the applicant's work had significantly contributed to an aggravation and/or exacerbation of the painful symptoms. While they initially reported on aggravation, they later preferred the expression exacerbation, stating that the symptoms were likely to spontaneously resolve and therefore be of temporary duration. The court took these expert opinions into account in determining the relationship between the condition and the employment.

In regards to the incapacity to work overtime, the court accepted the applicant's testimony that the extent of his pain at the end of his base hours incapacitated him from working overtime. It did not dismiss the possibility of overtime being resumed, but only if the applicant was appropriately treated and the work undertaken in overtime allowed him to remain seated. The court found that the applicant had a present entitlement to compensation benefits for the incapacity to work overtime, as the respondent had ceased compensation payments for loss of income by incapacity to work overtime without sufficient justification.

The court's reasoning and ratio in this case established the binding legal principle that an employee's employment can significantly contribute to the manifestation of a diagnosed condition, and that in such cases, the employer may be liable for compensation benefits. The court departed from the respondent's argument that the relationship between the condition and the employment was not significant and that any pain suffered by the applicant was merely a temporary exacerbation. The court followed the expert opinions of medical professionals in concluding that the applicant's employment had indeed contributed to a significant degree to the manifestation of his bilateral plantar fasciitis.