[2023] HCATrans 160
IN THE HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Office of the Registry
Adelaide No A9 of 2023
B e t w e e n -
TESSERACT INTERNATIONAL PTY LTD
Appellant
and
PASCALE CONSTRUCTION PTY LTD
Respondent
GAGELER CJ
GORDON J
EDELMAN J
STEWARD J
GLEESON J
JAGOT J
BEECH‑JONES J
TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS
AT CANBERRA ON WEDNESDAY, 15 NOVEMBER 2023, AT 10.00 AM
Copyright in the High Court of Australia
MR B.W. WALKER, SC: May it please the Court, I appear with my learned friends, MR T.J. MARGETTS, KC and MR L.J. CONNOLLY for the appellant. (instructed by Macpherson Kelley)
MR F.P. HICKS, SC: May it please the Court, I appear with my learned friend MR W.V. McMANUS for the respondent. (instructed by Kennedys (Australasia) Partnership and FBR Law (as known Agent))
GAGELER CJ: Mr Walker.
MR WALKER: May it please your Honours. The starting point is the statute concerning the decision or rules for an arbitration governed by the Commercial Arbitration Act by way of a general proposition, which is uncontroversial between these parties and currently in this country. The Act is a mixture of international influence and local stipulation. Section 28 of the Commercial Arbitration Act 2011 distinguishes between the party choice of the:
rules of law as . . . applicable to the substance of the dispute.
That is subsection (1), and that which may follow from the designation by the parties, subsection (2), or:
Failing any designation –
by the application of the relevant:
conflict of laws rules –
subsection (3), for the choice of that decision or law. In this case, it is uncontroversial – and for obvious reasons – that it was the law of South Australia, being an Australian jurisdiction. Of course, that means the amalgam of the common law of the Commonwealth, the legislative law of the Commonwealth and, of course, the legislative of the State. Subsection (4) of section 28 contemplates though with no particular footing in this case, particular agreement between parties to an arbitration for what are called:
such other considerations as are agreed –
by them to decide the dispute. And subsection (5) returns to the notion of contract and, bearing in mind the epithet commercial contains a traditional reference to “the usages of the trade”. Those are, as I say, familiar and in large part traditional but modernised provisions concerning the decisional law that must be applied pursuant to an arbitration agreement.
In this case, that law was and is still agreed by the parties to be as determined by the parties by their agreement in light of the circumstances bringing into play the choice of law to be the law of South Australia, including what we have labelled the “proportionate liability law”, being a portmanteau expression designed to convey both the South Australian provisions of the Law Reform (Contributory Negligence and Apportionment of Liability) Act 2001 as well as the relevant provisions of the Competition and Consumer Act2010 (Cth).
As your Honours…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Tesseract International Pty Ltd v Pascale Construction Pty L... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2023] HCATrans 160
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the High Court was whether a party to a contract, who has purported to terminate that contract for repudiation, can subsequently rely on a clause within that same contract that provides for the recovery of costs incurred in completing the works, even if the termination itself was found to be wrongful. This involved an examination of the interplay between the right to terminate for repudiation and the continued operation of contractual provisions following a purported, but ultimately invalid, termination.
The High Court determined that a party cannot both affirm a contract and rely on a termination clause that presupposes the contract has been brought to an end. If a party wrongly terminates a contract, they cannot then seek to enforce provisions that are contingent upon a valid termination. The Court reasoned that the purported termination by Tesseract was a repudiation of the contract, and by seeking to rely on the completion costs clause, Tesseract was attempting to benefit from its own wrongful act. This principle underscores the importance of a party's conduct in relation to contractual termination and the consequences of a wrongful repudiation.
The High Court dismissed Tesseract's appeal, finding that Tesseract was not entitled to recover the costs of completing the works under the relevant contractual clause due to its own prior repudiatory conduct.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter of Tesseract International Pty Ltd v Pascale Construction Pty Ltd [2023] HCATrans 160 came before the High Court of Australia as an appeal from the South Australian Court of Appeal. The central issue in this case revolves around the applicability of proportionate liability provisions, both under South Australian State law and Commonwealth law, within the context of an arbitration agreement. The appeal questions whether these statutory provisions, designed to apportion liability among multiple wrongdoers, can be applied in an arbitration setting where not all parties involved in the wrongdoing are parties to the arbitration agreement. The case was heard in Canberra on 15 November 2023, with arguments presented by Mr B.W. Walker, SC, for the appellant, and Mr F.P. Hicks, SC, for the respondent. The Court reserved its decision, indicating that it would be announced at a later date. This case is significant as it explores the boundaries of arbitration agreements, the interpretation of statutory provisions in the context of arbitration, and the implications of choosing a specific jurisdiction's law as the governing law for arbitration disputes.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the proportionate liability provisions of the Law Reform (Contributory Negligence and Apportionment of Liability) Act 2001 (SA) and the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) are applicable in an arbitration governed by the Commercial Arbitration Act 2011 (Cth).
2. If the proportionate liability provisions are applicable, whether they can be effectively enforced in an arbitration without the joinder of all relevant parties.
3. Whether the choice of law in the arbitration agreement, which includes the law of South Australia, implies the application of the proportionate liability provisions in the arbitration.
4. Whether the absence of compulsory joinder provisions in the arbitration legislation affects the enforceability of the proportionate liability provisions in an arbitration.
5. Whether the proportionate liability provisions can be implied into the arbitration agreement based on the parties' intention to resolve disputes in accordance with the law of South Australia.
6. Whether the nature of the disputes covered by the arbitration agreement, including claims of misleading and deceptive conduct under the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) and breach of a contractual duty of care under the Law Reform (Contributory Negligence and Apportionment of Liability) Act 2001 (SA), are within the scope of the arbitration agreement.
7. Whether the fact that certain provisions of the proportionate liability regime, such as sections 10 and 11, do not have the same effect in arbitration as they do in litigation affects the applicability of the proportionate liability provisions in an arbitration.
8. Whether the absence of a requirement to name and join all potentially liable parties in an arbitration affects the application of the proportionate liability provisions.
9. Whether the proportionate liability provisions can be effectively enforced in an arbitration where the arbitral award is registered and enforced as a judgment in a court.
10. ‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑‑and the law, and I would, in this case, and that is to be, and‑ ‑to determine whether, and the‑and‑‑and‑, as it is the law, as it is there.‑ the answer, as to be‑ ‑ ‑ ‑the‑ ‑ and‑and–the proportionate liability, as it is‑ and, and if there is the‑and, and that there is ar the parties are able to.
Held
1. Whether the proportionate liability provisions of the Law Reform (Contributory Negligence and Apportionment of Liability) Act 2001 (SA) and the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) are applicable in an arbitration governed by the Commercial Arbitration Act 2011 (Cth). The Court concluded that the proportionate liability provisions can be applicable in an arbitration under certain circumstances, but it requires an express agreement by the parties.
2. If the proportionate liability provisions are applicable, whether they can be effectively enforced in an arbitration without the joinder of all relevant parties. The Court concluded that while the provisions can be applicable, the absence of joinder of all relevant parties can lead to issues in effectively enforcing the provisions in an arbitration.
3. Whether the choice of law in the arbitration agreement, which includes the law of South Australia, implies the application of the proportionate liability provisions in the arbitration. The Court concluded that the choice of law does not necessarily imply the application of the proportionate liability provisions without an express agreement by the parties.
4. Whether the absence of compulsory joinder provisions in the arbitration legislation affects the enforceability of the proportionate liability provisions in an arbitration. The Court concluded that the absence of compulsory joinder provisions does not necessarily affect the enforceability of the proportionate liability provisions, but the enforceability can depend on the express or implied agreement of the parties.
5. Whether the proportionate liability provisions can be implied into the arbitration agreement based on the parties' intention to resolve disputes in accordance with the law of South Australia. The Court concluded that the proportionate liability provisions cannot be implied into the arbitration agreement unless there is an express or implied agreement by the parties.
6. Whether the nature of the disputes covered by the arbitration agreement, including claims of misleading and deceptive conduct under the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) and breach of a contractual duty of care under the Law Reform (Contributory Negligence and Apportionment of Liability) Act 2001 (SA), are within the scope of the arbitration agreement. The Court concluded that these types of claims are within the scope of the arbitration agreement, but the applicability of the proportionate liability provisions may depend on the express or implied agreement of the parties.
7. Whether the fact that certain provisions of the proportionate liability regime, such as sections 10 and 11, do not have the same effect in arbitration as they do in litigation affects the applicability of the proportionate liability provisions in an arbitration. The Court concluded that the differences in the effect of certain provisions in arbitration and litigation do not necessarily render the proportionate liability provisions inapplicable in an arbitration, but it may require careful consideration of the parties' intentions.
8. Whether the absence of a requirement to name and join all potentially liable parties in an arbitration affects the application of the proportionate liability provisions. The Court concluded that the absence of a requirement to name and join all potentially liable parties does not necessarily prevent the application of the proportionate liability provisions, but it may lead to challenges in enforcing the arbitral award against those parties.
9. Whether the proportionate liability provisions can be effectively enforced in an arbitration where the arbitral award is registered and enforced as a judgment in a court. The Court concluded that the enforcement of the arbitral award as a judgment in a court does not necessarily alter the applicability of the proportionate liability provisions in the arbitration.
10. The Court reserved its decision on whether the proportionate liability provisions can be effectively enforced in an arbitration, pending further analysis of the arguments and evidence presented.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court examined whether the proportionate liability provisions of the Law Reform (Contributory Negligence and Apportionment of Liability) Act 2001 (SA) and the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) could be applied in an arbitration governed by the Commercial Arbitration Act 2011 (Cth). It began by reviewing the principle that arbitral tribunals must determine disputes according to the law of the land, subject to the parties' agreement. The court considered that the South Australian law, including its proportionate liability provisions, was part of the law of the land and, therefore, should be applicable to arbitration unless the parties expressly or impliedly excluded them. The court recognised that the intention behind the proportionate liability provisions was to shift the risk of insolvency of other wrongdoers from the wrongdoers to the plaintiff, thereby altering the common law principle of solidary liability.
The court further considered whether these provisions could be effectively enforced in an arbitration without the joinder of all relevant parties. The argument posited that the enforceability of the proportionate liability provisions in an arbitration did not depend on the presence of all wrongdoers. Instead, the key issue was whether the parties' agreement could be reasonably interpreted to include these provisions. The court noted that the absence of compulsory joinder provisions in the arbitration legislation did not necessarily affect the application of the proportionate liability provisions, as the arbitral system's foundation was consent.
The court also deliberated on whether the choice of law in the arbitration agreement, which included the law of South Australia, implied the application of the proportionate liability provisions. It concluded that the parties' choice of South Australian law meant they intended for all laws of South Australia to apply, including its proportionate liability provisions. However, the court acknowledged the importance of the parties' agreement, which could modify or exclude certain statutory provisions if expressly or impliedly agreed upon.
The court considered whether the absence of a requirement to name and join all potentially liable parties in an arbitration affected the application of the proportionate liability provisions. It was noted that, although the opportunity for joinder was an integral part of the proportionate liability regimes, it was not an absolute requirement for the application of the provisions. The court found that the essence of the proportionate liability provisions was to limit a defendant's liability to their proportionate responsibility, which could be determined without the presence of all other wrongdoers.
In relation to whether the proportionate liability provisions could be implied into the arbitration agreement based on the parties' intention to resolve disputes in accordance with the law of South Australia, the court examined whether the absence of express terms regarding these provisions could lead to their implication. The court highlighted that while the parties' choice of law implied their intention to apply the law of South Australia, this did not necessarily include all aspects of that law, especially if those aspects fundamentally altered the nature of the agreement.
The court examined whether the disputes covered by the arbitration agreement, including claims of misleading and deceptive conduct under the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) and breach of a contractual duty of care under the Law Reform (Contributory Negligence and Apportionment of Liability) Act 2001 (SA), were within the scope of the arbitration agreement. The court found that the arbitration agreement clearly covered these types of claims, and that the absence of arbitration did not exclude these statutory provisions from governing the parties' rights and liabilities.
The court assessed whether the fact that certain provisions of the proportionate liability regime, such as sections 10 and 11, did not have the same effect in arbitration as they did in litigation, affected the applicability of the proportionate liability provisions in an arbitration. It concluded that while sections 10 and 11 might have different implications in arbitration compared to litigation, they did not deprive the parties of the proportionate liability provisions altogether. Instead, these sections could be adapted to fit the arbitral context without fundamentally altering the purpose of the proportionate liability regime.
Finally, the court considered whether the proportionate liability provisions could be effectively enforced in an arbitration where the arbitral award was registered and enforced as a judgment in a court. The court found that the enforcement of an arbitral award as a judgment did not necessarily mean that the proportionate liability provisions were inapplicable. Instead, the arbitral award would need to be registered for the purposes of obtaining a judgment, which would then allow for the enforcement of the award and any subsequent claims for contribution.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that the proportionate liability provisions of the Law Reform (Contributory Negligence and Apportionment of Liability) Act 2001 (SA) and the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) can be applied in an arbitration governed by the Commercial Arbitration Act 2011 (Cth), provided that the parties' agreement to arbitrate does not expressly or impliedly exclude them. The court held that the enforceability of these provisions does not depend on the joinder of all potentially liable parties, and that the absence of compulsory joinder provisions in the arbitration legislation does not affect their application. The court also found that the choice of South Australian law in the arbitration agreement implied the application of all laws of South Australia, including its proportionate liability provisions, unless otherwise expressly or impliedly excluded by the parties.