Television Food Network G.P. v Fppd Channel Network Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Objection by Television Food Network G.P. to an application by Food Channel Network Pty Ltd for an extension of time to serve evidence in answer to the Opposition by Television Food Network G.P. to registration of trade mark application number 1074227 in the name of Food Channel Network Pty Ltd

Delegate: Debrett Lyons
Representation: Opponent :   Ian Tannahill, Patent Attorney of Ahearn Fox, Patent & Trade Mark Attorneys
Applicant :   No appearance
Decision: 2007 ATMO 69
1. Regulation 5.15 : Late application for further time to complete evidence in answer : application allowed
2.  No costs award made

Background

  1. Food Channel Network Pty Ltd (‘FCN’) has applied under application number 1074227 to register a trade mark.  That trade mark application was accepted for possible registration but has been opposed by Television Food Network G.P. (‘TFN’) which completed the service of its evidence in support of the opposition on 14 January 2007.

  2. Under paragraph 5.9 of the Trade Mark Regulations 1995 (‘Regulations’) a copy of any evidence in answer to the opposition on which FCN wished to reply was due to be served no later than 14 April 2007.

  3. On 4 April 2007, FCN served TFN with a copy of a Statutory Declaration of Paul Lawrence together with exhibits 1-17.  The cover letter to that evidence made it plain that further evidence in answer was to follow.

  4. On 26 April 2007, FCN served TFN with a copy of a second Statutory Declaration of Paul Lawrence together with exhibit 18 (‘second declaration’).  That concluded the evidence in answer.

  5. On 2 May 2007 a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks (‘Registrar’) wrote to FCN advising it that this second declaration was served and filed out of time.  That letter explained that FCN would need to apply for an extension of time to admit that evidence.

  6. On 14 May 2007, FCN filed an application under paragraph 5.15 of the Regulations retrospectively seeking a one month extension of time to 14 May 2007 in which to have served the second declaration (‘the application’).  The application was supported by a further Statutory Declaration (‘supporting declaration’) of Mr Lawrence explaining the delay and the appropriate application fee was paid.

  7. TFN’s attorneys subsequently wrote to the Registrar objecting to allowance of the application but received a reply from a delegate of the Registrar that since the second declaration had been served, the Registrar’s delegate proposed to grant the application but gave TFN the opportunity to make representations on the matter, either in writing or at a hearing.

  8. That opportunity to be heard was taken up and the matter was set for Hearing before me, Debrett Lyons, as a delegate of the Registrar in Brisbane on 23 July, 2007.  TFN was represented by Ian Tannahill of Ahearn Fox, Patent & Trade Mark Attorneys.  FCN did not appear but provided written submissions which I have read and taken into account and which were…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Television Food Network G.P. v Fppd Channel Network Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] ATMO 69
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Television Food Network G.P. (the applicant) sought an extension of time to serve evidence in opposition proceedings against Fppd Channel Network Pty Ltd (the opponent). The dispute concerned the admissibility of a second declaration from the applicant, which was filed outside the prescribed time limits. The matter came before a Hearing Officer of the Trade Marks Hearings.

The primary legal issue was whether to grant the applicant an extension of time to serve its second declaration, pursuant to regulation 5.15 of the relevant regulations. This required the Hearing Officer to consider the criteria set out in regulation 5.15, including whether granting the extension was appropriate, and to balance the interests of both parties and the public interest.

The Hearing Officer reasoned that while the applicant had not provided a formal explanation for the delay in filing the second declaration, as typically required by Trade Marks Office practice, the overall circumstances warranted granting the extension. The Hearing Officer noted that the additional delay was short, this was the first extension sought by the applicant, and the opponent had already received a significant extension of time. Furthermore, the Hearing Officer considered the public interest in ensuring the accuracy of the register by allowing relevant evidence, and the efficient running of the system.

The Hearing Officer decided that the Registrar's delegate was correct in indicating an intention to grant the extension of time. Consequently, the second declaration was admitted as part of the record of the applicant's evidence. No order as to costs was made, as the opponent did not seek costs and made no appearance at the hearing.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Regulation 5.15 states in part:Extension of period to serve evidence and service of further evidence (1) A party to the opposition proceedings may apply to the Registrar: (a) for an extension of the period for serving a copy of the evidence under regulation 5.7, 5.10 or 5.12; or (b) for permission to serve a copy of further evidence on the other party. (2) The Registrar may grant an application on reasonable terms specified by the Registrar. (3) The Registrar must not grant an application unless the Registrar: (a) is reasonably satisfied that the applicant has served a copy of the application, and of any documents accompanying the application, on the other party; and (b) has given the parties a reasonable opportunity to make representations concerning the application; and (c) is reasonably satisfied that: (i) in the case of an application to which paragraph (1) (a) applies -- the extension of the period for serving a copy of the evidence; and (ii) in the case of an application to which paragraph (1) (b) applies -- permission to serve a copy of further evidence; is appropriate. I am of the view that the case of Food Marketers Pty Ltd v Valley View Poultry Pty Ltd is only superficially instructive. That decision applied the now repealed Trade Marks Act 1955 and its Regulations. Old Regulation 69 considered in that case was caste in very different terms to its present day counterpart, Regulation 5.15. It provided that:An application for an extension of time under these Regulations shall be in writing and shall be lodged at the Trade Marks Office - (a) before the expiration of the time sought to be extended; or (b) if the Registrar is satisfied that special circumstances existed which prevented the application being made before that time, within such time as the Registrar allows. Many cases under the old law which considered Regulation 69 were concerned with what constituted “special circumstances”. That language is no longer part of the current law and does not guide me as to how Regulation 5.15 is to be understood. There is a balance of convenience to be struck between the parties in order that each side is given a reasonable opportunity to bring in relevant evidence, despite the inconvenience that delay must inevitably cause to the other party. Additionally the public interest in the accuracy of the register weighs on the side of allowing relevant evidence where there would be a public detriment by excluding it, which is most typically in the case of an opponent’s evidence rather than that of an applicant. There is also clear public interest in the efficient running of the system in an orderly and predictable way. To assess the state of that balance in this case, I note that the additional delay is short, a matter of days. Moreover, despite the obvious lack of explanation for the need for more time, the total is not excessive since this is the first extension of time to be sought by the trade mark applicant, whereas the objector in this matter has already sought and been granted six additional months to progress its own case.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I share some of Mr Tannahills’s concern that normal Trade Mark Office practice was not followed in that the applicant has not been required to explain, in declaratory form, the lateness of the second declaration (see Trade Marks Office Examiner’s Manual, part 51, annex A3), nonetheless, balancing as I have done the various factors I am of the view that the second declaration should be allowed onto the record.Decision For these reasons I decide that the Registrar’s delegate was right to indicate her intention to grant the extension of time application. In consequence the second declaration forms part of the record of FCN’s evidence.Costs FCN did not seek its costs in the event that the application was allowed following this Hearing. Since it made no appearance and is self-represented, I make no order as to costs.Debrett LyonsHearing OfficerTrade Marks Hearings31 October 2007

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established