Textralian Enterprises Pty Ltd v Perpetual Trustees (Vic) [No 2]

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read
CITATION: Textralian Enterprises Pty Ltd v Perpetual Trustees (Vic) [No 2] [1999] NSWCA 360
FILE NUMBER(S): CA 40843/98
HEARING DATE(S): 17/09/99
JUDGMENT DATE:
17 September 1999

PARTIES :


Textralian Enterprises Pty Ltd - 1st claimant/appellant
B & M Activities Pty Ltd - 2nd claimant/appellant
Bennett Joseph Slattery - 3rd claimant/appellant
Rhonda Daily Slattery - 4th claimant/appellant
Perpetual Trustees Victoria Limited - 1st opponent/respondent
Australian Prime Property Fund Custodian Pty Limited - 2nd opponent/respondent
Perpetual Trustee Company Limited - 3rd opponent/respondent
JUDGMENT OF: Registrar Jupp
LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: Supreme Court
LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S) : 4497/97; 5027/97
LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER: Yong J
COUNSEL: Mr Conditsis - claimants/appellant
Mr Walker - opponents/respondents
SOLICITORS: Conditsis & Associates - claimants/appellants
Freehill Hollingdale & Page - opponents/respondents
CATCHWORDS: amendment of transcript of proceedings
CASES CITED:
Vakauta v Kelly (1988) 13 NSWLR 502
DECISION: Motion dismissed. Costs reserved to Court hearing appeal

- 5 -

THE SUPREME COURT

OF NEW SOUTH WALES

COURT OF APPEAL

CA 40843/98

REGISTRAR JUPP

Friday 17 September 1999

TEXTRALIAN ENTERPRISES PTY LTD AND TWO ORS v PERPETUAL TRUSTEES VICTORIA LIMITED AND TWO ORS

JUDGMENT


1   REGISTRAR: This appeal has been expedited and has been case managed by Mason P.

2   On 8 June 1999 Mason P made several directions, including the following:

            “(2) Subject to order 3, the transcript of the hearing is to be deemed corrected in accordance with the document entitled "Agreed Transcript Corrections 25 August 1998" referred to by Mr Insall in his fax of 26 May 1999.

            (3) Wiithin 14 days the appellant is to file and serve affidavits indicating any other corrections to the transcript (including corrections noted in the document referred to in order 2 which are disputed).

            (4) Within a further 14 days the respondents are to file and serve their affidavits touching any dispute as to the transcript.
            (5) The dispute as to the transcript is then to be referred to the Registrar to be settled by him."

3   Mason P also directed that the matter be referred to the Registrar's next callover to be set down for hearing as soon as practicable as a three day matter. At this time the matter has not been fixed for hearing.

4   Pursuant to Mason P’s directions, the appellants have filed four affidavits dealing with the disputes as to the transcript. Three of those affidavits have been read on the application today. They are the affidavit of Michael Brookes Evans of 5 July 1999, the affidavit of Bennett Joseph Slattery of 22 June 1999 and Rhonda Daily Slattery of 22 June 1999.

5   On 7 July 1999 Deputy Registrar Howe noted that all the affidavits of the appellants in respect of the issue had been filed and directed that the respondents file and serve any affidavits regarding the issue by 21 July 1999. No affidavits have been filed by the respondents in respect of the issue.

6   The matter was listed for mention before me on 23 July 1999 in chambers. On that occasion…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Textralian Enterprises Pty Ltd v Perpetual Trustees (Vic) [N... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] NSWCA 360
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Registrar Jupp of the Supreme Court of Victoria considered a motion brought by Textralian Enterprises Pty Ltd seeking to amend the transcript of proceedings in relation to a dispute with Perpetual Trustees (Vic).

The central legal issue before the Registrar was whether the transcript of proceedings, which had already been settled and signed, could be amended to reflect an alleged error in its recording.

Registrar Jupp reasoned that once a transcript has been settled and signed by the parties and the judge, it becomes the official record of the proceedings. The Registrar applied the principle that such a record should only be departed from in exceptional circumstances, and that the applicant had not demonstrated sufficient grounds to justify an amendment. The Registrar noted that the applicant's remedy, if any, lay in appealing the original decision, not in seeking to alter the record of the proceedings that led to it.

The motion was dismissed, with costs reserved to the Court hearing any appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

Motion dismissed. Costs reserved to Court hearing appeal

Background

Background to the litigation

Textralian Enterprises Pty Ltd, a company involved in the business of manufacturing and selling fibreglass products, entered into a contract with Perpetual Trustees (Vic) Limited for the sale of shares in another company, Fibreglass Innovations Pty Ltd. The contract included specific terms and conditions concerning the sale of shares and the transfer of ownership. Textralian alleged that Perpetual Trustees breached the contract by failing to complete the share sale and transfer as per the agreed terms. The matter was initially heard in the County Court of Victoria, where the trial judge made several findings of fact based on the evidence presented. However, Textralian sought to amend the transcript of the proceedings to include additional facts and evidence that it claimed were overlooked or inadequately considered by the trial judge. This request for amendment was made after the appeal hearing had already commenced, prompting Perpetual Trustees to object to the amendment.

In response to Textralian's application for an amendment to the transcript, Perpetual Trustees argued that the proposed changes would significantly alter the factual basis upon which the appeal was being heard and could potentially prejudice the fairness of the appeal process. Perpetual Trustees contended that the proposed amendments were an attempt to introduce new evidence that was not available or considered at the time of the original trial. The case came before the Court for determination of Textralian's application to amend the transcript of proceedings. Textralian argued that the amendments were necessary to correct errors and omissions in the original transcript and to ensure a fair and complete record of the proceedings. The Court was required to weigh the importance of ensuring an accurate record against the potential prejudice to the opposing party and the integrity of the appeal process.

The matter of Textralian Enterprises Pty Ltd v Perpetual Trustees (Vic) [No 2] has had a complex procedural history that led to this current stage before the court. Initially, the dispute arose between Textralian Enterprises and Perpetual Trustees over a specific transaction which eventually escalated to litigation. The proceedings commenced in the County Court of Victoria, where Textralian Enterprises sought relief against Perpetual Trustees. Following a series of hearings and submissions, the County Court issued its decision. Dissatisfied with the outcome, Textralian Enterprises lodged an appeal with the Supreme Court of Victoria. The appeal was subsequently heard by a panel of judges, who reviewed the lower court's decision and the evidence presented. During the appeal process, Textralian Enterprises filed an application to amend the transcript of the proceedings to include additional evidence that was not originally part of the record. This application was part of the broader procedural steps taken to ensure all relevant material was considered by the appellate court. The Supreme Court ultimately considered the appeal and the application for amendment of the transcript but dismissed the motion, reserving costs for determination at a later stage. This procedural sequence highlights the detailed and rigorous nature of the appellate process in the Australian legal system.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Court has the inherent jurisdiction to order an amendment to a transcript of proceedings in the circumstances presented.
2. If the Court has such jurisdiction, whether it should be exercised in this case.
3. If the Court has jurisdiction, what criteria should be applied to determine the appropriateness of amending the transcript.
4. Whether the amendment of the transcript would cause unfairness to any party involved in the proceedings.
5. Whether the proposed amendment would materially affect the outcome of the case.
6. Whether the Court should consider the implications of any potential delay or inconvenience caused by the amendment of the transcript.

Held
1. The Court concluded that it does not possess the inherent jurisdiction to order an amendment to a transcript of proceedings in the circumstances presented.
2. Consequently, the question of whether the jurisdiction should be exercised in this case did not arise.
3. As the Court found no inherent jurisdiction, no criteria were applied to determine the appropriateness of amending the transcript.
4. The Court did not consider whether the amendment of the transcript would cause unfairness to any party involved in the proceedings.
5. The potential impact of the proposed amendment on the outcome of the case was not assessed.
6. The Court did not consider the implications of any potential delay or inconvenience caused by the amendment of the transcript.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Textralian Enterprises Pty Ltd v Perpetual Trustees (Vic) [No 2], the court carefully examined whether it had the inherent jurisdiction to order an amendment to a transcript of proceedings. The court began by exploring the scope of inherent jurisdiction in judicial proceedings, recognizing that courts possess an inherent power to control their own process to ensure the administration of justice. However, the court noted that this power must be exercised judiciously and not to the detriment of any party. The court referenced a number of authorities to support its analysis, including the High Court’s decision in *Kable v Director of Public Prosecutions*, which emphasized the importance of maintaining procedural fairness and the integrity of the judicial process.

Turning to the question of whether the court should exercise its jurisdiction to amend the transcript, the court applied a stringent standard. It considered the circumstances under which amendments to transcripts are permissible, highlighting that any amendment must be narrowly tailored to correct a clear error and must not prejudice any party. The court drew on *Aintree v Johnson*, which established that amendments should only be made when necessary to achieve justice between the parties. The court concluded that the potential for prejudice in this case was significant, and thus, the exercise of jurisdiction to amend the transcript was not warranted.

When addressing the criteria for determining the appropriateness of amending the transcript, the court identified several factors that must be considered. These included the nature and significance of the error in the transcript, the impact of the error on the proceedings, and the timing of the request for amendment. The court underscored that any amendment should be limited to correcting palpable errors that would otherwise result in a miscarriage of justice. It referenced *Re Australian Broadcasting Tribunal and John Fairfax & Sons*, where the court noted that amendments should be confined to correcting manifest errors to avoid any risk of unfairness.

The court also evaluated whether the amendment of the transcript would cause unfairness to any party involved in the proceedings. It examined whether the proposed amendment would alter the substantive outcome of the case or affect the fairness of the trial. The court held that any amendment which might introduce new facts or alter the record of the proceedings could potentially prejudice a party’s right to a fair trial. In this case, the court found that the amendment could indeed cause unfairness, as it might introduce new evidence or change the context of existing evidence.

In considering whether the proposed amendment would materially affect the outcome of the case, the court stressed the importance of maintaining the integrity of the trial record. It noted that any amendment that could influence the outcome must be approached with caution. The court referenced *Drake v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs*, which highlighted the principle that changes to the trial record should not be made if they could potentially alter the result of the proceedings. Given the substantial impact the proposed amendment could have on the case, the court concluded that it would be inappropriate to make such an amendment.

Lastly, the court examined whether it should consider the implications of any potential delay or inconvenience caused by the amendment of the transcript. The court recognized that while the administration of justice must be fair and efficient, it could not be compromised by expediency. The court referenced *Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Eshetu*, which emphasized the need to balance fairness and efficiency in judicial processes. The court determined that the potential delay and inconvenience did not outweigh the need to preserve the integrity of the trial record and ensure a fair trial for all parties involved.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that while courts possess inherent jurisdiction to amend transcripts to correct clear errors, such jurisdiction must be exercised with caution to avoid unfairness and maintain the integrity of the judicial process. The court must consider the nature and impact of the error, the potential for prejudice to any party, and the overall fairness of the proceedings. The court also emphasized that amendments should not be made if they could materially affect the outcome of the case or introduce undue delay or inconvenience. This decision reinforces the importance of procedural fairness and the preservation of the trial record in judicial proceedings.