TCT Group Pty Ltd v Polaris IP Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 45 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

TCT Group Pty Ltd v Polaris IP Pty Ltd [2022] FCA 1493

File number: NSD 1013 of 2020
Judgment of: BURLEY J
Date of judgment: 14 December 2022
Catchwords:

PATENTS –innovation patents relating to hinges – infringement – validity – claim construction

PATENTS – validity – priority – whether patents entitled to priority date of parent patent application or provisional application – priority date deferred to filing date

PATENTS – validity – lack of clear and complete description – classical sufficiency – s 40(2)(a) of the Patents Act 1990 (Cth) (Patents Act)– whether specifications enable skilled addressee to perform invention over the whole area claimed without undue burden

PATENTS – validity – lack of support – s 40(3) of the Patents Act – comparison between invention specified in the claims and that described in the specification – technical contribution to the art

PATENTS – validity – lack of novelty – whether two patents anticipated by prior art documents – lack of novelty established in relation to two claims of the 485 patent

PATENTS – validity – lack of innovative step – invention in the 485 patent found to lack innovative step – lack of innovative step not established for the 918 patent

PATENTS – unjustified threats – whether respondents made unjustified threats of patent infringement in breach of s 128 of the Patents Act

CONSUMER LAW – misleading and deceptive conduct – whether respondents contravened s 18 of the Australian Consumer Law by representing to a client of the applicants that it had engaged in patent infringement – dismissed

Legislation:

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth), Sch 2 (Australian Consumer Law) ss 18, 21, 29(1)(a)

Intellectual Property Laws Amendment (Raising the Bar) Bill 2011 [2012] (Cth) Explanatory Memorandum

Patents Act 1990 (Cth) ss 7, 13, 18(1A)(b), 40(2)(a), 40(3), 43, 43(2A), 79B(1), 120(2), 128, 138

Patents Regulations 1990 (Cth) reg 3.12(1), 3.12(4), 3.13D(4)(a), 3.13D(4)(b)

Cases cited:

Biogen Inc v Medeva Plc [1997] RPC 1

BLH Engineering and Construction Pty Ltd v Pro 3 Products Pty Ltd [2015] FCA 833; 114 IPR 105

Cytec Industries Inc v Nalco Company [2021] FCA 970; 162 IPR 202

Dura-Post (Aust) Pty Ltd v Delnorth Pty Ltd [2009] FCAFC 81; 177 FCR 239

Fuel Oils/Exxon, (T409/91) [1994] OJ EPO 653

GM Global Technology Operations LLC v S.S.S. Auto Parts Pty Ltd [2019] FCA 97; 139 IPR 199

Illumina Cambridge Ltd v Latvia MGI Tech [2021] EWHC 57; RPC 12

JMVB Enterprises Pty Ltd v Camoflag Pty Ltd [2005] FCA 1474; 67 IPR 68

Jupiters v Neurizon [2005] FCAFC 90; 65 IPR 86

Jusand Nominees Pty Ltd v Rattlejack Innovations Pty Ltd [2022] FCA 540; 167 IPR 1

Mentor Corp v Hollister Inc (No 2) [1992] 7 WLUK 465; [1993] RPC 7

Merck Sharpe & Dohme Corporation v Wyeth LLC (No 3) [2020] FCA 1477; 155 IPR 1

Product Management Group Pty Ltd v Blue Gentian LLC [2015] FCAFC 179; 240…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read TCT Group Pty Ltd v Polaris IP Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FCA 1493
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of TCT Group Pty Ltd v Polaris IP Pty Ltd involved a dispute over the validity and infringement of patents relating to hinges. The respondent, Polaris IP Pty Ltd, held two patents: a standard patent (the 485 Patent) and an innovation patent (the 918 Patent). The applicant, TCT Group Pty Ltd, sought to have the patents revoked on the basis that they were invalid due to lack of novelty, lack of an innovative step, and lack of clarity and completeness in their specifications. TCT also sought damages for unjustified threats of patent infringement. The primary legal issues before the court were the validity of the 485 and 918 patents and whether Polaris had made unjustified threats of patent infringement. The court first addressed the issue of priority dates for the patents. It found that the claims of neither the 485 nor the 918 patents were entitled to the priority dates of the parent or provisional application, deferring the priority date to the filing date of each patent. As a result, the use and sale of the Orion hinges before these priority dates rendered the claims of both patents lacking in novelty. The court also found that the specifications of both patents did not disclose the invention in a sufficiently clear and complete manner for a skilled person to perform the invention over the whole area claimed without undue burden, and that the claims were not supported by the matter disclosed in the specification. The court further determined that claims 1 and 4 of the 485 patent lacked novelty in light of prior art, and that all claims of the 485 patent lacked an innovative step over the prior art. The court held that TCT succeeded in its claim for unjustified threats based on correspondence sent by Polaris’ solicitors to TCT and Glass Pro, but failed in its claim under the Australian Consumer Law for misleading and deceptive conduct. The court found the claim for revocation of the patents must be allowed and that the cross-claim for patent infringement be dismissed. The matter will be relisted for the purpose of making final orders after allowing the parties time to confer and reach agreement as to the form of those orders, including as to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The parties confer and supply to the chambers of Justice Burley by 4pm on 1 February 2023 draft short minutes of order giving effect to these reasons and a timetable for further steps in the proceedings.

2. Insofar as the parties are unable to agree to the terms of the draft short minutes of order referred to in order 1, the areas of disagreement should be set out in mark-up.

3. The proceedings be listed for a case management hearing at 9.30am on 2 February 2023.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

This aspect of the case has been resolved by agreement and is not addressed further in these reasons.1.7 Summary of conclusions For the reasons set out in more detail below, I have found that:(1)the Orion hinges fall within the scope of the claims of each of the patents;(2)the claims of neither the 485 patent nor the 918 patent are entitled to claim their priority date from the date of filing of the parent or the provisional application;(3)by reason of the finding in (2), and the use and sale of the Orion hinges before the priority dates of 30 March 2020 and 21 October 2020, the claims of the 485 patent and the 918 lack novelty;(4)the specifications of the 485 patent and the 918 patent also do not disclose the invention in a manner which is clear enough and complete enough for the invention to be performed by a person skilled in the art within s 40(2)(a) of the Patents Act;(5)the claims of the 485 patent and the 918 patent are also not supported by matter disclosed in the specification within s 40(3) of the Patents Act;(6)claims 1 and 4 of the 485 patent lack novelty in light of the disclosure of the US015 and CN860 patents;(7)all of the claims of the 485 patent lack an innovative step over the disclosure of the US015 patent;(8)otherwise the challenge to the validity of the 485 patent and the 918 patent on the basis of lack of novelty in the light of the WO499, US015, CN860 and AU327 patents and lack of innovative step on the basis of those prior art documents fails; and(9)TCT succeeds in its claim for unjustified threats on the basis of the correspondence sent by the solicitors for Polaris to TCT and also to Glass Pro, but fails in its claim based on the same correspondence under s 18 of the ACL. The result is that the claim for revocation of the patents must be allowed and that the cross-claim for patent infringement be dismissed. The matter will be relisted for the purpose of making final orders after allowing the parties time to confer and reach agreement as to the form of those orders, including as to costs.2. THE WITNESSES2.1 TCT William Hunter is a mechanical engineer. From 1986 until 1993 he held positions in companies engaged in the design of products that utilised hinges. From 1994 until 2001 he worked in his own product development company and designed many products and machines including hinges. Since then he has worked as an independent design consultant engaged in mechanical engineering design. Mr Hunter was provided by the solicitors for TCT with copies of the parent, the provisional application, the 485 patent and the 918 patent. In his first affidavit he sets out what he understands to be the main concepts behind the hinge described in the parent, including the dampener feature. He then describes what he considers to be the disclosures of the 485 patent and the meaning of the claims, before comparing what he considers to be claimed in the 485 patent with the disclosure of the parent and the provisional application. He does the same exercise with the 918 patent. He then provides a review of what he considers to be the disclosure of (inter alia) the prior art documents and provides detailed claim charts that set out his view of the disclosure of the prior art documents when compared with the specific integers in the claims of the 485 and 918 patents. He then gives his opinion, relevant to the question of innovative step, as to whether or not the claims of the 485 and 918 patents vary from the information set out in the claim charts in ways “that make no substantial contribution to the working” of the inventions claimed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

It may be seen that the specification discloses three identified difficulties with the prior art, the first being the vibration problem caused by vibration in a direction orthogonal to the plane of the glass panel, the second being the thickness problem caused by the orthogonal orientation of the dampeners relative to the plane of glass and also the thickness of the magnets, and the third being the manufacturing problem caused by the amount of steel used in the hinge. Under the heading “Summary” the specification at [0011] sets out aspects and embodiments of the invention that are later reproduced in the claims. The first aspect of the invention is set out in [0011] and reproduces claim 1, which is set out in section 3.3 below. Other embodiments are described in [0012]-[0016]. There follows a brief description of the figures which are provided “by way of example only” of embodiments of the invention, which are described by reference to 45 drawings. The section entitled “Detailed Description of the Embodiments” commences by referring to an example of a hinge 10 in the glass-to-glass configuration in isometric drawing fig 1A: The hinge 10 includes a first leaf assembly 20 hingedly coupled to a second leaf assembly 30, one or more biasing components 190 (shown in later figures as a spring, see [53] below) which bias the hinge toward a closed position, and one or more dampeners 100 (shown in fig 3 below) to slow movement of the first and second leaf assemblies 20, 30 to the closed position. The specification says (emphasis added):[0066] The first leaf assembly 20 includes a first front leaf component 22 coupled to a first rear leaf component 24 for accommodating therebetween a portion of a first panel 500 having a first cut-out section 510 as shown in Figure 2A. The first leaf assembly 20 further includes a first insert component 40 which is tight fittingly receivable within the first cut-out section 510 of the first panel 500. The first insert component 40 is described in the specification to have “mouse ears” to fit within the cut-out part of the first panel 500, as shown in fig 2A. Figure 2A depicts the cut-outs which are respectively for the first insert 510 and second insert 610 as follows: The second leaf assembly 30, which comprises part of the glass-to-glass embodiment, is described to have a similar arrangement. The specification describes a dampener in more detail:[0069] A first portion 102 of each dampener 100 is secured or fixed within the first insert component 40 and a second portion 104 is configured to at least partially retract within the first insert component 40 when coming into contact with the second leaf assembly 30 during hinged movement toward the closed position under bias from the one or more biasing components 190. The second portion 104 of the dampener 100 extends and retracts along a longitudinal axis which is coplanar with the first panel 500. An exploded isometric view of hinge 10 in fig 1A is depicted in fig 3. It is quite complicated, but it may be seen that dampener 100 has a narrow, pin-like portion 102 and a larger cylindrical portion 104. Biasing spring 190 may be noted, and also the insert components 40 and 60 that have protrusions to match the mouse ears in the cut-out part of the panel: