Dirkis v Public Trustee and Guardian & Ors (Appeal)

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

DIRKIS v PUBLIC TRUSTEE AND GUARDIAN & ORS (Appeal) [2023] ACAT 49

AA 37/2021 (XD 32/2021)

Catchwords:               APPEAL – civil dispute – application in negligence brought by beneficiary of a will against the administrator of the estate and its legal representatives – appeal against decision to dismiss application as lacking in substance – no error in application of principles – no error in the original tribunal’s finding that a beneficiary does not have a cause of action in negligence against the administrator of an estate not vested – no error found in original tribunal’s finding that the tribunal lacks jurisdiction to grant equitable relief for breach of trust – no error in original tribunal’s finding absence of negligence where all actions taken pursuant to Court orders – appeal dismissed

Legislation cited:        ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 ss 19, 32

Subordinate

Legislation cited:        Court Procedures Rules rr 1720, 1734

Cases cited:Carey v Freehills [2013] FCA 954

Carlisle v Filara Pty Ltd [2002] ACTSC 33
David v David [2009] NSWCA 8
Dey v Victorian Railways Commissioners [1949] HCA 1
Dirkis v Public Trustee and Guardian as Trustee of the estate of Kathleen Mary Dirkis [2021] ACAT 57
FCT v Whiting [1943] HCA 45
Gonzales v Claridades [2003] NSWCA 227
Hill v van Erp [1997] HCA 9
Jamieson Mary v Australian Workers Union [1999] VCAT 628
The Public Trustee and Guardian v Dirkis [2021] ACTSC 29
The State Electricity Commission Board v Rabel [1998] 1 VR 102

List of

Texts/Papers cited:     Pearce, Administrative Appeals Tribunal (4th Edition, LexisNexis, 2015)

Tribunal:Temporary President G McCarthy

Date of Orders:  4 September 2023

Date of Reasons for Decision:      4 September 2023

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY          )

CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL     )          AA 37/2021

BETWEEN:

PAUL DIRKIS

Appellant

AND:

PUBLIC TRUSTEE AND GUARDIAN AS TRUSTEE OF THE ESTATE OF KATHLEEN MARY DIRKIS

First Respondent

AND:

ACT GOVERNMENT SOLICITOR

Second Respondent

AND:

PETER GARRISSON

Third Respondent

APPEAL TRIBUNAL:       Temporary President G McCarthy

DATE:4 September 2023

ORDER

The Tribunal orders that:

  1. The application for appeal is dismissed.

    ………………………………..

    Temporary President G McCarthy

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. This appeal arises from the appellant’s claim in the original proceeding that the first respondent, the second respondent who acted for the first respondent and the third respondent who had overarching responsibility for the legal work done by the second respondent were negligent in the manner in which they performed their functions.

  2. A statement of the factual background to the appellant’s claim in the original proceeding is necessary in order to understand the grounds of appeal.

Background

  1. The appellant’s mother died in 2009. By her will, she appointed the appellant and his brother, Michael Dirkis, as executors of her estate. The beneficiaries are the appellant and his three siblings. The executors were granted probate of the will on 4 October 2011 in Supreme Court proceeding PRO 513 of 2011 (subsequently re-identified as P 513 of 2011).

  2. On 3 March 2017, the appellant’s sister commenced proceeding…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Dirkis v Public Trustee and Guardian & Ors (Appeal) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] ACAT 49
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal in Dirkis v Public Trustee and Guardian & Ors was brought by Dirkis, a beneficiary of a will, against the Public Trustee and Guardian and others. The primary dispute revolved around an application in negligence which Dirkis had filed against the administrator of the estate and its legal representatives. Dirkis sought to challenge the decision of the tribunal to dismiss the application as lacking in substance. The legal issues before the court involved whether the tribunal correctly applied principles of law in dismissing the negligence claim, and whether the tribunal had jurisdiction to grant equitable relief for breach of trust.

The court examined the tribunal's reasoning and found no error in its application of principles. It confirmed that a beneficiary does not have a cause of action in negligence against the administrator of an estate that has not been vested. The tribunal's finding that it lacked jurisdiction to grant equitable relief for breach of trust was also upheld, as the court found no error in this determination. Additionally, the tribunal correctly found an absence of negligence because all actions taken were pursuant to court orders. Consequently, the court dismissed the appeal, finding no grounds for overturning the original tribunal’s decisions.

The tribunal's final orders were that the application for appeal be dismissed. This outcome upheld the tribunal's earlier decision that the negligence claim was without merit, and that it lacked the jurisdiction to grant the equitable relief sought by Dirkis. The dismissal of the appeal thus finalised the matter, leaving the original tribunal's determinations intact.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal orders that:

1. The application for appeal is dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a beneficiary of a will, Dirkis, who brought an application in negligence against the Public Trustee and Guardian and others, who are the administrator of the estate and its legal representatives. Dirkis's application was dismissed, and the decision to dismiss was upheld on appeal. The beneficiary claimed that the administrator of the estate was negligent in their actions. The estate had not yet been vested when the alleged negligence occurred. The beneficiary sought both damages for negligence and equitable relief for breach of trust.

Dirkis initially filed an application in negligence against the Public Trustee and Guardian and others. The application was dismissed by a tribunal, which found that the beneficiary did not have a cause of action in negligence against the administrator of the estate, which had not been vested at the time of the alleged negligence. The tribunal also held that it lacked jurisdiction to grant equitable relief for breach of trust and found no negligence because all actions were taken pursuant to court orders. Dirkis appealed this decision to a higher tribunal, which dismissed the appeal, upholding the original tribunal's findings.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did the original tribunal err in finding that a beneficiary does not have a cause of action in negligence against the administrator of an estate not vested?
2. Was there an error in the original tribunal's finding that it lacks jurisdiction to grant equitable relief for breach of trust?
3. Did the original tribunal err in finding an absence of negligence where all actions were taken pursuant to court orders?

Held
1. The court held that there was no error in the original tribunal’s finding that a beneficiary does not have a cause of action in negligence against the administrator of an estate not vested.
2. The court also held that there was no error in the original tribunal’s finding that the tribunal lacks jurisdiction to grant equitable relief for breach of trust.
3. Furthermore, the court held that there was no error in the original tribunal’s finding that there was an absence of negligence where all actions were taken pursuant to court orders.
4. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal reviewed the findings of the original tribunal concerning the beneficiary's claims against the estate administrator and legal representatives. Regarding the first issue, the court affirmed the original tribunal's decision that a beneficiary lacks a cause of action in negligence against an estate administrator where the estate has not been vested. This conclusion was based on established principles that negligence claims are contingent upon the existence of a duty of care and a breach of that duty, neither of which apply when an estate is not yet vested. The court reinforced this position by distinguishing previous cases that involved different factual circumstances.

On the second issue, the Court of Appeal found no error in the original tribunal's determination that it lacked jurisdiction to grant equitable relief for breach of trust. The court reasoned that equitable relief is typically the domain of higher courts with inherent jurisdiction over trusts, and not tribunals which have limited powers. The court relied on precedents which confirm that tribunals are generally not empowered to grant equitable remedies, supporting the original tribunal’s jurisdictional limitation.

Regarding the third issue, the court upheld the original tribunal's finding that there was no negligence because all actions were performed pursuant to court orders. The court accepted that compliance with court orders absolves the administrator from negligence claims, as the orders themselves are the legal directive governing the actions taken. The court’s decision underscored the principle that following court orders is a defense against claims of negligence.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that a beneficiary cannot bring a negligence claim against an estate administrator before the estate is vested, that tribunals lack jurisdiction to grant equitable relief for breach of trust, and that compliance with court orders negates claims of negligence. The court’s adherence to these principles without finding error in the original tribunal's reasoning led to the dismissal of the appeal.