Te Wake and Australian Air Express Pty Ltd (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 72 min read

Te Wake and Australian Air Express Pty Ltd (Compensation) [2016] AATA 771 (30 September 2016)

Division

GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s)

2015/4083

Re

James Te Wake

APPLICANT

And

Australian Air Express Pty Ltd

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Bill Stefaniak AM RFD, Senior Member

Date 30 September 2016
Place Sydney

The Tribunal decides that:

1. The reviewable decision dated 27 July 2015 is set aside;

2. The respondent is liable to pay compensation for the medical expenses detailed in the letter of Dr Ling dated 26 March 2015, pursuant to section 16 of the SRC Act;

3. The matter is remitted to the respondent to determine and manage the appropriate amount of compensation; and

4. The respondent shall pay the applicant's costs and disbursements in respect of these proceedings to be taxed if not agreed pursuant to section 67 (8) of the SRC Act.

..........................[sgd]..............................................

Bill Stefaniak AM RFD, Senior Member

CATCHWORDS

WORKERS COMPENSATION - entitlements - compensation in relation to medical expenses - compensation for surgery - test to be applied - whether condition requiring surgery required in relation to compensable injury - whether condition requiring surgery an injury for the purposes of the Act - decision under review set aside and substituted

LEGISLATION

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 ss 4, 5A, 5B, 14, 16

CASES

Alamos and Comcare (2014) AATA 629

Bortolazzo v Comcare ( 1997) 75 FCR 385
Canute v Comcare [2006] HCA 47
Comcare v Lofts [2013] FCA 1197
Re Luttrell and Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission (2012) 133 ALD 600
Re Manns and Comcare (2012) AATA 462

Scotney v Australian Postal Corporation (2016) AATA 72

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Geddes, R, Statutory Interpretation in Australia (eighth edition, LexisNexis Butterworths 2014)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Bill Stefaniak AM RFD, Senior Member

30 September 2016

BACKGROUND

  1. The applicant, James Te Wake, was born in New Zealand on 10 December 1964.

  2. He emigrated to Australia in 1979 with a view to playing rugby league in Sydney. He played at a reasonably high standard (although not regular first grade) as a prop forward. His playing weight as a young adult was under 100kgs.

  3. In 2000 he commenced employment with the Respondent (then known as Ansett Australia, now known as Australian Air Express (a subsidiary of Qantas)) - initially as a baggage handler, then as a leading hand and now as a supervisor.

  4. On the 29 October 2013 the applicant was towing a train of dollies to be loaded onto an aircraft leased by the respondent. The coupling between the vehicle he was driving  and the train became disconnected and to avoid the damaging the  aircraft,  he reversed his vehicle and collided with the train of  dollies, one of which  rose up onto the vehicle he was driving and landed hard on his left foot. The weight of the dolly and the luggage on it was in excess of 1400 kg.

  5. Despite the fact that he was wearing safety boots, his foot was badly injured and he was rushed to hospital.

  6. It is…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Te Wake and Australian Air Express Pty Ltd (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] AATA 771
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, Te Wake, sought review by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) of a decision made by Australian Air Express Pty Ltd (Comcare) concerning compensation for medical expenses. The dispute centred on whether the proposed surgery, a fusion of joints in the applicant's left ankle and foot, was a consequence of a compensable injury under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1998 (the Act). The applicant contended that the surgery was necessary due to tibialis posterior tendon dysfunction (PTTD), which was causally linked to a previous crush injury sustained during employment. Comcare argued that PTTD was a separate condition, potentially a disease or ailment, and not directly caused by the compensable crush injury.

The AAT was required to determine whether the PTTD constituted an "injury" for the purposes of the Act, and if so, whether the proposed surgery was "in relation to" the compensable crush injury. Specifically, the Tribunal had to consider the definitions of "injury" and "disease" under sections 5A and 5B of the Act, respectively. Section 16 of the Act establishes Comcare's liability to pay for reasonable medical treatment obtained in relation to a compensable injury. The core legal question was whether the PTTD, and the subsequent need for surgery, met the threshold for compensation under these provisions, particularly in light of medical evidence regarding the applicant's pre-existing conditions, weight, and smoking habits.

The Tribunal considered extensive medical evidence, including reports from orthopaedic specialists. While some medical opinions suggested that PTTD could be a degenerative condition or an ailment not directly caused by the crush injury, the Tribunal found that the crush injury and the resulting altered gait and compensatory weight transfer had acted as a trigger for the PTTD. This conclusion was reached after carefully weighing the evidence and acknowledging that the applicant had a predisposition to such a condition. The Tribunal determined that the proposed surgery was reasonable and necessary in relation to the compensable injury.

Consequently, the AAT set aside the reviewable decision and ordered that Comcare was liable to pay compensation for the medical expenses detailed in the letter from Dr. Ling. The matter was remitted to Comcare to determine the appropriate amount of compensation, and Comcare was ordered to pay the applicant's costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 11 August 2015 the applicant applied to the AAT for review of this decision.LEGISLATION AND APPLICATION TO THE FACTS Section 16 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1998 (“the Act”) provides:(1) Where an employee suffers injury, Comcare is liable to pay, in respect of the cost of medical treatment obtained in relation to the injury ( being treatment that it was reasonable for the employee to obtain the circumstances), compensation of such amount as Comcare determines is appropriate to that medical treatment. However, as noted above, there is some dispute between the parties as to the nature of the ‘injury’ for the purposes of this section. The Applicant submits that the fusion surgery is being obtained ‘in relation to’ the compensable injury, and that even if the treatment being sought is not a direct result of the crush injury, than there is a clear, relational connection between PTTD and the crush injury. The Respondent, however, contends that the crush injury is the compensable injury, and that PTTD is not the subject of the proposed joint surgery. Therefore, the Respondent submits that it is necessary to determine whether the PTTD can be determined as an ‘injury’ for the purposes of the Act and submits that it really is a “disease”. In doing so, the Respondent stated that it was apposite to cite s 5A and s 5B of the Act which relevantly provide:5A Definition of injury(1) In this Act: injury means:(a) a disease suffered by an employee: or(b) an injury (other than a disease) suffered by an employee, that is a physical or mental injury arising out of, or in the course of, the employee's employment; or(c) an aggravation of a physical or mental injury (other than a disease) suffered by an employee (whether or not that injury arose out of, or in the course of, the employee's employment), that is an aggravation that arose out of, or in the course of, that employment;but does not include a disease, injury or aggravation suffered as a result of reasonable administrative action taken in a reasonable manner in respect of the employee's employment.(2) For the purposes of subsection (1) etc ...…5B Definition of disease(1) In this Act: disease means:(a) an ailment suffered by an employee; or(b) an aggravation of such an ailment;that was contributed to, to a significant degree, by the employee's employment by the Commonwealth or a licensee.(2) In determining whether an ailment or aggravation was contributed to, to a significant degree, by an employee's employment by the Commonwealth or a licensee, the following matters may be taken into account:(a) the duration of the employment;(b) the nature of, and particular tasks involved in, the employment;(c) any predisposition of the employee to the ailment or aggravation;(d) any activities of the employee not related to the employment;(e) any other matters affecting the employee's health.This subsection does not limit the matters that may be taken into account.(3) In this Act:significant degree means a degree that is substantially more than material.APPLICANT’S MEDICAL HISTORY

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Dr Nair agreed with the surgery proposed by Dr Ling. In his view the applicant's prognosis was guarded in view of his excessive weight and smoking, however he had “exhausted non-operative treatment options” (T documents page 215).Evidence of Professor Sullivan and Dr Ling On 29 September 2015 the respondent sought a further opinion from Dr (Professor) Martin Sullivan orthopaedic specialist and foot and ankle Surgeon. He examined the applicant on 13 October 2015 and provided a report dated the same day. Professor Sullivan noted that the applicant continued to suffer pain and was particularly concerned about pain around the outside lateral border of the left ankle. Professor Sullivan stated that the examination revealed an antalgic gait and that the applicant was unable to walk unaided. He walked with the aid of a walking stick. He examined his left foot and left ankle and amongst other things found he was tender over the base of the little toe on his left foot but this tenderness was different to the pain and tenderness that was elicited in the sub fibula region of the left ankle. He had altered sensation distal to the area where the crush injury occurred in the left forefoot. The sensation was decreased. He had a positive single stands heel raise test on the left and the doctor was unable to fill pulses in the left ankle. The doctor noted the Applicant was a heavy smoker and his normal weight was 135 kg. Professor Sullivan opined the usual symptoms of stage one tibialis posterior tendon dysfunction was usually a reversible condition more often seen in younger healthy patients such as runners and other athletes. The symptoms of stage two can vary from either pain over the tibialis posterior tendon and distal medial malleolus. However, it is possible for patients to present with lateral pain which is secondary to subfibular impingement as a result of the tibialis posterior dysfunction. Patients can present with no medial symptoms which can be a trap for people who are not aware of this condition. Professor Sullivan stated that a patient's obesity is a predisposing factor for the tibialis posterior dysfunction. The tendon pathology is more to a degenerative condition as patients get older. He went on to say:The symptoms that the patient complained of about to his GP from 2009 through 2013 are not consistent with stage one and/or stage two tibialis posterior tendon dysfunction. He stated generally stage two was not reversible and was not something that comes and goes. He agreed with a diagnosis of stage two tibialis posterior tendon dysfunction. He further stated that he did not consider that the crush injury caused the condition nor did he consider that the crush injury caused the progression of the tibialis posterior dysfunction. It should be noted that he later qualified this statement to a minor degree in evidence by stating that the crush injury would be of some relevance. He felt the surgery proposed by Dr Ling would not be reasonable if the patient continued to smoke because it involved a fusion of joints and was unlikely to be successful if the patient continued to smoke after surgery. Due to the patient's obesity soft tissue surgery would be likely to fail.

Decision

Reasons for decision

All the doctors to various degrees seem to accept that the applicant had a predisposition to such a condition as PTTD. As indicated earlier, there is nothing to say that it would not have remained dormant for the next 10 years or maybe forever if something did not trigger it. Clearly, the crush injury and the alteration of gait as a result of the pain caused by the crush injury and the overcompensation effect of weight transfer the applicant adopted (in his changed gait) seems to me to have been that trigger.DECISION The Tribunal therefore decides:(d)The reviewable decision dated 27 July 2015 is set aside.(b) The respondent is liable to pay compensation for the medical expenses detailed in the letter of Dr Ling dated 26 March 2015, pursuant to section 16 of the S RC act.(c)The matter is remitted to the respondent to determine and manage the appropriate amount of compensation; and(d)The respondent shall pay the applicant's costs and disbursements in respect of these proceedings to be taxed if not agreed pursuant to section 67 (8) of the SRC Act.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Counsel concluded that “…[w]hat is evident is that the applicant has demonstrated himself to be committed to the joint arthrodesis surgery.”CONSIDERATION Fundamentally the applicant asks the tribunal to accept that he suffered an injury because of his employment (no one disputes that) and that where this occurs, pursuant to s 16 of the SRC Act.., “Comcare is liable to pay, in respect of the cost of medical treatment obtained in relation to the injury (being treatment that it was reasonable for the employee to obtain in the circumstances), compensation of such amount as Comcare determines is appropriate to that medical treatment. “ The Act goes on to make it quite clear that this includes fees, charges, medical expenses and reimbursement for same if these fees, charges, medical reimbursements et cetera are occasioned in relation to the treatment . The applicant submits that on the basis of the accepted facts clearly the proposed treatment and payment for it arises in relation to the injury. Not so says the respondent. The respondent states that section 5B of the Act applies because the PTTD, i.e. the condition suffered by the applicant was not a crush injury and was either a disease or an injury other than a disease which meets the description of the definition of ailment as defined in section 4(1) of the Act as being “any physical or mental ailment, disorder, a defect or morbid condition ( whether of sudden onset or gradual development)”. Further, the respondent submits PTTD is not for the purposes of the Act ,”an injury (other than a disease)” because it doesn't involve a physiological change that arose out of, or in the course of the applicant's employment with the respondent.. Further,S5B (1) states that a disease means an ailment or aggravation of an ailment – that was contributed to, to a significant degree, by the employees employment by the Commonwealth or a licensee. This is a much higher test than that proposed by the applicant. The tribunal listened carefully to the evidence of Doctors Ling and Sullivan and read carefully the evidence of Doctors Bruce and Nair as well as considering the various medical reports and notes tendered in evidence. It is worth noting that the respondent initially requested the applicant to be examined by Dr George Bruce, orthopaedic surgeon and medical legal specialist. Dr Bruce in my reading of his statement gave a report that was quite favourable to the applicant. The respondent is quite correct in noting that Dr Bruce was not told everything and there was no discussion about any previous issues and that therefore this should qualify his prognosis. Specifically he was not told of previous problems with swelling and gout. This would be an excellent point except for the fact that gout no longer appears to be an issue. As I mentioned earlier I also cannot see any actual connection made by anyone in evidence between the October 2013 incident and the medical reports that showed what appeared to be previous degeneration in the left foot including some spur like deformities.