Television Food Network GP v Food Channel Network Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Objection by Television Food Network G.P. to an application by Food Channel Network Pty Ltd for a late extension of time to serve evidence in support.

Delegate: Rachel Dunn
Representation: Extension Opponent: Ian Tannahill of Ahern Fox
Extension Applicant: Paul Lawrence, Managing Director of Food Channel Network Pty Ltd
Decision: ATMO
Regulation 5.15: Late application for further time to serve evidence in support: application refused.
Costs: Awarded against the extension applicant.

Background

  1. Television Food Network G.P. (the opponent in the extension matter, “Television Food”) applied on 14 August 2006 for removal of registered trade mark 733265 from the trade mark register for non-use.  This application was opposed by the registered owner, Food Channel Network Pty Ltd (the applicant in the extension matter, “Food Channel”), by Notice of Opposition, lodged on 16 November 2006.

  2. Food Channel’s evidence in support was originally due to be served on Television Food on 16 February 2007.  Food Channel successfully applied for the following extensions of time in which to serve evidence in support:

Date Filed Date of Service Extension Length New Due Date
16 February 2007 20 February 2007 1 month 16 March 2007
16 March 2007 16 March 2007 1 month 16 April 2007
16 April 2007 18 April 2007 1 month 16 May 2007
16 May 2007 16 May 2007 1 month 16 June 2007
26 June 2007 27 June 2007 3 months 16 September 2007
  1. Television Food objected to the granting of the last of those extensions on the basis that Food Channel had not provided compelling reasons supporting the extension, and that the application was filed out of time.  By letter dated 20 August 2007, Television Food was informed that, due to a miscommunication between the parties and this office it would have been, in retrospect, appropriate that proceedings were suspended while this issue was resolved.  Following this correspondence the due date for filing evidence in support was extended to 20 September 2007.  Both parties were informed ‘that it is highly unlikely that the 20 September deadline will be extended unless there is a compelling reason to do so.’  The following list of possible compelling reasons was provided:

    Øan error or omission on the part of an employee of IP Australia;

    Øan error or omission on Food Channel’s part or on the part of its agent;

    Øcircumstances beyond Food Channel’s control;

    Øserious settlement negotiations between the parties.

    The substance of the letter dated 20 August 2007 was re-iterated to both parties by a further letter dated 10 September 2007. 

  2. Food Channel filed its evidence in support — consisting of the Statutory Declaration of Paul Lawrence with Exhibits 1–23 (the Lawrence declaration) made 19 September 2007 — with the Brisbane office of IP Australia on 20 September 2007.  Food Channel did not serve the evidence in support on Television Food until 24 September 2007, four days after the due date for service.  Food Channel therefore needed…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Television Food Network GP v Food Channel Network Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] ATMO 25
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter came before Rachel Dunn, a Delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, concerning an application by Food Channel Network Pty Ltd (Food Channel) for an extension of time to serve its evidence in support of an opposition proceeding against Television Food Network GP (Television Food). Television Food objected to the late filing of Food Channel's evidence, arguing that the explanation provided for the delay was insufficient and that the late material would not assist Food Channel's case.

The primary legal issue before the Delegate was whether to grant Food Channel an extension of time to serve its evidence, despite the delay and the nature of the explanation offered. This required the Delegate to consider the merits of the application, the balance of convenience between the parties, and relevant principles of administrative law regarding extensions of time and procedural compliance. The Delegate also had to assess the adequacy of Food Channel's disclosure regarding the circumstances leading to the late service.

The Delegate reasoned that while the delay was only four days, there was no principle that automatically favoured granting extensions for minor procedural transgressions. The Delegate noted that while courts often focus on dealing with substantive oppositions on their merits, this was not applicable here as the late material was unlikely to benefit Food Channel's case. Applying the principle that each extension application must be considered on its own merits and balancing the convenience of the parties, the Delegate found that Food Channel had been consistently tardy and had failed to provide a compelling explanation for the delay, despite numerous warnings and considerable flexibility shown by the office. Consequently, the Delegate was not satisfied that it was reasonable to grant the extension of time.

The Delegate ordered that the extension of time be refused. Television Food, having been successful in this hearing, was awarded its costs against Food Channel.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The matter came to be heard before me, Rachel Dunn, as a Delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks. The hearing was held by teleconference in Canberra on 16 January 2008. Television Food was represented by Mr Ian Tannahill, of Ahearn Fox Patent and Trade Mark Attorneys. Mr Paul Lawrence represented Food Channel, in his capacity as Managing Director. Evidence and Submissions Mr Lawrence supported his final application for an extension of time with a Statutory Declaration made 10 October 2007 (Lawrence, 10 October). That declaration relevantly asserted:ØThat Mr Lawrence personally delivered Food Channel’s evidence in support to the Brisbane office of IP Australia on 20 September 2007. However, Mr Lawrence arranged for a courier service to deliver a copy to Television Food’s address for service on the same day. ØOn the afternoon of 20 September 2007 Mr Lawrence traveled to outback Queensland. Upon his return on 22 September 2007 he found that the copy had not been delivered, but had been left at his post box.ØFollowing this Mr Lawrence personally delivered the evidence in support to Television Food’s address for service. Television Food responded by letter dated 30 October 2007, objecting to the intention of the office to grant the extension of time. This letter was accompanied by the Statutory Declaration of Ian Robert Tannahill, made 30 October 2007. The letter noted that Mr Lawrence had failed to account for the non-performance of the courier company to deliver the evidence. It was noted that Television Food’s address for service was in close proximity to the Brisbane office of IP Australia. Television Food questioned why, in these circumstances, Mr Lawrence elected to employ a courier company to serve the evidence. The accompanying Statutory Declaration of Ian Robert Tannahill noted the following:ØThat Mr Lawrence had, on 4 previous occasions, personally hand delivered evidence to Television Food’s address for service in relation to associated opposition proceedings.ØThat the distance between the Brisbane office of IP Australia, and Television Food’s address for service is approximately 80 meters. Television Food restated its reasons for opposing the late extension of time in its written submissions, dated 16 January 2008. Food Channel did not provide any written submissions prior to the hearing. At the hearing I heard oral submissions from both Mr Tannahill and Mr Lawrence. I requested that Mr Lawrence provide a full and frank disclosure[1] as to the circumstances which led to the late service of Food Channel’s evidence in support. The substance of Mr Lawrence’s oral submissions were:Ø Mr Lawrence contracted a bike courier in the morning the evidence was due to be served, due to concerns about parking;Ø Mr Lawrence personally delivered a copy of the evidence in support to IP Australia, however, did not deliver a copy to Television Food’s address for service as:o He parked in an IP Australia parking bay, which he had previously been told not to use. He later stated that he had been told by IP Australia staff it was alright to park there, so long as he was quick;o He had to travel to outback Queensland later that afternoon and was concerned about time;o The thought of encountering Mr Tannahill made Mr Lawrence ‘sick’.Ø As regards the bike courier, Mr Lawrence suggested the courier may have been in an accident, and that the failure of the courier to deliver the evidence was a failure on the courier’s part, which was beyond Mr Lawrence’s control. [1] As per the guidelines set up by Jenkinson J in Kimberly-Clark v Commissioner of Patents (1988) 13 IPR 569 at 582-584

Decision

Reasons for decision

Though the evidence was served only four days late, the fact remains that it was served out of time. There is no principle, nor would it be appropriate for there to be a principle, which favours the automatic granting of extensions of time to excuse ‘minor’ transgressions concerning late service of evidence. A number of judgments involving applicants who fail to follow procedure focus on the need to deal with the substantive opposition on its merits. This is particularly so when it is clear that relevant material can be brought into the opposition, rather than being disqualified on the basis of a failure of procedure.[8] However, in this case it is clear that the late material will not contribute to Food Channel’s cause. Moreover, it is an obvious principle of administrative law that each extension application must be considered upon its own merits, bearing in mind the ‘balance of convenience’ between the parties, and between divergent public interests. [8] Kaiser Aluminium and Chemical Corporation v The Reynolds Metal Company 120 CLR 136 at 153Decision The merits on this occasion do not favour the granting of an extension of time. Food Channel has been consistently tardy in furthering this opposition. Further, in the face of numerous warnings, it has failed to provide anything approaching a compelling explanation and necessary disclosure of the circumstances which would warrant the granting of this extension of time. More than ample opportunity has been provided to Food Channel to explain its case, but despite considerable flexibility from this office, it has consistently failed to deliver what has been required. Balancing the considerations discussed above, including the relevance of the evidence, I am not satisfied that it is reasonable to grant an extension of time in these circumstances, and I refuse to do so. Costs Television Food, having been successful in relation to this hearing, is entitled to its costs, which I award against Food Channel in accordance with the official scale. Rachel DunnHearing Officer28 March 2008

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established