Telstra Corporation Ltd v Desktop Marketing Systems Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 78 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Telstra Corporation Limited v Desktop Marketing Systems Pty Ltd

[2001] FCA 612

INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY – copyright – originality – compilation of facts – telephone directory – whether intellectual effort required – infringement – reproduction – CD-rom – similarity with applicant’s work

Copyright Act 1968 (Cth) s 32(1) & s 32(2)

Statute of Anne of 1709

Autocaps (Aust)Pty Ltd v Pro-Kit Pty Ltd (1999) 46 IPR 339 applied
Autodesk Inc v Dyason (No 2) (1993) 176 CLR 300 discussed
BellSouth Advertising & Publishing Corp v Donnelley Information Publishing, Inc 999 F2d 1436 (11th Cir 1993), cert denied 510 US 1101 (1994) not followed
Collis v Cater, Stoffell and Fortt Ltd (1898) 78 LT(NS) 613 applied
Data Access Corporation v Powerflex Services Pty Ltd (1999) 73 ALJR 1435 discussed
Feist Publications, Inc v Rural Telephone Service Co, Inc 499 US 340 (1991) not followed
G A Cramp & Sons Ltd v Frank Smythson Ltd [1944] AC 329 discussed
H Blacklock & Co Ltd v C Arthur Pearson Ltd [1915] 2 Ch 376 discussed
Hotten v Arthur (1863) 1 H&M 603; 71 ER 264 not followed
Jeweler’s Circular Publishing Co v Keystone PublishingCo 281 F 83, 88 (2d Cir 1922), cert denied 259 US 581 (1922) discussed
Kelly v Morris (1866) 1 Eq 697 followed
Key Publications, Inc v Chinatown Today Publishing Enterprises Inc 945 F2d 509 (2d Cir 1991) discussed
Ladbroke (Football) Ltd v William Hill (Football) Ltd [1964] 1 WLR 273 applied
Leslie v J Young & Sons [1894] AC 335 discussed
Matthewson v Stockdale (1806) 12 Ves 270; 33 ER 103 applied
Morris v Ashbee (1868) 7 Eq 34 followed
Morris v Wright (1870) 5 Ch App 279 followed
S W Hart & Co v Edwards Hot Water Systems (1985) 159 CLR 466 applied
Tele-Direct (Publications) Inc v American Business Information Inc (1997) 154 DLR 4th 328 not followed
Victoria Park Racing and Recreation Grounds Company Ltd v Taylor (1937) 58 CLR 479 followed
Walter v Lane [1900] AC 539 followed

Arber E (ed), A Transcript of the Registehe Company of Stationers of London 1554-1640 (1876) vol 1
Boyarski J R, “The Heist of Feist:  Protections for Collections of Information and the Possible Federalization of “Hot News””, 21 Cardozo Law Review 871 (1999)
Copinger on Copyright, 2nd ed (1881)
Curtis on Copyright (1847)
Denicola R C, “Copyright in Collections of Facts:  A Theory for the Protection of Non-fiction Literary Work”, 81 Columbia Law Review 516 (1981)
Meade T L, “Ex-post Feist:  applications of a landmark copyright decision”, 2 Journal Intellectual Property Law 245, 251-252 (1994)
Scrutton T E, The Law of Copyright, 2nd ed (1890)
Silverstein M R, “The Copyrightability of Factual Compilations:  An Interpretation of Feist through cases of Maps and Numbers”, 1996 Annual Survey of American Law 147
Webb T P, A compendium of the Imperial law and statutes in force in the colony of Victoria, 2nd ed (1892)

York E R, “Warren Publishing, Inc v Microdos Data Corp:…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Telstra Corporation Ltd v Desktop Marketing Systems Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] FCA 612
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Telstra Corporation Limited claimed that Desktop Marketing Systems Pty Ltd (DtMS) had infringed its copyright in certain telephone directories and headings books. Telstra argued that the directories and headings books were original compilations and that DtMS had reproduced a substantial part of them. DtMS denied that there was copyright in the directories and headings books. The Court held that Telstra had copyright in the directories and headings books, and that DtMS had infringed that copyright. The Court held that copyright subsists in the directories and headings books because of the intellectual effort involved in their creation. The Court held that DtMS had reproduced a substantial part of the directories and headings books because it had reproduced the significant recorded facts and headings, even though the information was presented in a different format. The Court rejected DtMS's argument that the differences between the directories and headings books and DtMS's products were so extensive as to prevent a finding of infringement. The Court held that the substance of the information that had been taken from Telstra's works had been reproduced in DtMS's products, and that the differences were in the detail.

Background

Background to the litigation

Telstra Corporation Ltd, an Australian telecommunications company, produces annual white pages and yellow pages telephone directories. The white pages list subscribers' names, addresses, and telephone numbers alphabetically. The yellow pages list businesses under various headings, with subscribers able to purchase enhanced listings. Desktop Marketing Systems Pty Ltd (DtMS) and its director, Andrzej Scibor-Kaminski, have been accused of infringing Telstra's copyright by producing CD-ROM products that contain Telstra's directory data. DtMS's products include CD Phone Directory, Phonedisk, and Marketing Pro, which offer various search functions and additional data. Telstra claims that DtMS's products infringe on the copyright of the directories and headings books by reproducing a substantial part of Telstra's works.

The case was heard in the Federal Court of Australia, Victoria District Registry. The primary issue was whether Telstra's telephone directories and headings books were original works capable of copyright protection. The matter was contested on the basis that the directories and headings books were original literary works. The court examined whether the "industrious collection" of facts was sufficient to establish originality or whether some additional element, such as selection or arrangement, was necessary. The case involved a detailed examination of the process involved in creating the directories and headings books, including the selection of headings, the collection and verification of data, and the design and production of the directories.

Decision

Reasons for decision

FINKELSTEIN J
Issues
1. Does copyright subsist in Telstra’s telephone directories and headings books?
2. If so, has Desktop Marketing Systems Pty Ltd infringed that copyright by reproducing a substantial part of those works?

Held
1. The court held that Telstra Corporation Limited has copyright in its telephone directories and headings books, as they are original works under the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth).
2. The court held that Desktop Marketing Systems Pty Ltd infringed Telstra's copyright by reproducing a substantial part of the directories and headings books in their CD-rom products.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: FINKELSTEIN J

The court began by discussing the historical development of copyright law, emphasizing the requirement for a work to be "original" to attract copyright protection. The court noted that copyright does not protect facts themselves, but can protect the form in which facts are recorded. In relation to compilations of facts, the court examined both English and Australian case law, which generally support the idea that copyright can subsist in a compilation of facts if there has been sufficient intellectual effort, labor, or expense in gathering or arranging the facts. The court distinguished between copyrightable compilations, which require some level of creativity, and non-copyrightable compilations that lack sufficient intellectual effort or creativity.

In applying these principles to the facts, the court found that Telstra's telephone directories and headings books were original works that attracted copyright protection. The court held that the directories and headings books involved sufficient intellectual effort and labor in their creation, such as in selecting and arranging the information. The court rejected Desktop Marketing Systems' argument that copyright required some level of creativity beyond mere industrious collection.

Finally, the court found that Desktop Marketing Systems had reproduced a substantial part of Telstra's directories and headings books in their CD-rom products. While there were some differences between the works, the court held that the substantial information contained in the directories and headings books had been reproduced, amounting to copyright infringement. The court's decision was based on the principle that copyright protects the substantial information and arrangement of facts in a compilation, rather than merely the physical form of the work.

In summary, the court held that Telstra's directories and headings books were original works protected by copyright, and that Desktop Marketing Systems had infringed that copyright by reproducing a substantial part of the works in their CD-rom products. The court's decision followed established principles from English and Australian case law on the originality requirement for copyright in compilations of facts.