Territory v Dirkis

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

Case Title:  The Public Trustee and Guardian of the Australian Capital
Territory v Dirkis
Citation:  [2021] ACTSC 29
Hearing Date:  23 February 2021
Decision Date:  23 February 2021
Before:  Elkaim J
Decision:  See [18]
Catchwords:  CIVIL LAW – APPLICATION – Indemnity Costs – Failure to provide bill of costs – whether the plaintiff is classified as a third party payer – whether the plaintiff was acting with a conflict of
interest
Legislation Cited:  Court Procedures Rules 2006 (ACT) r 1720, 1803 Legal Profession Act 2006 (ACT) ss 261, 261A, 277, 282, 289, 271(1)(c), 294A(5)
Parties:  The Public Trustee and Guardian of the Australian Capital
Territory (Plaintiff)
Paul Vytis Dirkis (Defendant)
Representation:  Counsel
R McCrone (Plaintiff)
Self-represented (Defendant)
Solicitors
ACT Government Solicitor (Plaintiff)
Self-represented (Defendant)
File Number:  SC 35 of 2021
ELKAIM J: 

1. On 5 February 2021 the plaintiff filed an Originating Application seeking an order under r 1803 of the Court Procedures Rules 2006 (ACT) that the defendant file a bill of costs, arising from two proceedings, within 30 days.

2.       The plaintiff relied on an affidavit of Mr McCrone affirmed on 5 February 2021. In his affidavit he refers to costs orders made by McWilliam AsJ on 9 August 2017 in respect of matters SC 58 of 2017 and P 513 of 2011.

3.       Pursuant to the above orders the defendant is entitled to indemnity costs, to be paid from the estate of the late Kathleen Mary Dirkis.

4.       In his affidavit, Mr McCrone says that the parties have been unable to reach an agreement about the amount of costs to be paid under the above orders. Accordingly, he says, that on 27 November 2020 the plaintiff wrote to the defendant giving him notice of the application that is before the Court today.

5.       The defendant opposed the making of the order saying that he had enclosed particulars of his costs claims by emails in September and December 2019 and he should not have to provide any more.

6. He said that the plaintiff’s application was out of time by virtue of s 294A(5) of the Legal

Profession Act 2006 (ACT). Further he said that any extension of time, under

subsection (6), was not available to the plaintiff because the plaintiff is a “sophisticated
client”.

7.       The defendant said there was another reason for the application to be refused. This was because the plaintiff was acting with a conflict of interest.

8. Starting with s 294A, this section relates to an application by a “client or third party payer” for a costs assessment. A third party payer is defined in s 261A. A sophisticated

client is defined in s 261 to be read with s 272(1)(c).

9. The question here is whether or not the plaintiff is a third party payer. The plaintiff took me through the relevant part of the Act to show that a third party payer simply does not include his client. He said that a third…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Territory v Dirkis and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] ACTSC 29
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of The Public Trustee and Guardian of the Australian Capital Territory versus Paul Vytis Dirkis, the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory was called upon to consider an application for an order that the defendant file a bill of costs. The plaintiff, The Public Trustee and Guardian of the Australian Capital Territory, sought this order under r 1803 of the Court Procedures Rules 2006 (ACT) in relation to two proceedings. The plaintiff sought to recover costs from the defendant, Paul Vytis Dirkis, arising from the aforementioned proceedings. The defendant had been ordered to pay indemnity costs, which were to be paid from the estate of the late Kathleen Mary Dirkis.

The court was required to decide two main legal issues. The first issue was whether the plaintiff was classified as a third party payer under the Legal Profession Act 2006 (ACT). If the plaintiff was a third party payer, then they would be bound by the time limit imposed by s 294A(5) of the Act. The second issue was whether the plaintiff was acting with a conflict of interest in making the application for the order.

Justice Elkaim concluded that the plaintiff was not a third party payer as defined in s 261A(1) of the Act. The court reasoned that a third party payer is a person under an obligation to pay another person's legal costs, not by reason of being the losing party in litigation, but by reason of some association between the client and the person. The court found that the plaintiff did not fit within this definition, as they were not under an obligation to pay the defendant's legal costs, but rather, were seeking to recover costs ordered by the court. The court further held that the plaintiff was not bound by the time limit imposed by s 294A(5) of the Act. Additionally, Justice Elkaim rejected the defendant's argument that the plaintiff was acting with a conflict of interest, finding that the plaintiff was endeavouring to pay the defendant's costs in the manner ordered by the court and had not been able to do so because the parties had not reached an agreement as to the quantum of those costs.

The court made the following orders: (i) The defendant is to file a bill of costs in respect of his costs in proceedings SC 58 of 2017 and P 513 of 2011 within 30 days of the date of this order, and (ii) Each party to pay their own costs for the application.

Background

Background to the litigation

The facts of this case relate to an application made by The Public Trustee and Guardian of the Australian Capital Territory (the plaintiff) seeking an order that Paul Vytis Dirkis (the defendant) file a bill of costs within 30 days. This application arose from two proceedings, SC 58 of 2017 and P 513 of 2011, where the defendant was entitled to indemnity costs, to be paid from the estate of the late Kathleen Mary Dirkis. The plaintiff, who is self-represented, sought the order because the parties had been unable to reach an agreement on the amount of costs to be paid under the orders made on 9 August 2017 by McWilliam AsJ.

In opposition to the application, the defendant argued that he had already enclosed particulars of his costs claims by emails in September and December 2019, and he should not have to provide any more information. He also contended that the plaintiff's application was out of time by virtue of s 294A(5) of the Legal Profession Act 2006 (ACT) and that any extension of time was not available to the plaintiff because the plaintiff is a "sophisticated client". Furthermore, the defendant claimed that the plaintiff was acting with a conflict of interest, as it would be liable to the estate for any excess of the amount paid over what would have been the assessed amount if the plaintiff did not obtain the order it sought.

The Public Trustee and Guardian of the Australian Capital Territory, acting as plaintiff, filed an Originating Application on 5 February 2021 under rule 1803 of the Court Procedures Rules 2006 (ACT) against Paul Vytis Dirkis, the defendant, seeking an order that the defendant file a bill of costs. The plaintiff argued that it was entitled to indemnity costs from the estate of the late Kathleen Mary Dirkis, which arose from two previous proceedings, SC 58 of 2017 and P 513 of 2011, as per the costs orders made by McWilliam AsJ on 9 August 2017. The defendant opposed the application, arguing that he had already provided particulars of his costs claims via email in September and December 2019 and that the plaintiff's application was out of time under section 294A(5) of the Legal Profession Act 2006 (ACT). Additionally, the defendant claimed that the plaintiff was acting with a conflict of interest. The matter came before Elkaim J on 23 February 2021, who dismissed the defendant's arguments and ordered the defendant to file a bill of costs within 30 days, with each party to pay their own costs for the application.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the plaintiff is classified as a third party payer under the Legal Profession Act 2006 (ACT).
2. Whether the plaintiff's application for an order to file a bill of costs is out of time under s 294A(5) of the Legal Profession Act 2006 (ACT).
3. Whether the plaintiff is a "sophisticated client" under s 261 of the Legal Profession Act 2006 (ACT), and if so, whether this affects their entitlement to an extension of time under s 294A(6) of the Legal Profession Act 2006 (ACT).
4. Whether the plaintiff is acting with a conflict of interest in seeking the order to file a bill of costs.

Held
1. The plaintiff is not classified as a third party payer under s 261A of the Legal Profession Act 2006 (ACT), and therefore is not bound by the time limit imposed by s 294A(5).
2. The plaintiff's application for an order to file a bill of costs is not out of time under s 294A(5) of the Legal Profession Act 2006 (ACT).
3. The plaintiff is not a "sophisticated client" under s 261 of the Legal Profession Act 2006 (ACT), and therefore an extension of time under s 294A(6) of the Legal Profession Act 2006 (ACT) is not precluded.
4. The plaintiff is not acting with a conflict of interest in seeking the order to file a bill of costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by addressing the first major issue: whether the plaintiff was classified as a third party payer under the Legal Profession Act 2006 (ACT). The plaintiff argued that it did not fall within the definition of a third party payer, which is a person under an obligation to pay another person’s legal costs, not by reason of being the losing party in litigation but by reason of some association between the client and the person. The court agreed with the plaintiff's interpretation, finding that a third party payer is typically someone like an insurance company that is obliged to meet a litigant’s costs. The court concluded that the plaintiff, as the entity responsible for paying the defendant’s costs under the court's orders, did not fit this definition. The reasoning here is that the plaintiff's obligation to pay the defendant's costs stems from a court order, not from an association with the defendant or the client. Therefore, the plaintiff is not subject to the time limits set out in s 294A(5) of the Act for third party payers.

Next, the court examined whether the plaintiff's application for an order to file a bill of costs was out of time under s 294A(5) of the Legal Profession Act 2006 (ACT). The defendant argued that the application was out of time because the plaintiff had not filed the bill of costs within the stipulated period. The court found that since the plaintiff was not a third party payer, it was not bound by the time limit in s 294A(5). Instead, the court referred to r 1720 of the Court Procedures Rules 2006 (ACT), which states that a party is not entitled to recover costs unless they are assessed costs. This reinforces the court's earlier conclusion that the plaintiff, in its role as the entity responsible for paying the defendant’s costs, was not subject to the same time constraints as a third party payer.

The third issue the court addressed was whether the plaintiff is a "sophisticated client" under s 261 of the Legal Profession Act 2006 (ACT) and, if so, whether this affected their entitlement to an extension of time under s 294A(6) of the Act. The defendant argued that the plaintiff, as a sophisticated client, should not be granted an extension of time. However, the court did not explicitly address the definition of a "sophisticated client" in this context, focusing instead on the plaintiff's role in the proceedings. Since the court had already ruled that the plaintiff was not a third party payer and was thus not bound by the time limits for third party payers, it did not need to determine whether the plaintiff qualified as a sophisticated client. The court's reasoning here implicitly suggests that the status of the plaintiff as a "sophisticated client" would not affect their entitlement to an extension of time if they were considered a third party payer, but that was not applicable in this case.

Finally, the court considered whether the plaintiff was acting with a conflict of interest in seeking the order to file a bill of costs. The defendant argued that the plaintiff had a conflict because it would be liable to the estate for any excess amount paid over the assessed costs. The court dismissed this argument, stating that the plaintiff was simply trying to comply with the court's orders by having the defendant's costs assessed. The court found no evidence to suggest that the plaintiff had any ulterior motives or that it was acting against its own interests. The court's reasoning here is that the plaintiff's actions were aimed at ensuring that the costs were assessed in accordance with the court's orders, which is a legitimate and necessary step to comply with the court's direction.

In summary, the binding legal principle established by this decision is that the Public Trustee and Guardian, as the entity responsible for paying the defendant's costs, is not classified as a third party payer under the Legal Profession Act 2006 (ACT) and therefore is not bound by the time limits imposed on third party payers. The court also found that the plaintiff was not acting with a conflict of interest in seeking the order to file a bill of costs. This decision clarifies the roles and obligations of the parties in relation to costs assessments, emphasizing the importance of complying with court orders while ensuring that costs are assessed properly.